News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Filthy Lucre by fit2rule on Monday December 30, 2013 @06:10AM (#6984098)
>It's awfully hard to discern a point in this rambling piece.

The point is: its expensive being poor. The rich receive so many more benefits and rewards in their world, simply for the fact that they 'are rich' and thus 'have more potential' than the poor.

Until we realize that the poor are kept there by the wealthy, we'll never solve income-inequality in the world. Without such 'rich bubbles' existing in our society, there is no hope for us all to rise.

Re:Filthy Lucre by yummyfajitas on Monday December 30, 2013 @08:01AM (#6984416)
Can you explain the mechanism by which the rich keep the poor there?

(If the answer is simply "insufficient wealth redistribution", what is the right amount of wealth redistribution? I.e., at what amount of redistribution do we declare that the wealthy have done enough, and the problem must lie not with them?)

Re:Filthy Lucre by runako on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:09AM (#6984635)
One example, in the US: poor people get crappy education. The more our economy shifts to a knowledge-based economy, the more effective this is at keeping poor people poor.

Another example: access to legal services (in the US) is essentially required for fair treatment under the law. Poor people cannot afford legal services, and so will generally not get fair treatment under the law. So a mistake/misunderstanding/relatively minor infraction that would be a mere hassle for a richer person can be life-ruining for a poorer person. In the US, we've gone so far as to apply wildly different penalties to "poor people's drugs" and "rich people's drugs" (obviously stereotypes, but the stereotypes have some basis in fact and are why the laws were written that way).

Poor neighborhoods are more likely to experience elevated crime levels. In the US, this means they are often militarized. This makes everyone that lives in them more at risk for life-ruining run-ins with the law. The people of NYC have decided that it's fair for non-white juveniles to be subject to stopping & frisking anytime, for no cause. This is a tax for which no benefit is derived by the payers.

There are tons of examples like these that have nothing to do with redistribution. If you read the papers, you'll see examples every day.

Re:Filthy Lucre by yummyfajitas on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:14AM (#6985150)
How do the rich cause the poor to be poorly educated? Do they infiltrate the school boards in poor districts and cause them to enact bad policies? I was also completely unaware that the rich went into poor neighborhoods and committed crime. This is terrible!

One possible solution to this is to try and segregate rich from poor as much as possible. That will certainly reduce the harm these rich villains cause. Maybe we need barriers preventing the rich from entering poor neighborhoods (and vice versa, in the interest of fairness). That should reduce crime in poor neighborhoods and improve the schools, right?

I agree with you on the war on drugs.

Re:Filthy Lucre by AutoCorrect on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:41AM (#6984763)
Here's a newsflash for ya: DON'T BREAK THE LAW!!! If they weren't breaking they law there would be no need to send them to jail. I grew up around a bunch of potheads and saw by their example that I never wanted to be involved with drugs. Instead of spending my time getting drunk and high I spent my time in the library reading. I grew up in a trailer park, and now live in a middle-class suburb. Because I was interested in video games, I learned about computers.

Poor people are held down by the chains of their own bad habits, not by rich people.

Re:Filthy Lucre by sneak on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:46AM (#6984781)
There are so many laws in the US that everyone there is committing several felonies a day.

It's the poor and minorities the cops choose to scrutinize and enforce against most.

Few times have I seen such obliviousness to white middle-class privilege on HN.

Re:Filthy Lucre by bilbo0s on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:36AM (#6984986)
Yeah... I guess this one is true.

I'd have to challenge AutoCorrect's implicit assertion that (s)he doesn't break the law. There are so many laws that the assertion is a little difficult to believe. Your explanation is far more likely...

ie - this is the US and it's far better to be white than black, or rich than poor.

And the worst is to be poor and black.

Re:Filthy Lucre by glesica on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:47AM (#6985027)
runako already dealt with this by pointing out that because poor areas are militarized, run-ins with the law are more likely even for "normal" law-breaking. What kid doesn't break the law? I did, tons of times. I wasn't out murdering people, but I took part in the usual American youth mischief. If I'd grown up in a poor, black neighborhood, there's a good chance I would have gone to prison. As it is, I grew up in a middle-class white neighborhood, so I got away with it (and turned out MUCH better than I would have if I'd gone to prison).

Aside from this, militarization leads to people who didn't even break the law being incarcerated or killed. Take a look at the Innocence Project, and AFAIK they don't even handle people wrongfully convicted of minor offenses.

