Right -- and that's the problem. Because once you start down that road of criminalization of proxies for bad acts, you end up with proxies for proxies, like when the city I lived in criminalized -- no joke -- possession of spray paint, marker pens, and other things by teens on public right-of-ways. Because graffiti as a proxy for gang activity was still not easy enough of a prosecution lever, so they wanted to prosecute possession of items which could in theory be used for graffitti (which itself was a proxy for gang activitty).
And eventually you just criminalize everything as a proxy for being bad -- and then criminal justice is no longer really driven at all by law (since you've criminalized all kinds of things that you don't want, or expect, to enforced against everyone), its about arbitrary determinations by police and prosecutors -- guided by personal biases -- about who really "needs" to be punished, and you always know you'll have a convenient lever to prosecute once that determination is made.
And the whole concept of rule of law and proof beyond a reasonable doubt becomes meaningless, because you no longer are prosecuting for the real offense, but for distant meaningless proxies for harmful activities chosen specifically because people are certain to violate many of them in ways that are easy to prove whether or not they are doing any of the acts for which they are notionally proxies.
Millions of people do graffiti -- and very few of them have anything to do with "gang activity".
This "proxy" notion doesn't hold. Neither would such retribution to such "offences" be fair even if it was so.
In fact, sending people to jail for such trivial stuff is a more effective introduction to serious crime than their initial offences.
At the least, they are not fully independent events, so it's not totally idiotic. If you combine that with broken window theory, it makes a lot of sense [to the cops] to rely on such statutes as a way to fight gangs at the same time as other petty crime.
Millions of people do graffiti -- and very few of them have anything to do with "gang activity".
I imagine that depends on where the crime takes place. If you're in the ghetto tagging a wall it's far more likely to be gang related than it would be if it were some kid in the suburbs.The problem is that the only people who seem to benefit from laws being enforced based on their spirit not their letter are white people. Minorities on the other hand don't seem to enjoy the same benefits.
And getting past the issue of faulty heuristics, the authors experience post-arrest was pretty ridiculous.
How is anyone or anything served by treating arrested people like that?
Keeping in mind that hypothetically you are innocent until proven guilty. You should not be punished until you've been convicted of something.
There are 5 ways to commit a crime: * Accidentally (usually not a crime) * Through negligence (Malpractice) * Recklessly (Manslaughter) * Knowingly (2nd Degree Murder) * On Purpose (1st Degree Murder)
In the case of murder, all 5 cases leads to someone innocent dying. But the justice system is completely designed around figuring out the state of mind of the individual, and then punishing them either more severely or less severely... based on the state of mind.
We are looking at a man who premeditated and purposefully committed a crime. The justice system will be exceptionally harsh on him.
In what percentage of cases of vandalism that could be called tagging could the person be said to have committed the crime accidentally? Virtually none[1]. This crime is more or less always committed on purpose. Not always with journalistic intent, but still.
The author was punished more harshly because (it seems) he embarrassed people. That is unjust.
Not to mention the generally deplorable conditions in the holding cell where he was kept, filled with other people who presumably were guilty of nothing.
[1]Please. I understand that you could create any scenario in which anything happens. But the vast majority of people who commit a similar crime (spray paint on unowned surface) certainly are doing it on purpose.
This was no schoolboy on a dare, this was a political activist making a political point. The author was punished severely, but do not trust his reasons for it. (Last year, it was because of Stop and Frisk. This time, he doesn't even seem to have a political excuse... it seems more like a call to a generic "$%#$# the police").
He did NOT seek to "learn about the justice system", he explicitly tried to get arrested to protest the stop and frisk laws that were being implemented in New York City. Jailtimes and Probation are the expected risks you take when you a political dissident like that.
Besides, there are less obtrusive ways of protest than spray painting a public building.
How does that work exactly? Surely if you want to target violent gangs, you target the violence. Arresting them for painting seems to be about the most backward thing imaginable.
The idea is to find something that is sufficiently common and easy to prove that people you are likely to want to punish for other reasons are likely to engage in (whether or not people who engage in it are likely to be people you want to punish for other reasons), so that you have a lever for prosecution and don't have to do the hard work of proving the actual offense of concern. Its essentially a hack around the Constitutional requirement for proof beyond a reasonable doubt for criminal conviction.
The reasoning is that if you can't nail them for the thing you can't prove, you wing them with the thing you can.
Firstly, Capone was doing tax evasion and the crime of tax evasion had not been brought in to deter gang violence, which is the argument being used here about grafitti, but was considered a serious matter in and of itself.
Also the fact that one major crime boss was once able to be jailed through using tax evasion laws, does not therefore mean that this is a broadly applicable tactic and also does not mean that entire areas of law should be made harsher on the idea that some of the people you are doing for grafitti might be murderers. It is just pure nonsense.
If you're open carrying a gun in Alabama and carrying an ice cream cone in your back pocket, guess what you will be arrested for--the ice cream cone, the thing that's actually illegal. Never mind that the police were called out in the first place for the gun.
And the problem with that reasoning is that it conveniently ignores the point that once you start down that path, you start catching a lot of people who aren't Al Capone in your net.
You are referring to the broken windows policy of policing, where minor crimes or infractions are pursued heavily under the notion that catching people that do this early will somehow curb harsher or violent crimes in the future. However, crime rates in NYC have been falling even before that policy came into existence in the 90s and that policy also has been applied in a way that ties in to racism.
And then there's the question of what "the spirit of the law" means. The courts wouldn't allow a blanket prohibition on "gang activity," even if that may be what legislature had in mind.
I hear Banksy is the head of a premier criminal gang in the UK.
I don't think we know that. Maybe it's true, but I can't rule out other possibilities.
But otherwise a tag is a tag.
> But in between the important cases, I found myself spending most of my time prosecuting people of color for things we white kids did with impunity growing up in the suburbs.
However, I think he ignores a really salient distinction: a lot of these "crimes" like the laws against graffiti, exist not because the acts themselves are particularly heinous, but because they're proxies for things that are dangerous, namely gang activity.
In not going after the author, the police simply did the analysis they are required to do: is this guy a threat within the spirit of the law?
Now, obviously there are shortcomings in the heuristics the police are using here. It's not okay to conclude that someone is a threat because they're a black teenager in a hoodie and aren't a threat because they're a white professional in a suit. But I don't think we really want a mechanical justice system that follows the mere letter of the law instead of the spirit. We don't want police to ignore the distinction between someone tagging a public building to make a point, and gang members tagging a private building to "make a point."