Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by moot on Monday December 02, 2013 @01:56PM
(#6835609)
Totally. In our case the main security benefit is that we allow the uploading of SWFs, and it mitigates the threat of cookie stealing via Flash (which we've actually seen attempted). Previously we'd used 4channel.org for this, but I switched that over along with the migration to 4cdn.org.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by gokhan on Monday December 02, 2013 @03:13PM
(#6836193)
If you give the url of the photo you are allowed to see to someone else, you can give the actual photo as well. I don't get the security risk here.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by trothoun on Monday December 02, 2013 @03:36PM
(#6836323)
If the urls are guessable then someone could harvest images without having been given urls by authorized users.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by sliverstorm on Monday December 02, 2013 @04:02PM
(#6836495)
I kind of like it for FB. It's nice to be able to easily show a friend a photo, whether or not they are friends with the person who posted that photo and sometimes even whether or not the friend has a FB account.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by brown9-2 on Monday December 02, 2013 @04:06PM
(#6836523)
Nice for you, but potentially not so nice for the poster of the photo who thinks that only his or her friends can access it.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by sliverstorm on Monday December 02, 2013 @04:08PM
(#6836531)
Yeah, I acknowledge it has some less ideal traits as well. Of course, if I can see it, I can show it to anyone, whether or not I can direct-link.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by xerophtye on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @04:45AM
(#6839436)
yep, this process just speeds up the process. Images are something that really can NOT be protected. If they are visible, they are steal-able
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by jsmeaton on Monday December 02, 2013 @04:24PM
(#6836627)
Nothing that right-click, save, upload to imgur couldn't accomplish though.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by kuschku on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @08:31AM
(#6840082)
Or printing out and handing it over.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by zachrose on Monday December 02, 2013 @01:56PM
(#6835615)
I'm interested in learning more about _how_ secure random URL parts are, and what kinds of attacks are seen in practice. Presumably an IP would get blocked after enough 404s?
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by moot on Monday December 02, 2013 @01:58PM
(#6835635)
I'm pretty certain 4channers are good at tracking down profile URLs from just a Facebook image URL/filename. I don't think you can access the full album per se, but you can definitely locate the profile.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by hnha on Monday December 02, 2013 @02:12PM
(#6835752)
that's because the image urls actually include the profile id.
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by na85 on Monday December 02, 2013 @03:45PM
(#6836393)
I thought they changed this behaviour months ago?
Re:Small things add up: 4chan's migration to a cookieless do...
by hrrsn on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @01:56AM
(#6839034)
I just tried it and it definitely still has the profile ID in the URL.
This works for 4chan, but in case of Facebook, it actually reduces security - since cookies cannot be checked for photos on static domains, everybody can access every photo (as long as they are given an URL), regardless of the photo's privacy settings. In the case of Facebook, they are probably using sufficiently random URLs that mostly mitigate the issue, but a naive implementation could be very problematic.