News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by kylec on Sunday July 12, 2009 @09:00PM (#700823)
I swear, "not Hacker News" seems to be the overriding meme here on HN, and it's getting old.

Sure this article's partially about feminism, but it's also about academic integrity, which I think falls well under the purview of "Hacker News". Not to mention the fact that CS and programming are often the focus of gender difference issues by feminists.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by tptacek on Sunday July 12, 2009 @10:02PM (#700907)
This is an essay from an AEI fellow about gender politics. The fact that it centers on academia does give it a foothold on HN, but it's misleading to suggest that this editorial is more than a borderline Hacker News submission.

I wouldn't flag it, but I wouldn't protest if it had gotten flagged off. There are hundreds and hundreds of similar articles, all epsilon from "Hacker-Newsworthy", that thankfully don't make it onto HN.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by cdr on Sunday July 12, 2009 @09:57PM (#700895)
What anybody thinks about it in a post is irrelevant.

Upvote it (or not) if you think it belongs, flag it if you think it doesn't.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by kragen on Sunday July 12, 2009 @10:49PM (#700973)
Maybe we should have a separate category for comments about the categorization of an article.

    1. Δ Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship (chronicle.com)
         35 points by kylec 2 hours ago | 11 comments | 28 relevance flames
Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by DanielBMarkham on Monday July 13, 2009 @06:22AM (#701419)
I think if you gave folks some public way of indicating their complain, instead of an anonymous/invisible flag, it might help. Sometimes people are just driven to do something publicly. After all, flagging might be the way HN works, but it's not necessarily the way people work.
Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by maggie on Sunday July 12, 2009 @10:37PM (#700958)
CS and programming are actually /not/ often the focus of gender issues by feminists.

The discussion on the gender-balance in said fields is brought up internally, most of the time, if not always. The 'feminist' crowd (gender theorists, women's studies academics, etc.) is honestly not that interested, or aware, of our problems.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by gaius on Monday July 13, 2009 @01:59AM (#701178)
That is because computer programming is (still) not a particularly prestigious job, it still suffers from negative stereotypes, nerd, geek, etc. Right now, we're under their radar.

There is a reason feminists want us to say "chairperson" but don't care if you say "binman".

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by johnnybgoode on Sunday July 12, 2009 @10:53PM (#700979)
> The discussion...is brought up internally, most of the time, if not always.

You may be right, but I suspect the reason for the above has something to do with the influence of feminists.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by maggie on Sunday July 12, 2009 @11:33PM (#701034)
I doubt it.

That implies that the problems women face in computing (by being women) historically and currently are myths and only exist if you think about 'em.

They aren't, and there's plenty of evidence to show otherwise. email me if you really want a lit. review on the subject.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by rewt66 on Monday July 13, 2009 @12:55PM (#702035)
Data point: My mother was a programmer back in the 1950s. She wrote numerical programs that simulated missile trajectories... in octal. She thought it was great when she got an assembler.

I don't recall her ever saying anything about discrimination on the job. The thing she griped about was being told by a math professor that math was no place for a woman.

Maybe there are some gating effects happening that steer women away from trying technical fields? It seems to me that, within most software places, you belong if you know your stuff. Nobody cares about your race, gender, religion, sexual orientation, or other basis for "discrimination". We care if you can code. (If you can't code, and got the job as a token person-of-that-color/gender/sexual orientation, then we usually have a problem with that, but that's not the same as bias against that color or gender or sexual orientation.)

That's the way it's been almost everywhere I've ever worked, and I've been in software for 25 years.

So what I'm trying to say is, there's almost always room for some introspection, but maybe we're too hard on ourselves? Maybe the lack of women in software isn't really the software guys' fault?

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by johnnybgoode on Sunday July 12, 2009 @11:55PM (#701058)
No, that's not what I was implying. I'm suggesting that the issue would be brought up less often if feminists did not have significant influence in our society. I can put a positive spin on it if you prefer: Thanks to the work of feminists over the past few decades, women and men in computing know well enough to bring up the issue of sexism in their field on their own.
Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by kylec on Monday July 13, 2009 @12:51PM (#702029)
Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by davidw on Monday July 13, 2009 @01:40AM (#701160)
> I swear, "not Hacker News" seems to be the overriding meme here on HN, and it's getting old.

If people would post less of this sort of thing, then you wouldn't see it. Are you really interested in hacker / startup articles or do you just want to see "interesting" things? There are good subreddits for the latter.

See: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=700644

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by branden on Monday July 13, 2009 @01:55AM (#701172)
http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

"On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups."

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by davidw on Monday July 13, 2009 @03:30AM (#701286)
Taken at face value, this means that if you get enough people to vote for something, then it's ok, no matter how "off topic" it is.

Since there is no check for "being a hacker" to join this site, presumably I could find a bunch of people interested in, say, the Tour de France, get them to join, and start voting up bike racing articles. Or for that matter, perhaps there are enough people already here interested in bike racing to vote up those articles.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by branden on Monday July 13, 2009 @04:33AM (#701332)
Hence the flag button and editors.
Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by davidw on Monday July 13, 2009 @04:58AM (#701362)
So, effectively, there is some sort of "what should be here" standard. It is not just "anything goes" as per the guideline.

This kind of article completely fails the "of more interest to hackers than other people" test, which I think is more relevant.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by branden on Monday July 13, 2009 @05:31AM (#701382)
I agree that this article straddles the line, but like you point out, it's a big fuzzy line. I think it's best to just flag and move on.
Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by sho on Monday July 13, 2009 @10:30AM (#701741)
"This kind of article completely fails the "of more interest to hackers than other people" test"

Au contraire, it's front page news at HN, and I don't see it enjoying such popularity at any other aggregator service. That does suggest it is, in fact, of more interest to hackers - or at least the HN variety - than other people.

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by davidw on Monday July 13, 2009 @11:09AM (#701834)
Just getting something on the front page does not signify that it's hacker news. This article got there, for instance, and was subsequently killed:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=693525

Re:Persistent Myths in Feminist Scholarship by sho on Monday July 13, 2009 @01:44PM (#702134)
From the welcome message:

"Stories on HN don't have to be about hacking, because good hackers aren't only interested in hacking, but they do have to be deeply interesting.

What does "deeply interesting" mean? It means stuff that teaches you about the world. A story about a robbery, for example, would probably not be deeply interesting. But if this robbery was a sign of some bigger, underlying trend, then perhaps it could be."

http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

I thought that this submission fell into that category. If you don't agree, well, OK.

(edited to remove personal reference)