News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2013 @02:53PM (#6783308)
The kind of wishes people have about "I don't like it --> should be treason!" is one of the reasons that the US has a narrow definition of treason enshrined in the Constitution.

Plus, no, it wouldn't: the President is both immune to criminal prosecution while in office and has plenary power to pardon, so "someone could make a treason case out of it" wouldn't constrain executive abuses. The only thing that constrains those is a public that cares enough to extract a price for the abuses, starting with public outcry and action at the ballot box.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dllthomas on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:16PM (#6783424)
The President could be impeached and then tried.

Which is not to say I think it's a good idea.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by lambda on Friday November 22, 2013 @05:34PM (#6784205)
Not only the President. Federal judges, Cabinet Secretaries, and Senators all have been impeached in the past. The actual line from the Constitution is: "The President, Vice President, and all civil Officers of the United States shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other High Crimes and Misdemeanors."

While it may not be a good idea to impeach Obama over this, they could impeach Clapper over it, as he is the one who petitioned the government to dismiss the case on the basis that the plaintiffs didn't have grounds as they could not demonstrate that they had been affected, or possibly against Solicitor General Donald Verrilli who made the argument in court. Coupled with his lies to Congress during hearings about whether the NSA collected data on Americans ("not wittingly"), Clapper would probably be the best target.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by TallGuyShort on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:39PM (#6783566)
I don't believe that would work. You can't revoke someone's immunity and then prosecute them for crimes committed while they had immunity. Seems like it would violate the concept of rule of law...
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:36PM (#6783921)
I don't think its clear that the President has immunity for offenses committed while in office (I think the general consensus is that he does not, though ISTR seeing contrary arguments), but it is pretty clear that the President -- as the holder of executive authority -- can't be prosecuted for federal crimes by the US government while he is in office (because the President holds the executive power, thus a criminal action against the President would be the President acting against himself.)

This is not so much an issue of immunity as of a requirement for the prosecution and defense to not be different parties.

> Seems like it would violate the concept of rule of law...

I would argue that the President being immune to prosecution for crimes committed while in office would be a bigger violation of the concept of rule of law than the President being subject to prosecution for such violations but only after leaving office.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dllthomas on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:54PM (#6783674)
Placing the president above the law itself violates the concept of rule of law. I don't know of anything that explicitly grants the president immunity from criminal prosecution. The ability to pardon grants an implicit immunity absent impeachment, but pardon is forbidden in cases of impeachment.

This, of course, could be my ignorance. Certainly the only appearance of "immun" in the Constitution is in "immunities" in an unrelated context.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by gizmo686 on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:32PM (#6783901)
I don't think the president has blanket immunity. Rather, he has immunity for things he does as the president. This type of immunity is not uncommon. For example, judges have immunity for everything they do while acting as a judge.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dllthomas on Friday November 22, 2013 @07:23PM (#6784611)
Careful that we do not conflate civil immunity and criminal immunity. I am not confident that the latter is absent, and IANAL, but everything I find on judicial immunity is about the former.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by throwaway_yy2Di on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:53PM (#6783669)
I think giving immunity for breaking the law, in advance, also strains the concept of rule of law...
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by TallGuyShort on Friday November 22, 2013 @06:30PM (#6784453)
I agree - and in any case it seems I misinterpreted what kind of immunity the President actually has.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by pyre on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:05PM (#6783732)
If a President can pardon his- or herself, then why was Nixon pardoned by Gerald Ford? Why didn't Nixon just pardon himself before resigning? Why wasn't he immune by definition?
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:43PM (#6783964)
> If a President can pardon his- or herself, then why was Nixon pardoned by Gerald Ford?

Political optics, for one thing: they had the vote counts in and knew if he hung around the Senate was going to convict him and kick him out of office, so he was going to be out in any case. Resigning and having the new guy -- who had some credibility with people who had long ago lost any trust in Nixon -- say that a pardon was in the interest of the Nation looked better, while Nixon pardoning himself would have been even more divisive.

There's also, IIRC, at least some dispute about the extent of the scope of the exception to the pardon power that applies in cases of impeachment, and, while I'm not sure that it would have been resolved in a manner unfavorable to Nixon, pardoning himself while he was under an impeachment that had not yet been rendered moot by his resignation (as the impeachment power only extends against civil officers, not past officers) might have sparked an even longer and deeper crisis if someone thought to test the limits there.