News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by matthewmacleod on Sunday November 17, 2013 @08:29PM (#6751983)
What's with the sudden outpouring of Google-hate of late?

I totally get that Google is changing, and has been doing so for a while. But I don't see that as "evil," and I'm struggling to see why anybody would.

Google around maybe five or six years ago was a wasteland of shoddy, broken, unintegrated products, many with half-assed, confusing interfaces. That's been tightened up - many of their products are now substantially better; there's a coherent account and profile system in place; the weak products have been culled. Their focus is a lot better.

I'm probably using Google resources less than I used to - GMail's interface pisses me off, the new Maps layout is infuriating, and search is broadly speaking totally broken for me in places. I'm also acutely aware that Google's audience has changed - it's no longer tech-savvy early adopters, but almost everybody who has an Internet connection. Unfortunately, the interests of the minority groups of users are going to fall by the wayside as the business evolves.

To some extent, that's great - it opens up gaps in the market where other products can get a look-in. If Google's search sucks, I'm sure a competitor will pop up. Same with Gmail, or Docs, or Hangouts… etc.

There are unsurprisingly some areas in which Google's record is not 100% clean - they stopped supporting RSS, removed XMPP federation, require profile verification (apparently) - but in most cases, I can certainly see how the business or technical case for these could legitimately be made. These are not evil actions - they're just ones that you (and I) don't agree with. Fair enough - we're under no obligation to use Google's services. In the meantime, they continue to develop a huge diversity of open-source software and protocols, and I hear it's still a great place to work.

I guess at the end of the day you could be right - Google has declined from your perspective. But I doubt that's true from the perspective of their wider user base.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by rdtsc on Sunday November 17, 2013 @09:57PM (#6752224)
It's an avalanche effect. Once someone posts about Google, others start thinking and posting, and so on. Or maybe you can think of it like pinball machine, the ball goes in, and then just keeps bouncing around until eventually it dies down.

We have those often about languages, databases, operating system and so on. Sometime we see the opposite technology pop up. Like say one writes about "Why MySQL is awesome" then expect "Why MongoDB is the real deal" to appear on the front page.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by davidgerard on Monday November 18, 2013 @03:56AM (#6753376)
The watershed moment was a couple of years ago, when they introduced G+ and pushed hard on the Real Names policy for it.

They alienated a shitload of techies, and all those early adopters' friends, and blew thirteen years' accumulated good will in about two months. This was the point at which G+ would never, ever compete head-on with Facebook as an actual social network.

What's happening now is they just did another burst of that and alienated a much wider crowd of people. More people are seeing the mask crack.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by alextingle on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:11AM (#6753595)
Look, this isn't a new issue. Lots and lots of us have been getting increasingly dissatisfied with Google for years. But each problem is isolated and hasn't made much of a ripple in the wider world...

Is it a big deal to me that Google messed up their automated AdSense "publisher" interaction script, and cut off my income for a few weeks? Why yes, yes it is... but that doesn't mean that anyone else cares about that. Even if Google's generally poor supplier relations affects a lot of people (and it does), there's never enough of them for it to affect Google, the brand.

Same goes for any number of other Google problems. Did the "nym wars" cause lots of disaffection amongst Google users? Yes, but again not enough. Did adding lots of pointless JavaScript to search results pages piss off a lot of people? How about the fact that search results are much less specific/useful than they used to be? Unilateral changes to the privacy policy? Or Google Reader? Code Search? Etcetera, etcetera...

Google have created a huge amount of simmering resentment over the last few years. So, once an issue like this starts to get some traction, there are a lot of people ready to wait in line to put the boot in.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by dorfsmay on Sunday November 17, 2013 @11:24PM (#6752524)
Going away from standard and becoming incompatible. They are becoming very much like Microsoft that way. VOIP had a chance to become as ubiquitous and convenient as email, but the drop of xmpp fot voice and video took us back 10 years.... Same with replacing rss by g+. Google exists because of standards such as http and html, but they are slowly moving away from all standards in the name of locking users.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by jmillikin on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:41AM (#6752970)

  > VOIP had a chance to become as ubiquitous and convenient
  > as email, but the drop of xmpp fot voice and video took
  > us back 10 years.
XMPP had its chance, and failed to deliver. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebRTC is the modern standard-to-be for VOIP, and the original implementation was created by Google.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by dorfsmay on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:18PM (#6755419)
Thanks for the link, this is informative. BUT:

- unless I read this wrong, this protocol does not describe how the initial call is initiated, just how the video and audio is negotiated and transferred over the web.

