News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by dcc1 on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @01:58PM (#7025630)
This is bad news (despite being a BMW owner)

In future driving will no longer be fun, if you want to drive "non-automated" car or disable "auto-pilot" your insurance company will automatically jack up your premium, since they would consider self driving cars "safer"

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by imgabe on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:12PM (#7025745)
If you want to have fun, there will no doubt be private tracks where you can go and drive in a fun way. As someone who just gave up commuting about 1 traffic-laden hour each way, driving stopped being fun long, long ago.

Too many of my commutes were made an unnecessary 50% or more longer because of drivers who were probably having a lot of fun until they caused an accident and backed up the road for everyone else.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Pxtl on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:28PM (#7026344)
At the same time, the entire continent is finally pushing back on that 1-hour commute. People are returning to cities, transit and infill and dense construction are becoming political issues, etc. Part of the impetus for this re-urbanization is the misery of commute.

Beyond commuting woes, density is also more efficient for providing services and for environmental concerns.

So I'm slightly worried that a move towards self-driving cars will allow us to backslide on this progress. Obviously I want the technology - it will be safer, more efficient, and healthier - but I'm worried about how culture could shift around it.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by joosters on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:32PM (#7026852)
When did people leave cities then? Which cities were shrinking but now aren't?
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by theatraine on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:38PM (#7026894)
This article gives a good overview in the USA: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Largest_cities_in_the_United_St...
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by joosters on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:35PM (#7027318)
I can't see any cities there that significantly shrank and then grew again. Care to name some if you know of any?
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by bskap on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @09:28PM (#7028379)
New York's population was steady from 1950-1970 before dropping about 10% between 1970 and 1980. Considering that the US population increased by about 50% between 1950 and 1980, I'd consider that a rather significant decrease.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by randallsquared on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:16PM (#7027575)
Backslide, or return to making forward progress against crowding? ;)
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by smileysteve on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:25PM (#7026315)
I autocross and take my car to a private track for time trials, I'm starting to face the fact that this is not the best plan because there is now a karting track (0-120 in 6 seconds) that is closer to me.

My car, that I justified it's sportiness because of this hobby, is more expensive at the track, burns more, fuel, has more maintenance issues, and could just never perform the 3gs that a kart can.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Pxtl on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:29PM (#7026354)
Embrace the Kart. My dad used to do that as a hobby and they're impressive machines. Just remember that you've got no crumple zones and your legs are right at the front.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by rayiner on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:30PM (#7025881)
As someone with a similar commute, I lament I can only upvote this once. Every time I-95 severely backs up because some asshole managed to crash on a day with perfect weather and visibility, I think to myself: "I hope it was worth it."
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by wwweston on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:38PM (#7026416)
As bad as being stuck in traffic is, usually you're having a better day than whoever was involved in the wreck, most of whom probably didn't do it on purpose.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by joshu on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:06PM (#7026161)
I would LOVE to have the car drive me autonomously to the track and back. Highway driving is tiring/dangerous/boring.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by rayiner on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:26PM (#7025854)
As a BMW owner myself, I say: "good riddance to driving being fun." I used to get a kick out of it when I was younger, but now that I'm married with a kid it's just an exercise in paranoia and frustration. People are fucking nuts in the way they drive. My friend just got T-boned hard enough to flip his car 360 degrees a couple of months ago, by some asshole speeding in the shoulder as traffic was backed up. I see an accident at least once a week commuting into Philadelphia. Teenagers (16-20) just plain shouldn't be on the road the way most of them drive. It's no wonder that traffic accidents are the leading cause of death for people 5-35. The government should ban non-self-driving cars as soon as feasible. If you think about it: it's utterly ridiculous that a publicly-funded infrastructure with a crucial utilitarian purpose should be used for "fun."
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by sukuriant on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:14PM (#7027164)
"by some asshole speeding in the shoulder as traffic was backed up."

fun driving and reckless endangerment of the people on the road around you, including aggressive disregard for the rules of the road, especially driving on the shoulder are two very, very, very different things.

Raise the speed limits and make fines and enforcement more frequent for not using turn signals, aggressive lane-changing where other people are on the road, tail-gating, driving in the shoulder (REALLY???) and so on.

