News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by g8oz on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:12PM (#6811868)
It seems like no matter how blatantly Google carries out it's updated "Microsoft from the 1990's" act there will be a coterie of apologists on HN explaining away it's actions. The Cold War provided an appropriate label for this crowd: "useful idiots".
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by haberman on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:46PM (#6812076)
Let's recap.

Prior to today, a community-developed fork of Google's open-source operating system could be installed by using an app from Google's own app store (which sometimes bricked the phone).

After today, a community-developed fork of Google's open-source operating system can be installed by downloading the installer from the CM website.

This somehow makes Google like 90's Microsoft?

How many operating systems or web browsers did Microsoft open-source?

How many forks of their software did Microsoft tolerate?

Calling Google "90's Microsoft" is like calling Obama a socialist: it shows an utter lack of perspective of what a real socialist looks like. (If you want to see a real socialist, read about Kshama Sawant who was just elected to the Seattle City Council and wants to collectivize Amazon.com and Boeing).

I wouldn't even bother responding to stuff like this, but it's getting upvoted on HN which is depressing.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by gcb1 on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:01PM (#6812155)
let me see... google and the open handset aliance advertise an open source OS, that you cant install without voiding warranties and bending to proprietary radio and firmware code. just like pc manufacturers of the 80/90s (bios was reverse engineered from IBM and then tightly controled by ami. it only looked slighly open because IBM was much more closed. same with android standing next to apple.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by haberman on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:10PM (#6812204)
> that you cant install without voiding warranties

So you think that a user should be able install an OS that bricks their phone and still have the phone still covered by warranty?

How does that make sense?

Is this people's expectation of Google, that if they don't give you whatever you want (at their own expense) then they are like 90s Microsoft?

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by moron4hire on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:34PM (#6812300)
It makes complete sense because it shouldn't be possible to brick the phone just from trying to install a different OS, and installing software shouldn't make it possible to void the warranty. Hardware and software should be separate.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by veemjeem on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:58PM (#6812405)
Hm, at what point is hardware separate from software? When you write some C code that gets loaded on the Attiny85 chip, is that still considered software? Many SoCs come with the firmware already loaded so it just looks like a normal cpu when in actuality it contains a mini OS, graphics, networking, etc, all on a single QFN-72 package.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by moron4hire on Thursday November 28, 2013 @02:45PM (#6816093)
The point at which hardware is separate from software is when hardware is transistors and software is instructions. This isn't a difficult concept. And even if you want to get super pedantic in true insufferable-nerd fashion and argue about microcode, it doesn't apply to the operating system level, which is well, well into software level.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by makomk on Thursday November 28, 2013 @01:10PM (#6815707)
Most of the phones that have been "bricked" by the CyanogenMod installer aren't actually permanently bricked, they're just not fixable by anyone who'd actually need the CyanogenMod installer to help them install it.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @09:48PM (#6812742)
Any user action that is completely reversible, like installing software, should not render the warranty void.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by victorhooi on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:08AM (#6813112)
Hi,

Yes - but why don't you think what you said through a bit...

I flash my motherboard with a custom BIOS image I've hex-edited together.

Now, it won't boot correctly.

Yes, it's reversible - I can probably figure out a way to flash the original image back on.

However, the motherboard manufacturer is hardly going to tolerate me taking it back going, you need to fix this. That's hardly reasonable.

They're going to be...err...you did something stupid and unsupported. You fix it. They might give me advice, but the onus is certainly not on them.

Or say I flash my car's ECU to give me another 5 HP of output. Then my car stops starting up reliably. I can't exactly take it back to Honda and say, fix it. They'll be like, we sold you a working car - you did something out of spec, and overrode the ECU software - we aren't fixing it.

Yes, it's reversible - I can flash the right ECU image back on and it will start up correctly - but the onus isn't on them to hand hold me through that process.

Cheers, Victor

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by fnordfnordfnord on Friday November 29, 2013 @02:09PM (#6820600)
>...why don't you think what you said through a bit...

I have.

>I flash my motherboard with a custom BIOS image I've hex-edited together.

Congratulations.

>Now, it won't boot correctly.

woops

>Yes, it's reversible - I can probably figure out a way to flash the original image back on.

