Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by olalonde on Thursday December 05, 2013 @02:16AM
(#6853087)
You are arguing on semantics. The word "transaction" in the title doesn't refer to bits and bytes transactions found in the blockchain but to the more common definition "an instance of buying or selling something". I agree that a better title would have been: "Stop saying that Bitcoin transactions have to be irreversible".
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by steveklabnik on Thursday December 05, 2013 @03:47AM
(#6853287)
Every domain has domain terms: specialized knowledge and vocabulary.
Within payments, "transactions," "reversibility," "revocability," and "escrow" have definitions. Since BitCoin is in this space, I'd expect an article to use the domain terms from this space.
Yes, if you re-define these terms to mean something more colloquial, it may look like that. If you squint. But that doesn't make it not look amateurish.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by w-ll on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:52PM
(#6852386)
Not to be pedantic, but that's not necessarily true; we've had 1 major chain split before that killed ##'s of blocks containing thousands of transactions.
And also transactions that don't make it into a block will just die if the original node doesn't rebroadcast it. So after 1 confirm it's mostly irreversible.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by olalonde on Thursday December 05, 2013 @02:21AM
(#6853099)
To be truly pedantic, those transactions were never Bitcoin transactions to begin with since they were never on the Bitcoin blockchain :)
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by makomk on Thursday December 05, 2013 @10:51AM
(#6854982)
To be truely pedantic, at the time they were on the Bitcoin blockchain, it wasn't until well after the incident started that the developers and pool owners decided to reject that blockchain (which was just as compliant with the stated Bitcoin rules and had a mining majority) and switch to the other side of the form.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by fragsworth on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:42PM
(#6852549)
That's pretty pedantic...
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by paulgb on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:48PM
(#6852571)
I'm sure it isn't pedantic to the recipients of transactions in the orphaned block chain
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by vacri on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:58PM
(#6852605)
To be pedantic, those aren't really 'reversed transactions' so much as 'data loss'. It's not like specific transactions were targeted. If a bank incorrectly recorded a credit card purchase of yours, you wouldn't classify it as 'a reversed transaction'.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by wmf on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:54PM
(#6852591)
If your transaction gets orphaned you can just broadcast it again.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by jameshart on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:24PM
(#6852687)
If the goods you purchased are already in your hands, and your bitcoin payment has been lost in a blockchain accident, what is your incentive to rebroadcast your bitcoin payment?
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by wmf on Thursday December 05, 2013 @12:46AM
(#6852898)
That's why this thread is discussing m-of-n and escrow. But since transactions are public anyone (like the recipient) could rebroadcast it.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by ZoF on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:57PM
(#6852782)
Honor my friend, honor. Unfortunately I find myself sorely lacking.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by unlimited_power on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:52PM
(#6852582)
I believe you can use nLockTime[0] to construct and broadcast a transaction that cannot be accepted into a block at least until a particular time. Before that time is reached, you should be able to broadcast a conflicting transaction if so desired that is included in a block sooner, thus invalidating the previously broadcast transaction.
Re:Stop Saying Bitcoin Transactions Aren’t Reversible
by nwh on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:56PM
(#6852593)
That's right. You have to keep broadcasting it though, the transaction won't be retained in the nodes storage for a long period of time.
What this post describes is a 2-of-3 multisig, which adds further encumbrances in constructing a valid transaction.
But any transaction, once broadcast, is irreversible.