News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by abstractbill on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:39AM (#7151568)
"But it feels really unfair. People seem to be more sensitive to relative economic status than absolute. So even if people are much better off being poor today than king 500 years ago, most people compare themselves to the richest people today, and not the richest people from the past."

I don't think this is the whole story. It's not just that it feels unfair, it's that it really is unfair. Rich people can buy political representation, and unlike wealth, representation is a zero-sum game.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by allochthon on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:51AM (#7151630)
it's that it really is unfair.

Moreover, the the creation of wealth depends upon a functioning society with a working police force, fire department, transportation system, etc., not to mention the accumulative effect that inherited money brings to kids growing up in a supportive environment and going to the best schools. It is a myth that the wealthy earned their wealth all on their own, but one Americans love because of their (our) infatuation with rugged individualism and personal agency. I personally do not mind levying tons of taxes to level the playing field, but that's probably just my temperament. I want to live in a society in which there is equal opportunity, not a plutocracy with a handful of perpetual dynasties.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:58AM (#7151675)
There are so many who would argue that the wealthly earned their success all on their on that it is frightening (Even on HN).

I've gotten into this discussion multiple times here and it amazes me how often people will fail to acknowledge that the 'birth lottery', as Warren Buffett describes it, is a huge factor in the vast majority of success stories.

This sort of thing may be the primary reason that there will likely be some sort of very uncomfortable upheaval in the next couple of decades.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by refurb on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:38PM (#7151964)
I always find it interesting when the argument of why people are poor comes up. Usually it looks like this...

"People are poor because they make bad life decisions" - usually comes from the right of the political spectrum

"People are poor because the system is stacked against them, it's not their fault" - usually from the left of the political spectrum.

Like most arguments, the truth is likely somewhere in the middle.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by kamaal on Thursday January 30, 2014 @10:43PM (#7155112)
Indeed.

Of the things that I see especially the poor is how their belief becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

Most poor people I know, some of them close friends of mind. Even a few middle class people, and I see this among my cousins. There is a tendency to resign to one's fate. Its like they don't even want to try because it's just not going to work.

There are a few people who do try and break out of those shackles. But they are by and large considered to be lucky.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:44PM (#7152005)
Agreed.

If someone is professing either of those things or something similar they may be missing the point.

People are not poor BECAUSE the system is stacked against them. But if they are poor (by birth, by screwing up royally, what have you), they have much less of a chance to become not poor, because the system is stacked against them.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dragonwriter on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:48PM (#7152041)
> People are not poor BECAUSE the system is stacked against them.

Yes, they (often) are.

> But if they are poor (by birth, by screwing up royally, what have you), they have much less of a chance to become not poor, because the system is stacked against them.

But then that means that there children are very often poor by birth because the system is stacked against them; specifically, the same features by which the system which made it more difficult for X's ancestor(s) to escape poverty by circumstance mean that the system is stacked against X in a way which produced X's poverty.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:02PM (#7152157)
I think we're saying basically the same thing.

My point was more that a given person is not poor because they are lazy (necessarily), because even if they are not lazy, if the system is totally stacked against them, they are screwed. The cycle continues forever and in that sense yes the system being stacked against them made them poor.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dragonwriter on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:08PM (#7152207)
I read your post as saying -- or at least, suggesting -- that the system maintained but did not originally produce poverty for particular individuals, I was pointing out that maintaining poverty for particular individuals in one generation implies causing poverty for particular individuals in the next generation.

I didn't see it as a fundamental disagreement so much as highlighting an implication which seemed to be downplayed in your post.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ZenoArrow on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:53PM (#7152576)
The point ITendToDisagree was making is that the causality between starting poor and ending poor is not direct, i.e. starting poor = ending poor is too simplistic. The truth is there are a myriad of factors at play, but what we can say is that starting poor ends up being a big disadvantage to overcoming poverty in our current system. It's not about downplaying this factor, it's about recognising there are other factors at play, including factors that can tip the odds in someone's favour, the main one being education (and an enriching social life, but that's harder to mandate).

Look at countries like India, they still have huge issues with poverty, but it's also clear that the focus on education has been instrumental in their growth in personal income. The issue with countries like the US is coupling poverty with a system that does not have the same broad level of commitment to education. The situation will continue to get worse, but it doesn't have to, that's the real tragedy.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by yummyfajitas on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:40AM (#7155791)
...it's also clear that the focus on education has been instrumental in their growth in personal income...

Is it clear? The general opinion I see over here is that most education (beyond primary school) is useless, but you can't get hired without it anyway.

I'm also not sure why you'd characterize India as having a "commitment to education" greater than the US - education is far more available and far more common in the US. For example, while I'm harshly critical of the lack of accountability surrounding teaching in the US, teachers are at least required to show up to work.

