News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by fleitz on Friday November 22, 2013 @02:40PM (#6783224)
I wish someone could make a treason case out of perjury in relation to a matter of national security during a time of war for these actions.

This crap would stop pretty fast.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2013 @02:53PM (#6783308)
The kind of wishes people have about "I don't like it --> should be treason!" is one of the reasons that the US has a narrow definition of treason enshrined in the Constitution.

Plus, no, it wouldn't: the President is both immune to criminal prosecution while in office and has plenary power to pardon, so "someone could make a treason case out of it" wouldn't constrain executive abuses. The only thing that constrains those is a public that cares enough to extract a price for the abuses, starting with public outcry and action at the ballot box.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dllthomas on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:16PM (#6783424)
The President could be impeached and then tried.

Which is not to say I think it's a good idea.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by lambda on Friday November 22, 2013 @05:34PM (#6784205)
Not only the President. Federal judges, Cabinet Secretaries, and Senators all have been impeached in the past. The actual line from the Constitution is: "The President, Vice President, and all civil Officers of the United States shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other High Crimes and Misdemeanors."

While it may not be a good idea to impeach Obama over this, they could impeach Clapper over it, as he is the one who petitioned the government to dismiss the case on the basis that the plaintiffs didn't have grounds as they could not demonstrate that they had been affected, or possibly against Solicitor General Donald Verrilli who made the argument in court. Coupled with his lies to Congress during hearings about whether the NSA collected data on Americans ("not wittingly"), Clapper would probably be the best target.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by TallGuyShort on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:39PM (#6783566)
I don't believe that would work. You can't revoke someone's immunity and then prosecute them for crimes committed while they had immunity. Seems like it would violate the concept of rule of law...
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:36PM (#6783921)
I don't think its clear that the President has immunity for offenses committed while in office (I think the general consensus is that he does not, though ISTR seeing contrary arguments), but it is pretty clear that the President -- as the holder of executive authority -- can't be prosecuted for federal crimes by the US government while he is in office (because the President holds the executive power, thus a criminal action against the President would be the President acting against himself.)

This is not so much an issue of immunity as of a requirement for the prosecution and defense to not be different parties.

> Seems like it would violate the concept of rule of law...

I would argue that the President being immune to prosecution for crimes committed while in office would be a bigger violation of the concept of rule of law than the President being subject to prosecution for such violations but only after leaving office.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dllthomas on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:54PM (#6783674)
Placing the president above the law itself violates the concept of rule of law. I don't know of anything that explicitly grants the president immunity from criminal prosecution. The ability to pardon grants an implicit immunity absent impeachment, but pardon is forbidden in cases of impeachment.

This, of course, could be my ignorance. Certainly the only appearance of "immun" in the Constitution is in "immunities" in an unrelated context.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by gizmo686 on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:32PM (#6783901)
I don't think the president has blanket immunity. Rather, he has immunity for things he does as the president. This type of immunity is not uncommon. For example, judges have immunity for everything they do while acting as a judge.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dllthomas on Friday November 22, 2013 @07:23PM (#6784611)
Careful that we do not conflate civil immunity and criminal immunity. I am not confident that the latter is absent, and IANAL, but everything I find on judicial immunity is about the former.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by throwaway_yy2Di on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:53PM (#6783669)
I think giving immunity for breaking the law, in advance, also strains the concept of rule of law...
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by TallGuyShort on Friday November 22, 2013 @06:30PM (#6784453)
I agree - and in any case it seems I misinterpreted what kind of immunity the President actually has.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by pyre on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:05PM (#6783732)
If a President can pardon his- or herself, then why was Nixon pardoned by Gerald Ford? Why didn't Nixon just pardon himself before resigning? Why wasn't he immune by definition?
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:43PM (#6783964)
> If a President can pardon his- or herself, then why was Nixon pardoned by Gerald Ford?

Political optics, for one thing: they had the vote counts in and knew if he hung around the Senate was going to convict him and kick him out of office, so he was going to be out in any case. Resigning and having the new guy -- who had some credibility with people who had long ago lost any trust in Nixon -- say that a pardon was in the interest of the Nation looked better, while Nixon pardoning himself would have been even more divisive.

There's also, IIRC, at least some dispute about the extent of the scope of the exception to the pardon power that applies in cases of impeachment, and, while I'm not sure that it would have been resolved in a manner unfavorable to Nixon, pardoning himself while he was under an impeachment that had not yet been rendered moot by his resignation (as the impeachment power only extends against civil officers, not past officers) might have sparked an even longer and deeper crisis if someone thought to test the limits there.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by rayiner on Friday November 22, 2013 @02:50PM (#6783292)
Let's not go there: http://www.heritage.org/constitution/#!/articles/3/essays/11....