- there is no way to federate with google hangout or other WebRTC services, is there? This is the issue. hHangout is an amazing piece of software, but they give it to us for free to force us to register and use google accounts.

btw, I don't think xmpp failed, what failed is to settle on good standards for voice and video (every time a standard emerged, somebody came up with a better one that was closed source which broke inter-compatibility) and really good clients (only skype and google voice could echo cancellation properly). xmpp, and SIP for that matter, are really about establishing the connection, they don't really care how the rest of the communication is done. What you are saying is like saying email failed because different people interpret html slightly differently.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by jmillikin on Monday November 18, 2013 @06:49PM (#6758178)

  > unless I read this wrong, this protocol does not
  > describe how the initial call is initiated, just how the
  > video and audio is negotiated and transferred over the web.
Correct. The underlying application is responsible for initiating calls, using a protocol such as SIP.

  > there is no way to federate with google hangout or
  > other WebRTC services, is there?
That's up to the service. Hangouts doesn't permit federation, but there should be no technical barriers to launching a federated video-chat service.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by kruipen on Sunday November 17, 2013 @09:24PM (#6752145)
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by Kequc on Sunday November 17, 2013 @09:52PM (#6752205)
People don't like change. People like what they had. People hate that Google is deciding to move forward. Now forcing the changes on their user base so that Google doesn't have an unlimited number of different things to maintain.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by wpietri on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:07PM (#6752252)
I think it's more than a dislike of change. It's not clear to me that Google is moving forward. I might characterize it more as "upward" in the sense that they're solidifying their dominant position. Moving forward is precisely what I fear them losing.

Of course, it's easy to move forward when you're new and have nothing to lose. Moving forward is much harder when you're the dominant player, because moving forward puts you at risk.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by Kequc on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:50PM (#6752385)
I feel that I've been waiting for them to do something with youtube for a long time. Making it and Google plus the same thing is probably the right move. Youtube in general needs a lot of renovation.

The structure of Google plus suits content aggregation really well, it was designed for it. So I think it's a really good fit and I can't really wait for the transition to be finished.

My hesitation used to be something along the lines of I don't want Youtube users on Google plus. But I've come to remember, since it has started. I still have complete control over who shows up in my streams.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by alandarev on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:04AM (#6753396)
Indeed, why not enforce people use social network if they want to watch a video?
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by skriticos2 on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:54AM (#6753202)
I always wondered why this is. I know people hate change and it baffles me (I long for progressive change). I understand that having a basic stable framework is a nice thing to have, but rejecting change outright is somewhat backward IMO.

Then again I was always a fan of SciFi thinking about where we'll be in the future, so I'm probably a weird oddball person.

I'm probably overlooking something here, like re-learning changing stuff is not preferable for many and tech is only tool and not lifestyle.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by onetwofiveten on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:49AM (#6753703)
I don't think that's the case. Google is a relatively young company and its entire success grew out of smart people recognising good quality products and embracing change. It happens that Google is now changing in a way that ultimately will hurt (and is hurting) users. The smart connected early adopters that previously loved Google can see what is going on and they don't like it.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by Kequc on Monday November 18, 2013 @10:42AM (#6754790)
I'll respond.

I've been an early adopter of most of the products google has made available. They're consistently ahead of the curve with only a few exceptions. Youtube is technologically ahead of the curve, talking about the bandwidth and processing that goes on within that service is mind numbing. But other than what they've managed to accomplish on a technical scale with the service, everything else has been lacking. First and foremost I would say that unifying sign in with the rest of Google's products is a no brainer. But people have even been fighting that on Youtube.

Google+ is their identity service, first and foremost so all accounts are being moved there. If you don't want to use the social aspects of it you don't have to. I'd suggest you do because it's really convenient.

They are investing a lot of money into context awareness. They already know who you are. What you search for, what you like, what you want to know. They know your name phone number and birth date. Putting this identity service into play just brings all of that up to the surface and gives you some control.

