News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by steven2012 on Monday January 27, 2014 @10:31PM (#7135144)
To the OP:

If I were you, I would check your credit report IMMEDIATELY.

I'm in the same boat as you, except I'm in my 40s. Most companies use Experian or Equifax to do some sort of credit verification by asking these questions. However, about 5 years ago, the credit agencies merged my credit record with someone else with the same name, but entirely different birthday and location.

Evidently, they don't give a fuck because it took me years to get this wrong information off of my credit records. I don't understand how this isn't libel, since they are spreading false information about me, and that drastically affected my credit, and I had to jump through hoops to get everything corrected.

The thing that really sucks is that Experian STILL has the wrong information about me, so when I'm asked these credit questions, it's mixed with the other person's data, so I always fail the credit check. Despite having nearly perfect credit, I've failed the credit check numerous times, and like you, the decision has always been final, because no one appears to give a fuck.

The problem is I have no idea how to get Experian to refresh their data, even though it's several years old now.

It might be the case that the OP's credit history has been merged with someone else, and if this is the case, they need to fix it as soon as possible. Use the yearly free credit report to make sure there is no loans or credit cards associated with your name, and if so, you need to call every single credit agency and dispute it. It really sucks, and I don't understand how we let the credit agencies have this much power, where we the consumers have to suffer like this whenever THEY fuck up.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by otterley on Monday January 27, 2014 @11:05PM (#7135240)
Regarding your libel question: The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) expressly pre-empted state defamation suits against credit reporting agencies. 15 U.S.C. 1681h(e).

> [N]o consumer may bring any action or proceeding in the nature of defamation, invasion of privacy, or negligence with respect to the reporting of information against any consumer reporting agency ...

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by moultano on Monday January 27, 2014 @11:13PM (#7135273)
Ich. Did we get something in return out of that act or was it a coup? Do they have any legal obligation to get this stuff right?
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by patio11 on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @02:19AM (#7135833)
I have intimate personal experience with the FCRA. Sadly I don't have an hour to talk about it at the moment, but ping me any time. Short version: it's one of the most absurdly customer-friendly pieces of legislation in the US, assuming you know how to work it. There exist Internet communities where they basically do nothing but assist each other with using the FCRA to get legitimate debts removed from their credit report, which, when combined with the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, means you can essentially unilaterally absolve yourself of many debts if the party currently owning it is not on the ball for compliance.

The brief version, with the exact search queries you'll want bracketed: you send a [debt validation letter] under the FCRA to the CRAs. This starts a 30 day clock, during which time they have to get to the reporter and receive evidence from the reporter that you actually own the debt. If that clock expires, the CRAs must remove that tradeline from your report and never reinstate it. Roughly simultaneously with that letter, you send the collection agency a [FDCPA dispute letter], and allege specifically that you have "No recollection of the particulars of the debt" (this stops short of saying "It isn't mine"), request documentation of it, and -- this is the magic part -- remind them that the FDCPA means they have to stop collection activities until they've produced docs for you. Collection activities include responding to inquiries from the CRAs. If the CRA comes back to you with a "We validated the debt with the reporter." prior to you hearing from the reporter directly, you've got documentary evidence of a per-se violation of the FDCPA, which you can use to get the debt discharged and statutory damages (if you sue) or just threaten to do that in return for the reporter agreeing to tell the CRA to delete the tradeline.

No response from the CRA? You watch your mail box like a hawk for the next 30 days. Odds are, you'll get nothing back from the reporter in that timeframe, because most debt collection agencies are poorly organized and can't find the original documentation for the debt in their files quickly enough. Many simply won't have original documentation -- they just have a CSV file from the original lender listing people and amounts.

If you get nothing back from the reporter in 30 days, game over, you win. The CRA is now legally required to delete the tradeline and never put it back. Sometimes you have to send a few pieces of mail to get this to stick. You will probably follow-up on this with a second letter to the reporter, asserting the FDCPA right to not receive any communication from them which is inconvenient, and you'll tell them that all communication is inconvenient. (This letter is sometimes referred to as a [FOAD letter], for eff-off-and-die.) The reporter's only possible choices at that point are to abandon collection attempts entirely or sue you. If they sue you prior to sending validation, that was a very bad move, because that is a per-se FDCPA violation and means your debt will be voided. (That assumes you owe it in the first place. Lots of the people doing these mechanics actually did owe the debt at one point, but are betting that it can't be conveniently demonstrated that they owe the debt.)

