News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by briandear on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:06PM (#6644121)
We can blame the programmers, but who is ultimately responsible. The Whitehouse is the executive branch; they are paid to execute and ultimately this is entirely their responsibility. They are the project managers of this entire mess. Now imagine those same people deciding your medical treatment. It's just sheer incompetence disguised as politics. Of course a more subversive view would suggest that this was engineered in order to pave the way for single payer. The Soviets built better cars than the US government builds websites.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by llamataboot on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:16PM (#6644183)
Last I checked, the Affordable Care Act really didn't involve anyone at the Executive Branch deciding on what medical treatment I could get. Downvoted for fearmongering and paranoid speculation. (purposely botched implementation of a large software project to make single payer easier? Because the Tea Party shutting down the US government to try to block this healthcare bill makes it likely we will see single payer pass?)
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Shivetya on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:52PM (#6644356)
Actually if the Independent Payment Advisory Board fails to develop a proposal should costs exceed certain thresholds then the Secretary of Health and Human services must submit a proposal themselves which they must implement.

Since all appointees to this committee must be agreed upon by the Executive Branch as well as both minority and majority leaders from each party (hence 12 from Congress with the Presidents approval/recommendation) and 3 from the President, yes the Executive branch could very well determine what health options are available too you.

The real issues before us now are.

1) why can the Secretary of Health and Human Services even refuse to divulge enrollment numbers? 2) why is the same not keeping the President fully aware or made aware of the problems the site faced before launch and after (conspiracy advocated claim the President knew) 3) By regulating what must be covered and not covered they are deciding what you can have and have not. Remember, there are a lot of gray areas in the law which the Secretary has shown more than enough interest in creating actual rules.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by generj on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @08:07PM (#6644438)
Of course, the nice part is that since they do have analytics (as terribly implemented as it appears to have been), we can force enrollment number disclosure by filing a FOIA request for the web analytics data.

Which, incidentally, I did today before this story broke.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by cma on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @08:26PM (#6644523)
You can still by supplemental insurance, so they aren't regulating what you can have, they are regulating the minimum floor.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by RickHull on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:42PM (#6644911)
> they aren't regulating what you can have, they are regulating the minimum floor.

This is utter nonsense on its face. If I have (or want) something under the minimum floor, they have regulated that away from me. They have regulated what I can have.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by VladRussian2 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:02PM (#6644977)
They also regulated away spoiled beef in stores, non smoke detectors equipped bedrooms and poisoned tap water. You can't have it. Minimum floor.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:54PM (#6645134)
Spoiled beef is quite a different thing from requiring a 60 year old man to buy maternity coverage.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:55AM (#6645324)
You mean spreading the cost of maternity coverage across all policyholders. Perhaps you're not aware of how insurance works, spreading risk and all that jazz.

Have healthcare system where costs are externalized? People complain. Have healthcare system where costs are internalized and properly accounted for? People complain.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Turing_Machine on Thursday October 31, 2013 @01:19AM (#6645392)
1) You don't get to tell me what I "mean". 2) I'm quite aware of how insurance works. Please do share with us the probability of a 60 year old man becoming pregnant, then explain why that "risk" needs to be "spread".
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by ncarroll on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:16AM (#6646144)
I wonder what the probability of a 60 year old man getting his lovely partner pregnant might be? That looks like a reason for spreading risk to me.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Turing_Machine on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:21AM (#6646154)
Given that the law also requires the lovely partner to have her own coverage, I think your "reason" is dubious at best.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Turing_Machine on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:54AM (#6646264)
Also note that the law requires 60 year old women to buy maternity coverage. Is their lovely partner going to make them pregnant?

Given that the Guinness record for the oldest natural conception is 59, I think not (there are a few cases of older women giving birth, but those all involved in vitro fertilization or the like).

What other astoundingly unlikely events do you guys think people should be required to insure against? Meteor impact? Virgin birth? All the molecules of air rushing to one side of the room and suffocating you?

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by VladRussian2 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @02:00AM (#6645491)
well, i truly doubt that the law mandates for male coverage to include maternity or female coverage - prostate cancer. The law just mandates the same insurance price for males and females.

It is pretty much the same as me paying [through taxes] for the FDA beef inspectors even though i don't eat beef. Just a socialization of the cost of basic government services (healthcare is among them, it is just Republicans are slower as usual to recognize the facts of reality, and thus "socialization" of the cost happens inside an insurance pool instead of society-wide as it would be in the case of single-payer )

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Turing_Machine on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:24AM (#6645736)
"well, i truly doubt that the law mandates for male coverage to include maternity or female coverage - prostate cancer."

