Re:I have been banned from Wikipedia for the contents of thi...
by ben0x539 on Sunday November 10, 2013 @08:58AM
(#6706420)
This is a weird way to put it. The topic has been on the agenda for a long time, gender identity disorder wasn't just discovered yesterday, and there's broad consensus and best practices in the relevant parts of the medical community.
Invoking some "holistic psycho-physical" intuition to dismiss years of research and experience with transgender issues is somewhat presuming.
Re:I have been banned from Wikipedia for the contents of thi...
by enko on Sunday November 10, 2013 @09:10AM
(#6706455)
I'm not trying to dismiss anything, or claiming to be anything other than a layperson. I'm trying to say that, as that layperson, I find the language we use to be very counter-intuitive, confusing, and fraught with obvious potential for conflict.
And yes, I am sure in certain circles this issue has been discussed for years, but I would say Manning's case is the first time a lot of people have thought about these issues.
Re:I have been banned from Wikipedia for the contents of thi...
by sugerman on Sunday November 10, 2013 @09:16AM
(#6706474)
I would think they'd be more offended by you saying they have a disorder than people struggling over the correct pronoun.
Re:I have been banned from Wikipedia for the contents of thi...
by ceejayoz on Sunday November 10, 2013 @08:57AM
(#6706419)
You're mixing "woman" - gender - and "female" - biological sex - a lot here. The two are not the same.
Re:I have been banned from Wikipedia for the contents of thi...
by enko on Sunday November 10, 2013 @09:01AM
(#6706429)
The dictionary mixes them too, then.
woman |ˈwo͝omən|
noun ( pl. women |ˈwimin| )
an adult human female.
And so does the author of that post - I looked at the talk page and it says "female" all over the place. You're proving my point.If those two words did in fact have the distinct meanings you imply, that would solve some of the problem.
I have no problem whatsoever with "trans" people but do not think it is optimal for, eg, Ms Manning to be simply labelled a woman. She is clearly not, at least not 100%, female, not in the same holistic psycho-physical way that other females are. For example, I'd like to see her try to use a female changeroom and see if the other females go along quietly with that.
Of course Manning should have the right to her name of choice and to be treated as the person she identifies as. But asserting that one can change gender just by announcing it - even when it is a completely sincere statement - seems far too simplistic to me. I of course understand the argument that inventing some new gender designator could further marginalise an already vulnerable demographic, but by simply avoiding the question I think we've dug ourselves into a bit of a hole.
As another commenter said, names are important. It is important for Chelsea to be addressed as she wishes. But it's also important for our language to have a reasonable set of tools to unambiguously describe things. Simply declaring "she's a girl now, and if you disagree with that in the slightest you're a transphobic cis majority oppressor patriarchal bigot", as I see far too much on Twitter, is not the solution.
It's a complex question and I'm not sure what we can do to solve it. I am glad, however, that the topic is on the agenda - the fact we're even talking about it is surely a step forward.