Boeing became huge in the 1920s and 30s. I imagine pilots talked to each other a lot about what planes they liked flying, and they could not have succeeded if those conversations didn't favor them.
For example, Time Warner Cable Oceania now provides cable service to the entire Hawai'ian island chain, but they had just bought out the last two systems (by island) in 2002 when I visited. Where I live, Comcast acquired Adelphia, who had acquired AT&T, who had acquired TCI, who had acquired Telemedia.
The Robber-Barons of the 1920s consolidated steel, railroads and banking. Edison and Westinghouse (with Tesla's AC) consolidated small utility companies AND supplied most of the equipment.
I think acquisitions played a huge part in the growth of airplane companies too (McDonnell-Douglas was originally two companies) ... there are very few car companies now compared to the early part of the 1900s and most recently we've watched banks become huge through acquisitions.
Unfortunately, I think the premise of the article is completely wrong, but I wasted my time reading until the end and wondered how so little content could consume so many words. You grow big by knowing a market could be huge and then having the confidence to buy when the price is right (even if the indicators aren't in your favor at the moment).
There are a whole host of business requirements that can sink the process of becoming big. Adelphia failed because the Rigas family aggressively expanded the company, took it public but continued to treat it as though it was still family owned (I shouldn't say more). So the business acumen to run an enterprise at different sizes is important - I've seen leaders fail to hire appropriately, then delegate kill promising companies too. I think we could make a long list of reasons for failure.
larrys:
I'd love to hear your audio ... Jerrold was purchased by General Instruments who was in turn purchased by Motorola. Motorola added Jerrold's set-top boxes, to GI's trunk amplifier and line extenders (and other head-end equipment), then Motorola added both to their cable modem business and that conglomerate was ultimately bought by Google. Cisco purchased Scientific Atlanta who was the main competitor.
Iirc (this was a long long time ago) his Philadelphia connection to Ralph Roberts (comcast) was how he built Jerrold (they made cable boxes).
Comcast of course grew large by starting and getting it's first cable franchise in a small town in Mississippi. Nobody chooses their cable company the cable company chooses you.
(I actually have an audio tape of that interview that I made.)
With respect to Boeing one of the first things actually was a government contract that they received for the war effort. Then they nearly went bust after the war ended.
This is some of the story. There is also an excellent documentary on Boeing.
http://www.boeing.com/boeing/commercial/boeing_bio/chapter3....
If you go back to the early days of Oracle for example, they were providing a highly flexible database and would do it on (mostly) any computer platform you had. The competition was databases that were glorified flat files on mainframes, and IBM dominated that market. It took a few to take the plunge, but the others followed.
Overall his point is very valid.
That's pretty forced.
There are plenty of ways for companies to grow, and word-of-mouth is just one of them. For example, a company can grow by getting a military contract, thus being infused with cash and lots of credibility. You don't get a government contract because Sally told Jim at the DoD about how great you are.
Edit: I noticed many of the comments that share my sentiment are being downvoted. Why?
There is always more than one way to skin a cat.
Companies can limp along for a few years with the latter strategy (I worked at one once), but they don't grow, and eventually they get sick of selling stuff that nobody wants to buy and close up shop. For the examples given (Cisco, Oracle), everybody who's in a purchasing position in the industries they serve has heard of them, and they go into a sales cycle "warm". The salesperson's job is to iron out the details and explain how to integrate the product into a customer's existing workflows to make them more efficient.
I wrote about it a while ago: http://chester.id.au/2013/01/05/on-selling-to-consumers/
Time magazine, Warner Bros, TBS and HBO all benefitted immensely from excellent products and word of mouth.
Regarding Comcast, I know you're hung up on the use of "only" but being a government-issued monopoly probably makes it a less interesting example for this topic. Despite that, we would need to go back in Comcast's history to really understand how it grew.
Oracle and Cisco are terrible examples since they originally produced market-leading products and gained very strong word-of-mouth.
From a cursory reading of Epic history, it also sounds like a bad example for you since it relied heavily on reference customers.
Drugs obviously have huge word-of-mouth spread.
Military contractors are a whole other issue, of course.
This is a few paragraphs mentioning a fairly obvious point about growing companies, but trying too hard to seem groundbreaking.
Microsoft got itself lucky with an exclusive licensing arrangement then played that hand for all it was worth. Court documents largely from the Novell lawsuit (though there were numerous others) reveal just how cut-throat the company was.
In general, finding some initial advantage and leveraging it is what has tended to work. Government contract, sweetheart deal with an existing major player (Google's search deal with Yahoo early on, for example), patents, strategic lawsuits, FUD, and others.
Altman's premise really doesn't hold water.
This is a bad opening premise. Time Warner and Comcast are huge and they don't seem like word of mouth companies to me. Boeing is pretty huge and they don't sell anything directly to ordinary consumers. I would never run around marketing Pfizer products to my friends.
Take a scan down the Fortune 500 and "viral" growth companies are in the minority.
Even limiting yourself to tech companies, which I presume is all that the author was thinking of, the principle is no less general. Epic is a gargantuan EHR vendor and they grew via acquisition of other vendors, not word of mouth. Cisco did much of the same, and consider Oracle. The list goes on and on.