News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by mrb on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6756086)
If you compare Tulip Mania to the world's first decentralized, censorship-resistant, inflation-resistant, digital currency, then you don't understand Bitcoin. At all.

Combine this with absolutely zero efforts to estimate the worth of the Bitcoin system, how Bitcoin is used today, etc. That's the difference between being published at Techcrunch and more prestigious publications like http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/31/technology/bitcoin-pursues... or http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/11/08...

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by maxerickson on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:00PM (#6756132)
If in, say, 5 years, you turn out to be hilariously wrong, will you eat your bitcoins?
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by moocowduckquack on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:10PM (#6756199)
I expect bitcoin to crash and burn at some point. But that is because I think bitcoin has flaws that make it likely to be replaced by future crypto-currencies, or possibly something weirder. Until those currencies exist and gain traction however, bitcoin is going to get bigger. A lot bigger. I don't think this is even that stupid a time to buy, I strongly suspect that there is at least another 10x growth still there, a $10,000 bitcoin price within 3 years would not shock me at all.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by mrb on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:53PM (#6756503)
Let me clarify my position: the utility of decentralized digital currencies on society is so enormous that it is inevitable that they will succeed. Decentralized digital financial transactions are an invention as big as the Internet.

Is it Bitcoin that will succeed, or some other cryptocurrency? I don't know, but it has a good shot at it because it has the first-mover advantage and benefits from network effect.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by rafcavallaro on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:25PM (#6757157)
By the same utility argument there should be no nuclear weapons, an all out push for zero emissions energy, and world peace, but don't hold your breath. There are existing, very powerful stakeholders such as the governments and militaries of numerous world powers who would far prefer that financial transactions not be anonymous. Tech folk sometimes forget that their bodies live in meat space, not cyberspace, and whoever controls the guys with weapons (i.e., controls police and armies) controls meat space.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by mrb on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @12:08AM (#6759405)
The difference being of course: nobody has a clue on how to achieve no nuclear weapons, 100% zero emmission energy, world peace, etc. So you might wish it, but it just not going to happen right now.

But Bitcoin is a known solution demonstrating how to implement a decentralized digital currency. It is working. Today. So the utility it has, and the impact it is about to make on society is enormous.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by VMG on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:07PM (#6756185)
The fact that most people don't get it is one of the most exciting things about it. I like reading negative articles more than positive ones.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by vijayboyapati on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:53PM (#6756067)
This is what the real-time monetization of a good looks like. In the early stages you have massive price increases until there is enough liquidity and volatility declines. Bitcoin looks like a bubble, but money is inherently a bubble phenomena: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/04/bitcoin...
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by exit on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:04PM (#6756162)
the author of the article you link to set up a donation address and received 1.159 btc on the same day, currently worth 678.52 usd.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by vijayboyapati on Monday November 18, 2013 @03:02PM (#6756549)
He actually received a total of a little more than 19 bitcoins. He's a very popular and respected blogger among libertarian circles. One of the most well read (of history and economics) authors I've come across.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by baddox on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6756076)
Unsurprisingly, the author makes no attempt to show why any BTC to USD exchange rate should be considered reasonable or unreasonable.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by corysama on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6756082)
Viewed on a log scale, it's clear that $650 is too high. But, it's not quite as outlandish as the linear plot implies. http://i.imgur.com/GOYWUMo.png According to that armchair-financier line fitting, the trend is for the price to still be below $300. What's more interesting is the long term trend of 10X price increase every 12.5 months for the past 3+ years running. Disclaimer: past performance is not an indicator of anything.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by ISL on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:01PM (#6756146)
It's clear that such a slope is unsustainable in the long term. If bitcoin continues its growth, with a $5B market cap now, and a ~$100T world GDP, it's clear that there's, at most, another four orders of magnitude to go.

And, given that perhaps a few thousand collectors are each willing to pay a few dollars to own most of the world's BTC, there's perhaps six orders of magnitude of room for the price to fall.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by corysama on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:25PM (#6756296)
Agreed. Even if it doesn't die, it's going to S-curve at some point. The range between $1000-$10,000 is going to be interesting times. At that point, a lot of the early hobbyists are going to be holding minor life-changing amounts of potential money ($10Ks-$100Ks). Even with the forecast of continued exponential growth, it's will be the smart move for a lot of people to "take some off the table" and cash out a significant portion of whatever they've been hoarding.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by a3voices on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:06PM (#6756181)
I agree it's unsustainable forever, but I see it as analogous to Facebook when its market cap. was only $6 billion or so.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by Everlag on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:49PM (#6756037)
I think it is telling that in the time from when this was posted to this reply, bitcoin is up to 668.5.