The U.S. hasn't convicted someone of treason for more than half a century. Even John Walker Lindh, who was literally fighting with the enemy against the U.S., was not prosecuted for treason.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by icambron on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:51PM (#6783660)
I wholeheartedly agree about treason, but perjury is a perfectly reasonable thing to charge people with here. And it's a plenty serious crime. For non-immune people, it means jail time. For the president, it's good grounds for impeachment.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by latj on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:27PM (#6783484)
Ok fine, but can we at least fire people who lie to Congress and then admit it? What is the point of Congress asking questions if you are allowed to testify in the least untruthful ways?
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by twoodfin on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:44PM (#6783603)
President Obama can fire anyone in his administration any time he would like. That's how accountability works in our system, particularly when no clear-cut crime is committed. If President Obama doesn't sufficiently share your outrage, fundraise, campaign and vote for someone who you think would.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by Silhouette on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:44PM (#6783969)
If President Obama doesn't sufficiently share your outrage, fundraise, campaign and vote for someone who you think would.

Why, so you can stop President Obama being elected for a third term?

To me as an outsider, this is a puzzling part of the US political system. The President has a huge amount of concentrated power within one branch of government, yet approximately half the time, the President of the day is effectively a lame duck with nothing to lose by behaving almost any way they like. Other parts of the government can make that President's job harder, but short of impeachment everyone is basically stuck with whoever it is until their time is up.

I increasingly feel that giving the electorate an absolute power of recall if an elected representative angers enough people during their term would change politics for the better at almost any level. Otherwise, any term of office that is sufficient for reasonable medium- to long-term planning is also sufficient to allow serious damage to be done with relative impunity if the wrong person won the election but the voters only learn that after the fact.

As a side benefit, this also balances the tendency for major elections to be fought on a tiny number of headline issues, with little if any incentive to represent the electorate's interests in all the other significant-but-not-dominant areas, because if you annoy too many small groups of the population, collectively they can become powerful enough to trigger a vote.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by rayiner on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:56PM (#6784038)
I contest that elections are fought over a "tiny number of headline issues." NSA spying is, for most people, the headline issue. The stuff that elections get fought over: Medicare, Social Security, taxes, etc, the big-ticket items of policy.

Look at it this way: how much do you think the average person would pay to get rid of the NSA program?[1] You think it's anywhere near how much money is on the line from Medicare/Social Security/tax policy choices? Or heck, even so-called "wedge issues" like gay rights or abortion rights?

[1] This is, of course, one easy way of valuing the negative utility of any given thing, by asking how much people would pay to avoid it.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by twoodfin on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:50PM (#6783994)
Democracy is all about giving the people what they want, good and hard. I'm sorry they got it "wrong" from your point of view last year, but in three years they get to try again.

I don't think your version of "serious damage" from this issue matches most voters. Even if this were a parliamentary system where sufficient public outcry could force new elections, or a "do over" recall was available (a terrible flaw in the state constitutions where it exists, IMHO), you'd still not be getting the U.S. administration you seem to want. You need to convince the public and then win elections, that's how change happens.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by Silhouette on Friday November 22, 2013 @08:11PM (#6784762)
Please note that I didn't express any opinion on the specific situation in the US today. I was just commenting that the checks and balances you implied in your previous post, where a senior individual in the government can choose to fire more junior individuals, don't seem to be very reliable if the senior person themselves has limited motivation to act in the interests of the people they are supposed to represent.

This lack of direct motivation is a systemic weakness in almost any electoral system that involves fixed terms of significant length, and it applies more generally than just the need to choose appropriate subordinates. What you described just happens to be one ineffective case that is relevant to the current discussion.

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by Solarsail on Friday November 22, 2013 @07:10PM (#6784585)
Why, then, is the president limited to serving two terms? There's essentially squat keeping the president doing anything at all resembling what he said he would do during his second term. (Said by a non-American, who views this aspect of American constitutional law as distinctly anti-democratic.) I'm also completely ignoring the degree to which voters are paying attention, how much the debate is swayed by powerful people to meaningless issues while the politicians run amok of everything etc. etc.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by latj on Friday November 22, 2013 @07:27PM (#6784633)
I'm not convinced that the president, congress, or the courts have the spy agencies under control. And I'm not convinced it matters much which representative of elite class gets elected. The important decisions are held in board rooms amongst people who are not democratically elected. They send the orders down to washington and, yes, there are conflicts between various elite groups, but it doesnt change much in the day to day life of an average American.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by sachinag on Friday November 22, 2013 @05:18PM (#6784142)
The other scary part of this is that all three signatories are Democrats, the same party as the President. If this becomes a partisan issue - and I fear it will despite occasional work by Issa and others in the GOP House delegation - then we're just royally screwed.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by blahbl4hblahtoo on Friday November 22, 2013 @02:53PM (#6783314)
Isn't this due to treason being interpreted as providing an enemy with information or assistance during a declared war?
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:01PM (#6783355)
> Isn't this due to treason being interpreted as providing an enemy with information or assistance during a declared war?

Its probably because of the narrow definition of treason written explicitly into the Constitution [1].

[1] http://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articleiii#section3

Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by blahbl4hblahtoo on Friday November 22, 2013 @04:46PM (#6783981)
cheers. thanks.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by girvo on Friday November 22, 2013 @02:48PM (#6783275)
Would be rather fitting, considering "Treason! Burn him at the stake!" was the battle-cry for some of the politicians in regards to Snowden's actions.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by fleitz on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:06PM (#6783373)
That was why I proposed something so ridiculous.
Re:DOJ lied to Supreme Court to avoid judicial review of war... by camus2 on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:38PM (#6783549)
if it was possible all the Bush jr administration would be in jail.