As far as I'm aware, the general economic consensus about India is that economic liberalization is what has led the growth in income.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ZenoArrow on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:08PM (#7158501)
Perhaps you're right about India's education system.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by solutionyogi on Thursday February 06, 2014 @08:24PM (#7194248)
I am from India, born in 1980 and saw first hand how fast things changed from 1991 onwards when economy was opened up [See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_liberalisation_in_Indi...]

Yes, Indian parents focus on education but that is not what lead to growth in personal income. My father did not finish high school nor did he go to a college but we saw remarkable improvement in our life style thanks to overall economy improvement as there was more demand for his work. I know many people who are completely illiterate but were able to grow their business as there was no more red-tape by government. In 1991, government allowed private banks to open (before that all banks were state owned) which lead to better access to capital allowing tons of businesses to flourish. Reliance Industries [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reliance_Industries] is the the largest private sector company by revenue and ranks 107 in Fortune 500. The company was started by Dhirubhai Ambani who did not go to college but was able to grow his company many fold after economy was opened up.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:10PM (#7151766)
>"I personally do not mind levying tons of taxes to level the playing field"

The question that comes to mind is whether you mind paying the taxes yourself, not what you think about foisting costs on others. It is very easy (and inexpensive) to say that every problem should be solved on someone else's dime; one might even care enough to vote with that in mind, but you are not taking any personal responsibility, or even using clever rhetoric to convince someone else to act.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dredmorbius on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:00PM (#7152616)
The question that comes to mind is whether you mind paying the taxes yourself, not what you think about foisting costs on others.

That's a shift of the argument and discussion.

And the simple truth is that taxes are and always will be a form of mutual coercion, mutually agreed on.

So long as the taxes are levied based on the ability to pay and not on "what other definable societal subgroup are you a member of", then anyone who happens to win at the wheel of fortune (in the metaphorical, not game-show, sense) is equally included.

Taxes are the price of a civil society.

Whether you are, as Anne Richards used to say of a fellow politician, born on third base thinking you hit a triple, happened to be fortunate enough to have been living on top of a patch of sand that had half the world's oil squirreled away underneath it (if you want to see a phenomenal story of windfall wealth impacts, look up the story of a few clans of former date farmers and oyster divers who got lucky), or just happened be be born within the geographical boundaries of one of the G7 industrial nations (the US, Canada, UK, Germany, Italy, France, Japan, though much of western Europe could also be included), scored at startup bingo, and/or were ruthless enough to take on all challengers to claim your piece of the pie (see the recent story of "anti-poaching" collusion among Silicon Valley firms), there are tremendous inefficiencies in how "the market" allocates its rewards.

Engineering systems almost always include negative feedback loops to prevent runaway destructive trends. Its a concept foreign to much of economics. Not in the least helped by the anti-empirical faith-based fundamentalism of Libertarian dogma that seems to be growing in popularity.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:22PM (#7152767)
>"[T]axes are and always will be a form of mutual coercion, mutually agreed on."

You appear to believe that my birth in a high-tax country is tantamount to acceptance of a social contract with an arbitrary tax level clause (subject to change without notice). For a valid contract, three elements are required: offer, acceptance, and competent persons.[1] I would contend that at my time of birth, I was not a competent person, and even then, I doubt that I would have accepted the contract which you are proposing.

>"Engineering systems almost always include negative feedback loops to prevent runaway destructive trends. Its a concept foreign to much of economics. Not in the least helped by the anti-empirical faith-based fundamentalism of Libertarian dogma that seems to be growing in popularity."

The problem is that democracy has almost no feedback at all, as people have very little incentive to accept that the policies they voted for have caused real harms; in addition, there are high switching costs when it comes to political views.[2]

Libertarians usually resort to two arguments, economic efficiency, and the morality of coercion; I am not sure which of these involves the "dogma" you describe, but I will assume you speak of the economic arguments. You state that there is no feedback in markets, when I believe the opposite is true, as markets react to new information, though they may not always do it very well; the efficient-market hypothesis explains this, and is entirely compatible with feedback control systems theory, (especially the strong form EMH).[3]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_God_that_Failed [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficient-market_hypothesis

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dredmorbius on Thursday January 30, 2014 @03:36PM (#7153199)
You appear to believe I accept your premises, definitions, logic, and conclusions concerning a social contract, or that it's material at all to this matter. I don't.

However, to invoke your own logic, assuming you've reached age of majority, you've consciously accepted that contract of which you speak.

The problem is that democracy...

Indeed. Those liberal concepts are rather problematic in many ways. I disagree that they have no feedback, and arguably democratic forms of governance have far better feedback systems than others. Their chief advantage isn't that they achieve the best results, but as Plato observed: they avoid the worst.

Libertarian dogma is grounded in von Mises Praxeology, and its axiomatic refutation of empiricism.

