News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by patrickmay on Friday January 17, 2014 @01:54PM (#7077661)
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."

The data shouldn't be collected in the first place.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by rayiner on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:46PM (#7077984)
"Second, even if petitioner did harbor some subjective expectation that the phone numbers he dialed would remain private, this expectation is not 'one that society is prepared to recognize as 'reasonable.'' Katz v. United States, 389 U. S., at 361. This Court consistently has held that a person has no legitimate expectation of privacy in information he voluntarily turns over to third parties. E. g., United States v. Miller, 425 U. S., at 442-444; Couch v. United States, 409 U. S., at 335-336; United States v. White, 401 U. S., at 752 (plurality opinion); Hoffa v. United States, 385 U. S. 293, 302 (1966); Lopez v. United States, 373 U. S. 427 (1963). In Miller, for example, the Court held that a bank depositor has no 'legitimate `expectation of privacy'' in financial information 'voluntarily conveyed to . . . banks and exposed to their employees in the ordinary course of business.' 425 U. S., at 442." Smith v. Maryland, 442 U.S. 735, 743-744 (1979).

Now, as a general principle, just because the Supreme Court has said something it doesn't mean they're not wrong, but the 4th amendment's use of the word "unreasonable" which is historically a signal indicating the need for judicial line drawing, puts this particular bit of line drawing peculiarly within their purview.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by afterburner on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:07PM (#7077738)
Really, not even when building, say, a RICO case against the mob?

I agree the NSA need to be reigned in, a lot, but there are grounds for listening in sometimes. Courts need evidence to convict.

EDIT: I agree that some kind of permission from a judge is needed for oversight.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by neohaven on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:08PM (#7077748)
Get a warrant. You can get evidence using one.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:44PM (#7077978)
Warrant requires probable cause.

How do you get probable cause without any information? How do you even get alerted to the idea that you should be opening an investigation into something, without any information?

I mean, how does that work in court? "Yes Your Honor, we would like to obtain a warrant to search Abdi Zullah's Internet-based communications for the next 3 months since we think that he maybe might be planning to blow something up. Maybe. And oh, this is all just a hunch, we've got no evidence at all for this yet."

You'd be laughed out of court, and rightfully so.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by revscat on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:55PM (#7078035)
Then so be it.

Plenty of criminals have been caught using traditional detective work. No issues, here. Many FEWER criminals have been caught using blanket surveillance, and the cost to democracy is high.

I'd rather have the occasional bomber than the government having this kind of access.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:11PM (#7078136)
> Plenty of criminals have been caught using traditional detective work.

Yes, but that's on the other side of time's arrow. The whole point to counter-terrorism is to detect it and stop it before (not after) it has happened.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by revscat on Friday January 17, 2014 @05:19PM (#7078845)
And that is the cost to living in a free society: occasionally you have to deal with violent assholes.

Again, I'd rather live in a society where the innocent are free and unmonitored than one which the NSA, etc., reign supreme. Counter-terrorism efforts are inherently anti-democratic and anti-freedom, despite protestations to the contrary.

Not interested.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Crito on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:20PM (#7078187)
Oh oh, while you are at it can you give us the "ticking bomb" justification of torture to? It's been a while since I've heard it; it's always worth a good laugh. I love ridiculous shit like this.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Zikes on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:03PM (#7078078)
I think we're all well aware that if the authorities were able to implement a perfectly omniscient surveillance network then it would effectively solve all manner of crimes.

The point is, we don't want it.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:09PM (#7078125)
Yes, that's why they refer to the balance between privacy and security instead of all-or-nothing concepts.

No one is asking for omniscience, so feel free to hang the strawman back in the barn. On the other hand, many are asking not to be left completely defenseless.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by DerpDerpDerp on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:15PM (#7078157)
> How do you get probable cause without any information? How do you even get alerted to the idea that you should be opening an investigation into something, without any information?

You're missing the fundamental point that we don't think the government should have this power.

The police should have to have an explainable reason, backed by some kind of evidence besides "I just feel that way" to use state power to infringe on the privacy or rights of a citizen even if that means some criminals get away with their crimes.

The potential abuses of unchecked investigative ability (and other law enforcement powers) is far, far more dangerous than a few mobsters.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:27PM (#7078214)
> You're missing the fundamental point that we don't think the government should have this power.

I'm not missing that at all, but I am saying it's hypocritical to say "just go get a warrant, geez". If it had been that easy FBI would already being doing it.