If Google wanted to be evil at this point they wouldn't need to give you Google+ to do it.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by josephlord on Monday November 18, 2013 @09:24AM (#6754396)
People aren't frogs and while the temperature of the water has been rising slowly increasing numbers of people are noticing.

When I was at the BBC in the early 2000's they experimented with Digital TV and gradually reduced the bitrate of the broadcasts until the numbers of complaints grew. The interesting thing was when the bitrates were returned to their original levels the complaints didn't stop as the viewers had been educated in compression artefacts.

I think that the gradual drift in user unfriendliness (privacy, increasing search ads, reader, G+'s pushiness into other areas etc.) is causing pushing various people to their limits of what can be allowed to pass without comment or action. It will be interesting if Google pulls back whether the complaints and departures (if they are actually happening yet - many people seem very tied to Gmail) actually slow or stop.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by lyagusha on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:12PM (#6757526)
>>tied to Gmail

Use GMVault once, and at least the archive of old emails is no longer an issue.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by Zoomla on Sunday November 17, 2013 @09:25PM (#6752147)
it looks like you answered your own question (at least partially): "GMail's [new] interface pisses me off, the new Maps layout is infuriating" ... but there is many other reasons to dislike Google's choices... I still miss the - and + operator when using Google search for example (this change happened when they started to push Google+)
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by flebron on Sunday November 17, 2013 @09:56PM (#6752220)
- still exists, and + is now "". That is, "foo" forces foo to appear exactly, just as +foo did.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by ywyrd on Saturday November 30, 2013 @02:39PM (#6824290)
They don't work. "Verbatim", which claims to be what "" used to be, does not work either. Nothing to be done about it.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by rhizome on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:13AM (#6752702)
I totally get that Google is changing

They aren't changing, they have changed.

And, "unintegrated" is not necessarily a bad thing.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by dredmorbius on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:41AM (#6753150)
As a guy who inspired two top-level stories yesterday, a few speculations.

For myself, the company I once turned to to provide me useful things, save me time, respect my privacy (and certainly not pester me for personal information or publicly link my activity across entirely independent activities and sites), and get out of the way of doing things, is now proving me increasingly useless, wasting my time, disrespecting my privacy (including pestering me for personal information and publicly linking my activity across entirely independent activities and sites), and getting in the way of my doing things.

The company's interests are no longer clearly aligned with mine.

I'm not convinced the company's evil (though I'm also not convinced it's not), but it's certainly lost a certain element of the soul it exhibited when I first encountered it in the late 1990s, and it seems to me that the culture has been broken. I've speculated on why this is, and cannot know for sure. I suspect a large part of it is riding the advertising tiger (see: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070708081303AA... "He who rides the tiger is afraid to dismount"), I fear that it may be cooperating, or forced to cooperate, with intelligence and surveillance operations, and it may well be that a sense of entitlement, exceptionalism, and hubris has taken hold (Vic Gundotra's 2005 blog post against Microsoft's endorsement of a gay marriage proposal in Washington State makes for interesting reading: http://web.archive.org/web/20051119214319/http://vicgundotra...)

Google five or six years ago was still fundamentally Search. Gmail was relatively new, and it was tossing a bunch of research projects "over the wall", some of which were actually pretty neat. Somewhat disorganized, yes, but ... interesting. Most significantly: not coercive. Which, if I think about it, is the biggest change I've seen.

There's a certain lifecycle to tech companies, going from promising upstarts to early pioneers to useful workhorses. And then, too often, it's a decline into an unorganized mess, forced integration among scattered products and tools, and an increasing use of entrenched market power to coerce the response that they can no longer inspire. Microsoft and IBM certainly fit this mold, as does Oracle. I'd consider Apple a curious exception despite my other criticisms of the company.

The single factor that's changed the most for me is that when I see Google's name on some product or tool, my first though now is "nice, but where can I find similar functionality elsewhere?"

And at the same time, the company does seem to be fighting, if slightly belatedly, for increased protections from surveillance and personal data disclosure. Largely on account that it realizes its business model is directly in the crosshairs of such practices.

