News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by HeXetic on Thursday November 21, 2013 @10:55AM (#6775269)
I don't understand how this court system can be so silly as to fail to recognize that it has no jurisdiction over someone. Isn't the question of jurisdiction one of the first steps in any court case?
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Xylakant on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:07AM (#6775356)
What do you mean by "no jurisdiction over someone?" If a crime was committed in france they can ask for extradition. That would probably not result in anything in this case, but as long as it's a crime by french law committed in france the case may as well be valid. So all the court will check whether a punishable crime was committed in france.

They could collect the fine when the blogger enters france or maybe, depending on the case, the european union or an associated state.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by salient on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:39AM (#6775607)
> If a crime was committed in france they can ask for extradition.

But it wasn't "committed in France". This is getting ridiculous, not to mention extremely dangerous. A few more cases of these from the "democracies" of the world, and soon China will start demanding the same thing.

"You said something bad about China online? We're just going to fine you, or ask for your extradition and arrest."

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by nitrogen on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:00PM (#6776208)
France could just be following in the footsteps of the O'Dwyer case.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Xylakant on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:36PM (#6776456)
> "You said something bad about China online? We're just going to fine you, or ask for your extradition and arrest."

Sure, that can happen. China can and might ask for extradition. This is however a different question from whether the USA will extradite. Extradition is usually denied in cases where the action in question was not a crime in the country that you're asking to extradite.

Think about it: A German commits a murder in the USA which is discovered only after he returns to Germany. Does your "no jurisdiction" line of reasoning still apply?

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Dylan16807 on Thursday November 21, 2013 @03:10PM (#6777123)
I don't understand the point of your hypothetical. A murder that physically took place in the USA is clearly "committed in the USA".
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by darkarmani on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:53AM (#6775725)
> it's a crime by french law committed in france

Did you miss the part where it was an American blogger? It wasn't committed in france.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Xylakant on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:33PM (#6776445)
The location where the crime occured on the internet is often defined as "is this website reachable in this region" which is basically true for all websites. It's a stupid concept, right, but that's true in germany as well. Make a website, make it in german, target german audiences and german courts can make that their jurisdiction. American courts often apply the same pattern when a .com domain is involved. See the latest round of ICE freezes.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by declan on Thursday November 21, 2013 @12:24PM (#6775974)
France has no jurisdiction. U.S. courts will not enforce this civil judgment. Our 1A precludes them from doing so. And the blogger in question said he's not going to France.

(BTW, a civil judgment is not "a crime by French law.")

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by aktiur on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:09PM (#6776283)
It was not a civil judgment but a public one handled by an independant administrative authority with the power to pronounce sanctions (French public law is separate from both criminal and civil law and includes administrative law).

It is not so much about free speech: the two guys have been fined for publishing incorrect information about the financial situation of a bank. It is more about financial regulation than free speech. I'm not so familiar with american law, but I'm pretty sure you got related situations (for example concerning the handling of sensitive financial information, or insider trading, etc.)

Disregarding the question of the reality of what they've been accused of, the fine against Mish is illegal considering the right of defendants to translation and an interpretor has not been respected. This decision will be very probably striken down by any real judge that get her hands on this case.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Dylan16807 on Thursday November 21, 2013 @02:11PM (#6776690)
>I'm not so familiar with american law, but I'm pretty sure you got related situations (for example concerning the handling of sensitive financial information, or insider trading, etc.

We have laws that apply to stakeholders and insiders. As far as I know third parties are free to say or even make up anything they want, as long as it's not fraud or libel.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by declan on Thursday November 21, 2013 @06:38PM (#6778353)
It is all about free speech. Publishing incorrect information about the financial situation of a bank (in the way Mish did it, and even assuming it's incorrect) is protected by the First Amendment in the United States. But it is not in France. See NYT v. Sullivan and the separate but related concept of "neutral reportage."
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by vidarh on Thursday November 21, 2013 @02:18PM (#6776738)
France, as any other country, decides for itself whether or not it has jurisdiction other than if/when the jurisdiction is decided through treaties.

E.g. I'm Norwegian - Norway claims jurisdiction for certain types of crimes worldwide for Norwegian citizens (quite a few other countries do too).