This is a bubble, anyone who thinks otherwise doesn't understand that people make an effectively stupid amount of money by using bitcoin as a pump and dump scheme.

If you think this bubble is helping bitcoin as a currency, then you are terrifically incorrect. For all the good that bitcoin is capable of, how the hell do you base a payment system around something that has no price stability?

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by ISL on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:55PM (#6756092)
Agreed. I'd like to purchase a cheese sandwich at my local BTC-accepting food truck, but I'm going to skip it this week precisely because I might be able to buy twice as many (or half as many) sandwiches next week.

Things are so volatile this week, that even nearly-instantaneous transactions USD-->BTC-->BTC-->USD (whose utility isn't affected by the price of 1 BTC) aren't guaranteed to happen as expected. Better to wait a week for things to chill out. They will.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by aryastark on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:24PM (#6756291)
I'm not sure how people are determining this is a bubble. There are roughly 12 million bitcoins in existence. Priced at $668, that means there is a mere $8 billion in the entire Bitcoin system. That's tiny. For a global currency with the unique advantages Bitcoin has, I would expect the currency to be in the $10s to 100s of billions soon enough.

In order for bitcoin to actually matter, it needs to grow. You're going to get $668 bitcoins no matter what, if people start using it. That's simple supply and demand. Network effects being what they are, it's going to grow quickly.

In order for Bitcoin to remain stable, it would need to grow slowly. Thanks to the Internet and the plethora of Bitcoin news lately, I just don't see that happening.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by Jtsummers on Monday November 18, 2013 @03:00PM (#6756537)
I'm not sure it is a bubble (I see issues with bitcoin, but not the concept in general. Better cryptocurrencies seem possible.), but the total valuation is not evidence it isn't a bubble. A bubble really boils down to expansion beyond what the fundamentals support, and (only determined in retrospect) end in a contraction. While it's small scale, a $1 widget gaining widespread popularity and ballooning to $100 is a bubble if there's no real reason other than hype or artificial scarcity for it to reach that price. The total value of BTC being only 8 billion USD doesn't mean it isn't a bubble, it just means most economies will be unscathed should it turn out to be one.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by maxerickson on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:33PM (#6756343)
The actual number of bitcoin actively trading hands is a lot smaller than 12 million.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by wellboy on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:55PM (#6756095)
You need to understand what a bubble is and what isn't. It's a bubble when bets are made on things that have nothing backing up their immense valuation.

Now, you need some smartness to understand that the value in currencies is not in it´s physical value ($100 are worth maybe $0.02 in physical value), but how many people use it.

Millions of people now use bitcoin, thousands of businesses have started accepting bitcoin over the past 6 months. In a year these numbers will be 50-fold.

Things that people use a lot, are not bubbles. Also, this doesn't take into consideration the potential, which is a major factor determining a valuation. And that is that Bitcoin or something similar has the potential to replace all banks and all currencies entirely.

EDIT: Changed "don't have an underlying value" to have nothing backing up their immense valuation". And sorry I was a bit angry, but I've read it now a hundred times on hackernews over the past 2 years, we're in a bubble here, we're in a bubble there. It is not a bubble, when millions and millions of people are using it.

The 2000 bubble was a bubble because there were 300M internet users at the time. Now we have 2B, that's the difference.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by Everlag on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:03PM (#6756160)
So the value of bitcoin going from just around 350 to just around 700 dollars in a week is not a bubble?

Have businesses using bitcoins doubled? Have users of bitcoin doubled? While possible, I must say that the chance of people investing in the currency not as a currency to be used but as a money multiplier would be a bubble.

What underlying value has bitcoin shown to necessitate a 2x increase of value in a week? I'm honestly curious.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by jmduke on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:59PM (#6756121)
Seriously you people don´t understand what a bubble is. It´s when bets are made on things that don´t have an underlying value.

This is not true. There are many bets you can make on something that doesn't have an underlying value which does not constitute a bubble -- and many bubbles can be formed from things which have underlying values (such as real estate.)

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by RogerL on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:00PM (#6756130)
That is not what a bubble is. We have bubbles in the stock market all the time, and they are bid on things of significant "underlying value" (companies). A bubble is (roughly) when the bids are disconnected from that value, and more connected on the other bids in the system.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by genericuser on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:16PM (#6756243)
One of things about a 'bubble' is unfortunately that there isn't an exact way to determine what is and isn't a bubble prior to it bursting or when it finally levels off a bit because it reached an equilibrium of price and perceived value.

