News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by VaedaStrike on Saturday November 02, 2013 @09:46PM (#6661780)
The self-assured certainty imbedded in the tone of this article belies the pride manifest in such a view that prefers the novel application of modern intellectual enlightenment to the time tested bulwark that is our iterative and flexible legal foundation.

The fact that it sees the pain and dysfunction as symptoms of a systemic/endemic flaws is telling of a mentality similar to seeing children as inconvenient drains on environmental integrity or child-birth as merely some destructive medical condition from which women should be spared any time such is possible.

This kind of pride and double guessing of the 'anti-fragile' system that is emergent from the US Constitution is the very thinking that's going to cause more problems for our nation than the forward thinking policies of the Greenspan era that gave us snapshots of prosperity through propping intellectual ideas RATHER than promoting true progress as it comes with all it's warts and growing pains.

You don't win the future by throwing what's survived into the trash bin on account that it's not pretty or efficient enough for your liking or your intellectual enlightenment.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by maratd on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:00PM (#6661832)
> The fact that it sees the pain and dysfunction as symptoms of a systemic/endemic flaws is telling

Indeed.

One of the greatest strengths of the US Constitution, one of the reasons it is the oldest constitution in use to date, is the fact that it stemies government.

That dysfunction is what has led to the extraordinary prosperity experienced by the United States.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by halostatue on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:26PM (#6661907)
That’s a nice axiomatic assumption made based on faulty observations.

Not only are the facts to support that assumption not in evidence, the facts that exist about the history of the U.S. government show that

(a) dysfunction is not the normal mode of operation of the U.S. government and that

(b) the extraordinary prosperity of the U.S. since about 1930 has been to increasing levels of federal government involvement and investment in both infrastructure projects (e.g., the interstate highway system, the Internet, advances in medicine and sanitation) and social projects (the social safety net, some basic medicare services, education investment as a whole, desegregation and civil rights in general).

The U.S. has not been this actively dysfunctional for at least eighty years, and more likely for about 160 years (and the secondary reasons for the dysfunction 160 years ago are not too dissimilar to the reasons for dysfunction now, as ways of life and economic growth are deeply threatened by modernization). I’m not sure that we've seen sustained partisanship for this long ever in the history of the U.S. (about 18 years since Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich’s clashes in ’95).

Further, it’s questionable how sustainable the “prosperity” in the U.S. is over the 18–20 years, as has been well documented. Most of the money has flowed away from the middle class (the proverbial rising tide) and toward an already wealthy upper-upper class.

That the U.S. and its constitution have survived several shorter periods of hyper-partisanship and a civil war suggest that it is, as a document, more resilient than the article suggests, but there has been a sea change in the U.S. where I no longer recognize the country of my birth and can foresee the day when I choose no longer to be a U.S. citizen because I no longer identify with what it has become.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by VaedaStrike on Sunday November 03, 2013 @12:33AM (#6662234)
RE your point a)

this gets into the semantics of the term dysfunction. I think if we did a point by point walk through of any given portion of the history of US government one could find a bounty of examples of dysfunction. It would simply be a matter of choosing what portions of history you wished to look closely at.

and RE your point b)

This is a far bigger set of assumptions and faulty observations. Firstly not all of those projects constitute a singular 'success' rather than simply the emergent of some system that produces a wide range of results. The funding is simply a component of that and the ultimate determining factor as to whether or not the net result of that funding was better than other alternatives that could have existed in it's absence is something that's not easy to quickly determine.

Reminds me of getting a large and extremely demanding client. Certainly one may be gaining far more money than they ever did prior to having said client, but if the demands and side effects of having the client are too high then even the masses of money one makes, when placed in context to the big picture and the actual desired ends, may not result in an optimal, or even a positive, end.