Enforcability is entirely separate from jurisdiction.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by declan on Thursday November 21, 2013 @06:30PM (#6778313)
France can claim jurisdiction as much as it likes, but U.S. courts will not as a practical matter (we settled this in the Yahoo case) recognize it and enforce the judgment.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Xylakant on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:42PM (#6776487)
> France has no jurisdiction. U.S. courts will not enforce this civil judgment.

These two things are totally unrelated and I never said the lather would happen.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by cantankerous on Thursday November 21, 2013 @12:12PM (#6775873)
> it's a crime by french law committed in france

Was this actually a crime or just a civil dispute?

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by aktiur on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:13PM (#6776311)
Neither criminal nor civil! French has a separate body of law called public law that includes administrative law.

In this case, the fine was pronounced by an independent administrative authority in charge of the regulation of financial markets. No judge was involved in the sentencing.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by cpa on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:08AM (#6775367)
It's a bit more subtle. French judges consider that they have jurisdiction if one of the party is in France or (for internet-related things) if the intended public is french. See LICRA vs Yahoo! linked in another comment.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by HeXetic on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:17AM (#6775440)
But the intended public wasn't French in this case? The guy is an English-language blogger.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Spidler on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:38AM (#6775604)
If _one_ of the parties. In this case, the bank.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Dylan16807 on Thursday November 21, 2013 @03:15PM (#6777163)
But they weren't a party until they sued; you're saying that France claims jurisdiction whenever a French national sues anyone anywhere in the world over any action?
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by wpietri on Thursday November 21, 2013 @12:00PM (#6775774)
How very... American of them.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by aktiur on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:16AM (#6775426)
It is a peculiarity of French administrative law. It's not a court that fined Mish, but an Autorité Administrative Indépendante (AAI or independent administrative authority, but I'm sure you did not need the translation) with the power to fine people (there are only a few).

Basically, if he appeals, it will very probably be overturned by a proper judge. Another AAI in charge of the regulation of the telecommunications sector got striken badly by a decision of our Constitutionnal court (no less) which suppressed its power to pronounce sanctions, judging the protection of the rights of defence was not effective. It's going to end the same way here I would say.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by shrikant on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:00AM (#6775301)
Courts in France have never bothered about jurisdiction when it comes to the Internet. See [1] and [2], for e.g.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LICRA_v._Yahoo!

[2] http://news.yahoo.com/french-court-google-must-drop-9-mosley...

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by aroch on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:06AM (#6775346)
Ehh, Google has meaningful ties to France; ie. they do business there.

    Google Paris

    8 Rue de Londres

    75009 Paris
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by nandhp on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:18AM (#6775441)
Also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_of_Wikipedia#France (Although I'm not sure any courts were involved in that)
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by nraynaud on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:42AM (#6775642)
There was actually less than any court involved there, any rogue policeman could do that, somehow it's not even a censorship problem but a more general procedural problem that happened to involve censorship. The poor guy didn't know that you should always call a lawyer and not listen to the police when you're detained (they tell people calling a lawyer will result in longer detainment).
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by lxa478 on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:01AM (#6775311)
There would be enough jurisdiction to arrest the guy if he happened to travel to France though. Maybe not enough to have any charges stick, but probably enough to make his life misérables.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Hermel on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:01AM (#6775307)
Maybe the French are fed up with US judges doing this all the time and this is some kind of revenge?
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by rayiner on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:04AM (#6775326)
But U.S. judges don't do this all the time. Meanwhile, a number of European countries (notably the U.K.) are famous for dragging foreigners into defamation cases for conduct that happened entirely outside the country. The U.S. tends to invoke jurisdiction only when you do something quite targeted at the U.S.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by bausson on Thursday November 21, 2013 @12:52PM (#6776152)
To be fair, U.S. judges often don't have the time.

How many time did I see "SUSPECTED Al-Quaida member and his family and some of his neighbors were killed in an explosion while a drone coincidentally flew over his house" in the news this month? I lost count.

A few points:

* French are fed up with US agencies, nothing against US judges.

* This was a civil deliberation, and will probably be nuked if said blogger make appeal.

* That regulator have no way to enforce their decision.

* Yes, this judgment is beyond ridiculous.

