News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by examancer on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:58PM (#7157985)
This is a side show. Whether or not the statistics show rising or falling income inequality is irrelevant.

There is massive income inequality. Its trajectory isn't nearly as large of an issue as the status quo, which is pretty dismal.

Until that gini coefficient is much better, and we have no one living below the poverty line, we still have a ton of work to do.

This article seems to be making a shallow point only to encourage inaction on the core problem. The trajectory of income inequality is a red herring trying to distract us from the harsh reality of our present wealth, opportunity, and income inequality.

The right thing to do is to keep working to solve the core problem. Restore the US to a progressive tax system instead of regressive. Pass living wage laws. Improve the social safety net. Maybe even consider doing what Switzerland is considering, and give everyone (rich and poor) a reasonable guaranteed income as an alternative to expensive and sometimes ineffective welfare programs.

At the small scale, volunteer locally, especially anything having to do children and improving their education.

Unfortunately, along the way we will be fed a constant stream of garbage articles like this, held up with straight faces by a chorus of onlookers telling us there is no problem to fix. Look outside. There are poor and hard working people out there who aren't being rewarded for their hard work and are severely struggling. No amount of fancy statistics bending will justify inaction.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by ctdonath on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:06PM (#7158052)
Institutionalized theft isn't an acceptable solution. Such class jealousy does not, historically, end well.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by examancer on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:10PM (#7158080)
Calling progressive tax systems institutionalized theft is incredibly clever, and incredibly false.

No one who has wealth created it by themselves. You don't print your own money, you don't extract wealth from a vaccum. Wealth is built by extracting that wealth from a shared economy. Asking those who were able to extract the most wealth to help the most in paying to protect this shared system, and help those who were exploited by it, is not theft.

You are being intellectually dishonest. I would not be surprised if deliberately so.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by ctdonath on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:27PM (#7158987)
Not dishonest. It is possible, in fact, for people to have moral views which differ from yours in good faith. This warrants respect, not insults.

I create wealth by pure thought. Sure that sounds stupid to some, but it's quite true: with about a thousand dollars' worth of borrowed equipment, I sit here writing software to do things useful to my employer. I am not "extracting wealth", I am creating it, organizing electron flows to do things useful to clients, things they are willing to pay for whereby both of us (client & developer) benefit. It is my right to write software, my client's right to use that software, and our right to work out an exchange of representations of wealth. The only "extraction" happens by contracting the exchange of one thing/service for another, facilitated by the abstraction of currency; this creates more wealth in the system, leaving both in a better place than they would be otherwise.

My country's government was created to facilitate the exercise of rights by delegating limited powers to government. Insofar as the "shared system" goes, taxation exists to fund those limited powers, and arguably provide a minimal safety net to the truly destitute (insofar as charity is unable to). Beyond that, ownership is a respected & protected right, and the economy functions by people creating things to own (wealth) and exchanging representations of that wealth (money).

What you & other "wealth inequality" agitators "ask" for is theft, insofar as it demands - under threat of violence by those unrelated to that wealth - those who create or negotiate more wealth than others must, with no objective basis in ownership & contract, give to those who have done nothing for it.

I understand what we have is not a perfect system; that imperfection is a consequence of what some deem "original sin" (adjust terminology as your values see fit to match the point). Bad as it may be, it is better than any other system wherein one group extorts wealth from others without agreement or moral right thereto. Just because one manages to leverage opportunity better than others does not mean those others can "rectify" the situation by saying "we outnumber you, we've decided what you own belongs to us, and if you don't hand it over we'll do horrible things to you."

Yes, progressive taxation is institutionalized theft. Taxation should fund the costs of government carrying out limited powers to facilitate rights as delegated by the national constitution; insofar as income taxation is the current method, it should be blind (as justice should be). The counterpart to your notion that the wealthy exploit the system, is that the wealth pump the system too: their wealth is not squirreled away out of reach of the shared economy, it is rammed right back in thru investments, creation of markets for luxury goods, and prolific charity; the evil you impute is at minimum balanced by the good it creates. Every dollar should be taxed equally, as (on the whole) those who acquire more income do much in the shared economy with it. Insofar as sheer poverty fits in, I'll acquiesce to deducting a minimum income; if you're better off than objectively poor, you can do your fair share too.

Those agitating about "wealth inequality" always fail to objectively address the charity which the rich give to. Just because someone isn't giving money via taxation doesn't mean they're not doing tremendous good; confiscating more by taxation reduces what they can and do give by other ways.