One needs but look at state welfare in Europe to see an example of this. The state takes care of people and one of the fall outs is that individual persons, beyond what they are obligated to give through taxation, help their fellow countrymen at far lower rates than they do in less socialized nations. There's always unseen costs.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by halostatue on Sunday November 03, 2013 @01:08AM (#6662309)
Are you seriously going to try to make either of these arguments?

a. Your original point suggested that continuous dysfunction is the reason that the U.S. is successful. Not only is this nonsensical, it is ahistorical. Yes, the U.S. has had periods of hyper-partisanship prior to the last fifteen years. The most serious of these resulted in a war. However, over most of the last 224 years, the U.S. has had more periods of cooperation and compromise than hyper-partisanship and dysfunction. Even during the 1930s (where there a plot to stage a coup d'état, defeated only because the plotters misjudged their preferred candidate) and the 1950s (e.g., McCarthy) the business of government moved forward and there were measurable improvements in the quality of life and infrastructure directly attributable to government intervention. (See also the TVA.)

b. Your assessment is flat-out incorrect on numerous levels. Again, it assumes facts that are not only not in evidence, but contrary to the facts that actually exist. This is a common problem with choosing to believe ideological stances rather than comparing them against facts.

Under no circumstances do I think that all government programs are successful; however, the U.S. saw greater real economic growth during times of higher government spending on infrastructure programs and social programs (as I indicated) than it has when these things fall to the best “interests” of the monied classes and so-called “Christian charity”.

I don’t know what your particular political stance is, but your characterization of the charitable nature of Europeans is misguided, at best—a lot of the higher “charitable” donation rates in the U.S. are because (1) the government funds aren’t there to assist those in need, (2) there are greater tax incentives to donate more. I put “charitable” in quotes because all donations to churches—for any reason whatsoever—are considered tax deductible in the U.S. Most of those donations are not used for local charitable assistance (e.g., soup kitchens, etc.) activities; they are used for church building maintenance, salaries, mission work, etc.

I suspect (because I don’t know where to find the actual numbers for this) that if you were to measure per-capita charitable assistance spending through charitable donations, it would be similar. I also don't happen to think that the success of a nation should be measured on how financially charitable its people are to those less fortunate members of society—I think it should be measured on how few of its people have what is now termed food insecurity. If that can be done with charitable donations, great—but as the U.S. amply demonstrates, it cannot and never could.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by sseveran on Sunday November 03, 2013 @12:54AM (#6662273)
You would be hard pressed to say that the prosperity is the result of government. We were also aided by a war that killed 80M people left most of the industrialized world in ruins. And civil right, seriously? The government was the greatest force operating against civil rights last century.

The notion that everything was civil in the past is also a fanciful notion. The country has often been deeply divided and I don't see any reason why it should remain so.

Also the concentration of wealth this time around unlike a century ago has been caused by two things, technology and improvements to productivity and periods of artificially low interest rates. I don't see what we can do about the former and with the nomination of Yellen I don't think there will be significant changes to monetary policy.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by halostatue on Sunday November 03, 2013 @01:28AM (#6662334)
Actually, I wouldn't be hard pressed to say that. If I had said that it was exclusively the result of government, then I'd be saying something even more nonsensical than what's been said by the folks who actually think that government dysfunction is a path to success.

1. The increased government spending on infrastructure and social structure reduces private spending on infrastructure and social structure, freeing up that capital to be spent on other projects, or even enabling projects that could not be considered previously.

While we are facing a number of problems related to deep dependency on petroleum now, the Eisenhower Interstate Highway system revolutionized cargo transit. In general, greater spending on the highway system from the federal level required that states and municipalities spend more keeping their connecting roads up to date—to the point of paving more roads that had previously not been paved, increasing commercial access to everyone in general.

I've made the point some time ago, but increased social spending allows businesses to exist that would not otherwise exist precisely because of that social spending. In economically depressed areas, there will be people employed because recipients of social spending have funds that they would not otherwise have available.

While it is true that at times government gets in the way of progress, it is not generally because of an activist government looking out for the welfare of all of its citizens, but rather because of a conservative (meaning trying to preserve the status quo, not a political stance per se) government protecting the interests of an elite class. Both sorts of government can exist at the same time in a single administration.

