News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by perlpimp on Monday December 09, 2013 @03:45PM (#6876813)
Sounds like a trap to me, not having the source code. Maybe it works for now but investing trust as things are now I'd rather go with opensource client.

Trust must be earned, so far it they brag about way they made tech work with a patched version of android - they don't really put forth anything that will give them credibility as a very secure protocol.

Claims without proof are just that.

Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by tptacek on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:25PM (#6877137)
The track record of open source cryptography is bad.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by dublinben on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:27PM (#6877148)
The track record of closed source cryptography is worse.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by IanChiles on Monday December 09, 2013 @04:52PM (#6877305)
cough cryptocat cough
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by atmosx on Monday December 09, 2013 @05:12PM (#6877424)
The cryptocat issue can be viewed sideways:

* Open source applications are bad, see what happened to cryptocat?

* Open source is awesome! Look what happened to cryptocat!

If cryptocat was closed-source... would ever be noticed? I wonder...

Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by tptacek on Monday December 09, 2013 @05:25PM (#6877493)
People insist on looking at this through their default prism of "closed source bad, open source good". But people with crypto experience have other prisms; for instance, "competent, well-vetted crypto" versus "amateur enthusiast crypto". Sometimes open source is also competent and well-vetted, but vetting is expensive, and there is a lot of amateur crypto out there.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by nocoment on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @03:53AM (#6879663)
> Sometimes open source is also competent and well-vetted, but vetting is expensive, and there is a lot of amateur crypto out there.

You seem to be implying that one must be a hobbyist in order to write incompetent crypto software with no or incompetent review and tend to need company resources to get quality code reviews.

Having crypto is often an important checkmark and tack on for shipping a product and usually no one in the product group is competent to analyze the security of the way they tacked on encryption. If a few in the larger company are competent, they will avoid reviewing these projects. Being the engineer everyone associates with delays and frustrations doesn't do much for you and there will never be any proof of the costs you may have prevented.

The few better than I know how to criticize implementations that I have seen haveusually had considerable cross company and university involvement. That usually means open source or a lot of NDA and complex license agreements for cross organization code sharing.

Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by tptacek on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:31PM (#6885020)
I have no idea what you're trying to say here, but just a random stab at responding: my perspective in this discussion comes from managing a consulting practice that, among a few other things, specializes in assessing the security of cryptographic implementations.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by nocoment on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:34PM (#6889059)
I've been in a role of evaluating security vulnerabilities on security products and features from many different origins..

All I am saying is that I am in a position to estimate ~9/10 of everything critically exceeds the competence of its authors to safely combine features and security. So a primary explanation for failure that only applies to 40%(60%?) of the market doesn't sound right to me.

So either we disagree considerably on proportion of software that is poorly implemented or you are saying the majority of commercial software is also written by hobbyists?

Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by wglb on Monday December 09, 2013 @05:59PM (#6877697)
For example?
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by eliteraspberrie on Monday December 09, 2013 @06:53PM (#6877966)
There are claims that Crypto AG products used to leak keys in ciphertext, at the request of the NSA:

http://www.hermetic.ch/crypto/kalliste/speccoll.htm

Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by tptacek on Monday December 09, 2013 @06:12PM (#6877757)
I stifled the urge to say the same thing, but then realized that I'd lose the evening to defining what "mainstream" meant, after people dredged up random examples of snake oil from Schneier blog posts; not to mention the inevitable rehashing of the "beware custom algorithms and 390244 bit keys" thread, which is going to have to happen now because bringing up crypto truisms from the late-90s makes people feel smart.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by tga_d on Monday December 09, 2013 @09:21PM (#6878573)
You're being unfair and you know it. Lavabit, the RSA fiasco, Apple's imessage crypto, etc. are all perfectly mainstream examples of closed-source crypto done wrong. As you said yourself, the only thing that conclusively makes a difference is if the crypto is "well vetted," having the source available is simply a means of making this easier. Classifying the quality of crypto-implementations based on the source model alone ("The track record of open source cryptography is bad.")is just disingenuous.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by tptacek on Monday December 09, 2013 @09:37PM (#6878646)
No, I'm not being unfair. I don't think "open source" versus "closed source" has much at all to do with how secure a cryptosystem is. I do think having Trevor Perrin and Moxie Marlinspike working on your crypto design has a lot to do with how secure a cryptosystem is.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by tga_d on Monday December 09, 2013 @09:53PM (#6878715)
Yes, you are being unfair. You can't say I don't think "open source" versus "closed source" has much at all to do with how secure a cryptosystem is (somewhat agreed) while simultaneously saying The track record of open source cryptography is bad (utter nonsense and misleading), unless your point is that closed source cryptography has an equally bad record.
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by uniclaude on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:40AM (#6879348)
Please explain for those of us who are not good enough in the field (I'm genuinely asking).

I was under the impression that software like GnuPG and OpenSSL could be considered safe, so seeing a security professional warning about a negative track record of open source cryptography is worrisome.

What exactly should we be careful of when it comes to open source cryptography?

Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by lvh on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @03:14PM (#6883367)
Not all open source code is broken; just a lot of it is. I think tptacek is trying to say that open source vs closed source is a mediocre predictor of the quality of a cryptosystem :)
Re:TextSecure, Now With 10 Million More Users by illicium on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @03:53AM (#6879660)
OpenSSL