If the reporter sends a letter: "Uh, we have you in a CSV file." you wait patiently until day 31 then say "You've failed to produce documentary evidence of this debt under the FDCPA. Accordingly, you're barred from attempting to collect on it. If you dispute that this is how the FDCPA works, meet me in any court of competent jurisdiction because I have the certified mail return receipt from the letter I sent you and every judge in the United States can count to 30." and then you file that with the CRA alleging "This debt on my credit report is invalid." The CRA will get in touch with the debt collection company, have their attempt timeout, and nuke the trade line. You now still technically speaking owe money but you owe it to someone who can't collect on the debt, (licitly [+]) sell it, or report it against your credit.

I just outlined the semi-abusive use of those two laws, but the perfectly legitimate use (for resolving situations like mine, where my credit report was alleging that I owed $X00,000 in debts dating to before I was born) is structurally similar. My dropbox still has 30 PDFs for letters I sent to the 3 CRAs, several banks, and a few debt collection companies disputing the information on my report and taking polite professional notice that there was an easy way out of this predicament for them but that if they weren't willing to play ball on that I was well aware of the mechanics of the hard way.

[+] Owing more to disorganization and incompetence than malice, many debt collection companies will in fact sell debts which they're not longer legally entitled to. This happened to me twice. I sent out two "intent to sue" letters and they fixed the problem within a week.

[Edit: I last did this in 2006 and my recollection on some of the steps I took was faulty, so I've corrected them above and made it a little more flow-charty.]

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by aaronem on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @02:21PM (#7139085)
Wow. Having tried to resolve in a friendly manner a bill in which Verizon charged me $150 for DSL service at an address to which they not only never provided service but at which they eventually noticed they can't provide service, period, due to its distance from their nearest central office -- and having had them respond by sending the bill to a collection agency -- this information will be of great use to me, and I thank you very kindly for it.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by marvin on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:04AM (#7136796)
Absurdly interesting comment for those of us who aren't lawyers with this specialty. Thanks.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by sounds on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @02:32AM (#7135881)
Please have a beer on me sometime. Bitcoin address?
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by patio11 on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @05:59AM (#7136394)
I appreciate the sentiment. As an alternative, consider donating one beer extra on your next charitable donation and think of me when you do it. That accomplishes your objective and has a higher utility to me than either beer (which I don't drink) or bitcoin (which I would need to drink rather a lot to start using -- for my reasoning on this, see hnsearch for [patio11 bitcoin]).
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by alinajaf on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @09:34AM (#7137225)
Not saying that Patrick endorses this but just in case you need any inspiration I'm just going to leave this here...

https://watsi.org/profile/d619049fdda6-mathayo

I put in a $100 this morning, let's get little baby Mathayo's head fixed :)

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by lorenzk on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @05:46AM (#7136372)
In case you are not being sarcastic on purpose: Patrick despises crypto currencies and very probably has no *coin address.

You could always buy bingo card creator.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by hrabago on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:18AM (#7136841)
This is one of the times I wish HN had a "saved comments" feature.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by blueskin_ on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:58AM (#7137058)
Fascinating. Is there any equivalent process for the UK, or any good resources on it?
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by rmc on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @01:34PM (#7138811)
Ditto! I wonder is there any EU law on this...
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by zeroDivisible on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @05:36AM (#7136349)
Very informative post - even if you don't live in the states, you can learn a thing or two from this one.

Thank you for your time.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by spitfire on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @10:33PM (#7141664)
An epic comment from patio11, Well done.

I happen to know that in America there are collections agencies which peak at bulk debt purchases then contact the debtor trying to illegally collect a debt they don't own.

Eventually the bulk debt package gets sold and a rightful collections agency calls them up trying to legally collect a debt.

