Whether you believe it is loaded or not depends on your pre-existing beliefs. If you were brought up to believe in the American dream perhaps it seems controversial to expect to be paid just for having been born. But if you were brought up in a highly socialised society this would not sound controversial.
I've read quite a bit on basic income before and generally have the opinion that it might be a good idea so it does not sound negative to me to propose that people are paid to be alive. In that way I think it's a clever title as its meaning appears to change depending the reader's perspective.
Re:Switzerland’s Proposal to Pay People
by scrabble on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @11:20AM
(#6718634)
I found it funny that the title of the article was really negative, but if you read the article itself the end of the second page says that maybe it is also a good idea for the US.
Titles are written by editors not the author. The are intentionally linkbait.
The title isn't negative, though. Just radical.
Re:Switzerland’s Proposal to Pay People
by gnaritas on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @11:58AM
(#6718929)
No, that's a very negative title to a conservative; that's no accident.
To be fair, this is the same language used by the proponents of basic income, as noted in the article. That's probably what inspired the title.
>Charles Murray of the conservative American Enterprise Institute... suggested guaranteeing $10,000 a year to anyone meeting the following conditions: be American, be over 21, stay out of jail and — as he once quipped — “have a pulse.”
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2240002/Switzerland-...