Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by impostervt on Friday November 08, 2013 @09:18PM
(#6700405)
Was just thinking of making something similar today, but with a twist - let users create, save, and share their own filters. You could then show the popular filters, new filters, etc.
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by danso on Friday November 08, 2013 @07:40PM
(#6700102)
Nice...good execution and I like that instead of forcing the user to create an account, you give them an optional account to use in the future, as well as the ready-to-send image.
I don't know if this is meant to be just a hobby project or a MVP...but if it's the latter, I wouldn't position it as "better at making beautiful photos via filters". It's not just because that's a subjective argument between Instagram/Flickr/etc, but because the appeal of Instagram, in particular, is that it is so seamlessly tied to people's most frequently-used photo device and one with a large user network. People like the filters, but it's the casualness and the addictiveness of acquiring "Likes" that is Instagram's main draw, and that's more of a UI/UX thing than aesthetic appeal.
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by rallison on Friday November 08, 2013 @10:47PM
(#6700609)
Very nice. I was just looking at CamanJS [0] for a project, and your project overlaps with Caman with regard to filters. However, the great thing about your version is how instantaneous the changes are. Caman is great too, but making any changes results in a 1/2 second to 2 second wait on my machine.
Anyway, very nice work.
Edit: One note: I find the jump in effect for vignetting from 0 to 1 rather large. Maybe start the vignetting much further out so that the jump isn't quite so big?
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by hnriot on Friday November 08, 2013 @10:57PM
(#6700635)
these are far better than the OP's link. There's a reason the OP's filters are fast, they are trivially simple transforms. Doing something more interesting takes a little time. half a second won't kill me!
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by rallison on Saturday November 09, 2013 @12:08AM
(#6700750)
Fair enough, but even the simple operations on Caman - adjusting brightness, for example - have a delay. And don't get me wrong, I think Caman is great, and is much more powerful.
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by QuasiAlon on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:15AM
(#6700854)
Very nice, love the simplicity.
One thing I would tweak though: when you punch in the numbers for brightness and vignette (instead of using up/down), the effect doesn't take place until you click somewhere on the page. Would be nice to see it auto update as you write the values.
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by justbaker on Saturday November 09, 2013 @09:22AM
(#6701690)
My biggest issue is no description of the website anywhere! While I personally can figure out the purpose and usage, I think that it may confuse others. Otherwise nice work.
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by twanlass on Friday November 08, 2013 @08:23PM
(#6700251)
The nicest / most surprising thing to me was the instant image preview. In less than a second I had 'uploaded' a huge image and was editing. Nice work.
Re:Show HN: Better photo filters for web
by hnriot on Friday November 08, 2013 @10:55PM
(#6700633)
I don't get why everyone is so positive! The filters are horrible and just very basic color transforms. most leave a sickly look to the photo due to greens and blues.
I don't know if this is meant to be just a hobby project or a MVP...but if it's the latter, I wouldn't position it as "better at making beautiful photos via filters". It's not just because that's a subjective argument between Instagram/Flickr/etc, but because the appeal of Instagram, in particular, is that it is so seamlessly tied to people's most frequently-used photo device and one with a large user network. People like the filters, but it's the casualness and the addictiveness of acquiring "Likes" that is Instagram's main draw, and that's more of a UI/UX thing than aesthetic appeal.
Anyway, very nice work.
Edit: One note: I find the jump in effect for vignetting from 0 to 1 rather large. Maybe start the vignetting much further out so that the jump isn't quite so big?
[0] http://camanjs.com/examples/
One thing I would tweak though: when you punch in the numbers for brightness and vignette (instead of using up/down), the effect doesn't take place until you click somewhere on the page. Would be nice to see it auto update as you write the values.