In most cases. It is possible to brick some hardware, but easily-brickable hardware is probably not something that OEM's should ship; that's just asking for trouble.

>However, the motherboard manufacturer is hardly going to tolerate me taking it back going, you need to fix this. That's hardly reasonable.

They might if they like selling things. AMD tolerated and even encouraged overclocking, finding that it won them more sales than problems that it may have created.

>They're going to be...err...you did something stupid and unsupported. You fix it. They might give me advice, but the onus is certainly not on them.

Well, yes and no. They ought to either publish a spec that would tell you how to fix it, or let you ship it to them and re-flash it for a reasonable fee. People do send motherboards back all the time claiming that it "broke" or was "DOA" when they may know full well what broke it. Right or wrong, a company will have to do a postmortem engineering analysis on a part to prove it was tampered with, and they will need to be able to prove tampering if they don't want bad press from consumers. I'm not saying that makes lying right, but that is probably the reality for a lot of cases.

>Or say I flash my car's ECU to give me another 5 HP of output. Then my car stops starting up reliably.

>I can't exactly take it back to Honda and say, fix it. They'll be like, we sold you a working car - you did something out of spec, and overrode the ECU software - we aren't fixing it.

Again, the consumer can say "I didn't do anything, I'll sue you. I'll tell the local TV station." Now the dealer has to risk a lawsuit, bad press, in which case they will need a professional engineering analysis; or the Dealer could just re-flash the firmware. I'm not sure how it is handled these days, but the customer can create a lot of doubt about the origin of the problem, and make it difficult for the dealer/carmaker to prove malfeasance on the customer's part.

>Yes, it's reversible - I can flash the right ECU image back on and it will start up correctly - but the onus isn't on them to hand hold me through that process.

If markets worked the way I was taught they ought to, then customers would never tolerate that. Then you could expect to take your car to the dealer, and for a reasonable fee they'd re-flash your ECU firmware or whatever, and then try to sell you some new floor-mats and an oil change. Unfortunately in many cases you're right; you can expect to be treated like a chump at the car dealership's service dep't. which is why "Right to Repair" laws are important. I think it is interesting now that Toyota has tried the "Cosmic Ray Defense" for exploding firmware how a car-maker (especially Toyota) might react to a customer with a bricked ECU who offers no explanation as to why his ECU is bricked.

>Cheers, Victor

Cheers indeed, and happy Thanksgiving, unless you are Native American, in which case, my apologies. (If you're not in the US be thankful Columbus didn't find your country instead.)

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by crdoconnor on Thursday November 28, 2013 @01:07AM (#6813283)
>So you think that a user should be able install an OS that bricks their phone and still have the phone still covered by warranty? > >How does that make sense?

Because software shouldn't brick the phone. It should ALWAYS be possible to download and restore the pre-installed operating system and factory settings (it definitely was on my last android phone - an xperia - which I 'bricked' multiple times trying to get cyanogen to work).

This really does remind me of the bundle/don't bundle internet explorer wars. "Oh, but you can just download netscape if you really want it!"

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by joenathan on Thursday November 28, 2013 @01:52AM (#6813382)
>Because software shouldn't brick the phone.

It's not software, it's a damn operating system.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by babesh on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:05PM (#6815340)
Isn't it because the apps aren't completely customizable/removable without rooting? So if a carrier includes apps that you don't like and that you want uninstalled but can't. The same probably goes for google play services. What if you don't want that to auto update?
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by gcb1 on Friday December 06, 2013 @04:04PM (#6863791)
it only has the possibility to brick the phone because they went the extra mile to try to deny access to doing it.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by shooper on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:31PM (#6812282)
>So you think that a user should be able install an OS that bricks their phone and still have the phone still covered by warranty?

Yes

>How does that make sense?

It makes sense the same way that installing Linux and/or wiping Windows doesn't void a PCs warranty.

Should users be allowed to install any programs including keylogging malware on Windows computers? Shouldn't Microsoft protect them by locking it down so that only approved apps from their app store can be installed? Like mobile app stores?

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by veemjeem on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:49PM (#6812366)
It is rare to "brick" your PC by installing linux/windows. Phones are different because their input/output interfaces are limited to a single usb port, and in many cases that usb port doesn't even support host mode. Technically the phone isn't really bricked, but there's no way for a normal user to fix it without cracking open the phone to attach a jtag.

