News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:03AM (#6991136)
The LuaJIT author, Mike Pall recently stopped contributing to SO [0] after having an edit on one of his own posts about LuaJIT reverted by clueless mods [1].

The reply was highly precise and technical, and the reasons given by the mods to reject the edit are spurious, since they just couldn't understand it and its implications.

I reached out to two of them (I couldn't find how to contact the third one), but they didn't even reply to my mails.

[0] http://www.freelists.org/post/luajit/How-does-LuaJITs-trace-...

[1] http://stackoverflow.com/review/suggested-edits/3395606

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by cruise02 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:30AM (#6991286)
It's generally accepted by the community at Stack Overflow that you don't edit other people's answers except to make improvements to formatting and punctuation. Changing the code should be left to the original author of the post, as that changes the meaning of the answer. The people who rejected the edit probably didn't notice that it was the same person who suggested the edit.

Mike could have avoided that by just using the same account to edit his original post. You can always edit your own work without it going through the review process.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by Shog9 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:37PM (#6992043)
FWIW, I've merged his accounts now.

Probably too late, but... If he ever decides to come back, he'll be able to edit his own posts without review.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by protomyth on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:43PM (#6994183)
Did you fix the edit also?
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by itsadok on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @12:53AM (#6994337)
Somebody else already had, a month ago.

http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/11318414/4

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by mark-r on Thursday January 02, 2014 @01:32AM (#6998501)
So eventually the system was self correcting. Unfortunately that may be too late to redeem the site in the eyes of the contributor.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:55AM (#6991414)
None of that changes the fact that his valid edit was rejected by incompetent mods.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by cruise02 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:27PM (#6991596)
99.99% of the time, rejecting a suggested edit that changes code is the right thing to to. The competence of the reviewers isn't really the issue. The author should have just used his original account to make the edit and this would have been a non-issue.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:38PM (#6991663)
He probably didn't realise he had two accounts.

The incompetence of the mods is relevant because it is one of the main criticism of TFA. It's a nice example of the Pete principle.

If a mod doesn't understand an answer he should just pass, not vote according to what's right most of the time. They are incompetent, both regarding LuaJIT and as moderators.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by cruise02 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:55PM (#6991779)
How many LuaJIT experts do you suppose there are reviewing edits on Stack Overflow?
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:59PM (#6991798)
He used to be there. You can't find a better expert.

I'd expect mods familiar with Lua to recognize him, and he should have mod powers, to begin with.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by cruise02 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:16PM (#6991902)
He doesn't even recognize that he's using two separate accounts, but other people are supposed to recognize him and his accounts should have mod powers?

Again, if he had just used his original account to edit his answer, he wouldn't have needed any of that.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:30PM (#6991989)
Yes.

He's a world class expert in compilers and high performance, low level programming on modern hardware.

This addresses the core point of the article, being that the SO "meritocracy" is badly implemented, and conflates heavy site usage with maturity and technical ability.

Edit: If not a mod status, a VIP status. SO would gain a lot if its staff were to individually recruit people as talented as he is.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by dfbrown on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @04:55PM (#6993036)
This seems more like an argument that SO's "meritocracy" isn't perfect, not that it's poorly implemented. Having two accounts is an edge case.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by JimDabell on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:28PM (#6991975)
You're using the fact that he had two accounts as an excuse, but it really doesn't hold up. This was an edit with inarguable merit. Yet users rejected it because they were using the heuristic "changes to code is bad" as a substitute for understanding the edit. That's bad moderation. If you don't understand a change, you shouldn't vote on its worthiness.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by thedufer on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @12:20AM (#6994252)
So instead of taking the one in a thousand chance that its the wrong thing to do (which, from what I've seen, is generous) they should let edits languish for days or weeks until someone sufficiently knowledgable shows up? That just doesn't sound like a worthwhile tradeoff.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by auggierose on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @12:57AM (#6994347)
If something should not be edited through another account, then the software should just not allow it.

If it allows it, and delegates the check to moderators, then these moderators should either reject it if they are sure the change is wrong. In all other cases they should allow it.

It's really that simple.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by thedufer on Thursday January 02, 2014 @11:41AM (#7000449)
You have no idea what the spectrum of edits is on SO. Why do you think your heuristic is obviously better, despite making no argument for it?

