Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by cs702 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:09PM
(#6881905)
"I really like Bitcoin. I own bitcoins." - David Marcus, President, PayPal
He adds: "People are confused. They think because it's called cryptocurrency it's a currency. I don't think it is a currency. It's a store of value, a distributed ledger. It's a great place to put assets, especially in places like Argentina with 40 percent inflation, where $1 today is worth 60 cents in a year, and a government's currency does not hold value. It's also a good investment vehicle if you have an appetite for risk. But it won't be a currency until volatility slows down. Whenever the regulatory framework is clearer, and the volatility comes down, then we'll consider it."
I agree with him that Bitcoin is a ready-made solution for people living in less stable economies who want to diversify away from their (risky) local currency, particularly if they find it difficult or impossible to buy US dollars or euros through their local financial system.
Would you rather own (a) savings in a bank account denominated in a "soft" currency (whether Argentine pesos, Bolivian bolivianos, Libyan dinars, North Korean wons, Syrian pounds, Venezuelan bolivares, or some other one), or (b) bitcoins, which, despite their recent volatility, are used globally[1] and do not require trusting a third party?
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by gasull on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:12PM
(#6882427)
I would rather have bitcoins than any other currency for my savings. For spending, you just need the local currency, since Bitcoin isn't accepted in most places yet.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by alexmat on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:45PM
(#6884390)
On a day to day basis sure, but over weeks and months, the trend has been positive. As long as you purchase bitcoins well in advance of when you need to spend them, they have historically preformed very well even with all the volatility. Assuming you buy into the idea of network effect creating a positive price feedback loop, it's a reasonable place to stash cash that you may need on short notice or when traveling abroad.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by chalst on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:06AM
(#6886670)
I have the opposite view: Bitcoins are exciting and promising as a currency, but they are very flawed as a store of value.
If for some reason, I had no confidence in any currency/bonds I could get my hands on, I would prefer gold to Bitcoins, because I expect that, while it is more volatile than a properly run currency, it is far less volatile than Bitcoin and I expect that to remain so in the future.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by rthomas6 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:55PM
(#6882293)
All ebay has to do is accept bitcoins.
What is stopping something like this? If Ebay uses a service to convert directly from BTC to dollars, there's no volatility risk. Is it fear of bad press? Fear of angering existing players like Paypal? Is it logistics? I'm biased, but why wouldn't Ebay accept an additional form of payment for free?
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by acjohnson55 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:15PM
(#6882940)
That's why I'm convinced Bitcoin's inflation mitigation is irrelevant. If it proves to be a truly useful currency, people will simply mint other cryptocurrencies, which will be nearly-perfect substitutes.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by rthomas6 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:16PM
(#6882458)
Sure, accept all of them. Why not? It's trivial to accept them, the only difficulty is the volatility compared to dollars, which for Bitcoin is a solved problem.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by rthomas6 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:55PM
(#6882778)
Merchants don't have to hold Bitcoins to accept them as payment. Several services exist that convert Bitcoin payments directly into local currency, allowing merchants to accept Bitcoin without exposing themselves to its volatility.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by waps on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:07PM
(#6884869)
You're assuming ebay wouldn't take 14% of bitcoin sales. Hell, since they don't owe the credit card tax they could probably make it 10% and still make more per-transaction.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by Nursie on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:13AM
(#6887021)
I reckon paypal probably has enough volume to get a pretty sweet deal out of the credit-card processors compared to your average retailer. But you're right, they could take a cut of BTC transactions, and then the BTC folks would whine about high fees.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by Nursie on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:21PM
(#6882510)
icebraining beat me to it - from what I've read PayPal has historically made up a serious proportion of Ebay's profits, like 40% (though they have bought other payment processors recently so maybe it's been dropping).
Introducing non-paypal payment methods would cut directly into their profits.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by tomasien on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:54PM
(#6882289)
Paypal hangs on for 2 reasons:
1. Foreign countries, where credit cards aren't common (but banks are)
2. People in the US who hate entering CC info for every payment
3. Merchants without alternatives
People have felt for a while that there's nothing that can solve all 3 of those things, but I think there is.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by calpaterson on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:47AM
(#6881742)
I think NFC payment is more compelling in countries like the UK where you cannot swipe a card, you have to insert it and then enter your PIN (all or nearly UK bank cards are two-factor). For payments smaller than ~£15 though, you can just use NFC, which is a lot quick, especially for crowded pubs.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by canistr on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:12PM
(#6881937)
I disagree considering that in Canada, we already have PayPass (by Mastercard) and Interact Flash for simply tapping and paying on the go. It's faster than logging into my phone and keeps the simplicity of credit cards. And the risk is on the credit card companies for small payments (<$50).