So, when I came home yesterday to find two G+ posts (both strongly critical of Google) directly inspiring top-of-the-list HN articles, and a third "how to delete your G+ profile" item filling out the top 3, it was pretty surreal. I wonder (and speculated earlier on HN) that there might well be some gaming of the incoming queue, Google certainly has its enemies, and Microsoft's waged a dirty-tricks campaign against the company for years. Apple, Oracle, and Facebook are hardly fast friends. But a lot of what I see written seems pretty organic, and I'm well aware of friends, some who've worked at Google, who are also increasingly disenchanted by the company and its direction. pg would know his queue and voting dynamics.

That's all I've got.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by elastoplast on Monday November 18, 2013 @07:53AM (#6754053)
I work at Google, have done for about 7 years now. This is my first comment at HN.

I think your comment about "not coercive" is insightful. The biggest change I've seen over time here is that at the start, people never talked about what users should or should not do. They were treated as people who would use our products, or not, and that was A-OK.

The subtle trend that underlies a lot of this recent outpouring of dismay is that these days, this view has changed. It's not about chasing profit (it's still extremely rare at Google to see anything approaching a budget). It's not about being evil. It's that these days users are increasingly treated as if they were sheep that need to be herded around.

This trend is evidence in many different ways. The big push for Google+ comes from Larry's fear of Facebook. He got really scared a few years ago that Facebook was going to "win" in any area they competed in, simply through being social, regardless of how good their actual product was. Photos was taken as the canonical example: Facebook Photos was inferior in almost every way to PicasaWeb but it won handily in terms of market share because it was social (or so the theory goes). Messaging seemed similar, surveys showed the younger generation didn't use email anymore, it was all on Facebook. So at the time it was thought that Facebook were going to take on every one of Google's core products and win, simply through having the social graph. So that fear drove the massive investment in Google+ and the desire to win at any cost.

Of course this strategy has not worked, as was predictable. Google+ is an excellent social network, but people already had one and didn't care to change. Also, the threat from Facebook has never really seemed to materialise in the huge way Larry thought it would.

Unfortunately this fear drove a long series of mental rationalisations. People would use Google+, employees were told, because it would be good for them. They might not realise it now, but Google+ would make everything better, and that's why it's so important that they all sign up. Real Names might be unpopular to start with, but then people would realise the benefits and they'd all be happy.

The same thinking has driven a bunch of other problems. That damn red alerting bell that Google+ users all get? It can't be switched off, rationale: "if we allow users to switch it off because it's too noisy, after we fix that they won't switch it back on and then they'd end up in a worse state. It's really better for people in the long term that there be no way to disable it".

Unfortunately Larry is so committed to this fear-driven social strategy that he can't mentally accept that a large population of users is never going to be excited about or use Google+. For him, if Google+ loses, Google itself will become entirely irrelevant a short time later. It's literally an existential crisis. This places Vic in a very powerful position where he's able to get whatever he wants, and pushback from the lower ranks is ignored in order to seem to be making progress with this "better for the users" social integration.

I guess YouTube comments are a good recent example of this. Presumably someone at the bottom of the YouTube org understood that removing character limits and allowing links would immediately cause floods of spam, but the "social is better" meme is now so unmoveable amongst management that these sorts of practical considerations (which would once have been the dominant factor in decision making) get tossed aside.

I don't know if Google will change, but unless Larry wakes up and realises Facebook isn't going to kill his business, I think it will continue down the current path for a long time yet.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by sirkneeland on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:40PM (#6755594)
Wasn't this "fear- driven strategy" of aggressive paranoia (I hate to use the word here because it has a strongly negative connotation when such paranoia may be entirely warranted) a hallmark of the aggressive and tech expansionist culture of... Microsoft?

This is the upshot and downside of companies with ambitions that are essentially limitless:

When you treat EVERYTHING as an opportunity, you inevitably come to see EVERYTHING as a potential threat.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by dredmorbius on Monday November 18, 2013 @09:49PM (#6758936)
I think your comment about "not coercive" is insightful.

Thanks. That's one of the biggest changes I've seen. Your comments are interesting (of course, no way to know if you are who you claim to be, though, similarly for myself).

Larry's fear of Facebook.

I've written multiple times on G+ why Google should be focused on Amazon, not FB. Social is ultimately ephemeral. The evaporative cooling effect always kicks in. Given G+'s lack of effective filtering, sooner there than elsewhere. I've posted far too often to Shimrit Ben-Yair (G+'s product manager) on aspects of this.

The other trend I see is self-hosting / distributed services becoming viable. See FreedomBox as an example. A few years off yet, but it'll be a game-changer.