Re:Filthy Lucre by fit2rule on Monday December 30, 2013 @08:25AM (#6984479)
The rich get a lot of things for free that most people would have to pay large amounts of money for .. such as free glasses of sekt while waiting for the plane, or gift bags when you enter the host bar, and so on. By just accepting this as a matter of 'life as a rich person', the rich do indeed steal from the poor - those bags had to get paid somehow, the sekt doesn't just bottle itself.

I recently attended a large art opening in a very wealthy city. The party was full of millionaires and billionaires. Everywhere: free food, free drinks, free everything. I felt more connection with the waiters and servers than I did with any of the rich people enjoying the fruits of all the servers work ..

What I think has to happen is that the rich have to realize that their privilege has to be shared, and they simply have to share it as much as they can. This dividing line between 'me and them' has to disappear. I don't think that wealth-redistribution by the government is any sort of solution; what has to happen is that society has to enlighten itself to the point where these greedy, self-indulgent people do not get created by societys' institutions.

I tipped the waiters, anyway. Nobody else in the room did.

Re:Filthy Lucre by yummyfajitas on Monday December 30, 2013 @08:34AM (#6984507)
An economy ticket costs from London to Mumbai costs $485, whereas the first class ticket costs $2348. The rich person is paying for their own sekt and gift bags. Or are you somehow implying that the poor pay for the perks associated to the first class ticket?

This is like saying the poor rob the rich because they get free ketchup at Burger King.

Re:Filthy Lucre by djrobstep on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:22AM (#6984673)
Highly unequal property rights enforcement by the state. There is a great deal of property in the world. Rich people use the state to control a vast amount of it for themselves. They use that control to deny the poor access to most of that property, coerce the poor into doing their bidding, and accumulate even more control of that property.
Re:Filthy Lucre by onebaddude on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:14AM (#6984648)
>"Can you explain the mechanism by which the rich keep the poor there?"

The political system. Same as it's been for thousands of years.

Re:Filthy Lucre by stirno on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:35AM (#6984734)
The poor also participate in the US political system and help maintain the regrettable status quo.
Re:Filthy Lucre by HarryHirsch on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:12AM (#6984894)
Newsflash: politics != going to the polls

Being a politician is expensive; fundraising, free time and access is required to rise through the ranks and get stuff done. Also, especially in the US, there is this issue of campaign donations. Giving to someone's campaign is also participating in politics.

And then there is the issue of becoming part of the party apparatus. At my present university, a state university in the Northeast US both College Republicans and Democrats are near invisible. In contrast, at my previous uni, a member of the Ivy League in New England, both parties managed to invite all sorts of established party members, and they were recruiting for campaigning. Think internships.

Yet here on HN we see the benefits of state universities extolled. They may be cheap, but that's because one of the things you go to college for is to build a network of peers and established figures in your chosen field.

Re:Filthy Lucre by simbolit on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:01AM (#6984841)
When was the last time you saw a lobbyist for the poor on Capitol Hill? And how big a bag of cash did they have with them?
Re:Filthy Lucre by gaius on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:28AM (#6984699)
Imagine that you are stranded on a desert island and the only source of food is coconuts, for which you must climb trees. You are bad at climbing trees and often go hungry. Is this unfair? Who is being unfair to you?
Re:Filthy Lucre by jljljl on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:00AM (#6984839)
Let's expand this to a second scenario:

Imagine you are stranded on a desert island with one other person and the only source of food is coconuts for which you must climb trees. You are worse at climbing trees than your fellow cast away. He climbs the trees before you, takes most of the coconuts, and hoards them. When you ask him for some coconuts he says you should have practiced climbing more as a child.

Is this unfair? Who is being unfair to you?

Re:Filthy Lucre by thinkr on Monday December 30, 2013 @12:17PM (#6985532)
How about a third scenario that may be closer to the situation we have been facing in the US:

Imagine you are stranded on a desert island with 3 other persons and the only source of food is coconuts for which you must climb trees. The 4 persons are you (adult 1), who is worse at climbing trees than your fellow cast away (adult 2). There is also child 1 who adult 1 is responsible for, and child 2 who adult 2 is responsible for. Both child 1 and child 2 have zero experience climbing trees and must depend on the adults. Adult 2 climbs the trees before you, takes most of the coconuts, and hoards them. When you ask him for some coconuts for both you and your child, he says you should have practiced climbing more as a child.

Whether his actions are considered fair or unfair, should your child have to suffer for your own lack of tree climbing experience?

Additionally, if you look at this in terms of evolution, is it okay for adult 1 and child 1 to die off, while adult 2 and child 2 to prosper, effectively moving towards a less diverse population?