If PCs in the 1980's could be destroyed simply by improperly installing an OS, you bet manufacturers would void warranty for software misuse.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by giovannibajo1 on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @08:26PM (#6812500)
Sounds like bad design though. It's normal for embedded devices to have a non upgradable bootloader that can always be triggered at boot and is able to reflash a pristine copy of the original firmware wiping whatever was later written. iOS does that (see DFU mode), and all embedded devices I design at work do the same. Why an Android device shouldn't? Apple devices are nominally warranty voided when you jailbreak them, but since you can always reflash an original firmware leaving no traces behind, it's basically moot.

NOTE: no sarcasm here, I'm genuinely interested on why android phones can be software bricked and can't have a boot loader like anything else.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by fpgeek on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @10:08PM (#6812793)
Android devices have similar failsafes (e.g. recovery, fastboot mode), but since they're part of the infrastructure that validates that you're only flashing authorized changes, you are often working around them when you modify your device.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by cdash on Thursday November 28, 2013 @03:57AM (#6813687)
Which is exactly the problem, the fact that you have to work around them to begin with.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by hrjet on Thursday November 28, 2013 @04:04AM (#6813713)
Which means that the barrier placed by Android manufacturers is artificial.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by fpgeek on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @08:28PM (#6812502)
> It makes sense the same way that installing Linux and/or wiping Windows > doesn't void a PCs warranty.

Have you ever actually tried getting warranty support for a Windows PC you installed Linux on? The last time I tried even just mentioning the word "Linux" was enough to get many support departments to drop you like a hot potato. In my experience, the minimum bar for support is keeping around a Windows partition and any diagnostic/recovery partitions they have, whether or not you want them otherwise. If you're unlucky, you'll have to blow away your Linux install even if it's completely irrelevant to the issue at hand.

Modded Windows PCs are easier to deal with because you can usually erase all traces of Linux/other OSes if you need to for support (no eFuses and similar nonsense), but the on-the-ground support policies aren't all that different from modded phones.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by DanBC on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:59PM (#6812413)
> It makes sense the same way that installing Linux and/or wiping Windows doesn't void a PCs warranty.

You need to take another look at user grade warranties for PCs. Many of them are void if the users installs a different OS. Especially if they break the HPA partition where the OS reinstall stuff is kept.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by niels_olson on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:54PM (#6812387)
If I download instructions to hotrod my lawnmower, and then engine block cracks when the head gasket blows out, should I blame Toro for not locking down my lawnmower?
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by Someone on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @09:04PM (#6812608)
But in this case Toro used to host those instructions on its website.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by victorhooi on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:18AM (#6813140)
But should they be?

Say there's a Toro site for add-ins (flashing lights or whatever, I have no idea how you'd mod a mower...lol).

And some of those add-ins will void your mower, and potentially break your machine. It's certainly within their prerogative to say "We won't host them. But you can just go to <some website> and get it from them instead". In fact, doesn't Google make a search engine? Surely, it's not hard to just Google for Cyanogenmod and find their hompage? In fact, if you can't do that, then probably shouldn't be flashing a ROM...

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by stusmall on Thursday November 28, 2013 @05:18PM (#6816771)
You can't install on some consumer hardware without voiding the warranty. The quality of the hardware you get subsidized from AT&T doesn't change the openness of Android.

If you had a board and wanted to start porting android to it today everything you need to make it happen is there and out with permissive licensing too. What more to do you want out of a software project?

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by throwawaykf02 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @01:03PM (#6815683)
> This somehow makes Google like 90's Microsoft?

You should have stopped there. Removing Cyanogenmod may not be it, but the rest of your post just opens it up for pointing out how Google is just like Microsoft.

> How many operating systems or web browsers did Microsoft open-source?

Red herring. Selling software and Operating Systems is Microsoft's core business, and you expect them to give it away? How much software that is the core of Google's business has Google given away? I see nothing of the search, advertising and distributed systems infrastructure being open sourced.

> How many forks of their software did Microsoft tolerate?

Hah, why don't we ask Acer that? The moment there's any leverage at all, Google will use it to squash forks. Conversely, has Microsoft ever tried to stop WINE or ReactOS? (Honest question, actually, I don't know.)

