News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by callmeed on Thursday January 23, 2014 @12:43PM (#7109695)
The comments on this thread make me want to quit HN for good.

I don't know Linda but I volunteered at RailsGirls in SF this past weekend. It was a wonderful experience and I'm hoping to organize one here in my area. I've got 4 kids (3 girls, 1 boy) and we do everything from LEGOs to making movies to programming to SnapCircuits to building robots.

I'm excited about this book. Even if I wasn't, I honestly can't imagine anything bad/wrong coming out of its existence. It's good to know many of you can. A woman who already speaks and organizes events is writing and illustrating a children's book about programming–and some of you sit and criticize her motives, pedagogy, and presentation skills from your desks. Bravo.

I generally don't swear, but some of you are jackasses.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by GuiA on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:43PM (#7110159)
On the contrary, I'm very glad that HN is as critical as it is. Is it the Only Correct Worldview? Absolutely not, and if you rely primarily on HN to forge your opinion of tech and startups and programming, you're going to be very cynical and blasé.

I'm sure that if Donald Knuth posted a "Show HN: I've been writing a book called The Art of Computer Programming", half of the comments would be negative (a fair lot of them would likely be about programming isn't an "art" and how it's preposterous to call it one). And so what? Again, I don't see this as a problem unless you hold HN to be some sort of ultimate source of information and discussion, which it is absolutely not.

But given how insufferably pompous SV culture can be at times ("Yeah we're changing the world with our totally rad app, and building the most amazing engineering team in the world"), I actually find it refreshing how comments on HN will try to pick anything apart and find whatever flaws it may have. It can be borderline ridiculous at times, but honestly so is everything else.

tl;dr if you're sick of HN, you're probably spending too much time on it

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by callmeed on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:58PM (#7110282)
I'm all for criticism that involves actual analysis and attempts to be constructive. That's not what I saw/see here.

"Show HN" posts are specifically for criticism because (a) the OP asks for it and (b) we can actually put our eyes/ears/fingers on the product in question. This is a Kickstarter page for a product that hasn't even shipped yet. Instead of "I hope they cover loops", we get "she is odd in front of a camera" and "too many alarm bells".

And BTW, I'm all for picking apart "insufferably pompous SV culture"–in fact, I'd love to make some spoof startup videos doing exactly that. That's just not what I'm seeing here.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by manish_gill on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:43PM (#7110638)
No. The truth is that you're being overly defensive.

> I'm excited about this book. Even if I wasn't, I honestly can't imagine anything bad/wrong coming out of its existence.

So we should all make smiley faces and exclamation marks and ZOMG children will learn coding because "nothing bad can come out of its existence"?

> (a) the OP asks for it

Oh I'm sorry, I'll never criticise anything ever again if OP doesn't ask for it!

> (b) we can actually put our eyes/ears/fingers on the product in question.

Dude/Dudette, that is literally the Kickstarter model. Are you saying a page explaining things about the book, with a video is just there for fun? Maybe I should give every kickstarter some money because hey, nothing bad/wrong can come out of their existence and I'm not allowed to criticise it since I can't put my ears/fingers on the product in question.

> Instead of "I hope they cover loops", we get "she is odd in front of a camera" and "too many alarm bells".

It'll be a pretty boring Maths book if all they cover are integers, strings and variables.

And yes, she did look odd in front of the camera. And I'm allowed to say that in this comment. Because she created it and put it up on Kickstarter. You want universal acceptance and love? I got some bad news for you...

And btw, the video was actually bad. Sorry.

> And BTW, I'm all for picking apart "insufferably pompous SV culture"–in fact, I'd love to make some spoof startup videos doing exactly that. That's just not what I'm seeing here.

I see a lot of pompousness in this post too. Lets be reasonable. It's a freaking children's book. The author is a well established member of the development community and works for one of the most well known programming tutorial website. One can presume that they would have the time and money to start working on a book which has lots of drawings. People were writing books before Kickstarter existed you know.

But of course, how dare I criticise anything about those cute drawings. Think of the Children!

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by chc on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:16PM (#7110906)
You're allowed to be a hater — much like you're allowed to walk around creepily breathing on people's necks — but it still makes your comments unpleasant and drags down the level of discourse here.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by manish_gill on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:37PM (#7111023)
Because there was a fairly intelligent discussion going on here, in which people call other people Jackass. :)

And honestly? I was't being a hater. I was apathetic towards this whole thing before reading the GP.

