News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by mpg33 on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @12:30PM (#6762743)
Hate when people use the tulips comparison. The basic protocol of bitcoin that allows people to send value anywhere in the world and solves the double spend problem must have some value unto itself. I don't know it's worth $0.10, $100, or $1000000 per bitcoin to use the protocol but to compare it to a plant seems kinda ridiculous.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by g8oz on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @12:43PM (#6762861)
But those attributes can be replicated by another crypto-currency right? So the distinct edge of both bitcoins and tulips are the maddened crowds. They have that in common.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by andrewla on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @04:35PM (#6764659)
This is actually a really good point that I don't feel has been adequately answered -- usually people say something like "well, bitcoin has momentum" or somesuch, which strikes me as being nonsense if you accept the idea of why bitcoins have value as being an intrinsic property related to their fungibility, scarcity, and non-consumability; in theory the same things that give all currencies their value.

The only explanation I've come up with that sounds plausible is that a new currency, even just Bitcoin with a different genesis block, should be as valuable as Bitcoins, but fails the test of scarcity -- it's too easy to counterfeit them by double-spend attacks because of the smaller power of the network.

I don't trust this idea, though -- it smacks of post-hoc reasoning. I guess by extension the value of a proof-of-work-backed currency in aggregate should be bounded by the expected cost of a 51% attack given rational actors; doing this math for the Bitcoin network would either give strong evidence that the current pricing is irrational or weak evidence that it is rational.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by mike_esspe on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @04:51PM (#6764766)
There are some rare metals, other than silver and gold, that did not become a currency, despite having all the same features. Why?
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by andrewla on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @06:21PM (#6765227)
I wouldn't even make the claim that silver and gold functioned as money. In pretty much all circumstances that I'm aware of, the scarcity (in the slightly unconventional sense I'm using it) and fungibility of gold and silver money is not great -- debasing with cheaper, more common metals resulted in differing standards of purity.

Most often, when gold and silver were used as currencies, it was because some dude punched his profile on one side of the coin, and because doing that as a private citizen was difficult and/or punishable by gruesome torture, the value of the money was related to how powerful the head on the coin was because that related to the probability that the coin wouldn't turn green.

This doesn't really answer the question you posed. Now I'm totally in the realm of post-hoc reasoning, though, and I can't really think of a concrete way of falsifying this argument, but I'll go for it anyway. Gold and silver occur naturally near the surface in relatively pure forms; gold especially since it doesn't really allow with anything. As a result, these metals were present in antiquity, and as systems of money grew up, they were good candidates because people thought they understood the scarcity -- an understanding that turned out to be proven incorrect several times in the history of coinage, with reasonably disastrous impacts on savers in those metals. Of course, "being used in antiquity" was not one of the properties I defined above. Arguably fungibility is a factor if the metals were not easily identifiable or distinguishable from other metals.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by kamjam on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @06:53PM (#6765430)
usually people say something like "well, bitcoin has momentum" or somesuch

Which is exactly why its so difficult to replicate "easy functionality" such as Facebook, Twitter, Instagram et al.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by kaoD on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @12:48PM (#6762909)
A plant has a value in itself. People consider tulips beautiful.

I don't know it's worth $0.10, $100, or $1000000...

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by orblivion on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @09:01PM (#6765898)
If you have interest, and the patience to excuse my long-windedness (still learning to write concisely), I give a pretty thorough counter-argument to this here: http://ill-logic-politik.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-fallacies-...

In short, that's begging the question. It's like saying "tulips are great because it lets me give people tulips".

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by TomGullen on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @01:11PM (#6763089)
The easiest way to refute the tulip argument is simply point out Bitcoins total money stock is fixed at 21 million units, wheras you can plant new tulips at will. (The skill/time required to do this is irrelevant to the point).
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by gwern on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @01:51PM (#6763421)
Actually, the interesting thing about tulips is that that's not true. I don't mean to single you out here, but this is a demonstration of how most people know jack shit about Tulipomania (even though many of them are perfectly willing to bloviate about it and compare Bitcoin to tulips).

One of the revolutionary things about tulips at that time was that the unique patterns caused by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip-breaking_virus were only partially inherited: after a few generations, the bulbs are too weakened to survive, and the particular pattern disappears permanently, no matter how lovely and beautiful it was.

If you read up on a book about Tulipomania, you'll notice there are no contemporary photos of tulips like Semper Augustus. Because Semper Augustus no longer exists.

So you can 'plant new tulips at will' the same way you can 'paint new Rembrandts at will' ie. slap some paint on a canvas and hope it looks vaguely similar and that's the best you can do, since you can never ever get another real Rembrandt or real Semper Augustus.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by TomGullen on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @02:28PM (#6763740)
Interesting thanks, what's a good book to read abou it all then?
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by gwern on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @05:48PM (#6765062)
If you just want some correctives to the popular mythology of Tulipomania, you can start with _Famous First Bubbles_: quick read which demolishes a lot of the platitudes and simplifications, and covers the virus & other issues.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by TomGullen on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @06:57AM (#6767517)
Thanks, have ordered it!
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Steko on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @02:39PM (#6763818)
The point of the tulips argument is being missed. The point of the tulips argument is that everything looks great when the price is still increasing in a bubble. This is true whether you're talking about tulips in Nov 1636 or tech stocks in 1998 or Las Vegas real estate in 2005 or gold in 2012 or possibly Bitcoin today.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by snake_plissken on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @02:38PM (#6763810)
That's not the point of the tulip mania comparison. It's more about the extraordinarily quick rise in price, and the (ir)rational choices/decisions that can follow.