Now let's ask some more relevant questions:

1. How many times has Google been investigated and fined by the FTC and DOJ for illegal business practices?

2. How many times has Google been investigated by US and EU government agencies for privacy breaches?

3. How many times has Google been investigated for anti-competitive behavior in the US and the EU?

4. How many times has Google been accused (and sued) by smaller companies for unfair business practices?

5. How many times has Google been accused of intentionally providing poor support for a competitor's product?

6. How many times has Google been sued for infringing somebody else's IP?

7. Has Google been sued by Sun for "hijacking" Java?

8. Has Microsoft been made to pay damages for abusing standards-essential patents?

9. Has Microsoft been sued for colluding in anti-poaching agreements?

Some things Google has escaped (e.g. antitrust in the US), and some don't apply to Microsoft (abusing FRAND patents, anti-poaching collusion, illegal pharma ads), but most apply to both: investigations, settlements and fines in the US and EU for anticompetitive conduct, privacy breaches and illegal business practices; accusations of crippling competitors' products (Netscape etc. for Microsoft, competing service providers like Yelp, YouTube/Maps on Windows Phone for Google); accusations of stealing IP and unfair business practices (e.g. Apple's UI lawsuit and i4i for Microsoft, Author's Guild and SkyHook for Google); and so on.

Anecdotally, having been privy to some negotiations with Google in two separate companies, they very much throw their weight around.

> I wouldn't even bother responding to stuff like this, but it's getting upvoted on HN which is depressing.

As much as you'd not like to admit it as an employee -- and it may not be apparent to the rank and file from inside -- there are very clear parallels in how both companies behave. Google is certainly throwing their weight around these days, which is precisely why Microsoft was hated in the 90s.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by haberman on Thursday November 28, 2013 @01:52PM (#6815895)
> Google is certainly throwing their weight around these days, which is precisely why Microsoft was hated in the 90s.

Not really. There's nothing intrinsically wrong with "throwing your weight around," as you put it. For example, that's exactly what IBM was doing when they decimated SCO's absurd lawsuit.

Microsoft was hated because they aggressively pushed out competitors in dishonest ways, because they intentionally made it difficult to interoperate with their software through proprietary protocols and file formats, and because they attacked open source.

Some of your questions directly illustrate why "throwing your weight around" can be a good thing. Did Sun/Oracle accuse Google of "stealing" Java? Yes, but do you really want to live in a world where people can copyright APIs, thereby giving creators of popular APIs a large amount of control over everyone else? I surely don't (and I say this as someone who has dedicated literally years of my life into designing APIs) but Oracle and Microsoft would like that world.

I don't "expect" Microsoft to give away anything, but the fact that their business model depends on tightly controlling it makes them an inherently less open source-friendly company than Google.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by throwawaykf02 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @02:59PM (#6816138)
> Microsoft was hated because they aggressively pushed out competitors in dishonest ways, because they intentionally made it difficult to interoperate with their software through proprietary protocols and file formats, and because they attacked open source.

To me that sounds a lot like "throwing their weight around" :-) As my post hoped to show, Google simply does it in different ways.

Well... if you believe Yelp, the SkyHook lawsuit and various antitrust complaints in the US and EU, "pushing out competitors in dishonest ways" is something Google is doing as well. And we all know how interoperable YouTube is with Windows Phone devices. And we saw how Google pressured OEMs into not supporting competing software (cf SkyHook, Acer).

So maybe not that different after all.

> Some of your questions directly illustrate why "throwing your weight around" can be a good thing.

No doubt Microsoft supporters will say the same thing about Microsoft's antics :-)

> Did Sun/Oracle accuse Google of "stealing" Java? Yes, but do you really want to live in a world where people can copyright APIs, thereby giving creators of popular APIs a large amount of control over everyone else?

Well, that's the purpose of IP, isn't it? If you create something popular that others find very useful, you deserve enough control to ensure proper compensation.

Otherwise you get what Google did to Sun. Sun sank millions in developing -- and billions in marketing -- Java to make it the dominant development language that it is and to create, out of nothing, a huge Java-savvy workforce. Google, to bring developers to their new platform, simply hijacked the ecosystem with nothing in return to Sun (now Oracle). Of course, Sun was very careless in its control of Java, but I think Google derived immense benefit from Sun's investment and is being extremely selfish in insisting on not respecting their rights.