In any case, I got nothing against the project itself. If it succeeds (which is fairly evident at this point), good for the people involved.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by maaaats on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:19PM (#7110924)
> But of course, how dare I criticise anything about those cute drawings. Think of the Children!

Your way of "argumenting" is not doing you any favors.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by manish_gill on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:37PM (#7111026)
I like how you ignored everything else in the comment.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by pavelrub on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:34PM (#7111373)
Wow, what a disgusting comment.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Confusion on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:50PM (#7110215)
So downvote and move on. You're not adding anything on topic with this meta comment and you could have foreseen it would hijack the top spot.

To add insult to injury, you're being drama-royalty: just because a few nobodies level unfounded criticism at her is not reason to "quit HN for good". Or you would've quit long ago. And instead of rubbing their face in their dumbness by explaining to them how wrong their criticism is, you're just going to stand on a soapbox and complain in general about how annoying the world is. Do something about it! And no, what you have posted is not doing something about it.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by MartinCron on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:00PM (#7110300)
There's nothing wrong with voicing concern about the state of a community that you care about.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Confusion on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:07PM (#7110372)
There is definitely something wrong with doing that with a top-level comment. It distracts from the actual topic. You should only do that if you have a very good reason, such as noting the same behavior multiple times on multiple topics.

You should certainly not do it within two hours after the article was posted, to allow time for selfcorrection. That is the point of the voting system.

There is also something wrong with doing it in an appeal-to-emotion fashion, threatening how this is 'almost making you leave'. You should clearly address the problem at hand, citing examples and explaining the problem, instead of hiding the actual problem that the fuss is about in the third paragraph.

Too little content, too much drama.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by MartinCron on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:27PM (#7110532)
You should only do that if you have a very good reason, such as noting the same behavior multiple times on multiple topics

A top level comment seems to be the only appropriate place to discuss the overall tone or tenor of a conversation. Responding to each dismissive/negative/unconstructive comment seems redundant and annoying.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:37PM (#7111022)
How about you don't respond to tone or tenor at all? It's a bad argument on the best of days (PG's hierarchy has that near the bottom, one step above straight up ad hominem.)

It's a diversion at best. If you feel someone is being unpleasant, deal with it. You needn't be pleasant to be right. If they're being unpleasant and wrong, reply with why they're wrong, or alternatively downvote and move on. No need for meta noise in any case.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by MartinCron on Thursday January 23, 2014 @05:28PM (#7111808)
I respectfully disagree with the idea that we should simply ignore unpleasantness in the community. A healthy ecosystem is determined by a lot more than mere factual correctness.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @05:44PM (#7111929)
But it's also determined by a lot more than a veneer of politically-correct pleasantness. I suggest that the best way to deal with such people is use the downvote button. Complaining about tone is just so much noise... it adds nothing to any discussion.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by burntsushi on Thursday January 23, 2014 @09:00PM (#7112939)
There is a very large gap between not being a jackass and being politically correct. The OP of this thread suggested the former.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @10:05PM (#7113129)
I see very little jackassery in this thread. Certainly nothing worth the amount of attention it's garnered.

I do, however, see a lot of useless, time-wasting, off topic tone arguments.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Crito on Thursday January 23, 2014 @06:59PM (#7112409)
A 'collapse thread' function would go a long way to eliminating the damage meta-threads and troll/flame-threads do to discussions. Yeah, I know there are extensions/userscripts that do it.

And yeah, I get the concern PG has about community fragmentation, but when I see a comment "leave HN" that has half a dozen replies under it, I really don't think I need to go down that thread of discussion any further.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by 14113 on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:03AM (#7113999)
If you install Hacker News Enhancement suite, it gives you the ability to collapse threads, as well a browse HN using keyboard shortcuts.

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/hacker-news-enhanc...

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by shangxiao on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:04PM (#7110347)
No there isn't, but the tactic was questionable (imho)
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by callmeed on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:05PM (#7110355)
You extrapolated my comment quite a bit. "Doing something" and "complaining" are not mutually exclusive–nor was my complaint about "how annoying the world is".