You state that there is no feedback in markets.

No, I do not.

The efficient-market hypothesis is bunk. See Quiggin, Zombie Economics. Full chapter on the topic.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @04:00PM (#7153327)
>"However, to invoke your own logic, assuming you've reached age of majority, you've consciously accepted that contract of which you speak."

I have not agreed to the contract. I never have, and I never will. The only way that my actions can be interpreted as acceptance of the offer is that I have not left the nation I currently reside within; and this is not how contracts work.

>"taxes are and always will be a form of mutual coercion, mutually agreed on."

I never agreed.

>"democratic forms of governance have far better feedback systems than others. Their chief advantage isn't that they achieve the best results, but as Plato observed: they avoid the worst."

I agree with you entirely, that democracy is the best type of government available at the moment, but that is faint praise.

>"The efficient-market hypothesis is bunk. See Quiggin, Zombie Economics. Full chapter on the topic."

I doubt we will ever agree on this, and I accept that there are a number of valid criticisms of EMH; but if the market is inefficient, some people should be able to find the inefficiencies and profit from them, of which there are few examples (except ephemeral ones).

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dredmorbius on Thursday January 30, 2014 @05:49PM (#7153898)
this is not how contracts work

You're invoking a "no true Scottsman" fallacy. That is, in fact, how this contract works.

I never agreed.

Do you pay your taxes? You're agreeing. Possibly under duress or objection, but you're agreeing. And no, I don't subscribe to the whole Libertarian spiel about voluntary vs. involuntary participation.

if the market is inefficient, some people should be able to find the inefficiencies and profit from them

That is, in fact, one of the larger inefficiencies of the market: that socially or long-term nonoptimal conditions can be arbitraged for personal gain. Regarding the longer view, there are numerous failures, including how markets break down under more general social failure, volatility, and, as J.M. Keynes noted, the capacity for markets to remain irrational longer than any given investor can remain solvent. Smart cookie that man.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @06:36PM (#7154154)
>"You're invoking a "no true Scottsman" fallacy. That is, in fact, how this contract works.'

No it is not; valid contracts require explicit offer, and acceptance (lack of opt-out is not acceptance), without duress (i.e. deportation or imprisonment).[1]

>"Do you pay your taxes? You're agreeing. Possibly under duress or objection, but you're agreeing."

I said that I never agreed, and while I do pay taxes, I never agreed to it.

>"I don't subscribe to the whole Libertarian spiel about voluntary vs. involuntary participation"

Next time you get robbed, just remember that is an involuntary charitable contribution for the welfare of the thief; this would give me little comfort, but it seems you don't mind.

>"socially or long-term nonoptimal conditions can be arbitraged for personal gain. "

Please provide examples of the people or organizations able to arbitrage consistently, over time, without the use of government coercion (i.e. no government granted monopoly or bailout). If you do happen to find this, you may want to keep it secret, so that you may have a monopoly on the arbitrage.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dredmorbius on Thursday January 30, 2014 @07:19PM (#7154376)
You're assuming the social contract follows the conventions of legal contracts between parties. It doesn't. Attempting to shoehorn it into that mode doesn't work, neither does argument by assertion.

while I do pay taxes, I never agreed to it.

And if I were to enter into a business relationship with an entity because there was literally no other choice (an email service provider as counterparty, a local monopoly, a services provider selected by my employer), then what? Willing or otherwise, you've agreed to the terms, which don't include "whistle while you pay".

Note that the State has also not consciously elected to support your ungrateful ass from the age of 0 to 18, prior to your age of majority, nor since. It simply does. That's its end of the bargain.

without the use of government coercion

I don't accept this limitation as it inherently ignores the fact that money is power, including political power, as well as the fact that all legal property is in fact a product of government coercion (as opposed to property by right of possession, might, moral suasion, tradition, or other constructs, which have their own origins).

Oh, and "property rights" aren't all that old a thing: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=property+right...

Please provide examples of the people or organizations able to arbitrage consistently, over time

Any holder of more productive land or assets (the substance of David Ricardo's lament in his Law of Rent), extractive oil producers, patent trolls, any party who writes or influences legislation to their advantage (as noted and strongly criticised by Adam Smith), market manipulators, technology and software vendors with positive returns to scale and lock-in effects (AT&T, IBM, Xerox, Microsoft, Google, Facebook) ... It's a long list, really. I'm not claiming that the power is unlimited or extends for all time, but while it persists it can be exceptionally difficult to dislodge.