> I surely don't (and I say this as someone who has dedicated literally years of my life into designing APIs) but Oracle and Microsoft would like that world.

I too have devoted years of my life designing APIs. I see little distinction in the creative effort that goes into either code or API, and I think both deserve equal protection.

In fact, personally, I see Google's world as worse than Oracle/Microsoft's world. Google's arguments in the Oracle case, taken to their logical conclusion, literally remove support for all copyright protection for software. Part of their argument is that APIs are not copyrightable because they're "functional". You know what else is functional? All the code in the world!

But then, Google's software remains locked away in data centers, away from the world's eyes, further protected by trade secret. Of course, it sees no value in other types of protection, only liabilities.

Me, I'd rather live in a world where valuable works cannot be taken without permission, especially since a lot of my work is exposed to the world. I've open sourced a lot of stuff too, but which of my work can be taken freely should always be my decision.

> I don't "expect" Microsoft to give away anything, but the fact that their business model depends on tightly controlling it makes them an inherently less open source-friendly company than Google.

There's nothing intrinsically wrong with being a "less open source-friendly company" either.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by ars_technician on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @09:15PM (#6812641)
>If you want to see a real socialist

No true Scotsman is a logical fallacy that you should avoid. Saying there is someone out there that is worse actually does nothing to address the original point.

Let me demonstrate, "You think Romney was conservative? Look at X tea party member that wants to own slaves." Do you see how that doesn't do anything to refute that Romney is conservative?

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by haberman on Thursday November 28, 2013 @04:16AM (#6813747)
> No true Scotsman is a logical fallacy that you should avoid.

Perhaps, but this is not No True Scotsman.

No True Scotsman involves ignoring a counterexample to a general/universal claim.

For example, if I said "No Republican would vote to increase the deficit" and you countered by saying "actually, George W. Bush is a Republican and did in fact vote to increase the deficit," and I responded by saying, "well, no TRUE Republican would vote to increase the deficit," that would be No True Scotsman. Because I'm ignoring the fact that my broad, sweeping rule has a clear counterexample.

Those elements are not here in this case. I did not make a broad sweeping claim, instead I made a specific one (Obama is not a socialist). Ergo, it is not No True Scotsman.

> Let me demonstrate, "You think Romney was conservative? Look at X tea party member that wants to own slaves." Do you see how that doesn't do anything to refute that Romney is conservative?

"Liberal" and "conservative" describes a spectrum of political belief. If some tea party members have much more extreme views than Romney, then yes, it would demonstrate that Romney is less conservative than more extremely conservative people, but does not refute that he is right-of-center.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by yongjik on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:33AM (#6813177)
Dude, calling Obama a socialist is not comparable to calling Romney conservative. It's more like calling Romney gay.

Oh, you say he isn't gay? No true homosexual Scotsman, it seems.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by rmrfrmrf on Thursday November 28, 2013 @01:56AM (#6813388)
Who says discussions on the Internet should be free of fallacy?
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by IgorPartola on Thursday November 28, 2013 @02:27AM (#6813468)
Agreed. I bet there was very little debate in soviet Russia or in nazi Germany, so at least we have some kind of debate here. We are clearly better than those two examples.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by guelo on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:31PM (#6811971)
Microsoft didn't have an app store to censor in the 90s. You're thinking "Apple from the 2000s".
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by coldtea on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:45PM (#6812067)
Or he isn't using the title THAT literarly, how about that?
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by kunai on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:51PM (#6812369)
Bullshit. Pulling CM from the Play Store is something Google is entitled to do as per their ToS. They didn't pull it because they wanted to drive away competition; they pulled it because CM was harming people's devices.

I am by no means still a fan of Google anymore, but credit has to be given where credit is due. They are still pulling the Microsoft schtick with Google+, but pulling CM isn't it in the slightest.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by devindotcom on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:17PM (#6811896)
This was a TOS violation, nothing 90s-Microsoft about it.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by zhuzhuor on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:33PM (#6811980)
quoted from the article:

After reaching out to the Play team, their feedback was that though application itself is harmless, and not actually in violation of their Terms of Service,...

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by patrickaljord on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:09PM (#6812195)
They updated the article, the app is in violation of the TOS.

