News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Hire by brown9-2 on Friday June 26, 2009 @12:20PM (#675583)
"I have just read that companies routinely review Facebook and MySpace activity when screening prospective candidates. One allegation is that if your profile is blocked to non-friends, they may ask you to log in in front of them to let them have a look."

Is this allegation backed up by any fact? Besides that one town in Montana which got in trouble for doing this and has since stopped (I believe this was posted a few days ago).

I may be naive but I really can't imagine this practice being all that widespread - if it's not more than a myth spawned by one or two idiotic hiring managers.

Seems like a lot of passion spawned by not a whole lot of fact.

Re:No Hire by carbon8 on Friday June 26, 2009 @12:31PM (#675605)
Googling someone and checking out their Facebook and MySpace? Yeah, it's common. I've seen surveys that put it at about 1/3 of hiring managers doing it. Is it common for them to make you log in? Probably not, but he didn't say it was.
Re:No Hire by bcl on Friday June 26, 2009 @12:39PM (#675616)
I'm not in management, but have been asked to help out reviewing candidates before. I always google them, but not to look for dirt. I'm interested in how active they are in the open source community. What kinds of projects have they helped out with, etc. I expect any company hiring me to have done the same.

But asking for or expecting access to private websites like facebook? No way. The OP looks to me like someone looking for something to rant about.

Re:No Hire by mblakele on Friday June 26, 2009 @12:57PM (#675651)
I'm not interested in a candidate's personal life, but I am interested in development experience. So I run a web search too, but it can be noisy. Lately I've found mailing list activity is more relevant. For example, http://markmail.org/search/?q=from%3A%22Linus+Torvalds%22
Re:No Hire by moe on Friday June 26, 2009 @04:58PM (#676114)
That Torvalds guy is clearly a bad hire as he apparently spends most of his energy on some useless pet project.
Re:No Hire by carbon8 on Friday June 26, 2009 @12:47PM (#675635)
He's talking about the practice of combing through personal online activity in general and only mentioned the log in issue as an "allegation" that provided an extreme example.
Re:No Hire by yangyang on Friday June 26, 2009 @01:27PM (#675709)
But the "making you log in" bit is the crux of the post. That's crossing the public / private line.
Re:No Hire by philh on Friday June 26, 2009 @04:22PM (#676036)
I get the impression that most of it would be written the same with or without that bit. He mentions Google, which will only reveal public information, in the same manner.
Re:No Hire by maryrosecook on Friday June 26, 2009 @04:24PM (#676042)
Some organisations make you take a drug test and a medical exam. I think this is scandalous, but looking at someone's Facebook is unobstusive in comparison.
Re:No Hire by graywh on Friday June 26, 2009 @04:34PM (#676067)
But at least the drug testing is about you as an employee. Some of the data that might be revealed in viewing a Facebook profile is illegal for interviewers to ask about (for example, religious affiliation and marital status).
Re:No Hire by tdavis on Friday June 26, 2009 @05:49PM (#676210)
How is it more about you as an employee than anything else? A positive drug test merely indicates that one has done drugs in some capacity over some recent span of time. It gives no indication if one would engage in illegal activity on company time.

Of course, it's absurd to suggest companies make sure every worker isn't high on the job every single day, but that doesn't change the fact that it's judging someone based on something which could have absolutely no bearing on their work.

Re:No Hire by kevinpet on Friday June 26, 2009 @08:47PM (#676447)
Big difference between "I don't think has bearing on the job" and "is illegal to ask about". I wouldn't work for a company that wanted to drug test me either, out of principle. On the other hand, if I'm an EMT, it would be arguably reasonable to drug test me, but still illegal to ask if I'm married.
Re:No Hire by falien on Friday June 26, 2009 @06:53PM (#676295)
But its possible that it has an immense bearing on their work. Likewise having 10 years experience doing one thing could have either incredible relevance or none at all. Its a matter of likelihoods and what society has deemed acceptable for making hiring decisions.
Re:No Hire by tdavis on Friday June 26, 2009 @08:25PM (#676421)
Well, almost anything is possible; your argument is specious. Drug tests shouldn't rationally tell you anything more than marital status because any reasonably intelligent drug user can beat a simple piss test. If anything, a drug test is testing for stupidity more than drug use, it just so happens that those have a tendency to go hand-in-hand with respect to low-wage workers.

But programmers? If Google drug tests people I'm sure they do so for liability reasons, not because they care what Johnny Genius does in his free time.

Re:No Hire by philwelch on Friday June 26, 2009 @08:28PM (#676425)
In theory, yes. In practice, they never seem to test people for alcoholism even though that's likely to be more highly correlated to job performance than recreational use of cannabis. It's mostly an exercise in, "we are a government contractor at some point in our business, and some regulation requires us to help enforce anti-drug laws".
Re:No Hire by gaius on Saturday June 27, 2009 @03:29AM (#676700)
That's an excellent point. I have both listed on my FB (along with sexual alignment). In the UK the first company to try this is going to get their arses handed to them by the courts.
Re:No Hire by yangyang on Saturday June 27, 2009 @07:09PM (#677302)
I doubt it.