The point is that initial leverage tends to multiply.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by TheCoelacanth on Friday January 31, 2014 @10:37AM (#7157163)
You are free to leave the country and renounce your citizenship. The fact that you have not constitutes acceptance of the social contract.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by allochthon on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:14PM (#7151793)
It is very easy (and inexpensive) to say that every problem should be solved on someone else's dime

It's not someone else's dime, full stop. The system misallocated the money in the first place by giving them a disproportionate amount. The mechanism for valuating people's contributions is self-serving and broken right now. A teacher contributes 1000000 times more to society than a hedge fund manager, despite what the hedge fund manager will tell you about the benefits of liquidity that his activities are supposedly bringing about.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by philwelch on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:25PM (#7151882)
The average teacher's contribution? In America? I'm not sure if it's even a positive number. You must have gone to really good schools.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:24PM (#7151879)
>"The system misallocated the money in the first place by giving them a disproportionate amount."

Though I have never seen convincing evidence (either way) on this subject, I will accept it ad argumentum.

Using coercion to force someone else to pay for things I want is still a cheap and lazy way for me to achieve my ends. My point is that one should convince the hedge fund manager to donate money to important causes. Alternatively, you might contribute your own hard-earned money to achieve the ends you profess (or pretend) to value so highly.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:38PM (#7151965)
How very Randian of you. I don't imagine that you'd have much luck convincing the hedge fund manager to donate to anything unless they themselves think it is important. And it is very hard to convince them that others have it bad when they have it so good.

Asking the parent to contribute their hard-earned money also seems sort of disingenuous. How do you know they are not doing so? Even if they did, if they are unable to contribute enough (for any number of reasons), it likely will not effect the issue in a large enough fashion.

A Democratic decision is not 'coercion'. If the public decides something is important enough to them to pass a law/change the tax code they are not coercing the rich to pay more. The wealthy could just leave (with all that would entail for both parties) and no longer make their money off/with said public... Or they could stay.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:53PM (#7152081)
>"A Democratic decision is not 'coercion'."

So if a state decides (through referendum or legislative measure(s)) to compel slavery or imprisonment of one race or another, through police or military action, that would not be "coercion"?

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:09PM (#7152214)
Are you really attempting to equate slavery with the wealthy paying higher taxes?

If we are reducing to absolute absurdity... This conversation is over. I have no interest in an HN fallacy battle. A 'democratic' decision to enforce slavery/commit genocide/etc is pretty clearly well outside of what was being discussed.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:35PM (#7152449)
>"If we are reducing to absolute absurdity... This conversation is over."

My example was based on the many governments which have treated certain races as sub-human; I agree it is not directly analogous, but I was trying to demonstrate that democracies are not always fonts of virtue.

You went and called me a "Randian" (without any demonstrated reason), I believe it was you who was enjoining a "battle" through unsubstantiated allegation.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by mempko on Thursday January 30, 2014 @04:12PM (#7153394)
That's a joke. Name me one democratic government that voted a race of people into slavery?
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @04:40PM (#7153519)
I said "slavery or imprisonment of one race or another", and I believe the three examples below are all debatable, as to which they exemplify.

Thirteen Colonies, 1705

Wood, Origins of American Slavery (1997), p. 92. "In 1705, almost exactly a century after the first colonists had set foot in Jamestown, the House of Burgesses codified and systematized Virginia's laws of slavery. These laws would be modified and added to over the next century and a half, but the essential legal framework within which the institution of slavery would subsequently operate had been put in place."

Germany, 1933

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_federal_election,_March_...

South Africa, 1948

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_general_election,...

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by mempko on Monday February 03, 2014 @02:51PM (#7172996)
Of course you realize these kinds of governments are labelled republics right? Ironically to prevent "the majority abusing the minority." So again, where is democracy involved here?

In other words I had a trick question. You first have to ask what democracy is before you can even approach it....

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:50PM (#7152546)
>Are you really attempting to equate slavery with the wealthy paying higher taxes?

Equate? No. But there are of course similarities.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by AnimalMuppet on Thursday January 30, 2014 @03:31PM (#7153170)
The system didn't allocate what was given to them. Most of the wealthy either earned it (by doing something that others wanted badly enough that they paid for it) or inherited it. The only system that gave it to them was the free market.

(Yes, I know: Some stole it, some got it via government influence, etc. But in the majority of cases, what I said is true. Bill Gates, for instance: what system gave him a disproportionate amount? Did he earn it by paying substandard wages to Microsoft employees? Well, no, he didn't.)

(Also note that nothing in this comment is a justification for the appallingly poor rate at which we pay teachers.)

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by gopher1 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @05:03PM (#7153633)
Actually, most of the wealth is created in the financial services industry, and one can make quite a compelling argument that most of this wealth is ill-gotten. Insider trading, market manipulation, government lobbying, money laundering, and on and on...
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:15PM (#7151808)
It may not be a question of if the person in question has to pay themselves. If enough people in a functioning democracy think that it is a good idea for those who are getting more, to pay more, then it would become law (decree if you like).