Overall it is a very sleazy business.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by jackmaney on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @11:18AM (#7137927)
Interesting... Do you have links for the aforementioned internet communities?
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by patio11 on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @11:50AM (#7138122)
creditboards.com is the one I had in mind when I wrote that particular bit. I also liked the Motley Fool Credit Cards and Consumer Debts board back in the day. Sentiment on that board is that people should pay their debts, which is closer to my personal feeling than creditboards' prevailing sentiment that getting advantage on a debt collector or creditor is always justified and praiseworthy.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by patio11 on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @03:45AM (#7136077)
I already wrote a longer response but think your sentiment also deserves a shorter one: The trade for the FCRA over state defamation suits is actually a net win for consumers.

To win a defamation suit, you have to prove (generally) a) you factually don't owe the debt and b) the CRA should have been aware that you factually don't own the debt. Those can be fairly difficult to demonstrate. (Quick, demonstrate that you don't owe $30,000 to Bank of America under account number #123456. Note you may be responding to a sworn deposition from a Bank of America representative which says "I have reviewed our firm's records, kept in the ordinary course of business, and they show that he does, indeed, owe us $30,000 on account #123456.")

To win a FCRA suit, all you need is a return receipt from a letter you sent and then observe "No return receipt for the letter they sent in response dated within 30 days? Then presumption is they didn't send one. Unless they can immediately produce documentary evidence to the contrary, they're facially non-compliant, and I win automatically. We never reach the question of whether I actually owe the debt at issue. It's irrelevant."

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by kevinchen on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @12:15AM (#7135472)
Not a lawyer, but I think they are also required to have a process for disputing inaccuracies. Also, there is the free annual credit report law.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by ajre on Monday January 27, 2014 @11:17PM (#7135283)
Amazing that companies maintaining credit histories are relying on a person's name to map financial data to a 'person'.

Don't we have unique identifiers call Social Security Numbers?

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by orclev on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @12:18AM (#7135486)
Social security numbers are most emphatically not identification. The social security department tried for many years to get people to stop using your social as a form of identification, but companies (and sometimes even the government) still keep doing it. Social security cards printed before 1972 actually had a disclaimer printed on them that said "Not for identification purposes", but the message has since been removed. Although rare, there are actually duplicate social security numbers as well, and not everyone has a social security number. A number of religious groups, most notably some sects of Amish, refuse to get social security numbers and regularly fight legal cases to prevent having a social security number as a requirement for access to government services (although obviously not social security).
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by T-hawk on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @01:02PM (#7138586)
Popular misconception here: That disclaimer meant possession of the card is not identification, since it doesn't have any verification like a photo. The number does represent identification, as far back as 1943.

Source, the Straight Dope: http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/141/why-does-my-old...

The SS card is a name-to-number mapping once the name is already identified by another document like a driver's license or passport.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by josephlord on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @04:20AM (#7136182)
The US seems to have this quite backwards. They should be identifiers NOT authentictors although it is always likely to be slightly messy as some people won't have one and others may end up with multiple but having multiple people with the same number sounds pretty wrong.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by ajre on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @01:51AM (#7135746)
Well that's interesting... Thanks for debunking my notion of SSN as an identifier. Sounds like a problem that needs to be solved.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by masklinn on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @03:46AM (#7136079)
It could be solved as pretty much every other country on the planet does it, with a national ID number (& card). But the US population rises up in outrage every time this is suggested.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by yen223 on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:54AM (#7137041)
My country's government has done a lot of idiotic things, but I don't believe that instituting a national identification system is one of them.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by reuven on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @12:35AM (#7135546)
Social Security numbers are not ID numbers, as other posters have written.

Other countries (including Israel, where I live) do have ID numbers, and they are used universally -- by governments, employers, credit-card companies, and the like. I actually very much like the convenience that this gives me. I have one number to remember, and I don't worry very much about it being taken or used by someone else.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by lambda on Monday January 27, 2014 @11:37PM (#7135342)
No, Social Security Numbers are not unique.

Furthermore, many sources of credit information do not have access to your social security number to use as a key. Your phone company, cable company, oil company, and so on all may need to send your bills to collections and put a mark on your credit report, but they don't have access to your social security number (they may ask for it, but you aren't required to provide it).

