News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:54AM (#6894699)
In other words, you'll only sell through venues which allow you to use DRM? That's your right, of course, but I don't know that you'll get much sympathy.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:27AM (#6901342)
I see so many people in this thread who are extremely disconnected from the reality of what it takes to be successful in ecommerce. They haven't had to deal with the fly-by-night sellers who set up, steal their product data and images from you, blow out everything at below MAP price and then shut down when they get caught only to pop up next week under a different name.

Third party sales channels represent a HUGE portion of the market, you can't afford to ignore them as a reseller. Often your only advantage in a third party channel is the quality of your data and images. Your company name is never allowed to feature prominently, and if you think good customer service will convince somebody to pay 20% more for your product than the guy who's breaking MAP policy you are kidding yourself. Good customer feedback is the minimum bar for selling successfully through third party channels, not a differentiator. In many marketplaces, sellers who have bad feedback will simply set up a new account and start over, seeding themselves with good feedback from day one.

What all this adds up to is a lose/lose for honest companies that play by the rules, make no mistake, protecting the images that you've invested capital in to create is very important.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:44AM (#6901425)
While that all sounds perfectly fine and reasonable, the fact is that you can basically s/ecommerce/music/ and your post would be right at home in a thread about sleazy DRM tactics by RIAA members.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @01:25PM (#6902013)
That is a completely specious argument and I think you know it.

A: We are not talking about a product here. We aren't selling an image to somebody, then slapping a watermark on it. We are creating material, at our own expense that we are using to advertise a product. Do you think that Coke should be allowed to use Pepsi's marketing as their own, or is not allowing that some sort of draconian DRM tactic too?

B: We aren't actually talking about consumers here at all - the issue is the inability to control how other companies use the materials you've created, and hold the rights to.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @01:34PM (#6902053)
Talk about specious arguments! Where did I ever say that other companies should be allowed to use your images? Please remember that DRM is completely unrelated to legal permission to violate someone's copyright. Confusing the two is a favorite tactic of RIAA-type people, though, so your post just makes the parallel all the stronger.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @04:35PM (#6903035)
I'm not sure why you are conflating a watermark with DRM in the first place, or how you could possibly think this has anything to do with 'RIAA-type people'.

I'm honestly not sure what to even say to you because you aren't making any sense.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @10:42PM (#6904481)
Watermarks are definitely DRM in my book. A technological measure used to prevent or at least discourage copyright infringement. It's the same basic idea as e.g. the coded anti-piracy dots you see in movie theaters.

My point is quite simple: the arguments being made defending watermarks are the exact same arguments people make to defend DRM on movies and music. That doesn't mean they're wrong, of course.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:45PM (#6904663)
Ah, I think I understand your position on this, thank you for explaining. Even if the arguments sound the same, they are valid (or not), for very different reasons, because the situations are very different.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by jborden13 on Thursday December 12, 2013 @04:19PM (#6897364)
The consolidation of eCommerce & product advertising to a 2 primary platforms makes this anti-competitive and an anti-trust issue. I sympathize with him as he has the right to compete and to not be unduly constrained from competition .
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Thursday December 12, 2013 @04:43PM (#6897478)
Even if there really are only two primary e-commerce platforms, I would say that Google Shopping is definitely not one of them. It's a terrible experience and nobody I know uses it intentionally.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by jborden13 on Thursday December 12, 2013 @04:58PM (#6897568)
"I would say that Google Shopping is definitely not one of them. It's a terrible experience and nobody I know uses it intentionally."

UI/UX aside - it and Amazon are the largest online sources for product promotion, information and purchasing (when Google finally launches their marketplace). Google Shopping is heavily used.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mikeash on Friday December 13, 2013 @10:42AM (#6901034)
I really wouldn't have guessed. When I think e-commerce, I think Amazon, eBay, NewEgg.... Do you happen to have any numbers on it? Finding e-commerce numbers is already pretty hard, and finding numbers for an aggregator like Google Shopping seems just about impossible.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:42AM (#6901412)
Your right, they don't use it intentionally, most people still think the google shopping results are part of the organic search return.