The heuristic they use is something along the lines of "only accept edits that are grammar fixes, equivalent thereof, or rewordings". Content changes without the authors consent are considered poor form.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by bryanlarsen on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:45AM (#6991363)
The biggest problem with this convention is that new & anonymous users cannot comment, so the only option they have is to edit the post. These then get rejected out of hand and useful contributions disappear. This is doubly wasteful since this behaviour often discourages people from every contributing again.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by cruise02 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:48AM (#6991379)
No, new and anonymous users do have another option, they can post their own answer.

That's irrelevant anyway, since that's not what happened here. The author of the post tried to edit his own answer with a second account. He should have just used his original account and this would have never happened.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by bryanlarsen on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:10PM (#6991498)
No, new and anonymous users do have another option, they can post their own answer.

Which is less wrong than an edit but it`s still wrong when the appropriate response is a comment.

A community can be judged by it`s responses to newbies. By this measure it fails miserably since the most common feedback many newbies get from SO are bare downvotes and rejections. What should happen is a polite response explaining the problem and the what should be done to correct it.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by cruise02 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:28PM (#6991600)
The appropriate response was an edit by the author with his original account, not a comment.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by aaronem on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:29PM (#6991984)
Speaking as a contributor and reviewer on Super User and Stack Overflow, your opinion of what should happen is shared by more or less everyone who is an established member of the community. The trouble is that there are a lot of newbies, many of whom don't take time either to read the "about" and "how to ask good questions" advice which the sites make prominently available for new users, or to characterize their problem in sufficient detail to make it solvable, or to search for the trivially obvious answer to whatever question they're asking.

Once you've seen enough of this sort of thing -- and, again, especially on the highly popular sites there is a lot of it -- there's a certain fatigue which sets in; you get jaded, I suppose, and that seems from what I've seen to be the proximate cause for newbie questions getting downvoted to oblivion or flagged for closure without anyone taking a moment to advise the asker on what he should've done differently.

Is this ideal? Of course not; in fact, it's not even close, and I say that as someone who has considerable experience with the phenomenon so described. But Stack Exchange sites are moderated by volunteers, and you can't issue ukazes to volunteers without a significant risk of losing them -- after all, if you make them not want to do what they do, they'll just stop doing it.

In any case, just as a community can be judged by its attitude toward newbies, so can those newbies be judged by their attitude toward the community in which they attempt to participate. As in any other such case, it is entirely reasonable for those who have invested time and effort into Stack Exchange sites to expect that new users will deport themselves with respect for the rules and mores of the community.

With regard to giving the ability to comment to new and unregistered users, there's a problem similar to that of low-quality newbie questions; so to broaden the provision of commenting privilege would produce an instant and enduring deluge of spam. You really can't expect volunteers to handle sewage disposal, especially when the sewage is deep enough to require hip waders. Again, this is not ideal, but it is a consequence of the Stack Exchange model's basic assumptions, and I'd have to say that model has acquitted itself well enough in practice to vindicate the claims made on its behalf.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by anu_gupta on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:08PM (#6991847)
His edit wasn't rejected by mods. It was rejected by other users who have the power to review edits. A mod has a specific meaning within SE sites.

If he'd raised an issue on meta, I'm sure a real mod would have sorted this out, or he could have just used the same account to make this edit.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:17PM (#6991912)
s/moderators/folks with lots of imaginary internet points enabling a restricted subset of the moderating powers available on SO/

You must also know about meta. I looked for ways to contact the mods in the UI and didn't find any. I suppose it's in the FAQ, but I didn't think about it at the time.

Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by insteadof on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @05:25PM (#6993176)
So "flag for moderator attention" means what to you?
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @05:41PM (#6993251)
It is nowhere to be seen. I'm logged out.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by daphneokeefe on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:44PM (#6991700)
A very unfortunate incident, but there are bound to be mistakes made when there are tens of thousands of developers and over six million questions. Eventually, bugs are going to appear. The kind of dumb mistakes that developers (and other humans) make all the time. That doesn't make the error any less painful. Stuff happens.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by smackfu on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:26AM (#6991267)
I don't see how stopping contributing solves anything.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by pygy_ on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:51AM (#6991395)
He doesn't care about SO, and his time is precious.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by jdludlow on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:22AM (#6991250)
It looks like user Tobu already fixed it, but that is quite ridiculous.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow by Guvante on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @11:36AM (#6991323)
Seems that the reviewers ignored the comment.

I know I have seen nearly 1 in 20 edit suggestions are some random person suggesting an edit to a post that completely changes the meaning.