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by bnastic on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:46PM
(#6882708)
Most debit/credit cards in the UK are now contactless, and the number of retailers deploying contactless card readers seems to be steadily increasing. It is easy and convenient, I see no need for NFC as it stands right now.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by JimmaDaRustla on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:13AM
(#6881506)
Um, what? He makes NFC sound inconvenient to customers - how can you be more minimalistic in approach other than just pressing two devices together and having the transaction complete seconds later?
I think he may be on to something - there is the current development of presenting cards by an NFC enabled device, like a phone. This is a huge process to get the virtual card to the customer securely - one of the abstract approaches, which I don't think is really being taken seriously, is virtualizing the card communication in a cloud, so the card is never downloaded or emulated on the device, like an Android phone. This is kind of leaning towards an "invisible" transaction he speaks of, where a secure payment could be done as an after thought without an actual device or interaction?
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by brownbat on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:20AM
(#6881553)
"It's not a question of whether people at a payment terminal would prefer to tap or swipe, he said, but a reality that people don't want to go to a payment terminal at all."
I think this is right. The amazing future doesn't change what I get out of my pocket. The amazing future lets me walk into a store and just walk out with things without stopping, while some computers in the background just make sure all accounts are settled.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by VLM on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:43AM
(#6881700)
"a reality that people don't want to go to a payment terminal at all"
I had to read that section about three times because I interpreted that as "amazon app, box arrives on doorstep in two days, cheaper than in store (store aka showroom)"
That's pretty much how I shop now. Going out and paying more is already an inconvenience, waving something around, or not, is already a rounding error of the total sum of inconvenience.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by JimmaDaRustla on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:38AM
(#6881676)
Truth be told, merchants don't want that risk. Merchants don't even want NFC - they want payment to be made securely and not have negative impact on their customers.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by seiji on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:43AM
(#6881699)
Apple Stores allow you to walk in, scan an item with your phone's camera, pay, put the item in your backpack, then walk out without talking to anybody.
There's a limit ($200 max on phone self-checkout), but they don't seem concerned with shrink.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by richardlblair on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:18PM
(#6882975)
I have an idea! Let's make broad statements based off the actions of a company with massive amounts of Cash on Hand.
Consider that most merchants don't have much of any cash. I know it's hard to believe because your world revolves around Starbucks and Apple, but put the iDevice down for a second and join the rest of reality. Merchants don't want risk. I know of merchants that do reasonably well, and a single chargeback is a real piss off. They (chargebacks) don't just cost money (you are out the money and the product), they also cost time if you try to dispute it.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by JimmaDaRustla on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:03PM
(#6882341)
I work in the smart card payment industry for a large north american bank. I've been in conferences with actual merchants voicing their concerns. I didn't make my observations sitting at Starbucks.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by JimmaDaRustla on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:32PM
(#6882596)
And also more secure than traditional payment methods since it is prepaid and the merchant is guaranteed not to be frauded.
What merchants don't want, typically, is added customer convenience to payment methods IF it adds additional risk for fraud. EMV Chip has been a huge success, and NFC is kind of a step backward because anyone can steal a NFC chip card and make small purchases, which means merchants still need to dispute fraud charges.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by a3voices on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:15AM
(#6881521)
You still have to unlock your phone and press some buttons on it. It's arguably not any easier than pulling a credit card out of your wallet and swiping it.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by JimmaDaRustla on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:33AM
(#6881639)
Context was NFC, no swiping, just tapping and done.
I was just using a phone as an example for virtualized cards, which kind of feeds his thoughts on an "invisible" transaction because the interaction between terminal and card is becoming emulated and not two physical devices communicating between each other.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by skloubkov on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:14PM
(#6883761)
I think this comes from the fact that Bitcoin transactions cant be refunded, but PayPal ones can be.
So buyer could cancel the purchase and keep bitcoin with merchant being unable to do anything.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by mrb on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:35AM
(#6881652)
I thought about this and it would be a great idea. Today's solutions typically involve scanning a QR code and the Bitcoin wallet sends the transaction over the Internet. But when you have poor signal, this does not work well.