2. The federal government has been the greatest force operating in favour of civil rights for about 150 years, although with a spotty record. The most recent failures exist primarily because of recidivist views about the nature of civil rights, primarily embodied in the views of the Roberts court and current (2010–2013) Tea Party Republicans. State governments, on the other hand, have by and large been powerful forces acting against civil rights that have been forced to act differently because of federal government intervention. Any argument otherwise had best be backed fairly heavily by reputable evidence, because that's the history.

3. I would appreciate that you not argue against a straw-man. I never said that the past was always civil. I said that the divisions that have existed in the past have never lasted this long and been this deep; they have (once) been deeper to the point of war, but most of those divisions have (i) been fairly short, limited to one or two sessions of congress, and (ii) not impeded the rest of the operation of government in any meaningful way. Even McCarthyism didn't break government the way that recent events have. Bills were still passed, and the business of government moved forward at a better pace than you would imagine.

4. Check your history again. IIRC, the monetary crises of the 1890s and the 1920s–1930s were caused in no small part by improvements to productivity (rapid industrialization, etc.) and technology (trains, cars, etc.) and low interest rates, as well as extremely loose regulatory environments. Both can be fixed by taking taxation seriously and not pretending that it is an evil thing, as far too many modern politicians and internet libertarians do.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by sseveran on Sunday November 03, 2013 @01:30AM (#6662433)
1. There is no doubt that government spending stimulates things until it no longer does. I find the outrage over Walmart to be particularly funny since over time it has evolved to maximize its benefit from government spending. Walmart is one of the largest supports of food stamps and other welfare programs because in some states it captures half of all money the government hands out. I find it to be a gross distortion of the market that will only grow larger over time.

Highways similarly distorted the markets and we will be living with those effects for some time. One primary distortion was the destruction of passenger railroads. It may have been the right thing to do but for every tamper we get right more are gotten wrong.

2. I can't do anything but shake my head.

3. Pre Civil War politics frequently involved guns over the issue of slavery on both sides. Post civil war for decades also involved lots of guns.

4. All financial crises (monetary or otherwise) stem from overextending credit to people that should not have it. Its the same whether its tulips, railroads, stocks, internet companies or mortgages. Rises and crashes are the natural ebb and flow of the business cycle and should be embraced. Downturns are a way of correcting mistakes. I don't see how they can be fixed with taxation. The real issue is interest rates.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by jacques_chester on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:16PM (#6661876)
> That dysfunction is what has led to the extraordinary prosperity experienced by the United States.

I think this is a rather simplistic view of history. Supposing that American history unfolded along Australian lines (no revolution, eventual unification by vote, constitutional bicameral monarchy with fused executive), I expect that it would still have wound up as the richest and most powerful nation in history.

The USA straddles what is, quite simply, the best place on earth for agriculture and trade. No other country in the world has better internal navigation by river. No country has such a vast bowl of rich soil red reliably by rain from two massive mountain ranges draining into the interior. No other country in the world has so many ideal ports. There are more good ports on the American Atlantic coast than there are on the European Atlantic coast.

It is difficult to make and sustain an argument that, once British institutions took root in such fertile conditions, the USA was never destined to be very wealthy and successful.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by halostatue on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:32PM (#6661924)
As I said in a sibling comment to this, it's also an incorrect view of history.

