News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by wpietri on Friday November 08, 2013 @07:43PM (#6700109)
Generalizing about groups can be problematic. However, not so when you're generalizing based on what the group has in common.

The whole PUA thing is about manipulating vulnerable people so you can have sex with them. It's definitionally assholish. Assuming that a given PUA is an asshole is like assuming an Englishman speaks English. It's not a perfect correlation, but it's certainly the way to bet.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by parasubvert on Friday November 08, 2013 @08:17PM (#6700230)
Or, perhaps the whole PUA thing is about offering a list of techniques of social interaction that some people intuitively aren't born with, and need actual coaching. Neil Strauss documents this pretty well in his "The Game" books about how he fell into pickup culture.

Such techniques of course can be abused by assholes against the vulnerable as well.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by ceol on Friday November 08, 2013 @09:18PM (#6700406)
Nobody's buying it, man. PUA techniques are for the socially awkward the same way blown glass pipes are for tobacco smokers. What people claim and what the vast majority use it for are two different things.

All you have to do is look at the OP's profile to find this picture.[0] That sure doesn't look like some poor bloke who has trouble talking to people.

[0]: (slightly NSFW) http://www.pualingo.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/herbal-ty...

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by wpietri on Friday November 08, 2013 @10:00PM (#6700486)
Yeah. A fine example is this article about how a well-known pick-up artist upset that a country with good social welfare programs makes it harder for him to manipulate women into letting him fuck them: http://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/cockblocked-by-redist...

Also, excellent analogy.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by patrickg_zill on Saturday November 09, 2013 @12:26AM (#6700767)
http://www.rooshv.com/katie-j-m-baker-purposefully-distorted...

She didn't accurately quote from his book and may have mis-represented key quotes that she pulls from it.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by ceol on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:27AM (#6700883)
> But the book never stated that the pussy flow was blocked in Denmark, just that there was low quality, masculine pussy.

He sure isn't helping his case. All of the random claims of "socialism" and "left-leaning" don't help, either.

In fact, none of his clarifications actually prove she misquoted him, and each time he quoted his book in that post, it fit exactly with the original review.

From his language (referring to women as "the pussy" instead of as, you know, actual people) to his extreme generalizations of women and cultures, it's apparent the original review was spot-on for both Roosh's book and PUA culture in general.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by tynan on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:57PM (#6702652)
I don't look like a "poor bloke who has trouble talking to people" because I learned pickup and learned how to talk to people. I was very fortunate to be in the right place at the right time and be taken under the wings of the best PUAs. As a result I went from being a VERY shy socially awkward guy to being generally comfortable around people. Pickup changed my life for the better-- one of the best things that happened to me.
Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by parasubvert on Sunday November 10, 2013 @06:53PM (#6709079)
This echoes my experience with myself and acquaintances who learned pickup (though I only read a couple books). My fiancé even respects and uses PUA techniques for gaining social power as a female executive in a male-dominated industry.

The point is that at its best this stuff is about learning to evolve how you handle yourself with others to have more success in social endeavors. Ie. most things that don't involve staring at a screen.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by Goladus on Saturday November 09, 2013 @10:10AM (#6701793)
What people claim and what the vast majority use it for are two different things.

True, but your implication has it backwards. Tynan is not part of the vast majority. He is an outlier, one degree of separation from Mystery(Erik von Markovik) and Neil Strauss.

The vast majority of people are unable or unwilling to be so ruthlessly selfish and sacrifice healthy, stable relationships on the altar of hedonistic sex-- even if they think that's all they want (and most will admit otherwise).

The dilemma is that guys who write about attraction and having sex with women tend to benefit a great deal by having a lot of experience with women. That's not very compatible with traditional monogamous relationships, so it will always be easy to attack them from this angle however irrelevant that angle may be.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by yaddayadda on Saturday November 09, 2013 @11:04AM (#6701978)
Yet the photo of Tynan on the original post look nothing like the image you link to.

http://cdn.sett.com/images/user/201311080003dc887f36b225a18e...

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by tynan on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:46PM (#6702609)
It is me, but it was taken probably around 2005, when I was 24. Funny how much things change over the years...
Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by nikatwork on Friday November 08, 2013 @11:11PM (#6700655)
I know some awkward nerdy guys who took up DJing partly so that people in clubs open to casual sex would find them interesting and choose them over others. Does this make them assholes?

PUA strikes me as a "sales and marketing" technique to advertise yourself as an interesting casual sex partner. There are some asshats who manipulate, but then there are also high-pressure salespeople who manipulate; that doesn't make all sales and marketing unethical.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by trentmb on Friday November 08, 2013 @11:51PM (#6700718)
> I know some awkward nerdy guys who took up DJing partly so that people in clubs open to casual sex would find them interesting and choose them over others. Does this make them assholes?