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by lkbm on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @04:55PM (#7140042)
There are cases of them being re-issued accidentally, but they're supposed to be unique, and we have massive data systems based on that premise. Texas has only just recently begun transitioning from using SSN as the primary key for their statewide student (and school staff) database.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by cowsandmilk on Monday January 27, 2014 @11:46PM (#7135378)
when one credit agency merged me with another person, they put both our social security numbers on the credit report. I found it the weirdest thing in the world. They also combined our address records, so I had two different residences for my whole life, and residences for 15 years before I was born.

These documents often lack in consistency.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by kevinchen on Monday January 27, 2014 @10:40PM (#7135172)
Thanks for the heads up! I actually tried to check all three before writing this post. One has the correct info, but it looks like the other two agencies are a bit slower. I have to do those by fax.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by aptwebapps on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @04:53AM (#7136264)
Did you try https://www.annualcreditreport.com/ ? Note: this the official website maintained by all three CRAs.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by kevinchen on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @02:11PM (#7139028)
Yeah, the site couldn't find me for 2 of the 3 credit reporting companies.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by strathmeyer on Monday January 27, 2014 @10:39PM (#7135167)
Damn thinking about living under such a system makes me want to run off and live alone in the wood.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by dclara on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @12:06AM (#7135442)
Using a non-common name heals all. We have too many David in the same office. It's appealing for people to remember so that it sounds nice. But it defeats the purpose for us to have a name. Name should make you unique.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by egypturnash on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @01:30AM (#7135687)
He'll just pop back about eighteen years and ask his parents to pick a different one, then? Or spend a few hundred bucks, and a few days of hassle, to get it changed. Oh and plus ordering some new proofs of name change every now and then whenever he needs to submit a birth certificate to something. I'm sure he's got no sentimental attachment to his name either. I can't see your plan of "have a unique name" resulting in any problems for him.

(I have changed my name for very different reason, I know precisely how much hassle it causes in the US.)

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by tommu on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @01:47AM (#7135735)
In choosing egypturnash you achieved your objective.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by dclara on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @02:25AM (#7135850)
I went through the name changing process too, although not for myself. I don't mean he needs to change his name to avoid this type of problem. But I raised a common problem for people to concern, especially for the next generation.

Our culture is encouraging more and more fast food and simple, short thinking. I don't quite value that value, especially from developer's point of view. As you can see, how complicated processes are involved in VLSI chip design and circuit design in iPhone. If people applied the same culture or manner or habit, we would not have those great products.

His problem is a dilemma because financial systems have to be that strict. There are just two many duplicated names even in one location. But I agree that simple name are more welcomed in the real life. So maybe our financial systems should be adjusted to use more field to uniquely identify a person.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by kevinchen on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @11:12PM (#7141825)
What does the complexity of PCB design have to do with improving customer service?
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by dclara on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:37AM (#7142142)
I'm seeing things on both sides. They have bad customer service due to some reasons such as operational cost. But it's necessary for their business to disqualified you and they have the right to reject serving you since the service is free on your clients side. Please don't take it for granted that you must be served. That's why I suggest them if they cannot afford the customer support like other decent online financial systems, they may verify on large transactions only so that they may still get the chance to serve customers with small or medium transactions, while large transaction itself can cover the service cost.

On the other hand, did you see there is another post directly suggesting you to have your name changed with a middle initial. Don't think you are always 100% perfect and it's all other people's fault. This is another caveat in culture for the new generation. When conflict occurs, check on yourself side first. I gave you advice because I wish this type of thing would not happen to you again. If you don't learn the lesson, you may have more similar type of experience down the road. Didn't you see the other people's story with his credit record? Do you think it's fun?

You didn't get my point at all. Choosing simple name and always making job simple has the same culture background as fast food. I don't need to mention about the good or bad about it. Everybody can make his own choice. You may stick to your common name and have the other consequences. Other than you, yourself, who will care?

iPhone is not made with regular PCB design techniques, it's not that easy. VLSI design is not PCB design. With this type of attitude, you are not qualified for any of those professional work until you are trained or change your attitude. This is my point.

BTW, if you don't mind, can you please tell me how you down voted me? Is it done by complaining to the YC admin? I can have different opinion with you, but I'm helping you. I will not down vote you because I have different opinion with you. What a decent manner you have.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by kevinchen on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:41PM (#7145404)
> On the other hand, did you see there is another post directly suggesting you to have your name changed with a middle initial.