You're wrong. The law says what the policy has to cover. Whether the policy holder is male or female doesn't enter into it.

"It is pretty much the same as me paying [through taxes] for the FDA beef inspectors"

Really? Since when is the FDA (actually, USDA in this case) a private, for-profit operation?

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by VladRussian2 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @02:34PM (#6648794)
>Really? Since when is the FDA (actually, USDA in this case) a private, for-profit operation?

i already addressed that - the Republicans forced for it to be done through private for-profit operations instead of a government agency like FDA/USDA/etc...

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by mrschwabe on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:39PM (#6645090)
Some municipalities mandate the addition of sodium fluoride in their public water systems. Sodium fluoride is a poison, so it's not necessarily accurate to claim they have 'regulated away' poisoned tap water.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Aloisius on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:12AM (#6645192)
No one drinking publicly fluoridated tap water in the US is coming even close to a toxic dose. You might as well call all caffeinated beverages toxic given the toxic dose of caffeine is 1/30th that of sodium fluoride.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by aric on Thursday October 31, 2013 @03:40AM (#6645662)
The difference is that said municipalities mandate that this toxic substance be added to people's water. With soda, people have more direct awareness and choice. With communal water, many people remain trusting and assuming. Meanwhile, there is no hard, double-blind science backing any clear benefits of fluoridation; yet the negatives keep growing. The EPA lowers their "recommended maximum" continually throughout the years, as pressure for sanity builds. Sane countries banned fluoridation long ago. Furthermore, the more it infects the food chain, the more "a little bit" adds up. It doesn't magically stay contained in tap water alone. Sure, it won't matter to most people, even not on principle alone. It will matter to some people, though, in compounding their chronic health problems. And that matters to me.

Then there is ethics.

Ethics and choice matter. Even if there were startling net benefits to this very toxic substance, using or ingesting it should be exclusively on an individual basis: personal choice, OTC, or per a physician. Advocating for needlessly and forcefully "medicating" (read: it's not medicine) other people through their communal water supply is, in no uncertain terms, blatantly unethical. It seems to stem from either psychopathy, greed, or sheer ignorance. It's on the same order as an industry and some physicians promoting nicotine cigarettes for health, once upon a time, and other such barbarities of an era.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Aloisius on Thursday October 31, 2013 @03:59PM (#6649325)
The difference is that said municipalities mandate that this toxic substance be added to people's water.

That horribly toxic chemical chlorine is added to water too. It is significantly more toxic than sodium fluoride. It also happens to be responsible for the greatest improvement in public health in the 20th century.

Sane countries banned fluoridation long ago.

Most countries who don't fluorinate water didn't ban it. They simply never implemented it or stopped implementing it because it is quite expensive and technically difficult to do well. Instead many simply add fluoride to their table salt (like France, Germany, Switzerland) or heavily pushed topical fluoride applications. The countries that have neither (like say Japan), tend to have significantly worse dental health than the US.

Meanwhile, there is no hard, double-blind science backing any clear benefits of fluoridation

You must be kidding. We have long-term longitudinal studies that clearly show the benefits and safety. Every decade, someone puts out a review paper[1] of the studies and comes to the same conclusion, fluoridation at low levels is good. We have scientific consensus that it is beneficial.

1. http://www.nature.com/ebd/journal/v9/n2/full/6400578a.html

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by aric on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:33PM (#6650831)
Chlorine has a clear justifiable use and is easy to remove. Hence, filtration is very popular and recommended to remove chlorine and other contaminants. Water treatment serves to bring a base level of safety. That which does not kill one quickly is not equivalent to that with which one should be satisfied.

Fluoridation, alternatively, is not easy to remove. Fortunately, I can afford distillation and reverse osmosis. Many other people can't. I'm not sure why you're so eager to medicate the water supply when more studies, decade after decade, present more negatives. Positive fluoride studies are notorious for conflating correlation with causation, especially in light of the more direct causation of cultural advances in education for merely brushing teeth as well as access to dental care. There is a lack of evidence showing significant variance in dental caries between fluoridated and non-fluoridated municipalities. That should alarm you. Fluoride accumulates. For whatever reason, you don't seem interested in its negatives.

Again...

Even if there are light or even startling benefits, it does not make valid the ethics of mass medication. You may feel strongly about wanting everyone to have fluoride. I suggest voicing your pro-fluoridation stance in a more positive way rather than advocating it be done through a water supply where it's very hard to remove, and compounds. Maybe advocate for "free fluoride tablets" and fluoride-filled toothpaste if you must. Don't include others in your treatment.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by maxerickson on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:29AM (#6646031)
Most things that are considered to be medicine are pretty toxic. It's the dose that makes them into medicine.