I dunno if I'd call them assholes, but I do feel sorry for them.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by nikatwork on Saturday November 09, 2013 @12:01AM (#6700738)
Why do you feel sorry for them?
Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by mindcrime on Friday November 08, 2013 @09:39PM (#6700443)
The whole PUA thing is about manipulating vulnerable people so you can have sex with them.

No it isn't.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by ceol on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:38AM (#6700909)
Yeah! It's about empowering socially awkward people who just have trouble holding conversations! That's why it's called "pick up artistry": because you're picking up conversations!

Wait...

---

I honestly wonder how far up your ass your head has to be to completely ignore just how saturated the PUA community is with terms designed to objectify, marginalize, belittle, and disparage specifically women, and just how many of the highest regarded figureheads of the community are throbbing dickholes whose only goal in life is to find a modicum of self worth by pandering to the most cliche stereotype of traditional, toxic masculinity.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by hacker789 on Saturday November 09, 2013 @02:06AM (#6700961)
> Yeah! It's about empowering socially awkward people who just have trouble holding conversations! That's why it's called "pick up artistry": because you're picking up conversations!

He didn't say the end goal is "picking up conversations". Mindcrime was almost certainly taking offense to the infantilizing attitudes expressed in the quote he included, not to its reference to sex.

For the most part, the end goal is sex, and sometimes it's long-term companionship. There's nothing wrong with either of those.

---

I honestly wonder how far up your _ss your head has to be to completely ignore just how saturated the feminist community is with terms designed to objectify, marginalize, belittle, and disparage specifically men, and just how many of the highest regarded figureheads of the community are throbbing c_nts whose only goal in life is to find a modicum of self worth by pandering to the most cliche stereotype of fragile, vulnerable femininity.

---

See? It's easy to disparage large groups!

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by ceol on Saturday November 09, 2013 @03:34PM (#6703065)
I love how you automatically assume I'm a feminist or have some connection to the feminist community, despite me never proclaiming that. Is this another PUA technique? To fall flat on your face in an argument?
Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by hacker789 on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:26AM (#6700881)
You're wrong.

Women aren't adults who can be held responsible for their own actions and decisions; they're vulnerable children who need to be protected at every turn.

If you (as a man) visit an Apple Store just to look around, and you walk out with a brand new laptop, you're a customer. You made a decision. Yes, Apple works very hard to maximize conversions, but you're an adult, and it's silly to shame and vilify Apple for "manipulating" a "vulnerable" man into buying their products.

However, if you (as a woman) choose to have sex with a man who reads tips about how to increase his chances of having sex, you're a vulnerable victim of manipulation. That mean, bad predator who took advantage of you needs to be shamed!

Western media is overflowing with tips for women to get what they want from men. And that's okay. :)

But if you're a man, don't you dare read tips about how to get what you want from women. That would be misogynist. You don't hate women, do you, mindcrime?

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by wpietri on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:34PM (#6702543)
We are all adults responsible for our decisions. We also are all adults, responsible for how we treat others, and how it shapes their decisions. Responsibility is not zero sum.

The common name for the system in which men and women manipulate one another is called "patriarchy". (When you look beyond men and women, it's called "kyriarchy".) It's bullshit on both sides.

There are two reason it's seen as worse for men, both historical. One is the men have had way more power and are still substantially advantaged. The more power you have, the more responsible you are for a fucked-up situation.

The other is that people with less power are forced to be manipulative to survive. E.g., 100-200 years ago, when professional women were very rare, women focused a lot marrying well, because they didn't have a lot of other options. So there's a bunch of cultural hangover from that.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by hacker789 on Saturday November 09, 2013 @05:54PM (#6703883)
This thread is not the place for a debate about whether life has historically been (or currently is) easier on men than on women.

So I'll simply say that it shows a remarkable lack of empathy and understanding for you to call those desperate men who resort to PUA tactics "powerful". Almost by definition, they are acting from a position of weakness.

I realize it's currently trendy to break the world down into large, tidy, digestible traits (maleness and femaleness in this case), labeling one as "privileged" and the other as "oppressed".

Life's way too complicated for that.

Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by wpietri on Sunday November 10, 2013 @12:51AM (#6705438)
The "let's not argue, so let me argue just a little" is bullshit.

As to your non-argument argument, I have plenty of empathy for the desperate. But I can still condemn them using what power they have to manipulate other desperate people.

Further: http://whatever.scalzi.com/2012/05/15/straight-white-male-th...

[deleted]
Re:Why Cruise Ships are My Favorite Remote Work Location by dragonwriter on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:38AM (#6700911)
> Many are quick to label casual sex as misogynistic, but this implies that women are inferior to men and can't be trusted to make their own decisions and must be protected from themselves.

A community dedicated to developing, sharing, and applying methods to manipulate women into sex being considered misogynistic is not the same as casual sex being considered misogynistic.