The issue is lots of third-rate universities proliferating for people who just don't belong in college. That's the bubble—not particular majors.
In fact, many of these terrible universities offer far more vocational/non-liberal-arts majors than the elite universities. You won't find communications majors at Yale. Indeed, the abundance of liberal arts majors is probably an indicator of a quality institution.
But that's not because of the great value of Harvard's teaching; it's because of what the two of them did in high school that got one into Harvard and the other into UP. It's not as though the two of started out equivalent at time of graduation but the benefit of $160,000 worth of Marxist post-whatever hogwash training turned the Harvard kid into a real-world champion. After being the kind of person who could fight his way into Harvard to begin with, then spending four years socially integrating with the children of the rich, smart, and powerful, then getting to walk away with a Harvard diploma and his contacts list, he could have majored in Sustainable Shoe Repair and he'd be no less prepared for success than with most non-STEM majors.
But for the kids who aren't qualified for entry into an elite university, what they major in (at least for a terminal degree) will matter more.
Indeed, the abundance of liberal arts majors is probably an indicator of a quality institution.
Well, yes, it's an indication that the more prestigious the institution, the less what they learn in class matters.
For example, a lot of philosophers make great programmers. Not because they specifically learned important things in philosophy, but because they know how to think logically.
I'm more impressed by the critical thinking in the physics department than the philosophy department, but departments like philosophy and law are way ahead of the pure activist studies departments, because they tend to genuinely reason about issues from multiple perspectives, not just proselytize the approved one.
Eh? I'm not sure what your college experience is based on, but I don't even know what you mean by "activist studies" departments. Most humanities classes don't even touch contemporary politics, and I couldn't even guess the political leanings of (for example) my literature professor.
I'd probably agree with your criticism when it comes to, say, gender studies. But the majority of liberal arts classes don't involve the "teacher's political agenda." In my experience, it's extremely possible to do well while completely disagreeing with the professor as long as your argument is well-reasoned and articulate.
But how can you blame them when it's become a requirement for pretty much any job, and not going is a social stigma.
http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d11/tables/dt11_286.asp
Their pay 10 years out is also supposedly in the top 10% (I recall the logic courses help them do well on the LSAT...):
http://www.forbes.com/2009/08/02/college-degree-pay-careers-...
Slide 13 is of particular interest, almost a third of all graduates wish they could:
a. Pursue more scholarship opportunities. While there is obvious parallel to reduction of their net debt, I also take this point as motivation to study harder (Quite a few of scholarships are merit based).
b. Pursue a different major. It is no secret that some majors have jobs out there that have high starting salaries.
c. Getting a job while in college. This is another work harder point.
http://blogs.wsj.com/atwork/2013/04/29/and-the-highest-paid-...
Here you can see jobs that pay well. I think it is safe to say, that significant portion of people who want to switch majors did not choose one of the well paying majors. AFAIK every single one of those top paying majors requires you to study hard.
As I see it, the main problem with college is that we as a society have put all of our eggs into a basket which is not owned by we the people (the public). If you would like to see a future in which all Americans go to college, then the cost should be spread across everyone. If you don't, then, I think we have different views of what the future could be. We should go back to free tuition, at least for state colleges, because an education requires so much more material than it did a century ago that stopping at K-12 was shortsighted/irresponsible, and now other countries are eating our lunch. An analogy is the private prison system: when we began outsourcing incarceration we created an incentive for prison industry lobbyists to interfere with the criminal justice system. Show me a private school that costs less than a public one.
Student motivation is a red herring. I've met just as many slackers who didn't go to college. In fact I would go as far as to say that pure book learning without introspection is not conducive to the human spirit. The best things I learned in college were how to redefine myself, and how to explore alternate ways of seeing the world. In essence my conscious and subconscious minds both grew as needed. Sometimes I wish that the US didn't have such a puritanical stance on recreation because we are in danger of creating a dystopian, authoritarian future. I wish with all our wealth and potential we could live more like europeans and invest in culture and the human experience. College isn't a trade school, I mean, who goes there to study besides freshmen?