Oh, and make that driving test harder.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:03PM (#7027501)
I'd say lower the speed limits. And implement ANPR systems on every straight part of every road, make them enforce those limits in a ruthlessly automated way. That should finally let traffic engineers do some real work optimizing the road network.

And then of course ban non self-driving cars from public roads the moment it becomes feasible.

EDIT: disregard the "lower the speed limits" part. I'm not sure why I wrote it (it was a long and tiring day...). Speed limits are mostly fine, but adherence to them is not. I stand by the rest of the comment.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by sukuriant on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:27PM (#7027613)
Roads are already engineered in the general case for faster than the speed limit. Why do you want them to go even slower?
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:36PM (#7027661)
You're right; I'm not sure why I wrote about lowering them.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by rayiner on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:48PM (#7027998)
> fun driving and reckless endangerment of the people on the road around you, including aggressive disregard for the rules of the road, especially driving on the shoulder are two very, very, very different things.

The two are not disjoint things. A lot of people, particularly teenagers, engage in reckless driving behaviors because it's fun.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by sukuriant on Thursday January 09, 2014 @02:16PM (#7032511)
And that particular style of 'fun driving' should be disallowed. It's not even allowed on race tracks; but there are other kinds of fun driving that I don't think should be stopped.

You're associating the two more closely than I am. Then again, I have a lot of fun driving many of the roads that I drive on and the fun that I have doesn't include the things I mentioned in my negatives list.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by ewoodrich on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:18PM (#7025797)
Why the scare quotes on "safer"?

If self-driving cars prove objectively to have fewer accidents and resulting injuries and deaths, wouldn't that just make them a superior technology?

In that case, why shouldn't insurance charge more for traditional driving if self-driving were available on your car? That's just how insurance works, nothing new there.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by WiseWeasel on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:44PM (#7025997)
A self-driving car system might be statistically safer than a human drivers in overall conditions, and still be prone to failure in an exceptional situation a particular driver wouldn't have been. If you have the potential to be that driver in that situation, I could understand feeling the scare quotes are warranted. Which percentile of the population does an automated system need to outperform to be safer rather than "safer"?
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by JshWright on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:14PM (#7026238)
I am (in my own estimation) a very good driver.

I drive a manual transmission car, and enjoy using the flexibility that provides in my daily driving.

I drive emergency vehicles of various sizes, in a lot of less than ideal conditions (I live in upstate New York, so weather is a big factor in driving conditions).

I have no problem believing that a computer will be able to do an objectively better job of driving than I can. It will be able to react more predictably in routine driving, and respond _much_ faster to exceptional situations. In a collision, a modern car is _done_ processing the event (detecting the impact, deciding which safety restraints to deploy, and deploying them) before your body even recognizes that it happened.

A computer controlled car will make fewer mistakes and react better in emergencies than a human being will. It has nothing to do with the skill of the driver. It has everything to do with the amount of data that the car can gather (do you have 360 degree radar vision or direct access to sensors built into the car), and the speed with which it can process that data. This technology still has a lot of maturing to do, but it has made amazing strides in the past decade, and I'm confident that it will continue to do that.

I, for one, welcome our new robot chauffeurs.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by delinka on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:31PM (#7026359)
Further, once all the cars on the road are automated, they can alert one another to their own changes in routing, mechanical failures, etc, allowing everyone else the chance to reroute and avoid as needed. We could eliminate traffic lights and stop signs and we'll not only get to our destinations safer, but also sooner.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by JshWright on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:35PM (#7026394)
Not only that, but emergency vehicle will be able preempt roads directly, rather than relying on the 18 year old kid with headphones on to a) recognize the lights and sirens, b) care, and c) do something not stupid (like pull into the way of the fire truck...)
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by hrjet on Thursday January 09, 2014 @01:16AM (#7029089)
> they can alert one another

Until someone misuses the protocol to gain an advantage or to cause a disruption (assuming it is peer to peer, decentralized).

If it is centralized, then um, there are other worries (privacy, control, etc).

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by WiseWeasel on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:37PM (#7027952)
So you feel that 100% is easily within reach? As a coder, I can't help but think it'll be a while before we iron out all the bugs in the driving AI, and as a result, we'll see self-driving cars on the roads long before they are able to outperform 100% of human drivers in all situations, or even your average sober, attentive driver in all situations.