EDIT: wanted to also add I had no intention/foresight of "hijacking" the top spot. Most of my HN comments get lost in the ether–which I'm perfectly fine with.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Confusion on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:14PM (#7110423)
Do you honestly think any of the commenters you are complaining about read your comment and thought "I guess he's talking about me and he's right"?
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by davidw on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:00PM (#7110783)
As the father of a nearly 6 year old girl, my first reaction when seeing the nice drawings and "programming for kids" was "COOOL! How much? Let me get my wallet out!". But then I saw "32 pages", and... yeah, that flipped my skeptic bit too. 32 pages is fine, but what am I getting there? An extremely broad but shallow overview? A few concepts explained... how? A neat story about how cool computers are? I don't really get a good sense of what all is covered in the book. Any of those things might make a fine book that I would buy - I really like the art shown - but "computer programming for kids" in such a short book just doesn't sound realistic.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by leoc on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:06PM (#7111192)
The old Usborne computer programming books got a lot done in about 50 pages. But then they were quite textually dense, and by no means perfect as teaching tools either https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7110676 .
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by davidw on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:15PM (#7111253)
Yeah, 50 pages of text might get you something. 32 pages of mostly drawings gets you... The Gruffalo ( http://www.amazon.com/Gruffalo-Julia-Donaldson/dp/0142403873... ), a popular book for kids that we also own. So there's nothing wrong with the format, but just don't over promise in terms of what it is.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by e12e on Thursday January 23, 2014 @06:55PM (#7112386)
It's 32+16 pages, which totals 48... so if you're happy with 50, it's a bit strange to be upset about 32 pages of story and 16 pages of activities?

edit: It's much shorter than 50 pages full of text -- but I think this project looks great, especially for the target audience. IMNHO there's a pretty thin line between children's books like this, and when those actually interested (and a little older, maybe) can get started with any old programming book (many of the Ruby and Python books should work fine -- if we could learn 68000 asm in a foreign language from a magazine at 12, surely most of the "proper" books should be within reach of a motivated 10 year old?). What's needed is some books and materials to make the field interesting and fun to get into.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:47PM (#7110199)
WTF is this crap? Have we gotten so deep into the PC weeds that any criticism of something a woman does is de-facto sexist/incorrect?!

If the (rather mild) contents of this thread are what you're hemming and hawing about, please make good on your threat, leave and take the horse you rode in on with you.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by mkdir on Thursday January 23, 2014 @05:26PM (#7111784)
Whenever a woman is criticized in a remotely harsh tone, you will find men who instinctively rush to her aid. Men who will pat her on the head, compliment her, and apologize on behalf of everyone.

Don't blame women for this phenomenon (and I'm not saying you are); blame those men who view women as fragile children in need of protection.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by run4_too on Thursday January 23, 2014 @12:51PM (#7109751)
Thanks for this comment. I thought I was the only one feeling this.

I'd say this is a perfect example of why there aren't more women in computers. From what I've seen, a lot of women have a low tolerance for this level of overt critique, regardless of whether the critique is correct or not.

There is nothing horrible about this project that warrants a negative view, particularly one that doesn't present any alternative.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by hendzen on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:18PM (#7109951)
> From what I've seen, a lot of women have a low tolerance for this level of overt critique, regardless of whether the critique is correct or not.

Please stop talking.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by run4_too on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:24PM (#7110012)
Why? Do you find that uncomfortable?

A lot of women do. So do a lot of men. Computer science is filled with people on the poor side of "social skill set", and that rubs a lot of people the wrong way. That's why there are less women in the field - they simply aren't going to tolerate a default reaction that is insulting first and helpful only if you ignore the attitude.

Don't get me wrong, we turn off a lot of people - men and women - because of this, but we lose a lot more women, percentage wise.

And just a note: The irony of you telling me to "please stop talking" is, well, perfectly suited to the topic of our conversation.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by nonrecursive on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:34PM (#7110087)
I can't speak for hendzen, but your suggestion that women avoid tech because they're not as thick-skinned as men -- as opposed to being constantly exposed to hostility -- can easily be perceived as offensive. It sounds like you're propagating the myth that women are delicate flowers who just aren't as tough as men, which is part of what allows men to continue getting away with bad behavior.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by run4_too on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:46PM (#7110194)
Well, that's not what I'm saying. What I am saying is that women are less tolerant of assholes, and there is nothing wrong with that.