And, just to hammer the point home yet another way (however palatable it may or not be): in a well-armed population, "majority rules" is not sufficient grounds for confiscation. There are a LOT of people prepared to fight back against the self-appointed redistributors of wealth. They know the consequences, so don't want to go there, but will if it comes to that.

TL;DR:

It's.

Not.

Yours.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by mjn on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:16PM (#7159236)
> This warrants respect, not insults.

Considering most of what you post is full of insults and attacks on people who have moral views which differ from yours in good faith, I would suggest you start at home with this advice. "I think the poors should stay poor because they're worthless while I create wealth, and I'm prepared to shoot anyone who tries to implement a contrary policy, be warned" is not a reasoned debate.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by ctdonath on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:28PM (#7159303)
Insults? attacks? where?

And yes there are lines which, when crossed with threat of force, will be met with force.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by mjn on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:32PM (#7159319)
And a tax rate is that line? I cannot think of any change in tax policy that would induce me to shoot a human.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by ctdonath on Saturday February 01, 2014 @09:04AM (#7161652)
The American Revolution was fought in large part over tax rates (and much lower ones than we're subject to now). Confiscate enough of one's fairly-earned wages and and he'll fight back.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by ctdonath on Saturday February 01, 2014 @09:38AM (#7161735)
You threaten to shoot a human to enforce that tax policy.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by guscost on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:17PM (#7158143)
> Wealth is built by extracting that wealth from a shared economy.

This is a very old argument, but the economy is not a zero-sum game.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by holograham on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:44PM (#7158333)
> Wealth is built by extracting that wealth from a shared economy.

This is wrong. First wealth is not extracted from people...it is created from a voluntary exchange. Think about why people handed over money to the "wealthy" in the first place. It was in exchange for a good or service that made that person wealthy where wealth is defined by being better off than they were before. Money is just a unit of exchange that we use to move wealth around. Following this logic the wealthy have already paid their dues so to speak by making other people more wealthy.

Again they do not EXTRACT wealth, they GENERATE wealth for their customers. People with a ton of money should be applauded for delivering so much wealth to society not vilified as if they stole it from them.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by guscost on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:21PM (#7158591)
For the most part I agree with this explanation, but it does not apply to certain cases such as inheritance. Unfortunately the tendency to portray all wealthy people as entitled heirs has been around since the days of explicit aristocracy.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by holograham on Monday February 03, 2014 @01:09AM (#7169124)
how does it not apply for inheritances? That money that was inherited came from delivering a good or service in a voluntary exchange. Just because the money was passed down a generation doesnt mean that money was acquired any different way.

I think you may be trying to point out that the inheritance isnt deserved because the receiver didnt create the wealth. I see inheritances as how the rich choose to spend their money. Some give it to charity, some give it to their kids (which could be a form of charity), some spend it frivolously. Doenst change the fact that the money was generated by creating wealth in the first place.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by brenschluss on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:48PM (#7158775)
> Following this logic the wealthy have already paid their dues so to speak by making other people more wealthy.

Wow, so simplistic. Answer this, then: Why are poor people poor?

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by holograham on Monday February 03, 2014 @01:16AM (#7169138)
I assume this question is to bait me into a debate about equal opportunity, discrimination, and wealthy privilege. I do not contend that there aren't issues to solve in these arenas.

So for the simple economic answer: Poor people are poor because they consume more wealth than they create (or at least break even).

Again as to not offend, I fully understand that economic well-being is still dependent on circumstance to a degree that needs to be addressed. But this fact does not change the economic answer to why poor people are poor.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by ctdonath on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:29PM (#7159000)
Wealth can be consumed and destroyed. If you consume/destroy more than you create and/or trade for, you have a net loss which isn't anyone else's fault.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by bwanab on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:28PM (#7158222)
I agree with you, but with reservations. Despite significant evidence to the contrary, there are those who, far from extracting wealth, actually create it by their brains, hard work and luck. If we can acknowledge that, we can still argue that the shared commonwealth through which they worked was indispensable to their achievements. From each according to his/her ability may be thought of as Marxist, but the idea predated Marx by at least 1800 years and still makes sense.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by dllthomas on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:27PM (#7158217)
"Calling progressive tax systems institutionalized theft is incredibly clever"

Or would be if it were original.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by mbell on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:27PM (#7158213)
> Asking those who were able to extract the most wealth to help the most in paying to protect this shared system, and help those who were exploited by it

That is already what happens. e.g. the top 10% by income already contribute >70% of the total federal income tax revenue.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by dragonwriter on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:28PM (#7158226)
> That is already what happens. e.g. the top 10% by income already contribute >70% of the total federal income tax revenue.

