News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by rayiner on Monday November 25, 2013 @03:33PM (#6796777)
I'm mystified by the pro-aristocracy tone of the article:

> There are some happy parts of the book. Clark uses her fabulous wealth to indulge a taste for the world’s best dollhouses and model Japanese castles, built by craftsmen in Germany and Japan. She pays an assistant to write down transcripts of Flintstone episodes. When she wants to make a little music, she takes a Stradivarius violin out of the closet (first she needs to choose which of her Stradivariuses to play).

Yes, it's horrible that these people took advantage of her, but I find it very difficult to get that worked up over it. On the balance, she still won the cosmic lottery, inheriting a tremendous fortune she did nothing to earn, and getting to spend it on trivialities like dollhouses. Rich heiresses attract scumbags for precisely the reasons suggested in the book (they are easy to deceive), and in a way such activity is just the natural downside of inheriting a large fortune in the first place. Without justifying the behavior of any of the people involved, I can't help but feel my feelings of pity are better directed elsewhere.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by specialist on Monday November 25, 2013 @03:54PM (#6796925)
Yes, it's horrible that these people took advantage of her, but I find it very difficult to get that worked up over it.

I'll be outraged for you. My family is very good about caring for our elderly. The predation is real. The woman in this article could easily have been my grandparents.

People over 70 start to lose their skepticism and can become easy prey for cons, high pressure sales, and other grifters. Just subscribe to your state's attorney general's newsletters to see how rampant this is.

Yes, she was born with a silver spoon in her mouth. But if this article is accurate, Huguette Clark was held as a virtual prisoner by Beth Israel Hospital, and was exploited many others. That just makes me sad.

Gross wealth inequity is a terrible societal problem. Fixing the tax codes is the solution, not stealing from little old ladies.

TL;DR: Two wrongs don't make a right.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by rayiner on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:06PM (#6797004)
I never said two wrongs made a right, nor did I say anything about wealth inequality. Indeed, I went to great lengths to avoid making any "right" and "wrong" judgments at all, simply because I find those awfully boring.

My problem was with the tone of the article. Why feel bad for someone who suffers a natural consequence of inherited wealth?

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by taude on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:18PM (#6797107)
"a natural consequence of inherited wealth"

This is a natural consequence, ehh?

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by MichaelGG on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:20PM (#6797126)
>Why feel bad for someone who suffers a natural consequence of inherited wealth?

Same reason you'd feel bad for anyone? "Natural consequence" doesn't really mean much. Why feel bad for someone that suffers a natural consequence of inherited genes?

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by rayiner on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:35PM (#6797227)
> Same reason you'd feel bad for anyone?

Do you feel bad for everyone that something bad happens to?

> Why feel bad for someone that suffers a natural consequence of inherited genes?

You feel bad for them because usually these people are dealt a bad hand in the cosmic game of cards. But this woman was dealt an unimaginably good hand, and then some bad things happened to her that tend to be correlated with the benefits of that fortune. But on the karmic balance, she still made out like a bandit.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by prawn on Monday November 25, 2013 @05:46PM (#6797638)
How great does this disparity need to be before someone garners your sympathy? Is there a chart we can refer to?
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by specialist on Monday November 25, 2013 @10:12PM (#6798870)
Followup: I hear you. I disagree. I've appreciated many of your other comments. So you and me are cool.

I would only ask that you consider that we're all stuck on this rock, with no instruction manual, and no way off, just trying to get through each day the best we can. I have one of those crazy cousins that brought all the badness down on himself. But none of us like seeing him suffer or exploited. Because he really didn't know any better.

Peace.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by kkowalczyk on Monday November 25, 2013 @03:48PM (#6796871)
I'm mystified by 'blame the victim' tone of your comment.

Does any old lady deserve to be taken advantage by scumbag lawyers or accounts?

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by thwest on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:26PM (#6797162)
The victim here is the masses of 19th century mine workers discarded in the production of her fortune.
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by iamjustin on Monday November 25, 2013 @07:24PM (#6798162)
Because there can be only one victim, right?
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by thwest on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @02:05AM (#6799639)
Because the slight of losing 0.001% of one's wealth in a non-violent manner is comparable to the loss of thousands of lives, right?
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by iamjustin on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @06:31PM (#6805061)
Whoa, how about not putting words in my mouth, dude. I didn't say it was the same.
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by fleitz on Monday November 25, 2013 @03:53PM (#6796918)
Did the old lady deserve the wealth of the indians who owned the land from which the copper was taken?
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by greenyoda on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:43PM (#6797274)
Do you live in the U.S.? If so, it's likely that any property that you or you employer own was also taken from the Indians at some point. Maybe your ancestors even lived off slave labor. Are you offering to give back your own ill-gotten wealth?
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by fleitz on Monday November 25, 2013 @06:34PM (#6797879)
I live in Canada, and yes, I advocate for land/property/claims of genocide and other disputes between civilized nations to be put before a court of competent jurisdiction such as the ICC so that they may be resolved in accordance with international law.