Some of this is because to be a medicine, a substance sort of needs to have a noticeable effect on our biology.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by aric on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:27AM (#6646361)
I appreciate your comment. You caught my conventional language and prodded me. I should be more careful. Toxicity is a factor of everything in medical science involving substances. ...in life rather. Medicine of all various forms is vast, highly varying per person, often contradictory over time in understanding, and constantly evolving. Conventionally, I consider medicine to be [something that is beneficial down to the personal level].

I'll rephrase. It isn't good medicine.

Fluoride treatments and water fluoridation are medicines like mercury treatment was once medicine. Explicit forms of "medication" must be relegated solely to an individual's active consent when consent is possible. That means a conscious choice to partake in the "medicine," on or in one's body, without medicating other people in the treatment. That's basic ethics. The benefit:negative ratio would have to be astronomically high to justify any less standard where medicine is concerned.

Medicine is very personal. Speaking for myself, when an extremely toxic substance to humans, no matter the dose, is intentionally added to something as important as water and thus a food chain, it has already lost the ethical equation. Massively "medicating" passive "patients" through the water supply is just sad. Worse still, ingesting fluoride hasn't been justified on any beneficial, medical level -- and quite the opposite with negatives. Thus, it's hard for me to associate the term "medicine" with it. I completely concede to that point though.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by pionar on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:18AM (#6646339)
Wow, I didn't know fluoride conspiracy theorists still existed. Thanks.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by aric on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:53AM (#6646477)
That's a snide dismissive. I encourage you to not be condescending to others for making statements against your preconceived notions. You may support ingesting fluoride for yourself, for whatever reason. I'd also encourage you to research it with a more skeptical and intellectual spirit, if only for the sake of your health.

How you treat others and yourself is up to you, of course. Beyond your personal choices, you'll then have a titanic task of providing basis for your support of fluoride as a medicine to the point where you justify medicating the rest of your community through its water supply.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by briandear on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:25AM (#6647330)
You aren't being forced at gunpoint by the IRS to drink tap water. You are free to buy whatever water you want. You are being forced to buy insurance. A very big difference.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by aric on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:57PM (#6650926)
They both use force. Putting heavily toxic, hard-to-remove substances into tap water -- as additives rather than as "necessary" treatments -- is, I would hope, an action considered aggressive and highly unethical to many people. Consider the degree to which people are now dependent on municipal water and the degree to which water is crucial to sustain life. I would call poisoning a water supply a form of force. It's physical and economic taxation, mostly hurting poor people (who can't afford proper filtration). And it's to the detriment of an entire food chain.

Under the new health insurance law, the penalty for not buying health insurance is a fine. I forget the yearly amount: $500-1000 (depending)? Yes, that's a form of force. The amount of the fine and who it impacts is the amount of force. It's economic taxation. It also further opens up a slippery slope in the ability for such forms of force to be used increasingly in other aspects of government and society. That's another topic.

Both propositions are easily argued as forms of force. They could easily be argued as unjustified compared to other systems and methods. However, for now, I'd argue that contaminating water is a larger form of force.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by VladRussian2 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @01:40PM (#6648305)
you're not forced to buy insurance. There is a new tax and you're just given a chance to avoid it by buying some specific product. For example i avoid some taxes by paying mortgage. Nobody forces me to have a mortgage or medical insurance. Either of it just reduces taxes and provides some benefits to me as perceived to me.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by RickHull on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:35PM (#6645073)
Indeed. I'm simply asking that we call a spade a spade.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by drivingmissm on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @09:23PM (#6644701)
Obamacare is not a "minimum floor" it is a full suite of mandated coverage for every politically connected medical sector.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 31, 2013 @02:10AM (#6645514)
Yes, its a minimum floor. And there are many plans that offer more than the ACA minimum.

You may not like where the minimum is set, but that doesn't make it anything but a minimum floor.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by briandear on Thursday October 31, 2013 @03:55AM (#6645689)
Actually, have you read the entire bill? If Government is controlling the insurance, they are controlling the care. And yes, if the Affordable Care Act forces insurers to leave markets, then the only thing left would be a call for single payer.

Harry Reid even said that Obamacare is "absolutely" a step towards single payer.

And, by the way, the calls for Single Payer because of the Obamacare "mess" are starting, Paul Krugman seems to be leading the charge along with others.

