News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by flippyhead on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:51PM (#6649753)
From what are you ducking and running?
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by potatolicious on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:06PM (#6649891)
Crackheads, the homeless, and a particularly loud (and occasionally violent) group of youth that are constantly at the corner of 3rd and Pike. Persistent (though not apocalyptic levels of) gun crime.

Downtown Seattle can be a bit rough. I wouldn't lay it squarely at the feet of the mayor though - a lot of it traces back to city planning gone disastrously wrong.

Just a few off the top of my head:

- the southern end of downtown is strictly commercial. Little to no mixed zoning here, meaning that as soon as 5pm rolls by the entire area is a ghost town. If you're there past 6-7pm you will see that the homeless and addicts move in to fill the void. There is no residential or leisure traffic to balance this out. This is US-style single-purpose urban zoning run amok. Vast portions of the urban core is entirely idle after work hours.

- downtown Seattle isn't a cultural or entertainment core, unlike the downtowns of most cities. The actual food scene, nightlife scene, music scene, etc, are in surrounding neighborhoods like Capitol Hill, Ballard, Fremont, etc. This contributes to low foot traffic after work hours, which contributes to higher crime and simultaneously a magnified perception of danger.

- poor urban planning decisions meant an explosion in large-scale development without sufficient requirement for retail frontage. Lots of buildings that take up the entire block with little to no ground-floor retail, making it a pedestrian dead zone and contributing to the feeling of walking down a shady alley no matter where you are. See: much of Belltown, where the declared intent was to produce a walkable neighborhood full of restaurants and nightlife - except few residential buildings wanted to play host to them. This has resulted in little pockets of activity with vast stretches of nothingness in between them.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by HelloMcFly on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:39PM (#6650157)
What city do you live in? Have you lived anywhere else?

I work in downtown Seattle and my work takes me a-walking across huge portions of it, and my bus stop is right by 3rd and Pike. I've certainly never felt unsafe, and only occasionally have I been accosted by the homeless (or possibly crackheads) looking for money. There are some problem spots, but nothing terribly aggressive, certainly not by standards I've come to expect from my time in other major cities.

It's much, MUCH better than what I saw/experienced while living in Atlanta, Chicago, San Francisco or Kansas City. Seattle may have some issues with theft, but violent crime isn't out of control. Play around with this [1] Wikipedia lin or this [2] comparison tool:

Seattle is 30th in total violent crime amongst cities with a population above 250,000. Not great, but not bad. For Murder Seattle is 67 out of 75. That's, comparatively, very good.

As for your specific points, I agree with them without regarding them as contributing as much negative impact as you state. You make it sound like Seattle is some pedestrian ghost town where you're taking your life into your own hands by taking a wrong turn. Like any city, some neighborhoods are better than others for leisure activities, and there are some worth avoiding into the night. But it's no worse than most other cities, and often considerably better.

--

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_cities_by_crime_r...

[2]http://www.areaconnect.com/crime/compare.htm?c1=Seattle&s1=W...

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by potatolicious on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:25PM (#6650442)
I live in NYC currently. Besides living in Seattle (2 yrs) I've also lived in San Francisco, Toronto, Vancouver, Ottawa, Waterloo, and London (Ontario, not the cool one).

I've seen a lot worse than what happens in downtown Seattle, and yeah, SF has it a lot worse. A lot worse.

I also have an intense dislike for the urban one-upsmanship that seems uniquely American in my experience. As if having seen/lived through worse crime is a badge of honor, and that people living/working in elevated crime areas (just less elevated than some other places) should just suck it up. SF is the absolute worst in this regard (far worse than Seattle), where any criticism about the state of poverty and crime in the city elicits a "hurrr go back to the midwest then hurrrr".

A spade is a spade, even if there are bigger spades out there. The fact that Seattle's urban planning cockups are less severe than San Francisco's should come only as a very mild, very cold comfort.

Part of Seattle's problem - one that I touched on but didn't expand on earlier - is that it feels less safe than it actually is. When it comes to quality of life though, perception of safety is equally important as actual safety. The vast stretches of nothingness at night presents a huge perception problem that I don't think can be conquered by simply telling people "yeah, that nearly empty street with no businesses and a lot aggressive panhandlers making catcalls at you isn't so bad, statistically your odds are good!".

