News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by michael_dorfman on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:13PM (#666516)
Who says modern scientists are dull? Compared to when?

Is it really necessary to knock down every straw man one can conceive of?

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:21PM (#666524)
Compared to Feynman or Erdős or Tesla ;-)
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by antiform on Sunday June 21, 2009 @01:48AM (#667161)
No way. There are tons of people in the sciences with very interesting lives, they just don't have people knocking down their door to write popular biographies like Feynman, Erdös, or Tesla.

I say that living mathematicians like John Nash Jr., Shing-tung Yau, and Alexander Grothendieck have much more interesting lives than the examples you mentioned.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by michael_dorfman on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:24PM (#666526)
Feynman and Erdős aren't modern? How about Hawking? I mean,"alive" would have to count for something in the "modern" department, right?
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by jamesbritt on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:42PM (#666601)
Nit picker.

:)

I was watching the original version of The Day the Earth Stood Still, and there was one scene that stood out as marking this film as truly from another time.

Klaatu is talking to the boy, asking him about who the famous scientists are. And the boy knows! And acts as if everyone in American knows!

I gather there are many interesting contemporary scientists, but they simply get no attention in modern culture.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:24PM (#666643)
I don't think it's a cultural thing - I just don't think modern scientists are as personally interesting (for the most part).

Most people know of, say, Hawking or Perelman because of their personal stories. But even their lives aren't as near as compelling as the greats of the last generation.

Not to mention the face that 50 years ago, the work being done was much more significant. I hate to say it, but no truly 'ground breaking' work has really been done in the last half century. There are still a lot of open questions - but we just haven't found the answer. We've just been refining our knowledge of the important work done before that.

(Note: I don't mean to say no new work has been done, just nothing major. Name something done in the last 50 years that could compare to the fundamental work done in Quantum Mechanics, Relativity, Genetics, Computation Theory, etc. before that.)

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by calambrac on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:59PM (#666684)
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Saturday June 20, 2009 @03:13PM (#666696)
Fine, you got me - that was 40 years ago, not 50 like I said ;-)
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by calambrac on Saturday June 20, 2009 @04:08PM (#666760)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Genome_Project (for the list of interesting contemporary scientists, I'll nominate Venter. That guy is a trip.)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_Grand_Challenge

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scanning_tunneling_microscope

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public-key_cryptography

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractals

All since 1970, is that recent enough? And, ya know, sometimes it does actually take a little time for major achievements to be recognized as such.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Sunday June 21, 2009 @06:47AM (#667312)
I don't know - Id on't consider those to be that significant. The Human Genome project was a fairly natural extension of the discovery of DNA 50+ years ago, the DARPA Grand Challenge is a pretty natural extension of Turing, Von Neumann, etc.'s works 50+ years ago.

I'm not saying the things you list weren't hugely important, I'm just saying that they weren't as fundamental as the entirely new fields that were developed earlier (relativity, quantum mechanics, theory of computation, etc).

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by calambrac on Sunday June 21, 2009 @12:27PM (#667474)
That the HGP isn't as significant as the discovery of DNA is pretty obvious - DNA ranks with fire and the atom as the most important discoveries in human history. But it (or, more precisely, the science and techniques developed to accomplish it) is easily as important as the other things you listed. The HGP is to the discovery of DNA as quantum mechanics is to the discovery of the atom.

And you're being overly reductive when you say the Grand Challenge is a "pretty natural extension of Turing, Von Neumann, etc.'s". I'm pretty sure the physicists that you've mentioned would take exception to the idea that their work didn't have a clear lineage of its own.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Sunday June 21, 2009 @02:01PM (#667574)
Of course no idea appears ex nihlio - but I think certain ideas are just so novel and groundbreaking that they mark a qualitative change in humanity (I would include, for example, newtonian physics, relativistic physics, or quantum mechanics.)

I just feel like their were are far fewer (if any) of those truly ground breaking discoveries now than there were in the early 20th century. This might just be perspective bias, but it seems like scientific progress was being made much more quickly from, say, 1850-1950 than any other time in human history.