Even if their reaction processing times are orders of magnitude faster and the sensors give you significantly better awareness, if there are conditions where the sequence of AI responses and priorities are conflicting or wrong, then you'll just be faster and better at getting the wrong solution, sometimes tragically so.

I don't doubt that we'll ultimately be much better off with self-driving cars being the rule, but it may be a bumpy road to get there.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by JshWright on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @11:33PM (#7028783)
I never said easily. In fact I said the technology still had a lot of maturing to do. I also never said it would be 100% (though I'd dare you to find me any human who would meet that 100% criteria either).

I absolutely agree there is still a ways to go before this is mainstream technology. I also agree that we will get there eventually, and the world will be a better place for it.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Planar on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @11:00PM (#7028667)
We (automotive active safety engineers) don't look at it as a percentage-of-inept-drivers, but more like the Trolley Problem[1], that is, overall harm vs benefit. To put it another way: seatbelts, airbags, and heart surgery hurt/kill some people, but the benefit outweights that harm.

[1] www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by maxerickson on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:16PM (#7026706)
The more interesting question might be the percentile where the auto-driver makes driving safer for everybody (by weeding out the worst drivers).

I would guess it is more like 15 or 20 than it is like 50 (but of course I'm guessing).

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Nicholas_C on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:15PM (#7025767)
I think the lives of humans are more important than some thrill seekers who want to drive around a few tons of metal without paying extra.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by schrodinger on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:45PM (#7025999)
What's the point of a life not enjoyed?
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by arrrg on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @08:22PM (#7028133)
I’m pretty sure people in one century will still be easily able to drive around for fun. Just like I can go horse riding for fun right now, despite horse riding being obsolete as actual transportation.

I’m also pretty sure that there were people waxing poetically about the joys of using horses for transportation a century ago and predicting doom and gloom because of the joyless and horseless future they foresaw. Those people probably didn’t shut up about it for the rest of their life, but in the end it all didn’t matter because they died and that’s that.

The thing is that most people on the street do not drive for fun, they drive to get from point A to point B and that’s that. Self-driving cars improve the quality and safety of going from point A to point B for them.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by a1a on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:02PM (#7026602)
What's the point of life if you die? I don't want to die, therefore I strongly suggest we make it illegal for humans to drive vehicles on public roads. The trade-off is in my opinion really small compared to the millions of lives saved.

If you want to have fun, have it at places where it doesn't kill people. It's like smoking, outside is fine - you are only killing yourself - but don't do it in bars/the office/hospitals/other places where you might kill others.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by mchusma on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:58PM (#7026102)
The issue is only people putting other lives at risk. Driving is statistically unsafe for other people, not just yourself.

1) you can still drive traditionally on private courses. 2) your right to enjoy hurling yourself around in a 2 ton missile shouldn't be more important than my right to life

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by freehunter on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:04PM (#7026614)
What's the point of a life wasted when someone loses control of their car and injures someone who was driving responsibly?
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by wazoox on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:18PM (#7026726)
Driving cars for most people is only fun in ads, where people always enjoy empty streets, wide roads across beautiful wilderness, and the joy of utter freedom. Truth is that almost all of real life driving is a terrible chore, and "having fun" on the road generally means taking irresponsible risks for you and others.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by robinhoode on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:05PM (#7025691)
Is the cost to society (in lives lost) worth the cost to individual enjoyment?
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Crito on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:55PM (#7027771)
Life becomes less valuable when you can do less with it. In the extreme case, we could all spend our lives in styrofoam boxes hooked up to feeding tubes, but what sort of life would that be? I would argue, a valueless one.

Is a collective devaluing of human life worth saving a few individual lives?

Consider if we cut down all trees within a dozen or so meters of roads, and installed guardrails everywhere. We could probably save many lives, but at the cost of devaluing the beauty of the countryside. Everyone's lives would become just that much more depressingly monotonous and sterile, for the sake of a preventing a few roadside deaths.

Safety should not be our society's primary concern. Quality of life is a much better thing to strive for.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by saraid216 on Thursday January 09, 2014 @02:50PM (#7032708)
> Consider if we cut down all trees within a dozen or so meters of roads, and installed guardrails everywhere.

You realize that we did that and it resulted in more deaths, right?

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Crito on Thursday January 09, 2014 @05:13PM (#7033658)
Whatever, bad example then. My point stands unless you lack an imagination.

