News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Class-based Programming Sucks (2011) by emn13 on Friday December 13, 2013 @06:52PM (#6903605)
I'm not suggesting that everything has a factory; I'm suggesting that having a factory isn't some java-specific code smell; it's a necessary pattern in an OO language. You obviously don't need one for a point. The context was some color picker example - and I could well imagine multiple color pickers and a useful color picker factory.

And I entirely agree with you that a PointFactory is unwanted (barring special circumstances) - though I entire disagree you'd want points to be mutable. Certain control points? Certainly - make a MutablePoint which is (conceptually) simply a reference to a point value. All points? That's just asking for pain; I really have better things than to track down with nested submodule thought it was mutating a copy but due to some optimization interaction turned out to be mutating a copy someone was actually looking on. Not to mention that reference semantics don't work very nicely with hashtables and lots of other datastructures which become a lot more complicated when the values can change right under them.

There are no comments on this comment yet.