Which would be meaningful, if "federal income tax" was the only federal tax, or even the only federal tax on income.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by bwanab on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:35PM (#7158276)
That's only income tax. When you include all federal taxes, the top 10% by income gives a still considerable 54%, but much lower than the 70% that is generally claimed.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by mjn on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:10PM (#7158088)
Class antagonism around here has ended pretty well historically. The 19th-century working class agitated against the aristocracy and landlord classes, and after a rocky start, the workers' parties successfully gained power in the 20th century. From around the 1920s/30s to about the 1970s most of the Nordic countries were led by nearly unchallenged social-democratic governments, which used their power to create the modern prosperous society. They did grow increasingly moderate as time went on, the system stabilized, and people lost appetite for more sweeping changes (the 1920s social democrats were solidly part of the socialist movement and much more radical in their ultimate aims, while nowadays they're more like the left wing of the liberal movement, and no longer have much association with Marxism).

The Nordic countries of the 19th century looked much different, and much worse. Huge income inequality, entrenched aristocracy, terrible living conditions for the urban working class, etc.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by rpenguin13 on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:13PM (#7159216)
Scandinavian countries have some of the highest external debt per Capita, good job spending money you don't really own.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by mjn on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:21PM (#7159267)
Did you check net external debt? One side of the debt equation (which is what the "external debt" figures show) is not a particularly interesting figure. If you owe people $75 billion, and they owe you $100 billion, you are "$75 billion in debt" by the external-debt statistic, but "$25 billion in the black" by the definition of indebtedness most people use. There are specific technical uses for external debt, but it does not equate to "spending money you don't really own".

The figure that nets these out is the "net international investment position", which subtracts liabilities from assets. The Scandinavian countries have very good positions here. Denmark's NIIP is +27% of GDP, versus the U.S.'s -17%.

The Scandinavian countries have high debt positions basically because they are advanced (i.e. highly financialized) economies with good credit ratings, so make a lot of use of cheap bonds. Same reason Apple issued a bunch of bonds last year despite their huge cash pile. Due to some quirks at the moment Denmark is actually making money on their bonds, as they are issued at negative interest rates— there has been an influx of EUR into DKK due to fears over the EUR, and to discourage that influx (to protect its pegged exchange rate) Denmark is offering negative rates...

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by dragonwriter on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:22PM (#7159271)
External debt per capita is a pretty silly measure; external debt to GDP ratio would be more sane to care about, and, on that measure, the Scandinavian countries aren't particularly bad compared to, say, most of Western Europe.

This is in addition to mjn's sibling post noting why "external debt" may not be the right thing to be concerned about to start with.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by Retric on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:11PM (#7158092)
Such class jealousy does not, historically, end well for the rich. Overall the Magna Carta was a boon for the English economy and the french revolution was surprisingly helpful for there economy in fact most of Europe prospered after similar disruptions. People with wealth and or power want to keep it, but concentrated power does not lead to efficient resource allocation.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by rayiner on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:28PM (#7158229)
It's a mistake to call progressive tax systems "institutionalized theft," one predicated on misunderstanding the nature of the benefit the rich derive from civil society.

The very title "Atlas Shrugged" exemplifies the mistake. Your typical "Atlas" in modern society does not look like this: http://static2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20131015180238/monster.... He looks like this: http://techrights.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/Lloyd-Blank....

The rich do not pay taxes to keep the masses from using violence upon them. They do it so the masses will suppress the "men of war" that would otherwise dominate them. In reality, John Galt is not in charge once he shrugs off the yoke of society. Instead, men skilled in violence and war take advantage of that power vacuum and subjugate him, and he works to serve them. This state of affairs is not unprecedented. You only have to look back to Europe during feudal times to see it in operation. The technologists of that time didn't run the world. Barons and Earls and other military men ran the world. The technologists served the military class.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by splawn on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:16PM (#7158131)
"Institutionalized theft" could be used to describe both sides of the gap issue.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by coldtea on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:38PM (#7158291)
>Institutionalized theft isn't an acceptable solution. Such class jealousy does not, historically, end well.

Historical precedents are not, historically, very useful.

Lots of things that worked at some point in time for some country (e.g a revolution) failed at other points in time for some other country and vice versa.

