News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Filthy Lucre by sejje on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:02AM (#6985088)
@jljljl

Yes, it's unfair to take his coconuts. He earned them, and risked injury (which could mean his life in this contrived example) to collect them, and they are his.

How they will be used is up to him, if things are fair.

Re:Filthy Lucre by jljljl on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:10AM (#6985128)
I find this interesting because: by hoarding the coconuts (without necessity in this example), the good climber is causing harm or injury to the poor climber. This injury is considered fair and justified. However, if the poor climber causes injury to the first by stealing the coconuts after the fact, this is seen as unfair.
Re:Filthy Lucre by sejje on Monday December 30, 2013 @03:15PM (#6986631)
It's your perception that the good climber is causing harm to the poorer.

How about this scenario: if the coconuts are equally retrieved, both climbers will have their lives threatened. Is it unfair for one of the climbers to take from the other at that point, when simply by having an equal share they are both threatening the life of each other?

Of course you probably have a difference of opinion from your previous position in this case, though I'm not sure how you'll sort it out.

I don't believe there's any inherent right of the poor climber to demand something from the good one. I think he has the right to exist and compete for the same coconuts, and that wherever that lands him is fair.

I have a big heart, and I'd hope that any better climber would share his coconuts, but I don't believe they should ever be taken from him or that he should be prohibited from climbing just because he's good at it, etc.

Re:Filthy Lucre by 21echoes on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @09:23PM (#6997837)
> It's your perception that the good climber is causing harm to the poorer.

pretty sure causing someone to starve is, indeed, harming them.