It's easy to just mandate some social construct you'd like to achieve, but that does mean you also have to accept the consequences.

The consequences of "no foreign network intelligence" isn't to merely make it a bit more difficult for NSA to do their job, it's to completely eliminate the ability of NSA to do their job, with all of the counter-terror consequences that will entail from that.

While you may be perfectly willing to have the rest of America take on that risk, 3000 people at a time, don't act like you can have your cake and eat it too by simply offering up an alternative course of action which can never be implemented in practice.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Zikes on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:17PM (#7078173)
It is no strawman. You're advocating that the government be given unfettered access to information that would normally require a warrant in order to be given permission to get a warrant.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:28PM (#7078216)
> You're advocating that the government be given unfettered access to information

Where have I advocated completely unfettered access? I'd be interested to see that.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Crito on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:30PM (#7078225)
Oh right, not unfettered access, just access when somebody has a "hunch". Very different!
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @06:33PM (#7079224)
Did you even read what I wrote, or is pattern-matching against text all you're able to do in these threads?
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Crito on Friday January 17, 2014 @06:45PM (#7079275)
Give to to me straight: Do you think that a search warrant should be obtained before violating the privacy of Abdi Zullah?

My question uses the word "should", not the word "could".

Because it sounds like you are saying that the investigation of Abdi Zullah should be permitted to circumvent the courts because the courts and the protections that they rightfully confer would not permit the violation of Abdi Zullah.

It sounds like you think the 4th amendment is great under 'normal circumstances', and it sounds like you think that "terrorism" and "I've got a hunch" should be a secret password for a process that circumvents it.

If this is a misunderstanding, then I do not seem to be the only one misunderstanding you. You should work on your delivery.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @07:21PM (#7079430)
> Give to to me straight: Do you think that a search warrant should be obtained before violating the privacy of Abdi Zullah?

For law enforcement? Yes, at least to the extent that an "unreasonable" search would be performed.

For military applications (such as, yes, counter-terrorism)? No, for the same reason we didn't get a warrant to wiretap Hitler's generals. I would still say that searches against any particular individual be supported by more than a single analyst's "hunch", or that non-individualized searches should be looking for particular things instead of just trawling what they can, if only for resource efficiency reasons.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Crito on Friday January 17, 2014 @08:58PM (#7079693)
I don't believe that anybody is suggesting that the CIA or NSA should request search warrants for non-citizens located outside of the US. Even if you had probable cause the courts would just be perplexed that you were coming to them with something from outside of the country.

(Many people, myself included, think that there is something wrong with how we are currently handling those situations, but search warrants for non-citizens outside of the country are obviously not the answer we are looking for there.)

Domestic terrorists? Get a warrant.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Saturday January 18, 2014 @06:41PM (#7082764)
What are you talking about? Domestic terrorists already require a warrant.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Crito on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:56PM (#7078045)
Nobody ever said police work is easy, or is suppose to be easy. There are a number of rights that we could dispense with to make their job easier. Imagine how easy their job could be if they could go wherever they pleased, and detain and interrogate whoever they pleased for as long as they pleased.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by MrZongle2 on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:57PM (#7078049)
"And oh, this is all just a hunch, we've got no evidence at all for this yet."

Then, really, the 4th Amendment should be tossed out the window because all citizens should be subjected to search at any given time based upon the "hunch" of somebody in law enforcement.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:11PM (#7078141)
> You'd be laughed out of court, and rightfully so.

I included the last sentence of my comment since you apparently missed it the first time.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by afterburner on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:06PM (#7078097)
I agree that some kind of permission from a judge is needed for oversight.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by saraid216 on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:27PM (#7077872)
Okay, not to single you out, but after months and months, this is really getting on my nerves:

> reigned in

There is no 'g' in "rein". They're homophones. They mean different things. "Reigning in the NSA" is what Alexander is doing. "Reining in the NSA" is what you want Obama to do.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Crito on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:48PM (#7078000)
You're not wrong, but the situation is complicated by "reins" often being used to talk metaphorically about being in control. Alexander is "at the reins" of the NSA. Obama "took the reins" during his first inauguration.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpclark on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:54PM (#7078032)
Yes, I believe that is the origin of the phrase "reined in". Reining in is the act of pulling on the reins to stop a horse.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by Crito on Friday January 17, 2014 @02:58PM (#7078056)
Well, I'd say that "reining in" refers to pulling back on the reins to stop the horse, while being "at the reins" or "having the reins" refers to merely possessing them (they could be used to stop the horse, or turn the horse, or have it speed up, etc).
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by giardini on Friday January 17, 2014 @08:42PM (#7079649)
Just something I'd like to toss out for consideration. Can RICO be used against the NSA itself? A second approach: target NSA contractors for RICO violation?
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by res0nat0r on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:03PM (#7078082)
This doesn't apply to data about you. It has been ruled legal that ATT / 3rd parties can collect and store who you call and when since this data belongs to them anyway.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by dllthomas on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:46PM (#7078290)
Unless it's covered by HIPAA...
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by giardini on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:13PM (#7078148)
patrickmay: "The data shouldn't be collected in the first place."