We still have a lot of big open questions, but progress seems to have slowed down. Hopefully the LHC will change that ...

As for the Grand Challenge, I work in the AI field myself (I'm engaged in some work for DARPA right now, and I know several people who were on Grand Challenge teams), and we're still basically stuck in turing/von-neumann paradigms. In my opinion, most of what we've done in the last 50 years in AI is come up with better search heuristics. It makes AI/ML much more useful - but it's nothing really paradigm shifting.

I will of course grant this could all be in my head, since I haven't, and probably couldn't, define a metric that measures the 'significance' of theory (maybe something about marginal information-theoretic predictive power, but that's difficult to measure and still not quite right).

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by apu on Sunday June 21, 2009 @12:14AM (#667105)
As well as the fact that sometimes entire new fields open up in very short periods of time -- for example, physicists thought at the end of the 19th century that they were basically just tying up loose ends, when relativity and quantum mechanics burst on the scene (in a relatively short time span).
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by yummyfajitas on Saturday June 20, 2009 @03:34PM (#666726)
Modern financial engineering is only about 30 years old. That's easily comparable to the fundamental works of physics, biology and computing.

As for the next big thing? My guess is that the field of high dimensional analysis (encompassing machine learning, compressed sensing, etc) will be comparable in importance to any of the fields you've mentioned.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by aswanson on Saturday June 20, 2009 @06:58PM (#666928)
Modern financial engineering is only about 30 years old. That's easily comparable to the fundamental works of physics, biology and computing

What?!?

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by yummyfajitas on Saturday June 20, 2009 @09:37PM (#667026)
I take it you disagree, but could you explain why?
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by aswanson on Sunday June 21, 2009 @03:44PM (#667709)
As an experiment, compare the relative merits of statistical arbitrage, black-scholes, and the gaussian copula (of mortgage backed securities fame) to Newtonian and quantum mechanics, general relativity, the germ theory of disease, DNA research, and any number of seminal papers in computing from the time of Turing to now. It seems fairly obvious to me that financial engineering is not in the same league.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by yummyfajitas on Monday June 22, 2009 @11:08AM (#668859)
I guess I'm not sure what you mean by "in the same league".

Statistical arbitrage, BS, etc form the fundamental theory of finance. It's certainly as fundamental to finance as DNA is to biology.

In terms of real world impact, financial engineering is definitely greater than knowledge of DNA. So far genetics has gotten us very little in terms practical outcomes.

Maybe you are just making a judgment that finance is less valuable than other fields? If so, I can't really argue with that.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Monday June 22, 2009 @12:08PM (#668971)
Wow ... You seriously think knowledge of financial engineering has a greater impact than knowledge of DNA?

You need some perspective.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by yummyfajitas on Monday June 22, 2009 @01:56PM (#669152)
If you disagree, could you tell me the practical applications of genetics and how they affect the lives of most people?

As far as I'm aware, all genetic engineering has gotten us is GM crops and a some drugs which only affect a few marginal cases. Hopefully that will change in the future, but I prefaced my statement with "so far".

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:16PM (#666634)
With all due respect to Hawking - I don't think he's anywhere near as interesting as Feynman or Erdos.

Feynman traveled to Brazil to learn Bongo drums on whim, he worked in a Strip Club, mastered the art of the pickup, broke into TS safes at the Manhattan Project, was a well known painter under a pseudonym, etc.

Erdos was basically homeless, and would show up at mathematician's doors unannounced looking for a roof - and while under their roof, would collaborate on some of the most ground breaking work of the century. He was a heavy drug user, active libertarian, etc.

I'm sure Hawking can compete in terms of intellect or work (I have no idea - I'm not capable of judging), but he is nowhere near as interesting.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by calambrac on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:40PM (#666657)
He's been unable to feed himself since 1974, yet he's still managed to assert himself as a world-renowned physicist and pop culture icon. It takes a special kind of jackass to think that's somehow less interesting than working in a strip club (sorry, a "Strip Club").
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Eliezer on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:25PM (#666644)
Oh, come on! Hawking's supposed to go mountain climbing or something? Guy's got a legitimate excuse.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by smanek on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:51PM (#666673)
Hawking's story is extraordinary - but you can fill books with entertaining anecdotes Feynman's exploits (in fact, they have). Hawkings probably 'wins' in terms of sheer impressiveness of what he has accomplished and what he has overcome.

