Trying to make code correspond to real world objects is annoying because after you've modeled your Car with Wheels that support Tires, and an Engine with EngineParts attached ... you then have to write a adaptation layer to make all that fit into your storage engine, your user interface, your query engine, etc ad nauseam. Strings are not "real world" objects, but we use them in our code nonetheless. They're a great UI item that lets us interface with our users. "I need input from the user. Here, type some text in this field and I shall call it String." Now you can manipulate the String with operations (methods on the object) that make sense for Strings.
Point: OO is not about "modeling the real world," it's about code organization. Some people organize with OO. Some with other means.
There is of course an alternative: use a function rather than a factory; but that's kind of the point of this discussion :-).
(Before we start a flame war: This isn't a criticsm of ruby or C# specifically, it's just something I've seen a lot in those code bases. Both languages allow writing factories or using lambdas.)
And I entirely agree with you that a PointFactory is unwanted (barring special circumstances) - though I entire disagree you'd want points to be mutable. Certain control points? Certainly - make a MutablePoint which is (conceptually) simply a reference to a point value. All points? That's just asking for pain; I really have better things than to track down with nested submodule thought it was mutating a copy but due to some optimization interaction turned out to be mutating a copy someone was actually looking on. Not to mention that reference semantics don't work very nicely with hashtables and lots of other datastructures which become a lot more complicated when the values can change right under them.
Something like "RectangleCollectionColorPickerFactory" is obviously a confusing and ridiculous concept, and exemplifies a failed application of OOP, not a failure of OOP itself. One could invent equally absurd demonstrations of functional programming, or indeed of any other paradigm.
I only really "got" design patterns when I realized that the strategy pattern was just treating an algorithm/implementation as an object and stopped thinking that OO was exclusively about mapping things to real world objects.
>> That's only true on a superficial level.
Exactly. I had forgot that I learned OOP by modelling a CD collection. When thinking about it now, "mapping" a program into real-world models and terms seems totally backwards.
What's the point of thinking in real-world models unless you program actually manipulates real-world objects? Of course there are properties that are useful to carry over, but why limit your program to real-world models?
That's only true on a superficial level. Sure, in CS 101 it's easy to explain how to make a Point object and add a Move() method to it. But dive into any real-world code base and you're more likely to meet RectangleCollectionColorPickerFactory instead. Let's face it, writing a large program is an exercise in abstract symbol manipulation. Trying to make it correspond to "real" objects is about as hopeless as basing literature on coloring books.