Nor should the tools that collected the data continue to exist. They should be disconnected and destroyed. All data, archives and logs, upstream and down, should be destroyed. All copies should be destroyed.

Any and all specifications of how the system is built should be gathered and destroyed.

Those persons who managed, conceived, designed and built the systems and wrote the software should be terminated w/o pension and tried for crimes against the state. I'm talking top to bottom of NSA.

They should be, regardless of conviction, forever banned from re-implementing any similar systems forever. They should also be marked someway in the public record as having participated in the creation of these systems so that we can track them all their lives and ensure that they do not repeat what they have done. A federal agency should be created to track them and check periodically that they are not violating these terms. In other words, they should serve a permanent "parole", with their civil rights reduced(as they have reduced those of millions of Americans), the remainder of their lives. They have forfeited their civil rights by participating in the NSA's offenses and should pay dearly for it.

Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by mpyne on Friday January 17, 2014 @03:32PM (#7078233)
Wow, I'm literally not sure if this is satire or not.
Re:Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government st... by giardini on Friday January 17, 2014 @08:00PM (#7079546)
It's not satire.

Both Clapper and Alexander have perjured themselves trying to hide what the NSA does. Is there a bigger arrow anywhere today pointing to a fundamental problem in government? This is way beyond "Cool Hand Luke"'s "We've got a failure to communicate."

Let's go through what I said item by item:

WHAT I SAID EARLIER:

"Nor should the tools that collected the data continue to exist. They should be disconnected and destroyed. All data, archives and logs, upstream and down, should be destroyed. All copies should be destroyed...Any and all specifications of how the system is built should be gathered and destroyed.."

ELABORATION:

Because if they aren't, then at any moment in the future the machines can be turned on again instantly and the process restarted, or the data retrieved. Where is our security in that?

In fact, because of what has happened, we must also either establish a method of oversight for the NSA or abolish it entirely. Reason for this is that the NSA has spun out of control (at least) once already and there is nothing to prevent it from happening again. Congressional oversight did not control the NSA nor did the Executive branch control the NSA; some other oversight is required at the very least. At worst the entire agency should be liquidated.

WHAT I SAID EARLIER:

"Those persons who managed, conceived, designed and built the systems and wrote the software should be terminated w/o pension and tried for crimes against the state. I'm talking top to bottom of NSA."

ELABORATION:

They have violated the most fundamental, the most basic of our human rights. To prevent this happening again they must be prosecuted and punished.

WHAT I SAID EARLIER:

"They should be, regardless of conviction, forever banned from re-implementing any similar systems forever. They should also be marked someway in the public record as having participated in the creation of these systems so that we can track them all their lives and ensure that they do not repeat what they have done. A federal agency should be created to track them and check periodically that they are not violating these terms. In other words, they should serve a permanent "parole", with their civil rights reduced (as they have reduced those of millions of Americans), the remainder of their lives. They have forfeited their civil rights by participating in the NSA's offenses and should pay dearly for it."

ELABORATION:

Again, once they are officially convicted and therefore felons they should be treated as such. Even if they aren't convicted, their future activities will have to be tracked until they die and their work product reviewed. Furthermore, because of the flagrancy of the violation and the dangers posed thereof, conviction or not, they should be prevented forever from participating in such activity again.

I know we're trying to put the genii back into the bottle here. But because we can't put the genii back into the bottle doesn't mean we can't for all practical purposes do damage control on his work. We can at least rip him and the bottle to shreds, burn every piece and scatter each shred under a different rock in some other part of the world. And by putting a federal agency on prosecutory watch for the next 20 years, we can suppress some of the damage already done by the NSA and some of the damage that their information-gathering would otherwise have done.

Satire, my ass.

The domestic portion of the NSA needs to be dismantled completely and utterly and the FISA court system discarded. The older open established legal framework for getting warrants must be restored for use by _all_ governmental agencies.