I would be more than happy to return any property judged by such a court to be ill-gotten to any rightful recipients of it.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by rayiner on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:03PM (#6796986)
Sure, nobody deserves to be taken advantage of, rich or poor. But being taken advantage of is a fact of life. It's pervasive in nature. Moreover, it comes with the territory of inheriting wealth.

It seems odd to me to feel bad for someone who had this problem only because she inherited a bunch of wealth she didn't earn. That's not a question of what she "deserves" but rather who "deserves" our sympathies.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by lmg643 on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:19PM (#6797118)
> But being taken advantage of is a fact of life

Hello? Beth Israel is a non-profit teaching hospital in New York City that is over 100 years old. that they might have a role in bilking an elderly patient is shocking, plain and simple. (I've been there as a patient myself.)

not to mention exposing the corruption of attorneys, doctors, and various caregivers - people who are supposed to, by virtue of their professions, put the client or patient's interest first.

would this have been a scandal if it were for someone's entire life savings at $100,000? $1,000,000?

at what point on the financial scale does someone become worthy of taking advantage of? some arbitrary metric, where a person is deemed to have "earned" their wealth?

i'm sure this type of thing happens on a smaller scale. we don't hear about it because there aren't enough juicy details to make a 300+ page book. if we're going to talk about who "deserves" our sympathies - imagine it was a family member, then answer accordingly.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by rayiner on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:31PM (#6797197)
> at what point on the financial scale does someone become worthy of taking advantage of?

You're missing my point. You're focusing on whether the actions of the caregivers are justified instead of focusing on our reaction to what happened. People do bad things all the time, surely you don't feel outraged every time it happens.

So why feel particularly sympathetic for someone who inherited a tremendous fortune, then didn't do anything to protect it, despite having every opportunity to do so? I can say "who cares?" without justifying the actions of anyone involved.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by derefr on Monday November 25, 2013 @05:14PM (#6797451)
I think the GP's point here is that we rely on/trust certain institutions to not take advantage of anybody, no matter whether they "deserve it" or not. When they do, it shakes the trust we have in them that they won't take advantage of us. This isn't a story about an old aristocrat; it's a story of a bunch of institutions that were more corrupt than we thought.
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by john_b on Monday November 25, 2013 @03:56PM (#6796946)
Redistributing wealth from a rich, out of touch heiress might count as a superior allocation of capital if it were taxed and used to fund construction projects or given to responsible charities, but when it is redistributed to opportunistic parasites who preyed on her cluelessness and possible senility, I have trouble believing the world is better off as a result.
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by marquis on Monday November 25, 2013 @03:47PM (#6796863)
I'd agree except for the part where she wasn't getting the care she deserved, and she clearly spent a large part of her old age alone without friends. You can't blame the second part on wealth but at least the care home should honour their contract. That was mostly what got me in this article.
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by neilk on Monday November 25, 2013 @05:35PM (#6797586)
The author is Philip Greenspun. His outlook on life is really dark.

He made some money in the 90's and since then seems to have spent a lot of time thinking about the problems of the rich. I once saw a talk he gave at Google, the upshot of which was that once you're rich there's almost nothing worth doing.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by DanielBMarkham on Monday November 25, 2013 @05:00PM (#6797387)
"Yes, it's horrible that these people took advantage of her, but I find it very difficult to get that worked up over it."

E-gads. That had to have been a mistake.

You are not supposed to get worked up over it, any more than you would get worked up over a poor person getting taken advantage of.

It's a bad thing. We observe it and learn from it. We treat everybody equally regardless of whether they "won the cosmic lottery" or not. Getting worked up should be the furthest thing from your mind.

Now perhaps you find it all boring. Fair enough. But to be proud of your own callousness towards others? Not a good thing to be advertising.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by defen on Monday November 25, 2013 @05:00PM (#6797388)
I think the point is that this can (and does) happen to anyone, but we never hear about it because they aren't rich. Sometimes it takes particularly egregious violations to call our attention to a broader class of wrongs - like the recent spate of cops raping people during routine traffic stops, or arresting a guy for trespassing at his workplace 63 times in the span of a few years.