> Update: Removed reference to stating the app was not in violation of TOS – this was a mischaracterization of Google’s statement.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by colechristensen on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:34PM (#6811993)
Having a rule in the TOS doesn't make it right.

And you are right, it's not 90s-Microsoft, it's worse. I'd say it's reasonable to believe that vast majority of average users _never_ acquire software outside of the walled gardens of Mirosoft, Google, and Apple's app stores. There sure are benefits to these walled gardens, but the loss of freedom to corporate whim should be a very serious concern to everyone here.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by thezilch on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:41PM (#6812028)
What freedoms were lost, exactly?
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by drcube on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @09:01PM (#6812597)
The freedom to install the software of your choosing? The freedom to actually own your own computer? Seriously?
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by thezilch on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @09:15PM (#6812639)
No installation freedoms were lost; you can still install the software from the article or the secondary software installed by the article's software. No ownership freedoms were lost -- whatever that has to do with the article. Seriously.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by drcube on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @10:29PM (#6812864)
You can install what you want -- maybe, if your carrier lets you or you find an exploit to root your non-Nexus phone -- on Android only. That's not the case with iPhones or Windows phones. And yes, this is worse (read: less freedom) than you got with a Windows machine in the 90s.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by victorhooi on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:15AM (#6813136)
No, you can just sideload the ADB from outside the Android Market.

That's a pretty basic task for any Android user. In fact, if you can't do that, then you probably have no business whatsoever installing a customer ROM.

Think of it as a basic intelligence test - you want to change your car's air filter - first step is to pop open the bonnet. If you can't do that, then you probably want to seriously consider, gee, should I just get a mechanic to do this?

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by drcube on Thursday November 28, 2013 @08:51AM (#6814457)
Can you sideload anything on Windows or Apple phones? No. And on most carrier locked Android phones, you have to find an exploit to root your device before they let you sideload apps. So my point, that you are less free today with modern smartphones than you were with your PC under MS dominance in the 90s, stands.

This isn't like some test to pass before changing your oil. It's like requiring Ford's permission to install some fuzzy dice or a custom seat cover.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by unfasten on Thursday November 28, 2013 @11:58AM (#6815305)
> And on most carrier locked Android phones, you have to find an exploit to root your device before they let you sideload apps.

This is wrong.

Allowing this is built in to Android and it's a user togglable setting.

Verizon explicitly mentions sideloading and how to enable it:

http://mobile.vzw.com/LocationAgent

    For Android devices, please confirm the device's Location Services
    setting GPS and Verizon Location Services (if present) are set to
    on and the device's Settings > Security > Unknown sources is checked.
http://cache.vzw.com/multimedia/mim/mot_droid_razr_hd/razrHD... PDF Page 15:

    To let your smartphone install apps that are not from 
    Google Play, tap Apps  >Settings >Security & Screen Lock
     and check Unknown sources
Ditto AT&T:

https://www.wireless.att.com/businesscenter/en_US/pdf/att-to... PDF Page 3:

    In order to install these apps, you must ensure the 'Unknown Sources'
    box is checked [...] Follow the instructions on your phone to enable
    this feature and continue with AT&T Toggle installation.
http://www.att.com/esupport/article.jsp?sid=KB410684&cv=820

    Before you begin, you'll need to set your Android smartphone
    to allow downloads from non-Market sources by selecting Unknown sources
    in the Settings menu on your device.
Ditto Sprint:

http://eguides.sprint.com/support/eguides/htcone/content/htc...

    Go to Settings > Security, and then select the Unknown sources
    option to allow the download and installation of the tool
    through your Web browser.
http://eguides.sprint.com/support/eguides/sprintvital/conten...

    If you want to install apps from sources other than the Google
    Play Store app, you must allow the installation of apps from
    unknown sources first.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by drcube on Thursday November 28, 2013 @03:35PM (#6816306)
Fair enough. I've seen phones that disable the setting for allowing sideloaded apps. But fortunately it's not as prevalent as I thought.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by victorhooi on Friday November 29, 2013 @12:04AM (#6817971)
Can you name any handset that do that?