Instead, a Bitcoin wallet could send the transaction (a few hundred bytes) over NFC. This gives an extra advantage: the point-of-sale would broadcast the transaction to hundreds of Bitcoin p2p nodes itself, hence reducing the risk of accepting a zero-confirmation transaction!
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by 00rion on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:49PM
(#6883183)
If it takes approximately 10 minutes to confirm a transaction, it seems like you would be putting merchants at risk. Perhaps some sort of bitcoin insurance would mitigate this risk for a small monthly fee.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by trekky1700 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:57PM
(#6882305)
Of course the president of PayPal would prefer a digital method of payments that he can capitalize on to one that works in physical shops. I use NFC as often as possible because it is so much faster and more convenient, especially for small purchases.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by trekky1700 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:52PM
(#6883204)
I give my card to the cashier, they swipe it, I then wait for a receipt to print, wait for the cashier to hand me a pen and the receipt, sign the receipt, hand it back to the cashier with the pen. If they're doing it right, they compare the signature to the one on the card, but in most cases I am then done.
versus
I wait for the onscreen prompt, I tap my card, hear a satisfying beep and am done.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by VLM on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:48AM
(#6881746)
The goal of NFC seems to be profit off mistakes.
Whoops finger slipped and that went on the corporate card; well, there's a $25 charge to transfer an accidental charge.
Or
Whoops finger slipped and that spouse christmas gift went on the shared expenses card. Well, if you don't want her to find out early, there's a simple $25 convenience fee to transfer to a different account.
Or
Whoops paid for the new snowblower in "cash" using direct debit from the checking account instead of the credit card. Woo hoo thats ten bounced checks at $50 pure profit, err, I mean, "fee", each!
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by swombat on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:38PM
(#6882159)
I've been using NFC to make various purchases for some time and have not made one single mistake. Even if I did, where exactly do these $25 charges come from? Who charges them?
I've not been charged any extra charges for using NFC.
The goal of NFC seems to be to make it easier to spend small amounts of money.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by sjtgraham on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:24PM
(#6882533)
I agree. In the event I did make a mistake I can log on to online banking (or open the app on my phone) and make a almost instant transfer the money to another account using faster payments for free.
Even if these fees were assessed, it strikes me as an incredibly inefficient way to generate revenue.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by trekky1700 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:54PM
(#6882288)
In Canada, NFC is pretty much everywhere and I have never, nor have I heard of anyone making a mistake. I use it as often as possible because of how fast and convenient it is, much better than chips and pins or the really old signature methods.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by jrockway on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:52PM
(#6882271)
Unfortunately, the "near" in NFC really makes that difficult. The antenna on the reader and the antenna on the card need to be about a centimeter apart. Only if you're really lucky will it work through a wallet, and with multiple cards in the way? Unlikely to work.
Re:PayPal president David Marcus: Bitcoin is good, NFC is bad
by dcc1 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:50AM
(#6881760)
Uhm f&k paypal, they regularly screw over sellers and businesses no matter how long you sell with them using paypal (or on ebay) or how low your chargeback rate is or how high your rating is.
f*k em, paypal are driving themselves to irrelevancy
On bright side 2 years ago when paypal screwed me and my company it pushed me to look at alternatives and i bought a pile of bitcoins when testing how it works, this turned out to be the best decision ever, thanks paypal for making me $$$
He adds: "People are confused. They think because it's called cryptocurrency it's a currency. I don't think it is a currency. It's a store of value, a distributed ledger. It's a great place to put assets, especially in places like Argentina with 40 percent inflation, where $1 today is worth 60 cents in a year, and a government's currency does not hold value. It's also a good investment vehicle if you have an appetite for risk. But it won't be a currency until volatility slows down. Whenever the regulatory framework is clearer, and the volatility comes down, then we'll consider it."
I agree with him that Bitcoin is a ready-made solution for people living in less stable economies who want to diversify away from their (risky) local currency, particularly if they find it difficult or impossible to buy US dollars or euros through their local financial system.
Would you rather own (a) savings in a bank account denominated in a "soft" currency (whether Argentine pesos, Bolivian bolivianos, Libyan dinars, North Korean wons, Syrian pounds, Venezuelan bolivares, or some other one), or (b) bitcoins, which, despite their recent volatility, are used globally[1] and do not require trusting a third party?
--
[1] http://getaddr.bitnodes.io/251/
For reference: http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg1460ztgSzm1g40...
Been working on a pure-BTC retirement portfolio fund that I'd luuuv to sell you. Step right up...