Seattle isn't that dangerous of a city - I made that clear earlier. The downtown is mildly sketchy, the homelessness problem is acute but not as bad as some other places, but the complete void that fills downtown after work is a huge problem that prevents any major progress on this front.

By the way, Seattle is a pedestrian ghost town. Even Pioneer Square on a busy night is ghostly compared to every other urban core in North America I've ever been to. Downtown Seattle (qualified as Olive/Pine all the way down to Yesler or Jackson, and west of I-5) is completely f'ing deserted at night.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by HelloMcFly on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:43PM (#6650546)
> I also have an intense dislike for the urban one-upsmanship that seems uniquely American in my experience.

That's fair, but you're talking about normative comparisons, and I'm talking about relative ones. I think relative comparisons are more useful in a country that, all things considered, has pretty safe cities. I don't mean to dismiss all of Seattle's problems, but it helps give perspective.

> Part of Seattle's problem - one that I touched on but didn't expand on earlier - is that it feels less safe than it actually is.

That's fair.

> Seattle is a pedestrian ghost town.

No, it's not. Downtown is, yes, but Seattle as a whole has many options for a pedestrian's nightlife. Capitol Hill is one of them, and it's an easy walk from downtown even.

I think that goes back to my last point. I just don't perceive the negatives of Seattle's "urban planning cockups" in nearly as dramatic of fashion.

I'm not from here, I'm not a homer. I just find much fewer problems here than I have anywhere else. I know you don't like relative comparisons, but when choosing a place to live relative comparisons are my most helpful tool.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by potatolicious on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:08PM (#6650711)
IMO relative comparisons are misplaced here. I'm talking about Seattle's problems, as they pertain to Seattle residents - that SF or Atlanta has it worse only is a factoid mainly tossed around to try and minimize the problem or suggest inaction. I am not suggesting that Seattle, on the whole is a bad place to live - please don't draw the wrong conclusion. I am suggesting that the city has deep planning problems and despite its relative peace compared to the rest of the country, needs to aggressively address them.

Seattle's downtown core is horribly planned, in a pattern that is sadly typical of American urban cores post white-flight. Its urban planning awfulness is hardly unique to itself, and like every other city that employed the disastrously myopic single-use zoning strategy, it needs to change.

Or at least, not continue - but before I left Seattle I saw the exact same pattern in Belltown, South Lake Union, and Capitol Hill. The failure to learn from the failure of downtown Seattle IMO threatens to turn perfectly fine neighborhoods into empty, unfriendly, unpleasant shells. Every point I mentioned - large full-block developments, insufficient requirements for retail frontage, and little planning around pedestrian dead zones - is demonstrated in new developments stretching out of downtown.

Note that I am not anti-gentrification or anti-development. I support building upwards and increased density. I support urban renewal. But the developmental policy and requirements that have been the city's norm for decades supports buildings that serve to enlarge the "dead zone". The city - and its voter base - has evidently not learned its lesson, or hasn't ever been to a long-term successful urban neighborhood. Now is not the time to compare yourself to crime hotspots like SF and Detroit and feel good about yourself. There is a problem, and it needs fixing, even if it isn't the same scale of a problem like San Francisco's gigantic urban fuckup.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by HelloMcFly on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:44PM (#6651113)
Well I appreciate your perspective, and will think about as I move about the city and decide where I'm going to five years from now. I do very much disagree on the value of relative comparisons though.

Ultimately, I just don't see nearly the extent of "urban fuckup" as you do even in normative terms, which is perhaps why the voters you admonish haven't responded as you think they should. I won't forget your comments though, and perhaps a in a year's time I'll be singing a different tune.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by nostromo on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:25PM (#6650063)
Compared to SF, Seattle's homeless issues are... quaint.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by jlgreco on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:31PM (#6650096)
Right.. and compared to Detroit, Seattle's crime issues are quaint. Saying that SF has a worse issue with homeless is damning with faint praise.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by saosebastiao on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:31PM (#6650095)
None of this has anything to do with McGinn. These policies started almost 5 decades ago.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by sleepybrett on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:59PM (#6650291)
The 3rd and Pine issue has existed in one form or another, on that very spot for at least 15 years ( I used to work at 3rd and Pine back in the day ). Blaming the sitting mayor for that street corner is laughable.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by CamperBob2 on Friday November 01, 2013 @03:14PM (#6655647)
The difference is, the rest of downtown now looks like 3rd and Pine used to.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by kevin_rubyhouse on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:19PM (#6650013)
I live in Redmond/Bellevue and this is very interesting. Do you know anywhere that I can read more about this?
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by aaronbrethorst on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:11PM (#6650727)
Justin Carder from CHS talks periodically about 3rd and Pine even though it's off his 'beat.' That street corner is a mess but it's been a mess for quite a while and it's obvious that stepped-up police presence alone won't address the problems there, or they'd already be fixed.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by jspaur on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:54PM (#6649785)
I'm assuming he means the Pike/Pine alley and Pioneer square, sadly famous for aggressive panhandling, unruly 'youth', and shootings. I live in and work in downtown (haven't driven in months) and it's def. getting a little more 'rough' by the month. Especially Westlake area.

