News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by argonaut on Friday January 10, 2014 @05:47PM (#7040174)
No, the graph is very misleading. The first one is not of rates of change, it's % relative to 2007. Which is a really really weird way to graph things.
Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by cinquemb on Friday January 10, 2014 @06:10PM (#7040302)
Yet it clearly stated what it was measuring in the title regardless of if "really weird" or not. If I was reading a graph that measured % moles of two different substances in a solution over a period of time that was adjusted at t=x and mentioned for in the title, sure, some might see that as "really weird", but one will still be able to extract information from it and apply it in a context of a report (as BoA did in theirs and mine in my statement).

But let me not sit here and type away on the internet and think that some graph is going to wipe away the cognitive dissonance of populations…

Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by argonaut on Friday January 10, 2014 @06:47PM (#7040487)
The graph is misleading because it misleads the reader into believing that college grads and non-college grads made the same real wage in 2007, disguising the fact that there was a substantial gap between their wages at 2007. The fact that both wages fall a similiar percentage relative to 2007 only tells us that the gap between both wage classes remained the same, in effect telling us nothing.

There are entire classes of misleading graphs that are misleading despite being technically, literally, valid.

Your snark is not helping.

Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by cinquemb on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:05PM (#7040601)
Telling us nothing, or you nothing?

Let's have an example… x = 60,000, y = 30,000 with difference, d = 30,000

>the fact that both wages fall a similar percentage relative

Let's pick some random rate and apply it to both, r = %10.

Now what decreased more: %10 of x or %10 of y?

>the gap between both wage classes remained the same

Really? Do the math, and d is now = 27,000.

I'm sure such math helps BoA in its positions in the private student loan market (and beyond) in such an environment.

Let's not pretend that my snark stands in the way of your understanding, clearly you had that going for you anyways…

Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by argonaut on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:26PM (#7040703)
I won't respond to this more than I already have. It's pretty clear you're reading too much into it emotionally.
Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by cinquemb on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:34PM (#7040741)
Haha yes, this has been pretty amusing to answer tangential nitpicking with basic arithmetic.
Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by seanmcdirmid on Friday January 10, 2014 @10:07PM (#7041323)
The discussion was about intellectual honesty, not math.
Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by mikeyouse on Friday January 10, 2014 @09:39PM (#7041225)
His obstinance aside, here is a better graph of the value of college diplomas:

http://i.imgur.com/s3GqHl2.png

Re:How the College Bubble Will Pop by auctiontheory on Saturday January 11, 2014 @02:17AM (#7041923)
The fact that both wages fall a similiar percentage relative to 2007 only tells us that the gap between both wage classes remained the same

Well, no. In dollar terms, the gap would have become smaller.