News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by maratd on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:41AM (#6894623)
> This is a sensible rule too--if everyone had watermarks the pages would be hideous.

So as a merchant, I have to invest a ton of money into getting quality photography of my products ... only to have my competitors use those same images for free?

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by jonknee on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:01AM (#6894730)
No one is forcing you to pay for ads on Google Shopping so you're free to do whatever, but why would you invest a ton of money into quality photography and then cover it up with a watermark?

If you're selling exactly what everyone else is selling the competitive point is customer service and price--I'd worry much more about that than someone copying your image. Such stores generally use the manufacturer's images anyways.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by maratd on Thursday December 12, 2013 @11:02AM (#6895114)
> No one is forcing you to pay for ads on Google Shopping so you're free to do whatever

Did I say otherwise?

> why would you invest a ton of money into quality photography and then cover it up with a watermark?

To make sure that this quality photography stays as a competitive asset or if used by others, turns into advertising for my store.

> If you're selling exactly what everyone else is selling the competitive point is customer service and price

When you're selling something online, photography is most certainly a differentiator. It is also a substantial barrier to entry for the competition, because quality photography is difficult and expensive.

> Such stores generally use the manufacturer's images anyways.

Manufacturer images, when they exist, are almost always terrible. Having good photos to clearly show off the product and everything included is the difference between a buyer clicking BUY and having them wander off.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by Spoom on Thursday December 12, 2013 @02:09PM (#6896355)
Use a digital watermark. You lose the advertising edge if competitors use it but you can prove that the copyright belongs to you and force them to take it down.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mark-r on Thursday December 12, 2013 @03:56PM (#6897190)
Getting them to take it down is more trouble than it's worth, even if it works. You'll be playing whack-a-mole all day long. Ideally you want them not to use it in the first place, and a visible watermark accomplishes that.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by simoncion on Thursday December 12, 2013 @03:58PM (#6897214)
> Use a digital watermark.

As opposed to those analog watermarks that we've all be hand-applying to our JPEGs? :)

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by Spoom on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:20PM (#6898503)
Digital watermarks are typically invisible.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_watermarking

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by simoncion on Friday December 13, 2013 @12:28PM (#6901702)
The results from this search are at odds with your assertion:

http://images.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=watermarked+image...

Regardless, you seem to have missed the gentle humour in my original post.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by dmethvin on Thursday December 12, 2013 @05:44PM (#6897800)
> why would you invest a ton of money into quality photography and then cover it up with a watermark

I can't speak to Google Shopping, but Amazon requires a high-quality image before you can list a product. So if you spend money on the shot you don't want others stealing it. EXIF data and other non-watermark solutions are easily removed.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by makomk on Thursday December 12, 2013 @11:12AM (#6895176)
No-one's forcing them to pay for ads on Google Shopping, it's just the only way to show up above the fold on Google searches for the products you're selling, which happens to be one of the main ways potential customers will look for sellers. (Google's the best-known search engine and set as the default almost everywhere, in large part based on their reputation from back when they actually tried to provide the best results rather than the most profitable ones.)
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:15AM (#6901243)
This is pie in the sky thinking. The realities of the marketplace right now just don't match up with what you are saying. Often, your product image is one of the key factors in your conversion rate when your products are in third party marketplaces, and it's also not tenable to simply ignore a huge sales channel such as Google shopping.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:29AM (#6894905)
Nope, you're covered by copyright laws there. You give Google an (implicit) license to use your photos, but not your competitors and you can send your lawyer after them.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by samworm on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:51AM (#6894675)
"I have to invest a ton of money" did you miss the bit where this is an optional service? A service which you (and your competitors) should only use if you consider the value offered to outweigh the cost?
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by nmcfarl on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:32AM (#6894926)
I think the parent is saying that without the ability to offer better service, via better photography than the competition, the benefits do not out way the cost for his use case.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by GotNothing on Thursday December 12, 2013 @12:26PM (#6895648)
You're "investing a ton of money" into getting a high quality image, only to then turn around and slap a watermark on it, which more than likely has now downgraded the quality of the image.

To fully deter your competitors from using it, you have to place the watermark in the center of the image/over the product so that they can't easily crop it out.

Now from the potential customers perspective they want to look at those quality images you took and visualize having that product, however now they have to look past/around your watermark which kind of puts a downer in their customer experience.

TLDR: So you've spent tons of money on photos to slap a watermark on top of them and hinder customer experience?

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by pessimizer on Thursday December 12, 2013 @02:51PM (#6896667)
As a person who has purchased things, I couldn't care less if there were a (mostly transparent) watermark on the picture of the thing, and I appreciate high quality photographs.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:54AM (#6894699)
In other words, you'll only sell through venues which allow you to use DRM? That's your right, of course, but I don't know that you'll get much sympathy.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:27AM (#6901342)
I see so many people in this thread who are extremely disconnected from the reality of what it takes to be successful in ecommerce. They haven't had to deal with the fly-by-night sellers who set up, steal their product data and images from you, blow out everything at below MAP price and then shut down when they get caught only to pop up next week under a different name.