We could string safety nets between all skyscrapers and under all bridges. We could ban convertibles. We could put fences along all rivers and ban backyard swimming pools. We could ban fireplaces.

There are any number of things that we could hypothetically do to prevent accidental or untimely deaths that we do not do because they would degrade the quality of our lives.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by saraid216 on Friday January 10, 2014 @02:16AM (#7035495)
Well, I wasn't trying to debate your point, but if you insist on being huffy,

Skyscrapers generally don't have windows that can be opened or easily broken, and very rarely have balconies. When's the last time you heard of someone going through a skyscraper window? It's a safety net.

We probably couldn't string safety nets under all bridges. However, we have already been fencing them off to prevent jumpers.

I'm not clear on why you are targeting convertibles specifically; I'm unaware of any special danger they pose. However, I would argue that banning cars entirely would raise our quality of life, if combined with other measures.

I'll concede the river one since there are too many possibilities there to argue exhaustively.

I could prevaricate on the swimming pool thing, since my parents own one and our quality of life probably would be better off without it, but not worth it.

I'm not clear on enough building codes to know how much we discourage fireplaces, but most new buildings don't seem to be built with them. We appear to have invented central heating over the last several decades, which is both safer and more effective.

The point being that the reason we don't implement a lot of "safety" measures is not because they "degrade the quality of our lives" but because they don't work. In fact, most of the so-called safety measures you luridly imagine actually should be done because they'd increase the quality of our lives... so really, the question is why we haven't done them, if QoL is such an important factor.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by barrkel on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:13PM (#7025749)
The cost of all your enjoyment is your own life; you too will die.

It depends on how much pleasure you get out of driving. I certainly think it's worth some fraction of a life. And of course, a certain amount of the risk comes from inattentive drivers who don't enjoy driving, and would rather read a book or eat cereal (or both) on the road.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by ewoodrich on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:20PM (#7025809)
Car accidents have unfortunate side effects, in that generally more than one driver's life is put at risk.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by barrkel on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:01PM (#7027059)
Indeed. That's why I ride motorcycles instead.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by bdamm on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:50PM (#7026036)
There is, I believe, a certain amount of risk simply be being on the road at all. No self-driving car is going to prevent that.

What I'd like to know, though, is that as self-driving cars become developed, the labs are calculating the risk factors of various intersections, streets, exchanges, etc. That is, different roads can be analyzed by the robot cars and independently assigned a risk factor for a given section of street.

The resulting impact to traffic engineering and city resource prioritization could be a very interesting side-effect to the introduction of self-driving cars.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by peterwwillis on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:26PM (#7025850)
I don't think this will be the case.

Automated driving is only useful if you know where you're going. If you're on a leisurely ride through the country or are looking for a place with no address, you can't use automated navigation. So disabling it would be a necessity for a variety of driving purposes. As an aside, motorsport enthusiasts would be up in arms if they had to pay a premium just to be able to drive their expensive sports sedan the way they want on a closed track.

What will probably happen is a black box will record if the car was in automated mode when a crash occurs. If it was driving itself, the manufacturer will probably be at fault and forced to pay the insurance company. If you were driving it, the standard rules apply.

I have to say though, automated drifting is really depressing. I used to drive a Toyota MR2, which is an ass-heavy car that was very susceptible to snap oversteer. Unlike most other cars, if you felt like the car's rear end was about to slide out of control, you had to PUNCH the gas to get traction back. You basically have to fight all your instincts and do something crazy in a split second or end up spinning backwards towards god knows what. It's the most exciting thing i've ever experienced in a car (even more than sitting in on hot laps with an indy driver in a Lexus IS-F), and I would never get to experience it with automated driving.

As for non-drifting, automated driving is definitely an amazing and useful feature. Writing code on my way to work sounds like fun. And I know it sounds controversial, but if there was some way to couple a breathalyzer with automated driving, we might be able to use our cars as taxis that pick us up and drop us off without us having the ability to drive. But perhaps that's hoping for too much...

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by UnFleshedOne on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:24PM (#7027601)
Insurance won't necessarily go up for manual driving. At least at first, it will be lower for automated cars (once insurance companies have enough data). Assuming sufficient competition, insurance companies charge just enough to cover their costs plus some profit. Statistically safer cars means fewer claims, and lower cost. A good opportunity to undercut any competitors not on the same page.