I've honestly never seen it before, and I'm curious what manufacturer would actually do this nowadays.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by drcube on Friday November 29, 2013 @02:33PM (#6820687)
My old Motorola Backflip, for one. Apparently AT&T removed the "unknown sources" setting from their phones prior to 2011[1]. I think my girlfriend's Samsung Exhilarate from a year or two ago is locked out of installing apps from unknown sources, but I should make sure before I go talking out of my ass again.

[1] http://www.sleetherz.com/2011/05/att-users-now-you-can-insta...

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by colechristensen on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:38PM (#6812314)
Besides the limitations spelled out in the TOS and the often reported issues with that, there are the invisible issues with developers not creating products which they know won't be approved.

There is a basic freedom lost when you allow yourself (the entire software market) to be subject to arbitrary corporate control especially when there is inadequate competition. It's clear that the terms are there only to serve the corporate interests and can change at any time if corporate interests change (hello G+ & YouTube)

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by thezilch on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @08:11PM (#6812451)
Being in <store> is now freedom? Should Google allow virus/spy/spamware to run free on their store? Libertas! How different is spamware from software that can brick one's device?
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by css771 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @02:09AM (#6813429)
I don't see why such a big deal is being made of this. If users want it, they can install the app from the CM website. The Windows app is also being installed from their website.

Google doesn't want people to hold it liable for potential bricking of devices and took it off its store. What's the issue here?

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by Zigurd on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @07:19PM (#6812238)
So is every packet filtering app that requires root, and many other categories of apps requiring root.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by byjove on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:38PM (#6812014)
I'm not sure what "Microsoft from the 1990's" or the "Cold War" have to do with anything here.

There have been reports of users bricking their devices using the app (check the various support forums) they then try to swap them only to find out they have voided the warranty. Google is asking CyanogenMod to properly inform users about those risks.

Yet inevitably some on the comments here are cringe worthy

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by shooper on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @06:45PM (#6812069)
The funny thing is that many of the same people you talk about were vehemently against UEFI Secure Boot on Windows 8 being on by default although it actually protects tens of millions of normal users from undetectable rootkits and bootkits because it made installing Linux slightly more difficult by needing to fiddle with the boot settings.

Now the reason being given for this removal is that it needs root(a lot of apps in the Play Store require root on Android, including ROM managers) and that it may brick a few devices, while ignoring the fact that for many who are stuck without security updates because of OEMs and carriers actually benefit from CM. Also wonder if this news was strategically timed before Thanksgiving when most people are on vacation traveling or busy with family.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by chinpokomon on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @08:47PM (#6812556)
The installer itself doesn't require root and that isn't why it was pulled. It was pulled because trying to install an unapproved OS on the device may have left the device in a state that non-technical users may not know how to fix. when their device is now "broken" manufactures say that installing the unapproved OS voids the warranty. The finger pointing goes back to Google for allowing an application in the Play Store that voids warranties. Since no application on the Play Store should break a user's device, they asked CyanogenMod to remove the application.

This in no way is meant to prevent users from voiding their warranty, users can still side load the application or they can use more traditional ways of installing a custom ROM. I'm not sure why this decision is ruffling feathers. CyanogenMod has over a million installs to date, and is still thriving. The installer made things a little less complicated, but removing it from the Play Store won't really slow them down.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by derleth on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @10:02PM (#6812771)
CM phones home by default. There's a word for software like that: Malware. The Play Store shouldn't have malware.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by yareally on Thursday November 28, 2013 @09:14PM (#6817526)
Seriously? You realize how many apps on the market use Google Analytics or some other form of Analytics? Nearly all of them, including Google's Apps. Nearly all of them give absolutely no way to opt out either short of host blocking. However, CM gives you an option to under device settings.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by derleth on Friday November 29, 2013 @02:26AM (#6818267)
So that's the standard we want to hold them to? Just a little better than Google?

Why isn't it opt-in?

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by fidotron on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @10:24PM (#6812847)
That's a nice ideal, but practically every app using the internet access permission is phoning home.

Mobile app analytics is huge, including by Google themselves.

Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by css771 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @02:13AM (#6813438)
Are you kidding me? They tell me exactly what data they collect and for what purpose. To say that is malware is either extreme sarcasm or extreme stupidity.
Re:CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store by derleth on Friday November 29, 2013 @02:29AM (#6818273)
Then why isn't it opt-in?