So could making the Obamacare rollout rougher than necessary prime the pump for a single payer push? I don't know, could closing the WWII memorial and Mt. Rushmore scenic roadside stops make the government shutdown worse than it needed to be to make a political point? The White House would never do that would they? That's just paranoid conspiracy stuff right? Strangely enough the Andrews Air Force Base golf course stayed open during the shutdown but the privately run Mt. Vernon (who happens to lease land from the Park Service) was forced to close. The even closed the Normandy beach in France! Yet, I had no problems getting a routine consular appointment during the shutdown in Marseille.

It's not paranoia if it's really happening.

http://www.healthcare-now.org/sen-reid-obamacare-absolutely-...

http://www.forbes.com/sites/paulroderickgregory/2013/10/28/o...

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by crusso on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:55PM (#6644382)
Actually, what I think about is the recent government shutdown where the administration went out of its way to close monuments even when those monuments required no federal funds to keep running... even those monuments that had remained open during previous shutdowns.

Obviously we witnessed an administration that wanted to really put the screws to the voting public to score political points.

Now imagine when they want to do something similar with your healthcare.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by mkramlich on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @09:16PM (#6644677)
If I were forced to choose between the following 3 entities/groups as to who the factual evidence suggests was trying to "put the screws to the voting public":

1. Presidency

2. Repubs in Congress

3. Dems in Congress

I'd have to pick #2. Overwhelming disposition of evidence pointing in that direction.

In the spirit of your point: now imagine what those folks would be willing to do to your healthcare. Actually, we don't have to imagine. Look at their actions.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by roboneal on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:27PM (#6644864)
Since these is not typically a political discussion forum, at least outline your "overwhelming" factual evidence.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by GVIrish on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:33AM (#6646379)
What evidence do you have that the administration had anything to do with shutting down monuments? Something like that is at the discretion of the director of a given federal agency. Now maybe the director of the National Park Service decided that he was going to shut monuments down as a matter of politics, but you have to recognize that there are good reasons to do so.

In DC in the last year we had a vandal deface the Lincoln Memorial and the National Cathedral. If during the shutdown the National Park Service just left all of the monuments unguarded and someone took a hammer to the nose of a statue of Jefferson, that'd be a humongous price to pay. In a national park, without park rangers to rescue people, if someone got themselves into trouble and died, that would be worse than ruining some people's vacations.

It is possible that the White House ordered parks and monuments closed for political reasons, but that's all speculation at this point. No different than speculating that George W. Bush allowed 9/11 to happen to justify invading Iraq.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by briandear on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:23AM (#6647308)
Perhaps you need a civics lesson. The national parks service is part of the department of the interior which is run by the Secretary of the Interior who reports to the President. We can't constantly keep blaming underlings. At some point the President of the United States is involved. He certainly didn't shutdown Healthcare.gov yet other HHS sites were shut down. Interesting. No money for Pubmed but plenty for Healthcare.gov
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by GVIrish on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:59PM (#6649839)
In this case I'm not blaming underlings, I'm just saying that there is no verifiable evidence that the White House ordered park and monument closings. The head of the National Parks Service could have made a decision to keep things open, or he could have made a decision to close things. The Secretary of the Interior could have done the same.

Do you have any evidence that the president sent out an order to close the parks and monuments? In that case, yes he is responsible. Otherwise you are just speculating, just like everyone else.

If you want to make the argument that ultimately the president is responsible for everything that happens on his watch, that's a different argument. The parent post was saying that Obama sent an order to close the parks.

We've been at sequestration level funding for months. Some agencies moved things around to minimize disruption, some didn't. Do you think the president sent orders down to individual agencies on how to mitigate the effects of sequestration, but didn't send that guidance to others? It's possible, but it is more likely that the different agencies figured things out for themselves and some made out better than others.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by plytheman on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:22PM (#6647716)
I don't have any authoritative source to confirm or deny why certain things were closed, but I would like to point out that there were some rangers still on duty and search and rescue employees on hand to rescue people in National Parks.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by crusso on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:29PM (#6651270)
What evidence do you have that the administration had anything to do with shutting down monuments?

You have to really be taking big gulps of the Kool Aid to have missed all the stories about how far park services went to deliberately shut down monuments. There were even reported stories of government officials showing up at some independent park operators who were utilizing government land. They ordered those parks shut down. So they didn't have money to operate parks but they had money to send people to shut down parks the government doesn't even operate?