That damn red alerting bell

One of the first things that lead me to segregate my G+ activities from "everything else I do on the Web". I've actually removed the bell via user-side CSS (repeatedly, thanks to repeated CSS class-name changes) from other Google properties. I ultimately found it was easier to 1) not use them when logged in (so: in another browser/session), or 2) use other services (DDG, OpenStreetMaps, FixYT.com / Vimeo, etc.).

if Google+ loses, Google itself will become entirely irrelevant a short time later.

He's wrong. However if he keeps cramming G+ down peoples' throats, he'll keep encouraging exploration of other servcies. Particularly among the more technically literate and thought leaders.

I don't know if Google will change, but unless Larry wakes up and realises Facebook isn't going to kill his business, I think it will continue down the current path for a long time yet.

Sad. In particular, even FB doesn't suffer disadvantage that it's sucking so much else of my information online (mail, video, search), though FB itself is pretty invasive (NB: I don't have a personal Facebook account).

As others have noted, the fear-driven strategy is highly reminiscent of Microsoft, and is among the factors which killed Microsoft's brand among end-users (the OEMs and business partners loved them so long as the money kept flowing).

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by silverlake on Monday November 18, 2013 @09:33AM (#6754424)
If we assume that Larry and his execs are fairly smart, then what is their rationale for pushing G+? I think they figured that G+ is just like FB, so no one would have a problem with it. All that social data can only improve Google's services. And G+ blunts any advantage that FB has. All good things. The downside is that people (particularly devs) hate when their existing services change. Also, G+ has never offered a compelling reason to switch, and few people are going to manage 2 identical social networking accounts. Google will have to build/buy something great, as they did with Maps & Mail, to attract users to G+. Otherwise, it's Buzz and Orkut all over again.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by rahoulb on Monday November 18, 2013 @09:37AM (#6754446)
Interesting, given that the original article makes the point about Steve Jobs' advice.

Apple is a company that famously suggests and pushes people into how it thinks things should be done.

From what you are saying, Larry seems to have heard that advice (which when I first read it I took to be about focus, not profit) and heard "push your users down a particular path".

Moving from a "free to do it your way" model to a "best if you do it our way" model is undoubtably going to cause a lot of grief to long-time Google users. In a similar vein that explains the upset about "moving" stuff from AOSP to Play Services.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by tonyplee on Monday November 18, 2013 @11:42AM (#6755155)
Remember "Don't be evil".

The growing up of google felt like story line of Starwar.

Judi night grew up and felt the power of the dark side. :-)

Also remind me of another line: If you're young and you're not a Democrat, you don't have a heart. If you're old and you're a Republican, you don't have a brain.

Google has "mature" now. :-)

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by jobot90 on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:53PM (#6757875)
Interesting. It seems that Google is switching from an "attract" to a "protect" strategy. Which is, IMO, short-sighted.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by narag on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:25PM (#6755475)
...unless Larry wakes up and realises Facebook isn't going to kill his business

Or is it? Actually I agree with you. But I also believed Microsoft was exaggerating his fears of Netscape. Now I don't know what to think.

Maybe it's better to err on the side of paranoia after all.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by dredmorbius on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @03:24AM (#6766917)
Given that Microsoft's primary threat right now is from SAAS / PAAS and browser-based, OS-independent tools, I'd say Microsoft's fear of Netscape was well-founded. Its error was in thinking that it could dispatch that threat by killing off the competitor. To borrow an overused metaphor, the problem wasn't Al Qaeda, but terrorism. It wasn't the specific competitor, but the technology and development model it represented.

And much in the same way: you can't really defeat a technology. As we now see with Microsoft, very slowly, responding to the threat by providing its own offerings, despite the considerable revenue threat this creates for the company. As with other fallen tech giants, it's turning increasingly to patent revenues and other forms of extractive revenue rather than productive activities.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by mcguire on Monday November 18, 2013 @01:11PM (#6755791)
"But I also believed Microsoft was exaggerating his fears of Netscape."

Microsoft is still in the same position as it was pre-Netscape. It still effectively owns the OS and office software markets. It just wasn't entirely able to take over a couple of new markets.