Right, I responded saying that I already have a middle initial which uniquely identifies me in the US, but Square won't take it on the signup form.

> Don't think you are always 100% perfect and it's all other people's fault. […] When conflict occurs, check on yourself side first. I gave you advice because I wish this type of thing would not happen to you again.

You are correct. However, I believe I made a genuine effort to find out what's going on: I spend hours researching on Square's website, comparing policies with other payment companies and other companies that use knowledge-based verification, and trying to ask them to clarify things I didn't understand.

> If you don't learn the lesson, you may have more similar type of experience down the road. Didn't you see the other people's story with his credit record? Do you think it's fun?

The person shared a name with someone else, so the system decided to merge their credit histories after awhile. That is not the customer's fault if they make a wholehearted effort to fix things.

> You didn't get my point at all. Choosing simple name and always making job simple has the same culture background as fast food. I don't need to mention about the good or bad about it. Everybody can make his own choice.

I did not choose my own name.

> You may stick to your common name and have the other consequences. Other than you, yourself, who will care?

For me, there is no way to win this game. Yes, I could waste a ton of time and money changing my name, updating government records, convincing everyone I meet that I am not an identity thief, re-purchasing things like domain names, etc. On the other hand, I could waste a bunch of time getting mixed up with other people named Kevin Chen.

Philosophically, that's asking humans to change themselves for the machine's convenience. As an engineer, I think that's a backwards concept and it should be the other way around.

> iPhone is not made with regular PCB design techniques, it's not that easy. VLSI design is not PCB design. With this type of attitude, you are not qualified for any of those professional work until you are trained or change your attitude. This is my point.

My attitude (as seen in other comments and in my post) is that I try to understand the other side and expect people to treat each other with courtesy.

> BTW, if you don't mind, can you please tell me how you down voted me?

If you were downvoted, I didn't do it. I just wanted to get some clarification on a seemingly off-topic comment.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by dclara on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:47PM (#7146246)
Thank you for your answer which clarified the misunderstandings. But your last post was not a clarification but raised a big question to me. It looks like I was talking nonsense about PCB design with customer service.

I never suggested you to change your name because I know it's your personal choice. Since I ran through it even with mistake and run a couple of rounds and waiting forever to get it done, name changing is still not a process with tons of time and effort. From this kind of experience, we learned that it is the government process. Because you haven't encountered too much hassle yet, you feel like this kind of tedious is not bearable. No, it's not. A lot of things are more tedious than that. That's why I took iphone design as an example. The same for software development and deployment. So much hassle.

Now I feel your attitude is a lot better. You did some research and try to understand their system. But still if you don't pay them a loyalty fee, you cannot argue. It's their choice and your choice is either go with it or take other action like changing your name.

The credit report example told us that it may occur at any time, and they are not going to change their process for the time being. I discuss this issue generally from the culture perspective because it's an alert to other people, not specifically go against you.

I feel sad for you to have this frustrated experiences. In the real world, we also have a lot of such experience. Again, think from the other side point of view, if they allow you which may take a risk for having a lot of free customers complaining against their customer support for real financial issues, what can they do? Then you may feel a lot easier to accept their decision.

Thank you for not down voting me. I took my time to make you understand.

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by logicchains on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @01:57AM (#7135765)
How about 'Root Null'? With a name like that, their systems would tremble.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by dclara on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @02:31AM (#7135876)
I guess eCommerce sites should know how to deal with online identity. Either verifying on transactions with large amount only or be really serious to come out with a paper process proven by the local financial institute. I recently encountered such case with US TreasuryDirect online. If they are not able to identify you, they have the paper process in place to you to follow.
Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by edraferi on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:25AM (#7136870)
well hello there little bobby tables!

http://xkcd.com/327/

Re:Square thinks I don’t exist by aptwebapps on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @04:47AM (#7136249)
I checked my credit history for the first time last year and discovered something similar with all three agencies. One of the bank accounts belonging to the other individual was actually older than me! I went through the online process with each agency and got it corrected. It took a little time but wasn't that hard. Don't have the exact link but if you poke around Experian's site you should find it pretty easily.