Those people who would have to pay then could either take their wealth and attempt to leave with it (with all the consequences for both parties that might entail), or they can pay the share they are designated, and attempt to make more money with their wealth/connections/etc.

Greed is funny in that if you have a lot, you don't tend to see wanting more (or to pay out less) as greedy, while those who are denied the same amount, see those with a great deal (who do not want to contribute what the public believes is their fair share) as greedy.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:37PM (#7151955)
>"If enough people in a functioning democracy think that it is a good idea for those who are getting more, to pay more, then it would become law"

This is how western democracies currently function, though it does not imply that the results are moral or even good.

>"Those people who would have to pay then could either take their wealth and attempt to leave with it (with all the consequences for both parties that might entail), or they can pay the share they are designated, and attempt to make more money with their wealth/connections/etc."

This statement basically says 'take it or leave it', which I suppose is fine, but does not mean that the state which implements high tax rates will achieve its desired results, and this does not speak to the morality of the average voter either.

You seem to ignore my point, which is that people who vote for higher tax rates and increased redistribution of wealth are not actually doing very much to solve any real problem. Voting to raise taxes on the rich demonstrates little personal responsibility, as the voter does not pay to solve the problem, and does not even try to convince others of their moral responsibilities.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dragonwriter on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:45PM (#7152018)
> You seem to ignore my point, which is that people who vote for higher tax rates and increased redistribution of wealth are not actually doing very much to solve any real problem.

This requires the assumption that the distribution of wealth that is being address is not a real problem.

> Voting to raise taxes on the rich demonstrates little personal responsibility, as the voter does not pay to solve the problem

Payment to solve the problem is a method to "demonstrate personal responsibility" because it is one method by which one exercises one's power to solve a problem one has perceived, but voting is equally so a method to "demonstrate personal responsibility".

> and does not even try to convince others of their moral responsibilities.

Well, sure, voting itself may not be an mechanism for trying to convince others of their moral responsibilities (then again, it may be, people have been known to cite drawing attention to an issue and raising awareness to be motivations for voting behavior on issues and candidates), but even where it is not it is often not an isolated behavior, people who based on a preference for a particular policy very often engage in advocacy around the policy, including advocacy based on the premise that it enforces a moral obligation.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:04PM (#7152179)
>"This requires the assumption that the distribution of wealth that is being address is not a real problem."

My point was that voting is 'not actually doing very much', as it is easy to do, and unlikely to have any real impact.

>"but voting is equally so a method to "demonstrate personal responsibility"."

Voting is cheap, easy, and free from repercussions; I struggle to see how it involves any measure of responsibility.

>"people have been known to cite drawing attention to an issue and raising awareness to be motivations for voting behavior on issues and candidates), but even where it is not it is often not an isolated behavior, people who based on a preference for a particular policy very often engage in advocacy around the policy, including advocacy based on the premise that it enforces a moral obligation."

You may be correct, and I may be too cynical, but I see 'raising awareness' as the last refuge of the ineffective activist.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:49PM (#7152048)
When did a democracy or a democratic decision imply moral absolutes? That would be my question.

does not mean that the state which implements high tax rates will achieve its desired results, and this does not speak to the morality of the average voter either.

Agreed! Every situation is different and that is by no means a silver bullet.

If people voted for increased redistribution to redistribute wealth than they are doing something to solve the 'real problem' as they see it. You are correct that it may not be the actual problem... But I do not think that you can effectively bring 'morals' into the equation of tax codes or being rich/poor.

Personal responsibility means very very different things to any given person. I do not think you can find many extremely wealthy people who think they have a moral responsibility to help out their lesser man (feed the poor), while you can find many 'poor' people who think it should be their moral responsibility ('if you have so much more than you can ever use why can't you help those less fortunate' sort of thing).

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:10PM (#7152224)
>"If people voted for increased redistribution to redistribute wealth than they are doing something to solve the 'real problem' as they see it."

Your vote is unlikely to have any real impact, (the same is true of mine,) so while the people may be 'doing something', this 'something' may be the least effective action one could possibly take. I vote in every election, but even I must acknowledge that I would be doing much more for my fellow citizens if I spent the same amount of time picking up garbage from the streets.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by djs123sdj on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:41PM (#7152876)
The problem with this argument is that it ignores the basic contract of power in a (functioning) democratic government:

The people, through their votes, lend their power to a government that aggregates that collective power to accomplish larger societal objectives (financing wars, building bridges, educating generations, enforcing civil society, etc), that would not be possible if the maintenance of society was left to everyone's individual will.

Just as valid: peoples votes in elections after 9/11 gave the government power to compromise civil liberties in the name of security.

Does your city have a street sweeping service (which are usually publicly funded by taxes approved by ... votes)? Without one, in an urban/suburban environment, your street would be full of garbage in no time, probably too much for you or other like-minded people to clean up.