That failure was pretty bad: MS is no longer seen as a "hot new thing", or a producer of hot new things. But in terms of doing damage to Microsoft, nothing from outside MS has done anything, as far as I can see. (Antitrust lawsuits notwithstanding.)

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by narag on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @05:07AM (#6760210)
You got a point (I upvoted you). But Netscape is not in the same position as it was pre-Microsoft. We can't know what would have happened, had Netscape survived.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by ChuckMcM on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:15PM (#6755395)
Strangely, if Facebook decided to do a web search product, they could put a serious dent in the engine that powers Google. However to date it isn't something they are interested in.
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by sirkneeland on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:42PM (#6755614)
I would question whether it is a matter of their not being interested in it vs. Their being interested in it but not having a compelling search product... yet
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by bgruber on Monday November 18, 2013 @09:34AM (#6754430)
> Google around maybe five or six years ago was a wasteland of shoddy, broken, unintegrated products, many with half-assed, confusing interfaces.

But:

> GMail's interface pisses me off, the new Maps layout is infuriating, and search is broadly speaking totally broken for me in places.

But it's all well integrated, and there's focus, and isn't that what counts?

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by hindsightbias on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:16AM (#6752712)
> Google-hate of late

It's just gotten hip of late. The lack of faith institutions is accelerating, almost as if by design.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by kybernetikos on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:20AM (#6753621)
Please do not include google in statements about 'lack of faith in institutions'. When people bemoan the declining faith in institutions, they're generally talking about the legal system, the legislative system, journalists. Institutions that are supposed to represent disparate social groups with at least part of their mission to make the society and the world generally a better place.

Profit driven corporations are not that.

Less faith in corporations would probably have very few disbenefits. Less faith in the legal system leads to people taking 'justice' into their own hands. Less faith in the political system leads to people becoming disengaged, threatening the legitimacy of government.

“The profit-driven corporate person, in other words, acts just like a natural person with Antisocial Personality Disorder, commonly called a sociopath or psychopath. ”

http://www.ladybud.com/2013/08/19/corporate-persons-are-diag...

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by hindsightbias on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:23AM (#6802242)
Nope. This website is filled with people who bemoan their loss in faith the teh google. They've supplanted their hopes and dreams in government with corporations, and some are now disappointed.

> Less faith

Disappointed, even though they have been indoctrinated into an ideology that "Government is [always] the problem"

> The profit-driven corporate person, in other words...

The profit-driven person.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by na85 on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:33PM (#6752337)
>What's with the sudden outpouring of Google-hate of late?

It's because Google is now an established corporation and has run out of "startup cred." Now that they've become a stable, profitable, publicly-traded member of the corporate scene, they're the antithesis of the HipsterNews crowd who want to keep making webapps with no marketabilitiy over and over again.

The Bay Area startup crowd are the definition of hipsters. Once something becomes big and mainstream, they're obligated to hate it because hipsters define themselves as "anti-x" where x is { corporation | government | society | whatever }.

Their only identity is as "not employees of a Big Software Company" and as a result, lately the culture on HN has been consumed by a seemingly neverending series of mediocre posts about startups and the absolutely horrible culture that surrounds them.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by mhurron on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:43PM (#6752362)
> It's because Google is now an established corporation and has run out of "startup cred." Now that they've become a stable, profitable, publicly-traded member of the corporate scene, they're the antithesis of the HipsterNews crowd who want to keep making webapps with no marketabilitiy over and over again.

Yes it has absolutely nothing to do with their recent and current actions. Everyone is just a startup hipster here.

Meh, I was hating on G+ before it was cool. No G+, no Facebook, no MySpace. You ain't got nothing on me.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by na85 on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:49PM (#6752382)
>Everyone is just a startup hipster here.

I recognize that my comment contained hyperbole but you know what? That "4chan does HN" thread was spot-on in many places.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by mhurron on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:55PM (#6752415)
Oh it sure was, but that doesn't change the fact that Google has earned this backlash.

Apple was an established company way before Google was, HN doesn't hate it.

Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by na85 on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:57PM (#6752423)
That's because hipsters love Apple, because Apple is seen as "not-PCs" or "not-Microsoft"
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by philwelch on Monday November 18, 2013 @12:53AM (#6752842)
Are you trolling?
Re:Google's Decline Really Bugs Me by dredmorbius on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:47AM (#6753174)
If you've got to ask ...