Re:New study shows nuts reduce cardiovascular disease risk u...
by greenyoda on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:06AM
(#6879695)
Note that these results are not the results of controlled experiments. The people who were eating nuts had other attributes that could have accounted for their better health:
Specifically, several confounding variables in the data could have accounted for part of the “nut effect”. The confounding variables included BMI, smoking, and exercise. Those that consumed nuts and ate a Mediterranean diet also had a lower BMI, a lower waist circumference, were less likely to smoke, and were more physically active. These factors may have “skewed” the results in favor of the “nut eaters.”
Also, the people who eat more nuts are probably eating less of something else. Since nuts are frequently eaten as snacks, it's likely that they're eating nuts instead of sugary, processed food like cookies or candy. So the improved health could be the result of what they're not eating rather than what they are eating.
Edit: Reading the article reminded me of this paper:
"Why Most Published Research Findings Are False" (2005)
Re:New study shows nuts reduce cardiovascular disease risk u...
by polskibus on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:10AM
(#6879709)
If this is true, squirrels should be immortal. Seriously though, nuts are quite hard to digest - you shouldnt really eat a lot of them especially when you are old - digesting nuts puts excessive strain on your liver, etc.
Re:New study shows nuts reduce cardiovascular disease risk u...
by Fundlab on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:05AM
(#6879869)
Boiled peanuts are anything but hard to digest. It appears the mode of preparation or consumption determines the level of strain it puts on the digestive system.
BTW i have a 90yr old dad who consumes roasted and salted peanuts daily. YMMV
Re:New study shows nuts reduce cardiovascular disease risk u...
by yconst on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:22AM
(#6879742)
Not even having read the article, I just want to express my disgust towards the often used "up to x" type statistics and their deceptive misguiding nature.
Re:New study shows nuts reduce cardiovascular disease risk u...
by vixen99 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @06:02AM
(#6880032)
One question on this should be does the 'modified palm oil' reported as one of the constituents, contain trans fats. i wouldn't touch it until I am reassured on that.
Specifically, several confounding variables in the data could have accounted for part of the “nut effect”. The confounding variables included BMI, smoking, and exercise. Those that consumed nuts and ate a Mediterranean diet also had a lower BMI, a lower waist circumference, were less likely to smoke, and were more physically active. These factors may have “skewed” the results in favor of the “nut eaters.”
Also, the people who eat more nuts are probably eating less of something else. Since nuts are frequently eaten as snacks, it's likely that they're eating nuts instead of sugary, processed food like cookies or candy. So the improved health could be the result of what they're not eating rather than what they are eating.
Edit: Reading the article reminded me of this paper:
"Why Most Published Research Findings Are False" (2005)
By John P. A. Ioannidis
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1182327/
There's also a discussion of Ioannidis' work here:
"Lies, Damned Lies, and Medical Science" (2010)
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/11/lies-dam...
It's more of a linguistic categorization than anything else.
And even though they may share some dietetic properties, well, Brazil nuts are one thing, Almonds are another, Pistachios are another.
i.e. it was the culture of eating rather than the content of the diet that made it healthy.
(Rather than "clean your plate", "second helpings", and "eat til you're full")
Edit: here is a link for the French diet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_paradox
BTW i have a 90yr old dad who consumes roasted and salted peanuts daily. YMMV
But then, the very idea of "healthy" and "unhealthy" foods is a fallacy. What's healthy or unhealthy is your diet in its entirety.