If for some reason, I had no confidence in any currency/bonds I could get my hands on, I would prefer gold to Bitcoins, because I expect that, while it is more volatile than a properly run currency, it is far less volatile than Bitcoin and I expect that to remain so in the future.
Was kinda hoping Bitcoin would finally be the micropayment system that kneecaps them.
What is stopping something like this? If Ebay uses a service to convert directly from BTC to dollars, there's no volatility risk. Is it fear of bad press? Fear of angering existing players like Paypal? Is it logistics? I'm biased, but why wouldn't Ebay accept an additional form of payment for free?
See: https://bitpay.com/
Introducing non-paypal payment methods would cut directly into their profits.
1. Foreign countries, where credit cards aren't common (but banks are) 2. People in the US who hate entering CC info for every payment 3. Merchants without alternatives
People have felt for a while that there's nothing that can solve all 3 of those things, but I think there is.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contactless_smart_card [2]: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-18265388
I think he may be on to something - there is the current development of presenting cards by an NFC enabled device, like a phone. This is a huge process to get the virtual card to the customer securely - one of the abstract approaches, which I don't think is really being taken seriously, is virtualizing the card communication in a cloud, so the card is never downloaded or emulated on the device, like an Android phone. This is kind of leaning towards an "invisible" transaction he speaks of, where a secure payment could be done as an after thought without an actual device or interaction?
I think this is right. The amazing future doesn't change what I get out of my pocket. The amazing future lets me walk into a store and just walk out with things without stopping, while some computers in the background just make sure all accounts are settled.
I had to read that section about three times because I interpreted that as "amazon app, box arrives on doorstep in two days, cheaper than in store (store aka showroom)"
That's pretty much how I shop now. Going out and paying more is already an inconvenience, waving something around, or not, is already a rounding error of the total sum of inconvenience.
There's a limit ($200 max on phone self-checkout), but they don't seem concerned with shrink.
Consider that most merchants don't have much of any cash. I know it's hard to believe because your world revolves around Starbucks and Apple, but put the iDevice down for a second and join the rest of reality. Merchants don't want risk. I know of merchants that do reasonably well, and a single chargeback is a real piss off. They (chargebacks) don't just cost money (you are out the money and the product), they also cost time if you try to dispute it.
What merchants don't want, typically, is added customer convenience to payment methods IF it adds additional risk for fraud. EMV Chip has been a huge success, and NFC is kind of a step backward because anyone can steal a NFC chip card and make small purchases, which means merchants still need to dispute fraud charges.
I was just using a phone as an example for virtualized cards, which kind of feeds his thoughts on an "invisible" transaction because the interaction between terminal and card is becoming emulated and not two physical devices communicating between each other.
While with nfc the phone manufacturers have full control and they will be dead in the water while Apple/Google process all the transactions.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eob532iEpqk
Did he have to play the two-step bank account shuffle like the rest of us?
Instead, a Bitcoin wallet could send the transaction (a few hundred bytes) over NFC. This gives an extra advantage: the point-of-sale would broadcast the transaction to hundreds of Bitcoin p2p nodes itself, hence reducing the risk of accepting a zero-confirmation transaction!
No handing cards, picking up terminals, signing receipts, checking signatures or any other nonsense.
It's also secure--tapping is chip compliant.
You can also have more than one card on your phone.
versus
I wait for the onscreen prompt, I tap my card, hear a satisfying beep and am done.
It's pretty obvious the difference.
Whoops finger slipped and that went on the corporate card; well, there's a $25 charge to transfer an accidental charge.
Or
Whoops finger slipped and that spouse christmas gift went on the shared expenses card. Well, if you don't want her to find out early, there's a simple $25 convenience fee to transfer to a different account.
Or
Whoops paid for the new snowblower in "cash" using direct debit from the checking account instead of the credit card. Woo hoo thats ten bounced checks at $50 pure profit, err, I mean, "fee", each!
I've not been charged any extra charges for using NFC.
The goal of NFC seems to be to make it easier to spend small amounts of money.
Even if these fees were assessed, it strikes me as an incredibly inefficient way to generate revenue.
Plus NFC is only for small amounts (usually) so the snow-blower thing is pure nonsense.
f*k em, paypal are driving themselves to irrelevancy
On bright side 2 years ago when paypal screwed me and my company it pushed me to look at alternatives and i bought a pile of bitcoins when testing how it works, this turned out to be the best decision ever, thanks paypal for making me $$$