News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by analog31 on Monday December 16, 2013 @08:30AM (#6914562)
Disclaimer: I work for a Fortune 500 company. I suspect the inefficiency added by managers is overblown, because most of them do not spend 100% of their time on traditional management activities such as supervision and decision making. A lot of their work is on tasks that would fall in somebody's lap within any organization. Some of those tasks are ones that I find to be dreadful.
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by RamiK on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:35AM (#6914904)
Parkinson's law and Peter's Principle apply to privately held corporate structures as well. There's whole mountains of busywork and paperwork related to hierarchical structures that give the impression of "work" to both outsiders and insiders where it's really just non-productive paper shovelling.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Principle

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law

Mind you, I'm not sure getting rid of the managerial staff is enough to address these problems fully.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by fiatjaf on Thursday December 19, 2013 @06:49AM (#6934071)
This is the best comment.
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by exodust on Monday December 16, 2013 @08:42AM (#6914609)
Most managers will instinctively delegate dreadful tasks. That's part of the fun of management.

I wonder if there's any managers around who also code? Maybe 50% of their time could be management, 50% coding. Nothing like getting hands dirty with the company code to see where things are at.

Shared management roles could also be an option. Or, manage by committee? There's enough design by committee happening, surely we can all jump in on management decisions?

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by weland on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:22AM (#6914808)
> I wonder if there's any managers around who also code? Maybe 50% of their time could be management, 50% coding. Nothing like getting hands dirty with the company code to see where things are at.

An important part of the reason why so many technical people have an "overblown" idea about the inefficiency added by management is negative experience.

I have met maybe a dozen people who were in management position and were not completely and utterly incompetent at what they were managing. More often than not, the managers I meet were people who started out as programmers, but quickly realized they don't stand a chance building a career out of it. This is an incredibly common career path.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by MrBuddyCasino on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:53AM (#6915014)
This. I'm working as a consultant, and I see the same thing over and over again. There aren't many "IT Managers" that are competent at what they're doing. If you are good at what you are doing (which might be programming), go and look for an environment with like-minded individuals with a sense of craftsmanship and pride in their work. Everything else will suck the life out of you.
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by kabdib on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:48AM (#6915909)
The best managers I've had are ex-coders who have fully realized they cannot both code and do a good job as a manager.

I had one really good coder cow-orker who became my manager. He tried, and it was pretty poignant at times, but eventually realized the truth. Until he did, he mostly sucked at both jobs.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by weland on Monday December 16, 2013 @02:31PM (#6917215)
Yeah, this pretty much sums up what I've seen as well. I know good ex-coders who became good managers, but the stepping stone to doing it was having to stop writing code.
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by mtrimpe on Monday December 16, 2013 @10:28AM (#6915255)
As one of my old (properly self-deprecating) managers used to say "If you're a lightweight you'll float to the top eventually."
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by _puk on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:53AM (#6915021)
> Most managers will instinctively delegate dreadful tasks. That's part of the fun of management.

I think this becomes one of the reasons that so many managers end up being viewed in a negative light.

Surely part of a manager's job is to protect the team from external pressures. The decision to delegate should be made on the basis of the impact of delegating / not delegating, not on how dreadful the task is.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by VLM on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:58AM (#6915062)
I've worked at places with this, usually called something like rotating team lead, or duty engineer, or ops duty, or pager week, or something like that. To the best of my knowledge everyone involved dreaded when their week came up. I've only experienced this implemented WRT (metaphorical) fire fighting not traditional dev work. If an earthshattering bug appears this week, you'll be fixing it and/or triaging it and/or figuring out who can help you fix it.

Its awesome at getting rid of "pass the buck" and awesome for everyone else in the org to have a single point of contact (even if its a different human each week). Not so awesome around changeover time or if your docs aren't up to spec or when you discover the hard way someones code isn't good. Also not so hot at fixing major architectural issues (like, its going to take more than a week to fix this correctly, and I'm only on duty for a week, so whip out the band aids...)

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by dredmorbius on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:12AM (#6920520)
Rotating through on call, especially having not just ops, but engineering rotate, is a huge benefit.

As much as DevOps is being promoted, there are still two fundamentally different skillsets and job descriptions, and if its just the Ops side of the house getting the 2am wake-up pages, you're going to get a decidedly different attitude toward Things Wot Breaks Prod than if the developers are on that rotation as well.

Plus it means rotation comes up that much less often, which is a good thing.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by embwbam on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:40AM (#6914930)
I've tried. It doesn't really work. Organizing is a "heads up" activity and trying to achieve flow while being available to answer questions and stuff is frustrating at best.
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by mattlutze on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:58AM (#6916004)
This is my life right now. About a month ago I took on ~4 reports, but still need to maintain my previous productivity levels. It's really hard to both be available for them / our client and still get into my groove.
Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by _puk on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:41AM (#6914934)
> I wonder if there's any managers around who also code? Maybe 50% of their time could be management, 50% coding. Nothing like getting hands dirty with the company code to see where things are at.

Yes.

Though there is such a mental disparity between coding and higher level management that it is not 100% efficient.

You're either coding or you're managing. You can't be knee deep in an obscure rendering bug whilst also still mentally committing to keeping track of what everyone else is doing. Getting back up to speed (from either one to the other) always takes a small amount of time.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by frobozz on Monday December 16, 2013 @10:38AM (#6915332)
What sort of dreadful tasks are you talking about?

There are plenty of things that managers do, that could just as well be done by some kind of junior administrator.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by analog31 on Monday December 16, 2013 @07:21PM (#6918884)
Tasks that require someone to be fairly articulate and numerate, and at a level where they can be "privy" to sensitive information. From a technical standpoint, a lot of it could be described as data gathering, analysis, and reporting, in situations where those things can't quite be automated.

Comment above about Parkinson's Law and the Peter Principle are duly noted. ;-) I was a manager for a while, so I don't exempt myself from those observations.

Re:First, Let's Fire All The Managers by api on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:50AM (#6915934)
I have seen this too. I worked for a while as a contractor for the U.S. federal government (IT/programming), and saw that the next rung up for me within the fed was becoming a "full fed" and entering management. I saw what many of those people did and ran away screaming, taking a higher-paying alternative coding gig instead.

One of them had worked in the past for Microsoft and said the fed was remarkably similar. I suspect any organization approaches the fed exponentially as its size approaches, say, tens of thousands.