It's chance it happened to him. It's also chance if I happen to get hit by a drunk. Yet we still hold the drunk responsible.
By that argument there's people who's responsible for the lack of possibility afforded the poor in both cases -- but in case of the global system we've set up that responsibility has been diluted to the point that we no longer seem to be able (or willing) to hold individuals responsible.
Is it even possible to disagree? This seems as obvious as gravity, but the counterargument (if one exists) may be interesting to hear.
Naturally it's mainly successful people who say this, but they say it with such fervent faith and belief that there's a fair few miserably poor folks who buy it, generally in the form of "I'm better than the rest of you poor bastards 'cause I work hard and I'm gonna be rich any minute now." And then they spend the rest of their lives slaving for minimum wage and not rocking the boat, always convinced that the American Dream is right over the next hill. It's sad.
Of course, I also live in the part of the country that doesn't measure happiness by the size of the bank account when you shuffle off the the great beyond. Although the farmers and vocationally trained in the area are doing pretty darn well.
Hard work seems to give one a better chance at reaching your goals, much like exercise seems to help with keeping you healthy. Some folks live a long time without exercising and some die early even when exercising regularly.
The one born into a rich family tends to get spoiled, become wasteful and when the money exhausts becomes poor.
The one born into a poor family develops a hard-working attitude, becomes more careful about money, and eventually becomes rich.
A rich person can draw on the professional expertise of others in order to stay rich if they are not particularly clever.
This is a huge reason why the rich stay rich.
If you come from an American point of view, then success = money and nothing else. In America you need lots of money for everything, just giving a good education for your kids is 10 to 15 times more expensive than in Europe or Asia, same with health care.
But on other countries success is defined differently, like having a good relationship with your family and friends.
I know quite a few very rich people, and some of them are as miserable or more miserable as people without money. With broken families, no real friends, and no time for living outside work. With women or men around them that just want their money and will do anything to get it.
For instance if you have weak body defenses and your kids are too, you'll be pretty understanding and know first hand lots of ways to help them, and they'd be handicaped put in other hands. Your kid won't be some random living being alien to you [1], the outcome of putting a kid in another random family doesn't make a balanced experiment about success or failure in society.
[1] that happens with adoption for instance, but that doesn't make a neutral experiment either.
I feel this is a very important concept.
I have some personal experience with aspergers and ASD, and have learned a great deal about how such people look at the world and how that differs from those more neurally typical.
I intend to have children, but I would seriously reconsider bringing someone with my genes into the world without the benefit of my experienced guidance. I would be able to teach them so much that other parents would not even realize they needed to learn. Borderline cases in particular can leave people relatively normal in appearance (although no one who knew me ever called me normal) but completely blind to so much that they need to be able to see to function successfully in the world.
I know it well because there was so much that nobody realized that I needed to learn, and so much needless suffering that I now know is largely preventable. An aware parent with your own genes is irreplaceable.
I personally struggle with some of these issues, and while I feel my father shows many of the same symptoms, he happened to grow up in an extremely large family (5 brothers and a sister) which I think helped him to get past the socialization issues.
What I learned from a passing interest in social psychology and repeated examination of significant events in my life gradually imparted an awareness of why some difficulties kept recurring, and also something of an understanding of what brought me to each point along the way. It helped that a close friend was a counselor, who shared with me experiences she had with autistic clients. This was important for providing an objective contrast of the conclusions humans would reach in different situations. I never knew anything I shouldn't, regarding the specifics of an individual or who they were, but I learned enough to gain a certain perspective on how we ASD thinkers tend to think, and what that often overlooks.
Thus the short, useless answer is: by thinking. Funny thing is, I have so little interest in contemplation and reflection, it's amazing I've ever accomplished anything with them.
To me the important thing is a perspective that can only be imparted by experience or a like minded thinker. This is why I believe it is crucially important for me to raise my own biological children. By understanding where they are as they develop, I will be able to guide them in ways I needed by never had. What I know about how other ASD individuals think is incidental. Not something I particularly care about, but something I happened to notice after speaking with some, after gaining my own perspective on very different forms of cognition.
if there were an intentional policy of randomly reassigning all children born on the same day to non-birth parents, does it also make no more sense to be angry at this policy than to be angry about some children being born to poor parents?
But: my parents are the people who raised me. If I found out I was adopted or switched at birth I don't think I'd see it any other way. A tiny chunk of dna is barely an investment at all compared to an entire lifetime of money, time, and support (whatever the means).
Also, it's not this guy's parents, of either set, or the hospital's fault that some people get a better education than others. It's society's fault as a whole and it's something that it would be nice if we could work on improving.
This is not a hunch right? There's so much evidence supporting this. Off the cuff, I can recall the following the studies. In the US, SAT scores correlate with parental wealth; in India, IIT JEE qualification success correlates with parental wealth; there was this story about 'crack babies' here a few mon ths ago which also cited a long term study showing that kids born in poverty are less likely to complete high-school, college etc.
I'd be interested in studies showing the opposite.
You can find e.g. that adopted children's income as adults is closely related to their biological parents' adult income, but unrelated to their adoptive parents' adult income.
I tried looking for a bit but couldn't find a citation for this. Can you help?
Families would lose every incentive to have a child in the first place, if it would be randomly switch to another (things like inheritance, family history and lineage comes in my mind). On the other hand, adoption would surely skyrocket.
I disagree, and I think the opposite could even be true. We are hard wired to protect our biological offspring; if we know that our offspring will be placed randomly into society, we would have greater reason to concern ourselves with the well-being of society in general.
(All successful modern societies have communistic and capitalistic components in simultaneous operation. Capitalism provides the incentive for productivity and communism ensures that incentives can be acted upon by as many people as possible. The most successful societies are arguably ones that balance these aspects well.)
There'd probably also be more inbreeding. Not truckloads, but more, just when chance decided to step in.
Well chosen word, "successful", because it refers only to income. Happiness itself is more correlated with social integration than money.
If anything, the parents would have a right to be upset, but not the child.
And of course while the single data point of the fact that the man ended up being a truck driver, while his counterpart became the president of a real estate company, proves nothing, I do find it an interesting anecdote. People who want to downplay the importance of class delineation like to point to the extraordinary people who rise from poverty into success. But my hunch is that given two individuals of ordinary moral fortitude, the one born into a rich family will tend to be pretty successful, while the one born into a poor family will tend not to be.