(http://seattletimes.com/html/localnews/2021614421_downtowncr...)

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by dubfan on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:01PM (#6649854)
Most of those complaints are from people who haven't lived in Seattle long enough to know those areas have been problem spots for at least 20 years. My father worked downtown in the early/mid-80s and says it was exactly the same then, if not a little bit worse. Not that that excuses the problem. Also, the Seattle PD is absolutely petrified of doing anything that might incur the wrath of the Department of Justice. Blaming McGinn for the street people is like blaming him for I-5 traffic: it's been a problem before, and it will continue to be a problem until something very drastic happens (and in the case of street people, it will take something unpalatable to Seattle's NIMBY/sensitive electorate)
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by jspaur on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:10PM (#6649926)
Crime is down nationally since the 80s. So for things to be the same, or only a little better says a lot.

I completely agree that SPD is petrified. I've live/worked in downtown Seattle for a while - and while I think some of the 'scaryness' is overblown, it's hard not to see a change in the trend over the past few years.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by CamperBob2 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:41PM (#6650171)
I don't know that I'd call it "petrified" -- I believe the common term is "de-policing." It's a passive-aggressive way for SPD to deal with leadership that they don't respect.

SPD has an incredibly strong union, which is where the real problem lies IMHO. A bad cop almost literally has to murder somebody before they can fire him. DOJ took note of the resulting abuses, but of course they aren't interested in going toe-to-toe with the union, and neither is the mayor.

It's a complex problem but it stems from a fairly ordinary failure of leadership, and that particular buck stops in the mayor's office.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by era86 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:05PM (#6649883)
Can confirm this. Fiancee works in Pioneer Square and I worry every time she has to work late...

And Westlake is looking a lot more like Portland every year (as far as homeless youth go).

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by era86 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:17PM (#6650001)
I apologize, this is an assumption I'm making. I guess I meant the youth that hang out all over Westlake, especially later at night, resemble the homeless youth around Portland.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by wehadfun on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:14PM (#6649974)
Homeless youth? Are they homeless or just kids hanging out?
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by jspaur on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:19PM (#6650016)
Considering a lot of them are there during school hours and you'll see the same ones there sleeping with tarps at night - I think its safe to say homeless. Probably better to say 'young adults' though - Seattle YouthCare (http://www.youthcare.org/) does a great job with the younger groups.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by gisenberg on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:12PM (#6649949)
I used to work at the intersection of 2nd and Pine, where a stabbing took place right outside of work. Most of the violence in the area being gang-related isn't exactly the best reassurance of your safety.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by vkou on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:08PM (#6649910)
If you want to find a scapegoat for panhandling, I'd first turn to the recession... And the anemic social/medical/mental safety net in this country.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by jlgreco on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:24PM (#6650047)
> "If you want to find a scapegoat for panhandling, I'd first turn to the recession..."

How many of those homeless people are on the streets because they lost their factory jobs and the bank kicked them out of their McMansion? I am guessing very few.

The recession didn't make these people heroin addicts or mentally ill. The homeless people that make people concerned about walking around downtown Seattle during the evening aren't the "couchsurfing until I can find a new job" kind of homeless people.

Pointing at the state of healthcare, mental or otherwise, hits the nail on the head. That is a problem larger than Seattle though.

Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by jspaur on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:12PM (#6649952)
Not looking for a scapegoat, only a solution. And I lived here before the recession/GFC. I'd completely agree that the "social/medical/mental safety net in this country" is a major problem.
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by BlackDeath3 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:00PM (#6649845)
I'm going to guess "rain".
Re:Comcast is donating to defeat mayor who is bringing gigab... by augbot on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:51PM (#6649762)
hipsters?