After it levels off or busts you will have groups saying "I told you so" giving you the same 'evidence' they used now to support their claim.

People that are 'sure' they know which this is should invest in either its success or failure, as arguing with people and trying to convince them you are right does little besides potentially increase the number of people you would have to share your profits with.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by jrs235 on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:04PM (#6756165)
Ouch.

Seriously you don't understand what a bubble is.

"It's when bets are made on things that don´t have an underlying value."

No. It's when speculation [betting] leads to overvaluing an "asset".

Homes have an underlying value. The bubble on home prices was a result of overvaluation [due to speculation].

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by VLM on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:00PM (#6756136)
You know, like houses. Or dotcom stocks.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by a3voices on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6756080)
Actually Bitcoin is following strong exponential growth from its inception. It's no more a bubble than Facebook is.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by ISL on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:48PM (#6756022)
Logarithmic plots!

A better way to look at a quantity which has changed so much is to use a logarithm.

http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/mtgoxUSD#tgSzm1g10zm2g25zvzl

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by johnrob on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:45PM (#6756008)
Bitcoin is a currency. Shouldn't we be more interested in the number purchases made with it instead of the current exchange value?
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by VLM on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:59PM (#6756120)
Transfers. The overall transfer market utilizes 100 BTC (made up) and the overall transfer market at any given instant is worth $65000 (made up) therefore the average price on the transfer market is $650, although that doesn't mean anything to anyone in the transfer market.

If the price collapsed to $10 tomorrow, then the international transfer market would still be worth $65000 at any given instant (duh, unless world trade collapses), it would just require 6500 BTC instead of 100 BTC. If the market can't provide 6500 BTC at $10 (I don't think it can..) then the market clearing price will rise until the transfer market obtains its average $65000.

The buy and hold and the pump and dump crowds get all confused about what it means.

The current exchange value on the open market has to remain constant-ish for months because of middlemen. So I ordered a Debian branded swiss army knife and the whole transaction must have taken months, I'd be pretty pissed if the exchange rate from $ to swiss francs or whatever it was varied much. On the other hand as a replacement for Western Union to send cash to Mexico or whatever, I guess the value needs to remain constant for what, like 10 minutes?

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by ISL on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:56PM (#6756104)
It's a thing. At the moment, some people are willing to trade ~600 cheeseburgers for one of them.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by craigyk on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:49PM (#6756030)
Yup, despite what it's advocates say, it sure isn't behaving like a currency. Major requirement of currency: very-low volatility.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by applecore on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6756079)
There are a number of currencies that experienced ridiculous levels of hyperinflation over the years.

When is a currency a currency? Until it isn't?

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by Jtsummers on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:10PM (#6756197)
Many currencies lack stability (meaning some low % inflation/deflation(?)). I think it would be reasonable to contend that almost anything could be a currency or used as one, but stability makes for more effective currencies. While the value of BTC vs USD (or other established currencies) continues to explode, it makes it more difficult to use as a currency proper (rather than as a commodity/investment). If you have 10 BTC, it'd be difficult to spend 0.05 BTC (over 30 USD now) on a good (not a necessity) when it seems like in a week you could spend 0.03 BTC for the same thing.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by craigyk on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @08:16PM (#6765770)
yes, I left out the 'effective' adjective. Or I should have put currency in sarcastic quotes.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by exit on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6756075)
is it a currency? is it a commodity? it may be something new which doesn't fit into existing categories.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by phaed on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:47PM (#6756016)
Not yet.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by a3voices on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:57PM (#6756106)
It's more like gold than a typical currency, due to its scarcity (20 million Bitcoins will be mined ever).
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by IanChiles on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:00PM (#6756135)
Now I'm just a little bit disappointed I didn't buy any when I first heard of them... But this feels like the same bubble Bitcoin has had twice before - it spikes then plummets, but it plummets to a point higher than the last drop
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by tlrobinson on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:00PM (#6756129)
So how exactly does one come up with a "reasonable" price for Bitcoin? Why is $100 any more "reasonable" than $645?
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by VikingCoder on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:06PM (#6756178)
So how exactly does one come up with a "reasonable" price for anything? Why is $10 for a chicken any more "reasonable" than $10,000?

Things have value because we (collectively) believe they do. Currency is a numbering system. In practical terms, what matters is how easy are the numbers to use, and what's the relative value of one thing versus another.

