News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by coldtea on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:38PM (#7158291)
>Institutionalized theft isn't an acceptable solution. Such class jealousy does not, historically, end well.

Historical precedents are not, historically, very useful.

Lots of things that worked at some point in time for some country (e.g a revolution) failed at other points in time for some other country and vice versa.

Each era has unique factors -- from technology to culture. You cannot make assumptions based on what happenned in this or that case 50 or 1000 years ago.

Plus, the notion of "institutionalized theft" is politically charged itself. Whole lotta assumptions there ("those who have lots of wealth deserve it", "they got it all by themselves", "society is better off if they don't be made to share it", etc).

How about inequality being "institutionalized theft" and redistribution being "justice"?

Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by rpenguin13 on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:18PM (#7159247)
Institutionalized by whom? In a society of voluntary contracts, those who have lots of wealth DO deserve it, and if they're clear under law then they DID get it all themselves, and "Society" is a mythical being: it has no right to forcibly steal from some more wealthy individuals. "Oh, so you built this house from LEGO blocks during break hour while the other kids where playing around?" "Yes" "It'd be better off for all of you if we could take that house and give it to stupid kids who can't build it."
Re:Have US Income and Wealth Inequality Actually Increased? by coldtea on Saturday February 01, 2014 @06:34AM (#7161428)
>Institutionalized by whom?

By those in power, now and in the past.

>In a society of voluntary contracts, those who have lots of wealth DO deserve it

For one, the form and reach of those "voluntary contracts" were made with no direct involvement from the population. Were you consulted when you grew up on how they'd be, apart from voting every 4 years or so?

Do the grandchildren of an industrial robber barron, "DO deserve" the money they inherited?

How about all the families that got rich by exploiting slaves? Do their descendants deserve their higher status in society they enjoy?

How about people with large real estate? How exactly Native American territories become the property of some real estate tycoons back in the day (and are passed forward now)?

Just because the law accepts a transition from then to now, doesn't mean the "deserve" question is settled.

>"Society" is a mythical being: it has no right to forcibly steal from some more wealthy individuals.

Well, society is the people. Nothing mythical about it. It's the origins of property that are mythical, as land and resources start off as free for all.

Rather, it's a social contract that allows the wealthy individuals to be wealthy. There's no "right" in that (except if you believe in God given rights), just what is deemed acceptable. That's something that can be reversed at any time, as the kings in France found out.