Re:Filthy Lucre by sejje on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:36AM (#6984987)
No, it's not unfair. He's being a dick, maybe, if there's enough coconuts for both of you with no risk of running out, or if it's very easy and risk-free for him to obtain them, etc, but this is ultimately fair imo.

His logic is stupid at best, of course. You can practice climbing trees as an adult, and you'll probably progress significantly faster than you would as a child.

His response should be "No, I collected these myself, and you can collect yours yourself."

Re:Filthy Lucre by mercer on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @09:47AM (#6995089)
I suppose this all hinges on how you define 'fair'. As long as there is no agreement on that, it's hard to discuss this issue in a meaningful way.

Fair, from my perspective, is taking care of others, especially those weaker than me. I happen to have been born in a nurturing environment, with above-average intelligence, and lots of valuable experiences that inform my decisions. While I do work hard, it sometimes shocks me how many things 'came free' for me.

From my perspective, it is not wrong that I happen to have won the lottery. It is also not wrong that others have not, and have less than me. But I would say it is unfair for me to not share my advantage with others, and to try to increase happiness of those around me through this.

That said, I respect that your view of fairness is different. I just don't like it, and choose to be different, and I'll fight for my version of fair...

Re:Filthy Lucre by pavelrub on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:45AM (#6985021)
Of course it's not unfair. He doesn't owe you anything. He collected the coconuts, and he can do whatever he wants with them.

Unfair would be if you collected the coconuts, and then somebody else came and took them from you just because he could. Which is not the case.

Re:Filthy Lucre by sejje on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:02AM (#6985088)
@jljljl

Yes, it's unfair to take his coconuts. He earned them, and risked injury (which could mean his life in this contrived example) to collect them, and they are his.

How they will be used is up to him, if things are fair.

Re:Filthy Lucre by jljljl on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:10AM (#6985128)
I find this interesting because: by hoarding the coconuts (without necessity in this example), the good climber is causing harm or injury to the poor climber. This injury is considered fair and justified. However, if the poor climber causes injury to the first by stealing the coconuts after the fact, this is seen as unfair.
Re:Filthy Lucre by sejje on Monday December 30, 2013 @03:15PM (#6986631)
It's your perception that the good climber is causing harm to the poorer.

How about this scenario: if the coconuts are equally retrieved, both climbers will have their lives threatened. Is it unfair for one of the climbers to take from the other at that point, when simply by having an equal share they are both threatening the life of each other?

Of course you probably have a difference of opinion from your previous position in this case, though I'm not sure how you'll sort it out.

I don't believe there's any inherent right of the poor climber to demand something from the good one. I think he has the right to exist and compete for the same coconuts, and that wherever that lands him is fair.

I have a big heart, and I'd hope that any better climber would share his coconuts, but I don't believe they should ever be taken from him or that he should be prohibited from climbing just because he's good at it, etc.

Re:Filthy Lucre by 21echoes on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @09:23PM (#6997837)
> It's your perception that the good climber is causing harm to the poorer.

pretty sure causing someone to starve is, indeed, harming them.

Re:Filthy Lucre by jljljl on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:56AM (#6985058)
Let's say there are plenty of coconuts available for both of you, but specifically because of his hoarding you are risking hunger or starvation (I.e., you are good enough at climbing trees that you could feed yourself)

Is it unfair or unjustified for you to take coconuts from him?

Re:Filthy Lucre by adharmad on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:55AM (#6985394)
Yes both unfair and unjustified. By your principle, force is the only way to interact between humans without regard to any individual rights. Why not extrapolate this in today's world? Surely even wars can be justified by this principle.

What the second person should do is to offer the first person something (maybe he can peel/cook coconuts better?) in return for some of the coconuts. Or find alternative means of food that do not involve climbing.

The problem with these life-boat scenarios is that you try to twist the problem in a scenario wherein the only solution is to harm one or the other person. In real life, there are more options and nuances. And regardless, initiating force is a clear no-no, regardless of the justification - else society quickly escalates into mob rule and might-is-right.

Re:Filthy Lucre by jljljl on Monday December 30, 2013 @01:24PM (#6985959)
I agree that they are not realistic. And I do not agree that force is the only way to interact between humans. I'm also not trying to twist the problem to justify violence.

The coconuts in this scenario are a shared resource. Neither individual owns the island or the trees. If there are plenty of coconuts on the island for both people, then a simple, "fair" solution for both people to survive is for each person to simply take the number of coconuts that they need.

Yet the answers suggest that a good climber is entitled to take most or all of the coconuts as their ability allows, even if this causes harm to other cast aways. But theft by the poor climber is never justified. Both actions cause harm, but one is considered just while the other is not.