Let's not forget that writing is still (I don't know how long it will remain) a creative art. And though the vast majority of it has been reduced to algorithmic, LCM commodities, surely we can allow a few artists to tell their stories the way they want to?
I know that a lot of people shy away from large pages of print, but the imagery and format of this article is pretty inconsistent.
That said, after reading it all, I think I agree with the author but it's hard to tell.
For example:
"A hundred years ago, at a time very like ours, a small group of journalists did just that. And the person who takes you back to that time is Tamara Mellon's ex-husband - Matthew Mellon."
"At the end of the 19th century, Matthew Mellon's great great uncle - Andrew Mellon - was one of the most powerful and richest men in the world. He was part of a small group of bankers and industrialists who not only dominated America - but were using the power of money to undermine, corrupt and control politicians, judges and the whole system of democracy."
He goes from talking about hacking, spying and intrusive tabloid journalism in the modern era to the turn of the century Robber Barons, and the only link is a coincidental blood relationship between the characters that he flits between.
I feel the author has something important to say, even if it's difficult to grasp exactly what it is. He would perhaps benefit from splitting the article into several pieces (surprising to say, as so many online publications abuse this in order to artificially drive page views) in order to focus on one topic at a time, and then bringing the narrative together at the end.
It's Adam Curtis. This is what he does.
His segues weren't all perfectly relevant this time, but it's just his style.
That's what many subscribe to. There are schools of thought that disagree. Some readers enjoy not knowing where the text is going; done well, it makes the payoff significantly more pleasurable.
What you said certainly does seem to be the fashion at the moment; the number of books whose first chapter is simply a dull forewarning of what each of the following chapters is going to be about certainly seems to have increased in recent years. I find it horrifically dull and generally skip that entirely. I see the same thing in presentations; it's just as dull (to me).
His recent post about syria was excellent as well, and more concrete than this one: http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/adamcurtis/posts/the_baby_and_the...
Personally, I disagree with all three items. This isn't the first time I've seen a text delay its thesis until the end. Yet none of them imparted the sense of utter bewilderment that this article has. I doubt word count is an issue since I read plenty of books. It's not as if all I read is buzzfeed, cracked, and HN. As for ideas, I don't know how this is relevant. HN's primary criticism is directed towards the presentation, not the underlying ideas. I do think Curtis has an interesting idea, but I still think the presentation was trash.
> writing is still a creative art. (...) surely we can allow a few artists to tell their stories the way they want to?
"Creating noise" is surely appropriate for sports stadiums, but probably not for journalism. This text is clearly explanatory. It's not a novel, it's not a poem, it's an article. Its purpose is to inform.
This goal is accomplished effectively most often by building a hierarchy of abstraction. The thesis is often a single abstract opinion/judgement supported by tangibles such as examples, anecdotes, statistics, etc. Paragraphs organize text so that tangibles support a minithesis, which often supports a main thesis, which sometimes supports a chapter in a book.
The author didn't take the normal route, but did he accomplish his goal of "informing the reader" effectively? I think his paragraphs were too short to organize his ideas meaningfully. And even if his paragraphs were longer, I would have preferred that Curtis group the paragraphs into "chapters" so I could mentally index each segment for the conclusion. In short, I think he failed his goal spectacularly.
By clearly you mean writing short articles that you can finish in five minutes? Adam Curtis always builds his stories with historical events to conclude with a point which is relevant today. You need to be patient to appreciate some of his stuff.
Except, when the majority of things I read are crap (and honestly, a post littered with videos typically is) I tend to come at articles with a "prove I should finish reading you" kind of attitude.
The beginning of this post wasn't very successful at capturing my attention. It would seem he has a very similar style as Venkat (though I think Venkat is a better writer) from RibbonFarm. I guess the difference is I have a general expectation that I realize he's building up to something bigger... and that conclusion might even be 3 or 4 posts from this long post. However he's earned my patience.
prove I should finish reading you
Maybe you can persist with reading through an article when you see it being very popular on Hacker News? I wasn't convinved he'd have the clarity of thought to put
a coherent big picture together and gave up reading...
I found the style very entertaining, I thought the video clips were relevant and interesting as well. I think the big difference is that I decided to trust the author and take for granted that it would all make sense by the end.I also had as much time as I wanted to read the piece, if I was more pressed for time I may have had to abandon it as well. I think it's unfair to accuse people who distrust the author as having some sort of attention problem. Perhaps they have another heuristic for deciding if a longer article is worth it and this one simply didn't meet those requirements.
Compare to something like this:
http://thepioneerwoman.com/cooking/2009/06/the-best-spinach-...
We've all seen and suffered through these, and the Upworthy/Buzzfeed crapstylebook dictates that the thesis be held out as long as possible.
That said: I've encountered a number of otherwise good journos who can't write a headline to save their life. And many more who can't write a decent lede.
I spent about 5 minutes reading before becoming completely lost and confused - was there a central thesis and was he ever going to get to a point substantiating it, or was I just reading somebody's fantasy about an old era glamour girl using journalism as a weak front story?
I wasn't convinced he'd have the clarity of thought to put a coherent big picture together and gave up reading, coming here instead to see if somebody had managed to decipher it all. (That being said I think he has a point and it's something I've wondered about myself.)