* Yes, the AMF should be disbanded (if they are as corrupt as they seem) or need a severe shake (in the case they are 'just' dangerously outdated).

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by rayiner on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:10PM (#6776288)
> How many time did I see "SUSPECTED Al-Quaida member and his family and some of his neighbors were killed in an explosion while a drone coincidentally flew over his house" in the news this month? I lost count.

How does this relate? Bombing someone in a foreign country is not an exercise of legal jurisdiction. It's an exercise of a country's sovereign right to exercise military power abroad.

There are two ways to interact with a country. If you're within its legal jurisdiction, you act through legal process. This is where words like "suspected" versus "guilty" have meaning. The other way is the interactions in the state of nature. This is a state of war.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by octo_t on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:07AM (#6775350)
Kim Dotcom?
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by rayiner on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:20AM (#6775463)
Aside from the fact that he made most of his money hosting infringing copies of American content, and serving ads to subscribers in the America, there was the more basic hook that he hosted some of the infringing content on servers in Virginia.

That's the problem most of the copyright infringement sites have. They deal primarily in content that is produced by Americans and considered a property right in America. The U.S. wouldn't give a shit if they were just trading foreign music and movies to each other. Even then, it was e.g. the Swedes that went after Pirate Bay (based on a criminal complaint filed by the MPAA in Sweden).

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by wpietri on Thursday November 21, 2013 @12:04PM (#6775807)
That seems essentially similar to the view of the French body here: if somebody somewhere harms somebody in our country, we can go after them, without regard to the law elsewhere.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by rayiner on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:11PM (#6776295)
If the guy had published the material on a French server, the analogy might be more apropos.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by wil421 on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:17AM (#6775432)
That wasnt a defamation case they were trying to bring him to court for copyright and online piracy violations.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by Mithaldu on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:16AM (#6775427)
> happened entirely outside the country

> do something quite targeted at the U.S.

You realize that those are two different measuring sticks?

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by hobzy on Thursday November 21, 2013 @10:58AM (#6775287)
Erm, ask the US?
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by alan_cx on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:48AM (#6775681)
Yeah, was wondering that myself. Quite ironic that small fact being utterly missed in all this.

Also like the anti French language ignorance. The letter came in French and the recipient couldn't be arsed to spend a few mins on google translate, and some how we are supposed to have some sympathy. On top of that, he also says that he knew there was a legal thing happening, so subsequent letters in French should have got his attention.

And then he has the sheer cheek to talk about insane French law. Hello USA? The go to place for mad law?

This whole thing to me reeks of both ignorance and arrogance.

Not saying the scenario is great, but come on HN. Balance? Or are we still in Freedom Fries mode?

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by darkarmani on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:56AM (#6775754)
> And then he has the sheer cheek to talk about insane French law. Hello USA? The go to place for mad law?

The US doesn't have insane libel law. Obviously France and the UK do. You can get sued for make factual statements and expect to lose in those countries. It doesn't get any crazier than that.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by nknighthb on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:57AM (#6775758)
Why would anyone, upon receiving a letter from a foreign country in a language they do not understand, spend any time at all trying to get it translated? I'd just toss it in the trash, since someone obviously screwed up and sent me a message intended for someone else.
Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by icebraining on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:06PM (#6776264)
From TFA:

I received one more express letter from France, in English, telling me subsequent letters would be in French (...)

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by antiterra on Thursday November 21, 2013 @12:46PM (#6776107)
The suggestion that a Google translation of a legal document is reliable is preposterous. Aside from the expected stilted mangling. pronouns are regularly confused and it's not uncommon for something to come across with the exact opposite of it's intended meaning because a negative modifier or idiom is missed.

Maybe let go of some of that righteous internet rage and go for a walk.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by jlgreco on Thursday November 21, 2013 @02:33PM (#6776841)
> And then he has the sheer cheek to talk about insane French law. Hello USA? The go to place for mad law?

Insane laws in one place do not make laws in another place any less insane. If we universalized your attitude towards criticism, then only those blessed to live in utopias would have the privilege of leveling complaints at other systems.

Re:US blogger fined 8,000 Euros by France for criticizing So... by yread on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:14AM (#6775410)
US doesn't need courts to deal out the punishments