The only way your proposed system could work would be if the government required all degrees to cost no more than X$ or severely restricted the number of people it paid for. More realistically, we can stop subsidizing students past 5 or perhaps 10K$ per year.
So this was actually the intention behind transitioning colleges from free to paid. It created the student loan bubble because there was no check on how much college could cost. To fix it, we could just do the reverse and make state colleges free with their budgets set by the government, substantially lower than they are now.
Free education is done from the K-12 level. Its' done in many European countries as well.
Is there any reason that the US government is special, and won't be able to handle a free university education without going bankrupt?
If you go to college to get a degree that is useless, then you will work at Walmart. I mean, seriously, is that really fucking news?
What's news is how colleges still manage to increase their tuition costs some 5 times the inflation rate year over year just to crank out vast quantities of mindless degrees that are of no use in this economy.
Bill Gates thinks it's a supply-and-demand issue, but it sounds like unmitigated greed to me.
Not true, and this is a large issue of the STEM mindset. People majoring in communications or business can work just as hard as someone who is a STEM major (note: I say work just as hard, not that one is more or less difficult). It is what you, as the individual, choose to take from the experience.
Most of the sales team that I work with must have majored in 'fucking around' then. Somehow they manage to work just as hard as us dev guys and pull their weight anyway.
It could be that both 1) People genuinely interested and determined to get into business, and 2) People fucking around major in business. This matches my anecdotal experience.
I wouldn't call it "valuable in the current workplace", but "valuable in the current world" instead. The former makes it sound like the situation would be solved if only corporations/government created more jobs for those unemployed/not valuable people. However, people with useful/practical skills can freelance as well, or start their own businesses. The problem is no one (even other people) is willing to pay them money for their skills, talents or output.
Businesses aren't looking for finance guys, salesmen, and accountants? My technology company has quite a few, including me. I guess I should tell them they're wasting millions of dollars a year.
Perhaps the difference between the US and UK higher education systems is that I did all that for $5000/year in fees. The ludicrous debt that some people get into is not particularly justifiable for social or educational reasons.
Wouldn't you have done all of that even without going to university?
> Universities are (obviously) places to learn in the academic sense, but an undergraduate degree is also a framework for developing into an independent adult.
By the time you're 20, you should already be an independent adult. I think modern parents are generally not doing a good job raising their kids, if people hit 18 and then need 4 more years to "become adults".
What are you basing should be on?
The age at which you're a functioning adult varies greatly among cultures, and it's usually based on necessity. In some cultures, children continue living with their parents well into their 20s and by definition aren't independent. There are also places where people we would consider children get married and start families of their own.
The age of adulthood is also constantly changing. I've seen polls that show that modern American's don't consider adulthood to really start until your mid 20s, while 150 years ago 12 year-olds went to work and were responsible for providing for the family.
As life expectancy and wealth goes up, the age before you are forced to take on adult responsibilities goes up.
Is this really a fair expectation? Your mind hasn't really fully matured until your early or mid 20s (25 is the most oft-cited age if I recall). I'd say that yes, when you're 18, you need about 4 more years to become an adult. Maybe spending $40k on a degree you don't really care about isn't the best way to do that, but I hardly think 18-year-olds are adults.
I'm in college and the apathy I'm surrounded by, despite being at a top college, is quite disappointing.
In grad school, I was a 4.0 student. I got it.
I had the huge luck of being able to go to my local four-year, decent university for virtually free because my father was a campus architect. If it wasn't for the fact that I could squander my time taking random classes without fiscal penalty, I would have probably dropped-out or gone to a two-year school to get my act together. I only detail that to emphasize the mental shifts that sometimes happen with extremely-young adults.
Not all STEM majors and not all computer related majors are in demand btw.