And if you think we can rationally decide how many chickens a hip placement is worth, you're still nuts.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by junto on Monday November 18, 2013 @03:08PM (#6756596)
Surely price is comparative? If you only earn $10 a week then $10 for a chicken is expensive, but if you earn $1000 a week then that chicken is pretty cheap.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by VikingCoder on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:24PM (#6757603)
Why does one guy earn $10 a week, and the other guy earns $1000 a week?

No, seriously.

Nothing is stable in an economy. Everything is dynamic. Everything is relative. Everything is a shared delusion. Luckily, most people buy into it, most of the time. When that fails, you get massive inflation.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by massarog on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:48PM (#6756020)
Looks like half the sites are down/have issues. Can't even login to my coinbase account without getting errors.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by aestra on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:53PM (#6756070)
They aren't sending me out SMS verification codes.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by MarkPNeyer on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:10PM (#6756195)
i'm not sure whether this current bitcoin price run is a bubble or just the currency becoming more valuable as it gains more attention and recognition from world governments. my guess is that a downward correction is coming soon. either way, though, i'm certain that in the long run, the currency is worth much more than the $600 it trades at now.

the model i'm using is BTC as a new form of gold. the current value of all the gold in the world, by my primitive calculation, is around 4 trillion. if all the bitcoins in circulation eventually reach a quarter of that value - which i think is totally realistic, most likely an underestimate, that puts the price per bitcoin at over $100k, a number that already seemed reasonable to me.

my guess is it'll be there in less than 10 years. anybody want over / under?

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by jjsz on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:35PM (#6756351)
Me neither but I gambled .XX BTC into it before it exploded in reddit than mainstream online articles.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by conductr on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6756084)
That article fails to mention what is going on in China right now which, whatever it is, is driving the price
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by conductr on Monday November 18, 2013 @06:01PM (#6757935)
Saw this gem on the front page, it goes in more detail about China and BTC

http://www.coindesk.com/china-leading-global-rise-bitcoin/

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by cft on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:02PM (#6756151)
Coinbase: Note! We've exceeded our normal buy limits for today. If you would still like to purchase you will receive the market price of bitcoin on Friday Nov 22, 2013 at 11:01AM PST after your funds have arrived.

The price is rapidly dropping, lost nearly 10% now from today's peak.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by ISL on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:07PM (#6756182)
Good for Coinbase. It's in their interests to remain solvent, and to encourage moderation. I really liked having my desire to buy tempered by their ~week-timescale delays in the past.

(That said, if you really want to buy, keep trying, Coinbase's buy limit opens and shuts sometimes.)

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by robius on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:22PM (#6756267)
This is just the beginning of the tides turning. This huge jump is just a few thousand Chinese investors coming online. More will come. Next think about when another country gets its own exchange, say India. Expect more large jumps before things settle down.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by JanezStupar on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:53PM (#6756068)
How does one short bitcoin? Any proxies?
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by tlrobinson on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:55PM (#6756097)
I don't care how bearish you are on Bitcoin, you'd have to be crazy to short it.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by JanezStupar on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:41PM (#6756415)
Indeed.

However I think that buying or holding bitcoin is just as crazy.

This is strictly a mental experiment. There is no way I am putting any kind of money into this market on any side.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by Moral_ on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:56PM (#6756099)
Shorting bitcoin doesn't really make any sense. You can't loan someone bitcoins and if you could, how would you get them back? So no.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by VLM on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:08PM (#6756189)
"You can't loan someone bitcoins and if you could, how would you get them back?"

Why do you say that? MPEx has been doing that for 3 years. As for how you get "them" back that is pretty obvious. How long would a margin call take with a digital currency, like 2 ms or something?

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by JanezStupar on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:39PM (#6756392)
That is why I am asking about a potential hedge trade. A long bet on an asset that is inversely correlated to the Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by CamperBob2 on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:58PM (#6756117)
You can't loan someone bitcoins

Someone should probably start working on that.

Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by simlevesque on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:04PM (#6756167)
You can do it using Ripple with trust lines.
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by tlrobinson on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:23PM (#6756280)
Of course you can loan Bitcoin, why wouldn't you be able to?
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by fragmede on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:25PM (#6756294)
If I loan you US dollars, how do I get them back?
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by VMG on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:57PM (#6756109)
other things that are completely unreasonable and yet seem to exist: the internet
Re:Bitcoin $645? Yeah, That’s Totally Reasonable by a3voices on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:50PM (#6756041)
It's not a bubble. It's very fast growth.

http://i.imgur.com/qgT9vxx.png