News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by ethnt on Thursday November 07, 2013 @02:19PM (#6691737)
And something that's actually profitable.
Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by jonknee on Thursday November 07, 2013 @02:26PM (#6691779)
Square isn't profitable... Even the linked article makes this clear:

> While the company is not yet profitable, Dorsey has done a number of things designed to generate profit within two years, including bringing on new board members.

New board members always means profits!

Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by cylinder on Thursday November 07, 2013 @03:13PM (#6692076)
Starting to think Dorsey doesn't have a clue about business and is just a good product guy. What a ridiculous comment.

Why shouldn't a payment processor be profitable?

Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by jonknee on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:17PM (#6692464)
That's not a terrible conclusion. Square loses money on lots of transactions (small ones--under ~$8 and they're losing money). Credit card processing involves a per-transaction fee which really adds up for small purchases and Square's pricing doesn't have a minimum or a per transaction fee.

Then there are things like Square Cash that make no business sense (there's no revenue, only expenses and risk). Great for consumers while it lasts though.

Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by biturd on Thursday November 07, 2013 @06:43PM (#6693349)
CC merchants are not supposed to ask a minimum CC charge. Call the merchant and complain, they have to take a one cent sale or a million dollar sale.
Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by jonknee on Thursday November 07, 2013 @07:34PM (#6693606)
That's not true anymore for under $10 transactions (see Dodd Frank), but the point was that since Square has no minimum fee they actually lose money on small transactions. Square is used a ton for these sort of small transactions which goes a ways to explain why they have never made a profit (but have billions in revenue).
Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by potatolicious on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:03PM (#6692379)
Because they're growing?

There are two types of profitability of concern here:

1 - Is the product itself profitable. In this case: does the cost of providing a payment transaction cost Square more money than they charge for said transaction. A company that fails #1 is a really long way from success.

2 - Is the company itself profitable. You can have #1 but not #2, if you're pouring the bulk of your income into expansion.

Square can very well be making money hand over fist, but still be in the red due to pouring all would-be profits into acquiring more market share and R&D into new markets (aka the Amazon model).

Naturally, this is a risky move - it presumes that the the core product is long-term sustainable (i.e. the new market share you're acquiring is just as profitable as the market share you already have), and that the new markets you're investing massively in are worth it.

All said and done, Square not turning a profit overall doesn't say much about the overall viability of their business model.

Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by pbreit on Thursday November 07, 2013 @03:43PM (#6692245)
There are a lot of ways to make a LOT of money on payment processing beyond the basic transaction fees. But you've gotta get big first. Square is playing this perfectly.
Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by capkutay on Thursday November 07, 2013 @07:20PM (#6693546)
Yeah remember that turning a profit means you pay taxes as a corporation. Growing companies with lots of revenues will, in many cases, take a loss since they are investing that money into their own growth instead of making some profit and throwing close to half that money to the government.
Re:Square talking to banks about possible 2014 IPO by throwmeaway2525 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @07:20PM (#6693548)
You've finally solved for the mysterious Step 2!

It was board members, all along (nobody believed me).