Personally, I dropped out of Brown 2 years ago, and pursued other opportunities that wouldn't leave me and my family in a mound of debt upon graduation for returns that wont be monetarily or mentally satisfying (Not many interesting options for ChemE's beyond working for big oil/big pharma/big food co). Still grinding it out, but I wouldn't go back unless things change, and considering how things are now (and how they continue to be more of the same) and what I have done since, some college grads I've worked with say I'll come out ahead, but at least I know I'm not getting behind…
[0] http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user3303...
[1] http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user3303...
For instance, the first is tuned to make it appear that college and high school graduates are on exactly equal footing in mid-2006, whereas in fact in 2006 the median income of a high-school graduate with no higher education is $37,000, but the median income for a bachelor degree holder with no higher education is $60,000.
It's useful for comparing the change in the two values over time, but it is not useful for comparing the values of the two at any given time. All I'm saying is, be careful not to let your intuition get in the way, and think carefully about what the graph is saying.
All I'm saying is, if one wants to work 40+ years of their life putting a significant portion of ones increasingly diminishing difference of median income levels (which for those with high expectations for oneself, the difference is a joke anyways in the scheme of things) into 401k/403b/RothIRA's "invested" for them in the thing we call a stock "market", while paying off increasing larger debts for things one does not need to survive or to enjoy life and that's if one is apart of the decreasingly smaller group of those "successful" enough to come out "ahead" in that game, that's ones prerogative, not mine.
But let me not sit here and type away on the internet and think that some graph is going to wipe away the cognitive dissonance of populations…
There are entire classes of misleading graphs that are misleading despite being technically, literally, valid.
Your snark is not helping.
Let's have an example… x = 60,000, y = 30,000 with difference, d = 30,000
>the fact that both wages fall a similar percentage relative
Let's pick some random rate and apply it to both, r = %10.
Now what decreased more: %10 of x or %10 of y?
>the gap between both wage classes remained the same
Really? Do the math, and d is now = 27,000.
I'm sure such math helps BoA in its positions in the private student loan market (and beyond) in such an environment.
Let's not pretend that my snark stands in the way of your understanding, clearly you had that going for you anyways…
Well, no. In dollar terms, the gap would have become smaller.
The whole purpose of a graph is that it makes information visually available and easily digestible. If you have to "read it carefully to not be mislead," that is a faulty graphic.
I'm not attacking your clarification, just clarifying my original personal anecdote that was dependent on state of the status quo and its direction (rates and % change, respectively).
[0] http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/graph
1. Relatively few colleges where you can get required networking. 2. People that do that generally do not have a problem with loans. 3. To build a network you got to be motivated.
In my experience, there's a lot of value in giving students the opportunity to step up and run a small self-governing enterprise. It's one way to counter-act the extension of adolescence into the college years, and I'd like to think that MIT isn't a unique place in regard to the value of independent living. I think there's enough value there that I give annually to MIT's Independent Residence Development Fund so that others continue to have the same opportunities I did.
Nit: Your use of the plural in "amount of fraternities/sorrorities[SIC]" is a hint that you've made an amount vs. number mistake. Also, sorority is the correct way to spell the word.
People who would have been "nerds" at other schools, forgive the crass stereotype, fit right into many MIT frats. Which is an awesome thing for MIT, but doesn't really help your argument.
1. Extremely easy access to loans for higher education. This, along with systematic misinformation makes for tons of philosophy/liberal arts majors that do not know what to do with themselves and their massive debt at the end of education.
2. Lack of student motivation. I went to college in order to obtain skills and knowledge. On the other hand, many people have other priorities as evidenced by amount of fraternities/sorrorities as well general alcohol consumption in college (Can anyone find number of liters of alcohol purchased in area near universities vs average? I remember seeing quite stark figure few years ago).
So, #1 was brought by college for everyone mantra. Problem with that is illustrated in #2, college should be only for people that want to and are willing to learn. IMHO, until those two issues are reconciled this particular higher education problem will not go away.