Sure you would pay more than owner of automated car, but probably not more than you are already paying. People on bicycles don't pay any insurance at all, I don't see anybody complaining about them (for that reason anyway).

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by femto on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @08:07PM (#7028069)
The scenarios in your first paragraph can be handled by treating the controls of the car as an input for the self-driving system. The accelerator asks the self-driving system to move forwards, whilst the steering wheel asks it to turn into the street to your right/left. Or, recognise that the existing controls no longer fit the purpose and come up with a better way of giving such input. For example, you might just point to where the car should go, or say "stop here".
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by alphydan on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:06PM (#7026167)
> If you're on a leisurely ride through the country or are looking for a place with no address, you can't use automated navigation.

I don't think those are impossible problems to solve. For the leisurely ride, define a radius or area and let the car do a 'random' walk (or ride on only small roads), or visit beautiful spots where g+ users have shared pictures, etc. For a place with no address, give a lng,lat or drop a pin on a map.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by ajcarpy2005 on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:16PM (#7026253)
You could even use way-point coordinates...like with an Xbox controller. Tell it where to turn and the computer will safely do the maneuvers that take you that route.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by sukuriant on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:10PM (#7027133)
I like controlling the car around those leisurely bends. Feels good to experience the wheels rotating in a certain way around a banked turn WITH an amazing view.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by stefan_kendall on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:54PM (#7026072)
Please stop "leisure driving". Traffic is a tremendous drain on my life as it is with superfluous cars on the road.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by sukuriant on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:09PM (#7027123)
Leisure driving isn't usually done on roads that are full of other cars all in gridlock trying to get home. It'll be on those same roads at much later times in the day, when the traffic is thinner, or it'll be off on a country road or mountain pass somewhere.

I love to drive. I do not enjoy dealing with major backups. When I'm leisure driving, it's out to a small town in the middle of nowhere later in the afternoon or when everyone is at work; or, it's out in the boonies because wow that view when I take a certain turn is just absolutely spectacular.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by chaz on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:05PM (#7026152)
I suspect people looking for a "leisure drive" abhor traffic as much as you. They're probably on quieter roads with fewer people, cars, and cops.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by peterwwillis on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:27PM (#7026802)
Please stop breathing. Carbon dioxide is a tremendous drain on the life of the planet as it is without your hot air added to it.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by uniclaude on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @10:37PM (#7028596)
This is great news to me.

Automated cars open the doors to:

- A potentially larger market for private tracks where you'll be enjoying racing, or even pleasure driving. It would be totally possible to have roads that are only here for pleasure driving. I can picture the Izu Skyline or other really beautiful roads that you pay to get a marvelous driving experience.

- A much safer world. If every car on public roads would be driving itself, you would not have to worry about a driver having an abnormal behavior and hurting/killing you in the process[1].

- Cheaper insurance? I don't really believe this, but it could happen, as there would be a lot less accidents.

I enjoy driving, I really do, but I'll use a self driving car any day, and I'm totally willing to pay an extra to drive in a safe and controlled environment like a private track. I think it's a win for everyone. If you enjoy driving, you'll enjoy staying safe, and self driving cars are bringing this safety.

[1]: I recently had an accident while coming back home, an old driver panicked because he didn't know where to go, and suddenly pushed hard on his brakes.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by saraid216 on Thursday January 09, 2014 @02:41PM (#7032663)
> - Cheaper insurance? I don't really believe this, but it could happen, as there would be a lot less accidents.

I haven't run the numbers myself, but it'd be worth checking to see what insurance numbers look like for private yachts or horses.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by eonil on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:01PM (#7026596)
I think that's absolutely reasonable that they remove your premium if you want to remove other people's safety just for your own fun.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by sliverstorm on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:04PM (#7025678)
In future driving will no longer be fun

It's funny seeing BMW try to be a forerunner in this space, after all of their "BMW: The Ultimate Driving Machine" ad campaigns. They were one of the few car makers that actually spoke of driving fun! (Or, well, driving pleasure)

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by CanSpice on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:16PM (#7026252)
Note that "The Ultimate Driving Machine" doesn't imply that a human is the one driving. :-)
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by User8712 on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:42PM (#7025981)
You'd pay a premium over those that exclusively use auto-pilot. That premium should still be lower than what you pay now. Reason being, you'll still be driving yourself, but now you're surrounded by auto-pilot vehicles. Therefore, you should be involved in less accidents as auto-pilot cars react faster to your mistakes, avoid following you too close, avoid merging into your lane, backing into you in a parking lot, etc. So, driving on auto-pilot might be 90% safer, and driving without auto-pilot, in a world where the majority use auto-pilot, you might be 60% safer than today. Either way, less accidents, safer roads, lower insurance.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by jonnathanson on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:11PM (#7025739)
Either that, or you'll take on some sort of hazard liability, and they'll find a way to see that you waive all coverage during the periods in which you're personally operating the vehicle.