Votes aren't a solution for every large problem, but it's far fetched to say that don't have any impact. Much of what we take for granted in modern public conveniences happened because people voted for representatives that in turn supported those endeavors.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @03:52PM (#7153281)
>"Just as valid: peoples votes in elections after 9/11 gave the government power to compromise civil liberties in the name of security."

I agree with you entirely on how the system functions, though not all people want to grant all the powers which the government has collected over the years, and it should not be assumed that a vote is a tacit agreement to the current system.

>"Does your city have a street sweeping service (which are usually publicly funded by taxes approved by ... votes)? Without one, in an urban/suburban environment, your street would be full of garbage in no time, probably too much for you or other like-minded people to clean up."

You assume the street must be state owned and maintained; plenty of private communities do a good job keeping things neat and tidy (though I do not live in one).

>"Votes aren't a solution for every large problem, but it's far fetched to say that don't have any impact. Much of what we take for granted in modern public conveniences happened because people voted for representatives that in turn supported those endeavors."

I never said that elections are bad, but saying that you "voted for 'x'" means that you did very little to actually make it happen, because individual votes are insignificant.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by tomp on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:15PM (#7151803)
But for almost every person, this question is not relevant - in most countries, if the top 1% (or the top 1% of the top 1%) was taxed as much (on income and on assets) as the average (or median) person is, all fiscal issues of the government would be solved. We don't really need to tax the general population more; we just need to make sure the rich stop avoiding their taxes.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:18PM (#7151833)
The average one percenter has a 23% effective tax rate, double the average (which is 12%).

http://taxfoundation.org/blog/top-one-percent-pays-twice-inc...

edit: dragonwriter correctly pointed out that the numbers mentioned above are actually 'income tax', not 'total tax'. I apologize for my vagueness.

edit: the average total effective tax rate for one percenters is 27.9%, compared to the lower 99%, who pay an average of 27.5% TETR http://www.ctj.org/pdf/taxday2012.pdf

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dragonwriter on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:30PM (#7151911)
> The average one percenter has a 23% effective tax rate, double the average (which is 12%).

Even assuming that there are no errors or misrepresentations in the material from the anti-taxes-on-the-rich propaganda outfit you cite, even they don't claim that. While they certainly count on people to conflate "effective income tax rate" with "effective tax rate" (or even "effective rate of taxation on income"), they carefully restrict their claim to "effective income tax rate".

Income tax isn't all of tax, or even (despite the name) the only (or, even, for most wage earners, the most significant) tax on income.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by nickff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:49PM (#7152049)
You are correct, I edited the post to include total effective tax rate for the top 1% and bottom 99%.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by thedufer on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:36PM (#7151948)
Thats specifically only income tax. At under $117k, people are paying 12-13% in social security; at the high end it approaches 0% thanks to the hard ceiling. Its kind of disingenuous to compare taxation on high earners vs average but ignore regressive taxes.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:26PM (#7151885)
Two questions.

Do they actually end up paying that tax rate? Or is that before deductions and only the rate on their personal earned income. There are a lot more ways to game the tax system when you have a great deal of wealth.

What percentage of the wealth do they have relative to everyone else?

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by refurb on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:34PM (#7151939)
The definition of "effective tax rate" is what they actually paid.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:52PM (#7152069)
But not in this case... which is why I asked. The parent has updated their post to show this.

The quoted number was only their income tax rate.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by refurb on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:59PM (#7152126)
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by mcguire on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:41PM (#7151983)
And the "average tax rate for the bottom 99%" is 9%.

1. Mean vs. median. Here be dragons.

2. That roughly corresponds with my experience: it's easy for a USA'er to compute their federal effective income tax rate: the IRS's idea of your income is at the bottom of the first page and the "total tax paid" is about two-thirds of the way down the second. Mine was around 15% for many years; it has gone up lately, but I don't remember specific numbers any more.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dictum on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:40PM (#7151974)
> I personally do not mind levying tons of taxes to level the playing field

My view is certainly tinged by living in a country where taxes are high but public services are mediocre at best, but there's no use paying high taxes if your money is eventually used in a war with Somewheristan, making the owners and stockholders of military-industrial complex companies richer.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:15PM (#7151798)
Can they? In spite of increased income inequality, our political process is becoming more hostile to the rich than it was historically.

Of course, after taking a walk through my locale (Parbhani, India), I'm fairly unsympathetic to claims that relative status is what matters. Perhaps it was the man lifting his lungi to poop next to an open sewer. Maybe it was the auto driver sleeping on the job. It could be the garbage everywhere (taking off your shoes when you enter an Indian home isn't a cultural quirk). Maybe it's the fact that the very nice hotel I'm staying in would be shut down immediately in the US.

