Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by austinz on Saturday November 02, 2013 @10:45PM
(#6661967)
The Chinese dynastic system lasted for thousands of years, until it stopped working because it turned out to be a shitty system that couldn't cope with the demands placed upon it by a rapidly changing and industrializing world. So I don't even feel that 'time tested' is a particularly good criterion.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by VaedaStrike on Sunday November 03, 2013 @12:17AM
(#6662206)
The Chinese dynastic system was never designed to be an iterative, democratic system that aimed at providing the pursuit of hapiness. Our system has lasted through changes equal in turbulence to that which we are going through now, just a different flavor of it. The Industrial Revolution as merely a single example.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by jacques_chester on Sunday November 03, 2013 @08:05AM
(#6663062)
What? China has had thousands of years of rotating cycles of stability and ruinous wars.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by austinz on Sunday November 03, 2013 @06:58PM
(#6665748)
There are philosophical and bureaucratic similarities among almost all of the major/dominant dynasties after Qin that disappeared after the Qing fell and probably won't come back ever again. But I could have chosen a better example.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by saraid216 on Sunday November 03, 2013 @02:11PM
(#6664522)
Though, to be fair, a good chunk of those dynasties lasted a few hundred years. :P
So clearly we should have dynasties and a couple wars of succession to devastate the nation every 50-100 years. Something about the blood of patriots and tyrants. 20 years?
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by VaedaStrike on Saturday November 02, 2013 @11:43PM
(#6662117)
Australia is not on the brightest of trajectories for stability at present. Who needs a brutal civil war to set you back when you just stop replacing your population? At a bit under 1.8 total fertility rate they're doing to their country, over the next generation, the equivalent of loosing 15% of their population, far more than we've lost in any single war. If the numbers on the civil war are correct, with 2% of the US population lost on the front lines, the present demographic condition of Australia will have more than seven times the impact on their society as the US Civil War had on ours in terms of lives not realized.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by jacques_chester on Sunday November 03, 2013 @08:00AM
(#6663050)
Australia's population is growing at 1.6% pa.
Re:The U.S. Needs a Constitution – Here's How to Write It
by halostatue on Sunday November 03, 2013 @03:26PM
(#6664861)
Australia is also, like Canada and the U.S. itself, an immigrant nation, making the importance of population replacement rates less important (the U.S. is around 1.9 right now, but second-generation and later fertility rates are below the replacement rate; immigrant and first-generation fertility rates are above the replacement rate, averaging out but resulting in the demographic shift that is disturbing certain folks among red states right now).
Other traditions are time tested too. I note that Australia didn't fall into a brutal civil war within 8 decades.