But I still stand by saying that Feynman was more entertaining.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Zancarius on Saturday June 20, 2009 @03:42PM (#666744)
> But I still stand by saying that Feynman was more entertaining.

I agree that Feynman is entertaining, and he's something of a legend.

I do feel that Hawking is not just fascinating in his own right but he's AMAZINGLY inspirational. Given the adversity he has faced for much of his life, the fact that he still pursues his love of science should be a lesson to all of us.

To call his story merely "extraordinary" is doing a grave disservice to such an incredible individual.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by calambrac on Saturday June 20, 2009 @04:11PM (#666765)
You didn't say 'entertaining' before, you said 'interesting'.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Alex3917 on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:33PM (#666536)
In the context of the article, I would consider modern to mean admitted into grad school later than 1985. It doesn't make sense to talk about people like Hawking because we're talking about the selection effects of school.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by michael_dorfman on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:49PM (#666548)
So, they don't really mean "modern", they mean "young". And they don't really measure a baseline of "dullness" for any preceding generation of young scientists. And of course it doesn't make sense to talk about Hawking, if he is a counter-example.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Alex3917 on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:25PM (#666528)
"Who says modern scientists are dull? Compared to when?"

Compare non-fiction books of the 70s to non-fiction books today. With the exception of a couple people like Ray Kurzweil, our books today aren't a tenth as creative or brilliant. I'd argue that in most fields today scientists are just refining models created between the 60s and early 80s. Linguistics, educational theory, psychology, and organization behavior are all good examples of this.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by michael_dorfman on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:51PM (#666553)
You sure about that? It sounds a lot like "Boy, this music these kids are listening to is just a lot of noise-- not nearly as good as the music when I was young...."
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by aswanson on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:52PM (#666554)
Most scientists don't publish books. They do research and publish papers.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Alex3917 on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:05PM (#666561)
"Most scientists don't publish books. They do research and publish papers."

But this is because they no longer get "credit" for writing books, which is exactly the point the article was making. Scientists used to write books all the time.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by yummyfajitas on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:41PM (#666599)
It has little to do with credit. Writing a book/survey paper can get you great recognition if you finish it and do a good job.

The reason scientists write papers is because science is fun, but writing is boring (compare: coding vs documentation). Research papers represent the bare minimum level of documentation you can get away with but still keep your job.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by aswanson on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:31PM (#666588)
I would venture that doing original research should be given more weight than writing books.

Books contained calcified knowledge that can be disseminated by someone familiar with the field; a non-scientist as it were. This is the point of publications of popular science.

Original research that leads to new insights into a field are more difficult to obtain, require a higher level of skill and ability and therefore should be more important to a scientific reputation.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Alex3917 on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:45PM (#666604)
Books used to contain original research and theories. (Think Stanley Milgram's book Obedience.) It's only in the last 30 years that science books tend to just be collections of other people's papers rewritten for the lay audience. Because modern academia rewards people for churning out large amounts of derivative work but not for spending time coming up with groundbreaking theories, pretty much the only time scientists write books is when they get 600k advances (like Gilbert).
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by njm on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:36PM (#666539)
This is generally the case across the physical and life sciences too. Even "revolutionary" fields like epigenetics and genomics are effectively refinements and extensions of the pioneering work done in molecular biology during the 1960s and 70s. The same goes for particle physics, where the framework for the standard model is decades old. It seems that scientific innovation occurs in punctuated equilibria.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Alex3917 on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:44PM (#666547)
There's no question things go in S-curves, but I really get the feeling that the kind of people who did great work in the 60s and 70s generally aren't allowed to go into academia today. I personally would probably get a PhD in another life, but there's no point because academia is generally designed to filter people like me out, so I would have to spend 2-4 years convincing the right people to go to bat for me and it's just not worth it.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by holygoat on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:35PM (#666590)
I actually abandoned a PhD (after 2+ years) in favor of industry. The modern academic world -- at least in CS -- seems largely to consist of producing as many papers as you can, putting forth unimportant results, so as to get more 'points' and another funded project and more students. (British universities really are assessed on published papers, with different weightings accorded to international conferences and journals. It's a game.)