I could be wrong, but I suspect that most of the people around me would be happy to have these problems fixed, even if it resulted in the income of "rich" people (like Americans below the American poverty line) quadrupling.

Inequality is a first world problem.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by mcguire on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:47PM (#7152035)
"In spite of increased income inequality, our political process is becoming more hostile to the rich than it was historically."

Is it? I don't know about the state in India, but here in the United States, you hear a lot about "hostility" but I have not noted any real changes in behavior.

Breaking a Google bus window is pretty lame, as such things go. I'll start believing in "hostility" when someone sets Mark Zuckerberg on fire or I have to start paying for security forces (which is more likely, I suspect).

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:18PM (#7151829)
You're saying there are no wealthy people in India? Or that there are no wealthy people in any given third world country? If that is part of your claim I think you may want to check the facts on that one...

Edit: You described inequality in your post given that so many have it so bad and some are incredibly well off by comparison.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:34PM (#7151929)
I'm saying that having a porcelain throne while someone else has a solid gold one is better than pooping in the sewer even if the rich man does the same thing.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:55PM (#7152089)
Fair enough, but that does not make inequality a 'first world problem'. Inequality is a thing in both systems, just because the difference is much more vast (or less so) does not mean that there is no inequality.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by benched on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:32PM (#7151920)
I agree that 'inequality' is too simplistic a concept to adequately describe what the problem is in the US. I believe the real problem is more that the stresses a poor person must contend with to hold down even the smallest apartment, buy food, and in many cases maintain a car, are extremely high compared with middle-class people. It's that the economy is skewed in such a way that makes the whole game seem unfair to a huge fraction of the population. You're right that the basic standard of infrastructure is higher in the US, and that most people here enjoy those benefits, so there's a relative effect there.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:39PM (#7151969)
Could you explain the "stresses" in some detail? And if stresses are the problem, why all the talk of inequality? Will the stresses somehow go up if programmers can create even more wealth?
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by fancyketchup on Thursday January 30, 2014 @03:41PM (#7153227)
The "stresses" come from trying to maintain a middle-class lifestyle on a lower-class income.

As someone who once spent a considerable amount of time (just over a decade) supporting myself on a just-above poverty line income, I notice that a lot of people talking about the impossibility of living on minimum wage are implicitly assuming that everyone must conform to certain cultural norms (living alone, owning and maintaining a car, going out to eat or for entertainment, etc). Many of the financial stresses of low income are moderated by not conforming to those norms.

For example, take this story: http://www.forbes.com/sites/laurashin/2013/07/18/why-mcdonal...

A major criticism of the McDonald's budget is that it only allocates $600 per month for rent. Ok, well, I'll grant you that it's hard to find a single-bedroom apartment in most major cities for that little. However, it is quite easy (I know, because I have done it) to find a two bedroom apartment in a nice, safe neighborhood in Los Angeles (of all places) for about double that. Living with roommates may not be everyone's ideal (some prefer it), but I find it disingenuous to assume that everyone ought be living in some culturally-defined way. Living with (a) roommate(s) is just one example of a "lifestyle sacrifice" that does not harm your health or safety, and doesn't affect your autonomy as a person (much). But it does significantly reduce living expenses.

Another example is car ownership. Even Los Angeles' "famously bad" bus network will take you anywhere in the county (and there is Zip Car for when it's absolutely necessary to drive). Resisting social pressure (from friends and potential mates) to own a car reduces living expenses dramatically. Some people will look down on you for not having one, but who cares what they think?

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by chflamplighter on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:01PM (#7152628)
I think the stresses are apparent if you have faced them. The main issue with being poor (speaking from experience) is the unavoidable fact that an unexpected outlay of $$ (car repair or trip to the doctor or parking ticket or broken water heater) can have such a profound effect on your finances, one which you may not recover from. The reality is that when you are poor, living pay check to paycheck, the margins are beyond fine. There is no second chance when life strikes, so the daily stress you feel is intense and surely has an effect on your state of mind. Soon you begin to feel trapped and that is when hope becomes a memory with survival the only concern. I feel fortunate to not have those stresses anymore and can tell you that the stresses I feel now are significantly less stressful in comparison. Stresses now could ruin my day but not my life (barring the most catastrophic events). When you are poor, everything $$ is significant and can have a radical impact on your life.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dictum on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:13PM (#7151787)
Also, most people don't compare themselves to the richest people today or the richest people from the past. They compare themselves to richer neighbors/relatives/coworkers/friends.

In the same way people don't get the implication of the word "trillion" when they hear it on the news, people don't really lament Bill Gates's billions or the Walton family's billions. They lament cousin Jack who's making 300k/year while they're making 60k.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by Jun8 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:26PM (#7151886)
"Rich people can buy political representation"

While that's true it's a very simplified picture of how money affects politics, which applies everywhere but is perhaps most conspicuous in the US. Different lobbies/pressure groups/unions also affect politics through large donations. As a small example, consider the California Teacher's Association: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Teachers_Association.... Goes on to show that financial pressures in politics may work both ways.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:48PM (#7152522)
"most people compare themselves to the richest people today"

This is insane!