Each era has unique factors -- from technology to culture. You cannot make assumptions based on what happenned in this or that case 50 or 1000 years ago.

Plus, the notion of "institutionalized theft" is politically charged itself. Whole lotta assumptions there ("those who have lots of wealth deserve it", "they got it all by themselves", "society is better off if they don't be made to share it", etc).

How about inequality being "institutionalized theft" and redistribution being "justice"?

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by rpenguin13 on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:18PM (#7159247)
Institutionalized by whom? In a society of voluntary contracts, those who have lots of wealth DO deserve it, and if they're clear under law then they DID get it all themselves, and "Society" is a mythical being: it has no right to forcibly steal from some more wealthy individuals. "Oh, so you built this house from LEGO blocks during break hour while the other kids where playing around?" "Yes" "It'd be better off for all of you if we could take that house and give it to stupid kids who can't build it."
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by coldtea on Saturday February 01, 2014 @06:34AM (#7161428)
>Institutionalized by whom?

By those in power, now and in the past.

>In a society of voluntary contracts, those who have lots of wealth DO deserve it

For one, the form and reach of those "voluntary contracts" were made with no direct involvement from the population. Were you consulted when you grew up on how they'd be, apart from voting every 4 years or so?

Do the grandchildren of an industrial robber barron, "DO deserve" the money they inherited?

How about all the families that got rich by exploiting slaves? Do their descendants deserve their higher status in society they enjoy?

How about people with large real estate? How exactly Native American territories become the property of some real estate tycoons back in the day (and are passed forward now)?

Just because the law accepts a transition from then to now, doesn't mean the "deserve" question is settled.

>"Society" is a mythical being: it has no right to forcibly steal from some more wealthy individuals.

Well, society is the people. Nothing mythical about it. It's the origins of property that are mythical, as land and resources start off as free for all.

Rather, it's a social contract that allows the wealthy individuals to be wealthy. There's no "right" in that (except if you believe in God given rights), just what is deemed acceptable. That's something that can be reversed at any time, as the kings in France found out.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by sharemywin on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:28PM (#7158224)
The government giveth and the government can taketh away. Property rights, money, laws are all government constructions without them you can only keep what you can forcibly defend. so, "theft" has no meaning without a government to back it up.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by cryoshon on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:12PM (#7158096)
It's not theft so much as performing your fundamental human directive to be your brother's keeper.

In modern society, we have many brothers who we've never met, but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't be helping them prosper.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by anigbrowl on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:18PM (#7158147)
Neither is ignoring the fact of negative externalities. One could view income redistribution as a crude method for quantifying the latter.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by baldfat on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:51PM (#7158385)
It is Institutionalized Theft! The Rich believe it is them who is being stolen from. When it is them who are stealing. If we did a flat 15% tax who would be paying more in taxes?????
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by mchusma on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:11PM (#7158090)
I'm not sure you read the article, because you make some of the same points I do.

"There is massive income inequality. Its trajectory isn't nearly as large of an issue as the status quo, which is pretty dismal." The point of the article is that inequality is itself isn't a good metric.

"The right thing to do is to keep working to solve the core problem....Maybe even consider doing what Switzerland is considering, and give everyone (rich and poor) a reasonable guaranteed income as an alternative to expensive and sometimes ineffective welfare program" -I suggest this briefly as my preferred solution.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by examancer on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:22PM (#7158183)
I read the article and recognize your closing arguments are much more nuanced than the thesis of the article suggests. I apologize for not making that clear in my post.

I still feel the overall point attacking the statistics of income inequality is much more likely to be used as a gavel to silence those working to improve the status quo. Articles like this are often cited when people try to take action to correct income inequality, regardless of what the article ultimately advocates.

That said, I do think its important to get the statistics correct. I don't think you said anything wrong (except maybe with your definition of gini, as others have noted). Your headline is a bit salacious, but ultimately my concern is how this article might be used by others.

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by mchusma on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:31PM (#7158254)
Thanks again. I did fix the Gini issue, which was my fault in trying to get something posted without sufficient editing.

I was surprised by how confusing the statistics were about the trend of income disparity. How the numbers varied widely by source, and how much definitions mattered. I think we both agree that the trend of this is not important.

I'm not sure if we agree or disagree on whether relative status is important or not. I would argue it is not important, except to the extent someone else pointed out that it provides political influence (which I do think I have a solution for). I prefer to look at absolute measures of improving the standard of living (life expectancy, health, food, entertainment, etc).