Women (overall of course, individuals vary) and men in general have different social cues and expectations. That's why each gender will act differently in the locker room than they will around the boardroom table.

Personally, I think there is nothing wrong with suggesting that women in general are less tolerant of being directly criticized in a public forum than men are. I don't view it as a sign of weakness. Men are much less tolerant of the behind the back insults that happen in women's circles than women are. The genders (overall, again) relate differently.

Neither is a sign of weakness, although they are exactly that when one of the two methods is dominant. And that's where we are today - computer science is closer to a locker room in culture and behaviour in many ways than it is to a boardroom. I see no reason not to accept the fact that many women would not be comfortable given that.

It isn't the women that need to change, though.

(I also see your point. My first comment may not have been properly clear.)

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by rimantas on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:29PM (#7110048)
You know, I think that socials skills are lacking those who are easily offended by anything.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by run4_too on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:35PM (#7110099)
Agreed and disagreed.

It's not healthy to be permanently offended, but presenting an idea and being told that it isn't good (by someone presenting no alternative) or that you have ulterior motives (by readers of a website directed to startups of all things) isn't something someone should need to deal with.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by derefr on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:22PM (#7110485)
> presenting an idea and being told that it isn't good (by someone presenting no alternative) ... isn't something someone should need to deal with.

I might be visualizing a different conversational domain than you are, but I'm not sure about this.

For example, when you build a bridge, there's a clear, objective line of quality somewhere above "the bridge stays standing." If I know enough about physics to see that your bridge won't stand, that doesn't mean that I also know enough about architecture to propose my own bridge -- but it doesn't have to; the knowledge that design X is fatally flawed is useful in its own right.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by run4_too on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:42PM (#7110634)
>For example, when you build a bridge, there's a clear, objective line of quality somewhere above

She isn't building a bridge, she's writing a story for children. The failure point is that nobody likes her story and therefore it doesn't sell. That's the absolute worst thing that can happen. Not a single child will be so critically scarred from her story that they never learn programming. Yet it may resonate for some.

There is no point to critique when the downside is so unbelievably inconsequential and the plus side is beneficial to a person, other than simply being an ass.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by derefr on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:07PM (#7110841)
But you made a general argument (no one should ever have to deal with negative feedback without a proposed alternative), not one specific to this case. And in the general case, it's wrong. I agree completely that it's right in this specific case -- but you were rhetorically over-reaching.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by lotsofcows on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:53AM (#7114297)
Social skills are those we develop to be able to function in a world of different weltanschauung. They are skills developed specifically to avoid offending anyone. Social skills can be taught but a thick skin can only be developed through experience.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by ahuth on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:01PM (#7110317)
Thanks for contributing, hendzen. Downvote.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday January 23, 2014 @10:50PM (#7113246)
What, you can't take a little bit of someone else getting a little bit of overt critique?
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by clark-kent on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:06PM (#7110359)
I believe the critiques are just a more vocal minority, most of us that think this is awesome, will simply upvote the topic without leaving a comment. This is even more common on HN where one-line comments like +1, awesome, great is frowned on.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by oe on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:57PM (#7110763)
To be fair the comments were pretty grim for the first hour. Positive comments seem to take more time? I'd hate to be the author and see that kind of response.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by shangxiao on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:19PM (#7109962)
I felt that the criticism was actually kind of light with the majority in support of the book.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by tinkerdol on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:31PM (#7110062)
Agreed. And since when is criticism a bad thing, esp. on HN? Especially since most of it here seemed meant to start a discussion, as in "I'm not sure this is the best way to teach programming, wouldn't X be better."

I thought this would be a worthwhile discussion to have as opposed to only useless "OMG this is the BEST thing ever" comments.

Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by callmeed on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:46PM (#7110197)
The initial comments appeared to me to be skewed toward criticism that was negative and/or tangential to the book's goals. It appears to have improved somewhat.
Re:Linda Liukas' Programming book for Children has Huge Firs... by SaneMethod on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:41AM (#7113524)
Must we really always find something to be critical of? Upvote the comments you think are worthy, ignore the rest (or indeed, just read the articles and ignore the comments altogether).

Comments about comments are an all too common contribution to noise in the SNR of the internet (and my apologies for contributing thereto! An effort at future signal clarity).

To all: Please avoid posting comments critical of critical comments, which in turn attract critical comments - down that road lies madness (and stack overflows).