People compare themselves to their peers - NOT to the richest people. We are envious of our successful friends and family members - particularly our brother in law ;)

Whether Zuckerberg has $1B or $5B or $50B makes literally no difference to us.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by philwelch on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:20PM (#7151850)
Fortunately(?), the extremely wealthy aren't a cabal of people with identical political opinions.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by chatmasta on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:47AM (#7151605)
Do you have a better idea for how to distribute political representation?
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by ItendToDisagree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:08PM (#7151748)
Perhaps in-depth public accounting of all political contributions/favors/etc and the finances of all politicians who serve one or more consecutive terms? If you want to be a politician you have to submit to public scrutiny of your finances prior to and following your political career?

I don't know really... But I think that might help weed out career politicians who rely on sources of dubious income.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by abstractbill on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:04PM (#7151722)
Well I don't think the whole system has to be broken down and rebuilt from scratch. There are lots of pretty basic ideas floating around for getting money out of politics.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by wwweston on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:28PM (#7152395)
There are some good ideas floating around, and we could do a lot better than the direction we're going now, but I don't think it's really possible to try and eliminate all the ways in which money buys influence.

Once you can employ people to work for your political ends (by directly engaging with congressional staff, by producing supportive research, by working a PR campaign...), you have a bigger voice than someone else, whether laws allow you funnel campaign cash by the shipping container or not.

My guess is that the only real way to balance this out is have more citizens talking to congressional staff.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:53PM (#7152566)
To say nothing of the fact that glamour can be used - and IS used - in lieu of money. Associating with movie stars, successful businesspersons, so on, is it's own reward.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by tomp on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:07PM (#7151742)
Make lobbying illegal (which the US, or at least it's Supreme Court, seems unwilling to do). Prevent big donations to politicians. Make tax returns and all other indicators of wealth public, i.e. completely transparent, at least for public officials (like Sweden).
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by maxerickson on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:23PM (#7151874)
The solution to 'people don't vote right', in the long term, has to be to increase engagement and education. Ever more rules about how the political discourse must be carried out is just running in circles.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by benched on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:05PM (#7151730)
Randians / Grahamians here always seem quick to echo that 'wealth isn't zero sum'. (I presume this is to help those who are or aspire to be wealthy feel awesome about their noble path.) Wealth may not be zero sum, but wealth buys plenty of important things that are zero sum - things that are in limited supply.

A big strategic one is access to education. Poor people do not have the same access to university education that rich people do. A big practical one is housing. Why do the children of well-off parents deserve access to education more than poor kids? Of course, in reality, there is no 'deserve' about it - it's just straightforward game mechanics.

But that's what public policy is all about - consciously deciding, do we like this? Do we like this business of limited numbers of people having it relatively easy, while large numbers of people continually face a whole other order of struggle, one that many just don't find their way out of? And heaven help the poor if even that conversation is captured by those who are already sitting pretty - especially those with moral conviction that the 'right sort of people' are already ok, and the only ones who fall through the cracks do so by moral failure.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by philwelch on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:17PM (#7151820)
I'm not convinced that university education is zero sum. Harvard is zero sum, but there's no important limit to the number of universities in the world nor the quality of each university.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dictum on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:34PM (#7151938)
The irreplaceable benefit of ivies, and especially Harvard, is getting an easy entry into established old-boy networks.

It sucks for individuals who don't get the opportunity to get this ticket to OBNs plus a good education, but for society as a whole, it's good that not everyone gets to go to Harvard. Universities should be part of their communities, not ivory towers. Students should come out of them willing to help their communities, not move to NY or SF and cash out quick. For an individual that's great. For society, it's mixed: sometimes the individual cashes out because they ve found a cure for cancer or a better way to grow food, but sometimes, because they played Soros with a country's currency.

Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by mcguire on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:24PM (#7151876)
Probably not naturally, no, but in practice they can likely be treated as zero-sum. Network effects and all.
Re:Technology and Wealth Inequality by dredmorbius on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:08PM (#7152680)
"Grahamians"?

Are you referring to pg? I'm not otherwise familiar with the term.

As to wealth being zero-sum, there's a pretty convincing case to be made, so far as I can make out, that wealth translates almost directly into per-capita resource consumption, and that the arguments that "decoupling" has occurred are pretty weak, particularly when considered at the global scale.

At best, as total energy utilization increases, per-capita efficiency in wealth generation improves, but that's quite consistent with the principles of dissipative systems: that higher levels of internal organization are possible, but only with higher total systemic throughput.

See: http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1vlksg/economic...