They're not allowed to discriminate based on these things, but it doesn't mean they can't know them (though obviously they probably won't ask you as that's asking for trouble).

You can't discriminate based on age or gender in the UK (amongst many other things). But if they interview you (face to face at least), I think they'd probably have a fairly good idea of those, without asking you (or looking at your facebook profile).

Re:No Hire by gaius on Sunday June 28, 2009 @03:42AM (#677591)
I interview people for my employer, and we're not even allowed to ask. It's impossible to tell - if you do ask someone their religion and then don't hire them, you'd better have some rock-solid paperwork to back you up (e.g. show their score on a standard list of questions is less than the candidate you did hire). That's just how it is.
Re:No Hire by yangyang on Tuesday June 30, 2009 @04:04AM (#680468)
Same for me. I'm pointing out that there are some things that you don't have to ask, you can tell by looking.
Re:No Hire by ensignavenger on Friday June 26, 2009 @05:42PM (#676192)
Depending on the demands of the job, the medical test may be very important.
Re:No Hire by pbhjpbhj on Saturday June 27, 2009 @11:09AM (#676902)
Unless your facebook mentions your medical condition or your drug use?!
Re:No Hire by ironkeith on Friday June 26, 2009 @01:20PM (#675691)
I don't think I've ever hired anyone without first Googling their name, if for no other reason than curiosity. That said, I've never not hired, or not interviewed based on something I've seen in the SERPs.
Re:No Hire by schof on Friday June 26, 2009 @05:19PM (#676152)
I have never (and would never) ask a candidate to allow me access to a private profile. However, I have rejected a candidate for what they posted on their blog.

Posting things on the public Internet that reflects poorly on the candidate shows a judgment issue that is a valid reason for rejecting a candidate.

In the case I'm thinking of, a cursory Google search on a candidate I would otherwise have hired showed that he had at least one job that he had quit without notice; this job was not listed on his resume. In addition, this first-person blog stated that he had shown up to work so hungover he could barely see, on more than one occasion.

Should I have hired this person, given the red flags I found via Google and that there were other equally-qualified candidates who did not have those red flags?

Re:No Hire by raganwald on Friday June 26, 2009 @06:02PM (#676220)
Both of the things you mention are directly work-related. Can you give some other examples of " things on the public Internet that reflects poorly on the candidate?"

For example, does posting something about anti-semitism reflect poorly on a candidate? How about a candidate that makes strong statements about the correlation between race and IQ?

Re:No Hire by statictype on Friday June 26, 2009 @11:21PM (#676553)
Those kinds of social issues are relevant for two reasons.

1) If the candidate has to work on a team with others, then he has to get along with the team - or at the very least, the chemistry shouldn't be bad enough to affect performance.

2)I think it's perfectly acceptable to reject someone because you don't consider him to be morally upstanding. The second statement about correlating race and IQ is a bit ambiguous and subjective, but if, say the candidate was philosophically in favor of lynching and ethnic genocide, then I wouldn't care how good a hacker he is, I wouldn't feel right hiring him.

Posting race\IQ issue wouldn't, in my opinion, reflect poorly on the candidate even though I don't necessarily agree with it. On the other hand, posting anti-semitic remarks probably would reflect poorly, depending on how they were phrased and the context (is it just pure hate or mere opposition to certain political stances...)

Re:No Hire by falien on Friday June 26, 2009 @07:01PM (#676307)
Whether they reflect poorly or not is a matter of personal philosophy. If I was face with someone who was blatantly racist, it would reflect poorly on their suitability for a job where they to interact with people who would take offense to such views. For such things, a decision would depend on how negative I anticipated that interaction to be. This is no different from not hiring someone based on their poor social skills during an interview. It is in public and they must expect it to be scrutinized and associated with them.
Re:No Hire by Goladus on Saturday June 27, 2009 @09:00AM (#676818)
Eh, I'd say you aren't being fair, no. Not that any interview process is really fair. I once worked with a guy who told me stories about waking up at work at his desk, not remembering how he got there. He never did anything remotely like that working with me. For 3 years he was sharp, punctual, and competent.

And frankly, the reason and manner in which someone left their last job is a piss-poor reason for not hiring someone. What if there was sexual harassment? Stuff like that you can't know from a google search or even an interview.

Re:No Hire by CamperBob on Saturday June 27, 2009 @05:32AM (#676742)
As an employer, I reserve the right to use any public data obtained from web/Usenet searches to understand where a candidate is coming from in his/her professional life. It's basic due diligence, whether legal or ethical or not, and I expect prospective co-workers to do the same to me. Moral: don't be a dick or a moron online, at least not in connection with your real name.

That said, the real peril is that of mistaken identity. I almost missed out on a (mostly) enjoyable 2+ year relationship because my Google search revealed that the woman I was chatting with was an activist for various evangelical Christian causes. Fortunately, before breaking contact with her, I asked her about it, and soon realized that Google was leading me astray.

Re:No Hire by mcormier on Friday June 26, 2009 @12:25PM (#675594)
Exactly, you don't get many credibility points if you don't back up your main statement.