Insurance companies have to compete on rate pricing to some extent, so there isn't too much room to move radically north there. But I could definitely see their getting into real-time pricing models, and/or denying coverage as a means of minimizing their responsibility in your agreement.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by saraid216 on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:04PM (#7025675)
More terrible than killing someone:

Spending more money to do it.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by aetherson on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:24PM (#7025838)
We should expect that, assuming that self-driving cars are in fact safer, insurance rates will go down for people with self-driving cars, and remain the same for manual drivers.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Someone on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:58PM (#7026101)
They will go down for manual drivers, too. If you hit your brakes now, you get hit from behind. If the car behind you is a robot, it will come to a stop at 5cm from your car.

Unless, of course, the manual drivers counteract by driving more dangerously. Why stop for a red traffic light if all other cars are driven by computer? Can you try and get an autonomous car to drive into a ditch by moving your car very close to it?

I think there will have to be laws governing such behavior ('harassment of an autonomous vehicle'), with video cameras in the autonomous vehicles providing the evidence.

That also is a reason that I think driverless cars will not work everywhere for quite a number of years. In the typical old city in Western Europe, an automated car will have to negotiate with pedestrians and cyclists for room. Once the pedestrians know that a car will brake if 'challenged', they will change their behavior. I know I would (I guess driving a self-driving car through the center of London or, better yet, Amsterdam in rush hour must be one of the hardest challenges)

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by maxerickson on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:30PM (#7026832)
It might work out better than you think in your last paragraph. Auto routed vehicles will reliably choose the 'main' route through an area (instead of whichever they feel is fastest), so segregated routing should work better (and with little additional physical infrastructure you can have one way rush hour streets and such).
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Someone on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:53PM (#7027759)
In many old city centers, there isn't much room for segregated routing.

Also, why would pedestrians or even cyclists care about one way streets? Even if they do, consider the case where streams of cyclists enter a one way street just in front of an automatic car. That could easily happen in Amsterdam (for an impression, see http://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2013/03/28/amsterdam-bicyc... or http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/21/world/europe/a-sea-of-bike...)

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by maxerickson on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:38PM (#7027957)
If there are 3 streets, the pedestrians and cyclists can take the one with no cars on it. In Amsterdam, cars could reliably be routed out and around (I think lots of people probably already use this strategy, but the point is that the auto router would never cheat).

Did you understand segregated routing to mean separate streets?

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by dwiel on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:50PM (#7026035)
The rates for manual drivers will be a function of how safe that pool of drivers are. If a large portion of the manual drivers do it for fun and are more reckless than the current average driver, their rates may in fact go up.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by jrockway on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:35PM (#7026395)
Considering insurance companies already insure airplanes, and you can turn the autopilot off without losing insurance, I somehow doubt this future. Airplanes are both more expensive and cause more damage when you crash them, and yet, you can rent them and insure them all the same.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by raldi on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:26PM (#7027266)
As I understand it, most car accidents are caused by driver error, and the belief is that self-driving cars will have a better miles-driven-to-accidents ratio.

However, I'm not aware of the same being true for airplanes, plane crashes, and autopilot systems.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by jrockway on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @11:25PM (#7028757)
Indeed, the GA autopilot systems are pretty simple: keep wings level, altitude hold, vertical speed hold, etc. On the other hand; you can take a lot more risks in your plane that will cost the insurance company a lot of money -- tailstrikes, flying into IMC, flying while sleepy, etc. If you total your Piper Cub, that's going to cost the insurance company a lot of money. If you total your Prius, that's cheaper.

On the other hand, it's a lot hard to get a pilot's license compared to a driver's license. (What are the requirements for a driver's license these days? Having a pulse? No, I don't think they check for that...)