That said, I'm not sure I agree with your assessment—if the U.S. had not had a revolution and had instead followed a Confederation model (e.g., the formation of Canada in 1867), I'm not sure that there would be a single nation in the land occupied by what is now the U.S., but more likely a few smaller nations. Other things could have also easily prevented the U.S.’s fate as the most powerful nation in the world, as for most of its existence, the U.S. was powerfully isolationist (at least outside of the North American continent) and inward-looking.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by jacques_chester on Sunday November 03, 2013 @08:07AM (#6663068)
Australia formed out of independent colonies out of simple expediency (eg, unified customs to improve trade). Americans have been a sufficiently practical people that similar considerations would, I think, eventually have brought them together.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by halostatue on Sunday November 03, 2013 @09:25AM (#6663269)
Fair enough; I'm looking at it more from the Canadian perspective with Québec thrown into the mix, which hasn't always been an enthusiastic partner with the rest of Canada. If the U.S. hadn't been a single nation, I personally believe that the regional differences between east and west would have resulted in different nations being formed longitudinally split roughly along the Mississippi river in what is now the U.S. and somewhere along that same longitude in Canada.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by incompatible on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:23PM (#6661898)
In what way is the US government stymied? I don't see much difference compared to other democratic systems. Just count the number of laws and regulations.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by npsimons on Sunday November 03, 2013 @11:25AM (#6663702)
The self-assured certainty imbedded in the tone of this article belies the pride manifest in such a view that prefers the novel application of modern intellectual enlightenment to the time tested bulwark that is our iterative and flexible legal foundation.

Not to mention the conceit that we are automatically smarter than those of the past merely because of progress. The framers were smart. More importantly, they worked hard. They studied history, thousands of years worth, all sorts of forms of governments, what worked, what didn't. To throw that all out and say, "hey, let's run the country like a startup mixed with IRV, because we're modern and know better!" just smacks of arrogance.

Sure, you can write a new constitution from scratch; first, do your homework and study all the other governments that have ever been. You've got all that modern technology at your disposal (which the founders didn't), so don't complain about the workload.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by jacques_chester on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:18PM (#6661884)
> the time tested bulwark that is our iterative and flexible legal foundation.

Other traditions are time tested too. I note that Australia didn't fall into a brutal civil war within 8 decades.

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by austinz on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:45PM (#6661967)
The Chinese dynastic system lasted for thousands of years, until it stopped working because it turned out to be a shitty system that couldn't cope with the demands placed upon it by a rapidly changing and industrializing world. So I don't even feel that 'time tested' is a particularly good criterion.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by VaedaStrike on Sunday November 03, 2013 @12:17AM (#6662206)
The Chinese dynastic system was never designed to be an iterative, democratic system that aimed at providing the pursuit of hapiness. Our system has lasted through changes equal in turbulence to that which we are going through now, just a different flavor of it. The Industrial Revolution as merely a single example.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by jacques_chester on Sunday November 03, 2013 @08:05AM (#6663062)
What? China has had thousands of years of rotating cycles of stability and ruinous wars.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by austinz on Sunday November 03, 2013 @06:58PM (#6665748)
There are philosophical and bureaucratic similarities among almost all of the major/dominant dynasties after Qin that disappeared after the Qing fell and probably won't come back ever again. But I could have chosen a better example.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by saraid216 on Sunday November 03, 2013 @02:11PM (#6664522)
Though, to be fair, a good chunk of those dynasties lasted a few hundred years. :P

So clearly we should have dynasties and a couple wars of succession to devastate the nation every 50-100 years. Something about the blood of patriots and tyrants. 20 years?

Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by VaedaStrike on Saturday November 02, 2013 @11:43PM (#6662117)
Australia is not on the brightest of trajectories for stability at present. Who needs a brutal civil war to set you back when you just stop replacing your population? At a bit under 1.8 total fertility rate they're doing to their country, over the next generation, the equivalent of loosing 15% of their population, far more than we've lost in any single war. If the numbers on the civil war are correct, with 2% of the US population lost on the front lines, the present demographic condition of Australia will have more than seven times the impact on their society as the US Civil War had on ours in terms of lives not realized.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by jacques_chester on Sunday November 03, 2013 @08:00AM (#6663050)
Australia's population is growing at 1.6% pa.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It by halostatue on Sunday November 03, 2013 @03:26PM (#6664861)
Australia is also, like Canada and the U.S. itself, an immigrant nation, making the importance of population replacement rates less important (the U.S. is around 1.9 right now, but second-generation and later fertility rates are below the replacement rate; immigrant and first-generation fertility rates are above the replacement rate, averaging out but resulting in the demographic shift that is disturbing certain folks among red states right now).