News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by specialist on Monday November 25, 2013 @03:54PM (#6796925)
Yes, it's horrible that these people took advantage of her, but I find it very difficult to get that worked up over it.

I'll be outraged for you. My family is very good about caring for our elderly. The predation is real. The woman in this article could easily have been my grandparents.

People over 70 start to lose their skepticism and can become easy prey for cons, high pressure sales, and other grifters. Just subscribe to your state's attorney general's newsletters to see how rampant this is.

Yes, she was born with a silver spoon in her mouth. But if this article is accurate, Huguette Clark was held as a virtual prisoner by Beth Israel Hospital, and was exploited many others. That just makes me sad.

Gross wealth inequity is a terrible societal problem. Fixing the tax codes is the solution, not stealing from little old ladies.

TL;DR: Two wrongs don't make a right.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by rayiner on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:06PM (#6797004)
I never said two wrongs made a right, nor did I say anything about wealth inequality. Indeed, I went to great lengths to avoid making any "right" and "wrong" judgments at all, simply because I find those awfully boring.

My problem was with the tone of the article. Why feel bad for someone who suffers a natural consequence of inherited wealth?

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by taude on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:18PM (#6797107)
"a natural consequence of inherited wealth"

This is a natural consequence, ehh?

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by MichaelGG on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:20PM (#6797126)
>Why feel bad for someone who suffers a natural consequence of inherited wealth?

Same reason you'd feel bad for anyone? "Natural consequence" doesn't really mean much. Why feel bad for someone that suffers a natural consequence of inherited genes?

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by rayiner on Monday November 25, 2013 @04:35PM (#6797227)
> Same reason you'd feel bad for anyone?

Do you feel bad for everyone that something bad happens to?

> Why feel bad for someone that suffers a natural consequence of inherited genes?

You feel bad for them because usually these people are dealt a bad hand in the cosmic game of cards. But this woman was dealt an unimaginably good hand, and then some bad things happened to her that tend to be correlated with the benefits of that fortune. But on the karmic balance, she still made out like a bandit.

Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by prawn on Monday November 25, 2013 @05:46PM (#6797638)
How great does this disparity need to be before someone garners your sympathy? Is there a chart we can refer to?
Re:Empty Mansions: Don’t be old and rich in New York City by specialist on Monday November 25, 2013 @10:12PM (#6798870)
Followup: I hear you. I disagree. I've appreciated many of your other comments. So you and me are cool.

I would only ask that you consider that we're all stuck on this rock, with no instruction manual, and no way off, just trying to get through each day the best we can. I have one of those crazy cousins that brought all the badness down on himself. But none of us like seeing him suffer or exploited. Because he really didn't know any better.

Peace.