Third party sales channels represent a HUGE portion of the market, you can't afford to ignore them as a reseller. Often your only advantage in a third party channel is the quality of your data and images. Your company name is never allowed to feature prominently, and if you think good customer service will convince somebody to pay 20% more for your product than the guy who's breaking MAP policy you are kidding yourself. Good customer feedback is the minimum bar for selling successfully through third party channels, not a differentiator. In many marketplaces, sellers who have bad feedback will simply set up a new account and start over, seeding themselves with good feedback from day one.

What all this adds up to is a lose/lose for honest companies that play by the rules, make no mistake, protecting the images that you've invested capital in to create is very important.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:44AM (#6901425)
While that all sounds perfectly fine and reasonable, the fact is that you can basically s/ecommerce/music/ and your post would be right at home in a thread about sleazy DRM tactics by RIAA members.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @01:25PM (#6902013)
That is a completely specious argument and I think you know it.

A: We are not talking about a product here. We aren't selling an image to somebody, then slapping a watermark on it. We are creating material, at our own expense that we are using to advertise a product. Do you think that Coke should be allowed to use Pepsi's marketing as their own, or is not allowing that some sort of draconian DRM tactic too?

B: We aren't actually talking about consumers here at all - the issue is the inability to control how other companies use the materials you've created, and hold the rights to.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @01:34PM (#6902053)
Talk about specious arguments! Where did I ever say that other companies should be allowed to use your images? Please remember that DRM is completely unrelated to legal permission to violate someone's copyright. Confusing the two is a favorite tactic of RIAA-type people, though, so your post just makes the parallel all the stronger.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @04:35PM (#6903035)
I'm not sure why you are conflating a watermark with DRM in the first place, or how you could possibly think this has anything to do with 'RIAA-type people'.

I'm honestly not sure what to even say to you because you aren't making any sense.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @10:42PM (#6904481)
Watermarks are definitely DRM in my book. A technological measure used to prevent or at least discourage copyright infringement. It's the same basic idea as e.g. the coded anti-piracy dots you see in movie theaters.

My point is quite simple: the arguments being made defending watermarks are the exact same arguments people make to defend DRM on movies and music. That doesn't mean they're wrong, of course.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:45PM (#6904663)
Ah, I think I understand your position on this, thank you for explaining. Even if the arguments sound the same, they are valid (or not), for very different reasons, because the situations are very different.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by jborden13 on Thursday December 12, 2013 @04:19PM (#6897364)
The consolidation of eCommerce & product advertising to a 2 primary platforms makes this anti-competitive and an anti-trust issue. I sympathize with him as he has the right to compete and to not be unduly constrained from competition .
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Thursday December 12, 2013 @04:43PM (#6897478)
Even if there really are only two primary e-commerce platforms, I would say that Google Shopping is definitely not one of them. It's a terrible experience and nobody I know uses it intentionally.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by jborden13 on Thursday December 12, 2013 @04:58PM (#6897568)
"I would say that Google Shopping is definitely not one of them. It's a terrible experience and nobody I know uses it intentionally."

UI/UX aside - it and Amazon are the largest online sources for product promotion, information and purchasing (when Google finally launches their marketplace). Google Shopping is heavily used.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @10:42AM (#6901034)
I really wouldn't have guessed. When I think e-commerce, I think Amazon, eBay, NewEgg.... Do you happen to have any numbers on it? Finding e-commerce numbers is already pretty hard, and finding numbers for an aggregator like Google Shopping seems just about impossible.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:42AM (#6901412)
Your right, they don't use it intentionally, most people still think the google shopping results are part of the organic search return.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by awestroke on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:51AM (#6894678)
If your competitors wanted to use your images, they'd just remove the watermarks and use them anyway. Also, who cares if your competitors use them? Aim for better service.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by hrktb on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:10AM (#6894786)
I am not sure to agree with the parent post, but I guess the point he/she tries to make is that the merchant will spend the time/money to have a product image, but this image will be reused for every other merchants selling the same product. It creates a situation where no merchant has an incentive to invest in having original or specific product images, as it won't make any difference relative to the competition, and if a product has a shitty image, tough luck.

The basic stance would be "that's Google's policy, deal with it", and I undestand it. At the same time, there are so many product with really awful images (for a coat, there would be no view of the inner fabric for instance). If a merchant would take the time to take relevant pictures of the right functionnalities of a product, I'd also understand wanting clients to know they're the one who cared about it. With google shopping's system, the product maker has the burden of providing decent images of it's product, or no one will care to make something better.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by spindritf on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:33AM (#6894937)
The maker/producer/distributor should provide advertising materials and they usually do. The system where every little shop selling the same thing takes its own photos of the product is terribly inefficient.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by maratd on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:54AM (#6895059)
> The maker/producer/distributor should provide advertising materials and they usually do.

They usually don't. To be more specific, their photos always suck.

When you're buying something online, photos do make the difference and having good photos is what makes people click on BUY.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by hrktb on Thursday December 12, 2013 @03:32PM (#6897019)
Often a maker's product image will be a single image taken at the best angle, hiding properties of the product that are not 'sexy'.

You'd see some really cheap goods but the image doesn't give any information about why it would be so, what trade-offs you're making. A shop can show these details and let people buy a better product if they feel like it, or buy the product without feeling betrayed at delivery.

Should every small shop care about product images ? of course no. Most of then should be OK with maker provided images. Would I value a shop showing even crappy but real images of the products ? Oh yes !