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by eonil on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:59PM (#7026583)
IMO, that's because the AI is not yet proven to be actually safer than human. And it's pretty interesting what will be happen if the AI eventually comes up. Anyway, it doesn't seem to happen anytime soon.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by ollysb on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:21PM (#7025820)
I can't see any reason why we can't have both; you control the car until it detects a dangerous situation and then takes over. Sounds ideal really, you could go faster than you can now, safe in the knowledge that if things go bad the computer will kick in and take over.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by darklajid on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:56PM (#7027018)
This is already the case today, albeit limited.

My Audi

- makes the steerwheel vibrate if I veer off my lane, actively works against that (limited 'self-steering', but really, really crappy, useless and stupid in its current incarnation)

- has lights in the side mirrors that light up when someone's left or right behind of me. If I set the turning signal to a 'blocked' direction, the lights flash. This system is immensely satisfying for me, works awesome.

- stops the car on its own if it believes that a crash cannot be avoided and while I still go 30km/h or less. It breaks _immediately_

- issues a high pitched warning noise if it assumes that a collision might be imminent but outside of the safety zone (> 30km/h)

- supports automated cruising control, that breaks/accelerates on its own, depending on the traffic ahead and to the side (it won't overtake a car while you're right of it).

That said: I love driving. I love leisure rides, love to drive on the Autobahn. That car's rather 'slow' (compared to previous company cars) and tops out at 220km/h. When it is safe I really like to drive at that speed.

I think the resistance to self-driving cars is based on mistrust (you give up control, after all) and ego mostly - but it doesn't help the industry or supporters of that idea to paint everyone that likes to drive as a potential 2 ton bullet. A little perspective on both sides would help a lot here.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by Planar on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @11:08PM (#7028696)
The 2014 Mercedes E- and S-klasses that I've tested also do active intervention if you try to change lanes towards a car in your blindspot. Via braking on the opposite side.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by darklajid on Thursday January 09, 2014 @01:10PM (#7032058)
Interesting. Would love to test that/feel how that works.

Here that's not combined, if there's something in my blind spot I just have those lights (flashing if I set a turning signal). There's an assistant that is supposed to keep me in my lane. In theory it ignored lane changes only if I set the turning signal (-> intended by me) and otherwise steers in the opposite direction (I can still beat it, it just tries to convince me otherwise). Plus, it vibrates the steering wheel.

It doesn't work, though. Audi was obviously so afraid that people start leaning back and drinking a nice cup of coffee that they added a very annoying 'are you still alive' test. That assistant is going to power down on its own as soon as it things you're not steering anymore. Which often happens without reason (just driving straight).

Basically that thing is only working if you hold the steering wheel like a 50's/60's Hollywood star, turning left and right on a dead straight street. Maybe the next incarnation will improve this design..

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by bdamm on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:44PM (#7025995)
I think part of the safety boost of self-driving cars is that they don't get impatient, and neither will you since you're reading a book/email/facebook/whatever.

Self-driving cars ought to also be capable of driving like grandmothers. That's part of why I expect them to be safer. The idea that you can drive a car to the brink of a high-speed collision and then magically expect it to out-react a seasoned driver into avoiding an essentially unavoidable accident is juvenile fantasy.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by m4x on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:11PM (#7026660)
There's no reason why you can't drive it to the brink of a crash and then have it recover for you. The 'brink' in this case is the latest the computer can reliably recover - not a point 100ms before an unavoidable collision.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:10PM (#7027543)
But why would you want that? Why wouldn't you want to use a system that can get you to your destination much faster, cheaper and safer[0], only because you want to experience the "fun" of being in a traffic jam?

[0] - self-driving cars constantly talking with each other could drive much closer to each other than current "safe distance", much faster, while utilizing aerodynamic effects to conserve fuel, and that system would still in principle be safer than human drivers.

Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by glhaynes on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:27PM (#7026334)
I'd think that very often by the time things have gone wrong, it's too late to prevent the crash even with perfect intelligence. Unless perhaps you have the system take back over so often that it's more frustrating to manually drive than to just leave it on auto-pilot anyway.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by akgoel on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:05PM (#7025692)
Disagree. Driving will now have increased insurance prices associated with increased risk. The roads will be safer.
Re:BMW shows off 'drifting' self-drive cars by jotm on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @11:47PM (#7028827)
Good news is this future won't be in our lifetime :-)