To do anything interesting means reducing or delaying your paper output (which your supervisor will not appreciate), and to get the results published requires you to write so as to persuade people with no vested interest in publishing novel output to agree with you... but without being able to have a dialogue.

I recall one amusing paper review by three reviewers which was essentially

1. "the treatment of X is great, but I'd like to see more Y", 2. "too much Y, not enough X", 3. "both X and Y are fine, but I'd have been really interested in seeing Z instead", where Z was entirely unrelated.

How on earth could an author anticipate the preferences of those authors and get three recommendations? Well, picking a non-controversial subject would be a good start.

Multiply this anecdote up to the size of the academic and industrial systems, and it's no wonder that so many people decide that academia is not for them. These people tend to be lumped in with the people "not cut out for it", but I think a significant percentage simply realize that academia has a different value system, and don't want to participate. Some of those people go on to do interesting or revolutionary things in corporate research, or even in mainstream industry.

Would the world be better if they were in universities instead? Probably not... but we'd have our interesting scientists back.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by timr on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:51PM (#666671)
Academia does tend to have a different value system, but it's a mistake to suggest that the one used by industry is better. It's just different.

Yes, in academics, professors X,Y and Z will usually try to get you to introduce their pet subjects in review. You also later find out that getting a paper approved has a lot to do with who you know (as opposed to what you know), and that getting the choice talks, collaborations and grants has a lot more to do with schmoozing and networking than anyone likes to admit. It's a social problem.

But you know what? That's life. Humans are fundamentally just a bunch of howler monkeys, flinging poo at the cage walls and trying to steal the shiny rock (or the girl) from the alpha. Put more than a few people together in any activity, and you'll get competition, preening, back-biting and politics.

In academics, powerful professors demand that you brown-nose and compete for favor; in industry, powerful rich people do the same. In academics, you find that most days are spent managing mundane chaos, with real research advancements happening only a few times a year; in industry, most of your time is spent appeasing people, reacting to short-term crises, and coordinating with your co-workers. When you really think about how chaotic humans are in groups, it's amazing that forward momentum happens at all.

Point is, I don't think it's fair to imply that "interesting" scientists migrate to industry because of some fundamental difference in values. Personally, I made the migration because the monetary up-side is much better in industry. Otherwise, I think the bullshit-to-accomplishment ratio is roughly the same.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by dinkumthinkum on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:16PM (#666574)
What exactly do you mean? I hear a lot of people put this kind of conspiracy theory view of academia out but I never really get the details.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Alex3917 on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:35PM (#666591)
What I mean is that the best grad schools in the US are purposely designed to have an extreme bias toward selecting students with the best grades and the highest GRE scores. You can still get in without good grades and without taking the GRE if you've done very good research and have earned the trust of the right people, but it's very difficult. And even if you do get accepted, you'd probably face an uphill battle throughout your entire career.
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by jibiki on Saturday June 20, 2009 @04:53PM (#666819)
For real? People have always told me that recommendations are pretty much the only thing good grad schools look at. (For math, at least.)
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by apu on Sunday June 21, 2009 @12:20AM (#667107)
This is true at all the top CS programs as well. They look at:

1. Past research (including published papers) 2. Recommendation letters

GRE scores are a pre-filter (not set too high, I think, and certainly the CS subject GRE is ignored, even when it is required), grades matter only slightly, and the admission essays are basically a chance to disqualify yourself by saying something stupid.

Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by Alex3917 on Sunday June 21, 2009 @12:31AM (#667118)
I've heard this too, but do the admission statistics actually confirm it? I suspect it's more along the lines of, "we only care about your recommendations, as long as you have above a 3.7 GPA." I could be wrong...
Re:Why are modern scientists so dull? by pradocchia on Saturday June 20, 2009 @06:33PM (#666909)
Math is a holdout.