If you start questioning the official line from the Administration, you might ask why the President and his spokespeople kept threatening default on national debts when the servicing of the debt is mandated by the 14th Amendment and easily accomplished with one tenth of the incoming federal revenues. It was all a big house of cards once you started looking at it.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by GVIrish on Friday November 01, 2013 @11:37AM (#6654482)
It's a bit ridiculous to accuse Kool Aid drinking when you haven't provided any evidence that the White House directly ordered NPS to close parks and monuments. It certainly is possible, but where is the proof? Even an off-the-record statement from a WH official would suffice.

There are plenty of reasons to not take Obama's word at face value, and there are plenty of real things to criticize him over without making up stuff.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by bdcravens on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:42PM (#6644908)
The US Government is accountable, yes. I'll even buy that the executive branch is the accountable party, given the role of implementing laws and programs. However, calling them the project manager of the site and then extending that to directly making medical treatment decisions is pretty crazy. If Amazon screws up my toilet paper order, does that mean they're automatically incompetent at auto-scaling my EC2 instances?

For what it's worth, there's some crazy delegation of tasks in the ACA. For over a year now, I've been on the interim Preexisting Condition Insurance Program. (expires 12/31, so I'm in a bit of freakout mode, but that's another story for another time ....) It's administered by the Department of Agriculture. Ummm.... moo?

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Aloisius on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:57AM (#6645330)
The Whitehouse is the executive branch; they are paid to execute and ultimately this is entirely their responsibility. They are the project managers of this entire mess. Now imagine those same people deciding your medical treatment. It's just sheer incompetence disguised as politics.

The executive branch has 2.1 million employees and is structured as set of a dozen subsidiary companies each with dozens of subsidiary companies. It is impossible for the Whitehouse, any Whitehouse, to manage except in a completely delegatory way. The idea that someone at the Whitehouse is going to be doing checkins with the contractors brought in to build a website is, frankly, laughable considering the number of things competing for attention.

I mean, would you call Warren Buffet incompetent if GEICO rolled out a faulty website because he ultimately controls it?

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by briandear on Thursday October 31, 2013 @03:36AM (#6645656)
Ok, so who the hell is in charge then? After all, The Affordable Car Act is the President's "Signature Legislative Achievement." So You going to simply say that the President isn't responsible because he has too many employes and can't possibly manage. That's a scary thought because the President is also in charge of another large organization -- the military. So your logic would suggest that the President isn't responsible for the acts of the military, yet in the same breath folks have no problem blaming Bush for Abu Ghraib.

As Harry Truman said, the buck stops here. By the way, Warren Buffet isn't the CEO of GEICO. Tom Nicely is and yes, I would certainly call Mr. Nicely incompetent is a website they had over 2 years of lead time to build faild, especially if it were part of Mr. Nicely's "Signature" achievement and grand promise to revolutionize auto insurance for the company's customers. Should Steve Balmer be blamed for Windows Vista? Balmer had almost 100K employees, so obviously Vista couldn't have been his fault.

Guys, it's a damned website! It's essentially just a guided questionnaire. The "tough" part is that it probably has to talk to insurance company APIs. Other than that, it was purely a greenfield project. I'm sure we could assemble a team of 10 guys (or girls) from right here in Hacker News and could build a better product in 25% of the time at 1/100th of the cost. Actually, I would go so far as to say that the basic functionality could be built with a team of 6 with a budget of $500K. Remember, this site ISN'T administering insurance. It's Kayak for insurance -- that's pretty much it.

There is NO excuse for this level of incompetence. If I built healthcare.gov for a private client I wouldn't have been paid. I probably would have been sued. Yet according to the person to whom I am replying, The White House bears no responsibility because the government is just too damned big for the President to be responsible.

I didn't elect the President to suck, but that's what's happening.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by GVIrish on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:46AM (#6646446)
The reason Bush is blamed for Abu Gharaib is because guidance came from the White House that torture was authorized in order to gain intelligence. Very different than if some subordinates tortured people of their own accord.

Healthcare.gov is not just a damned website. The backend has to integrate with the IRS, Medicare/Medicaid, Social Security, private insurance companies, and the various state exchanges. No you could not have assembled a team of 10 developers in 25% of the time for 1% of the cost. No offense but you clearly are not familiar with any of the details of why healthcare.gov failed.

Requirements came in so late that development didn't start until March, giving them at the most, 7 months of time to develop this thing. So you're saying that a team of 10 could've gotten this thing built in less than 2 months? And that this fictional team could've gotten away with 1 week of full integration testing? The government integrators (CMS) didn't make that full test happen until 1 week before launch.

I agree that there is no excuse for this level of incompetence, but a lot of that incompetence is on the part of the customer. An ill-prepared group was given systems integration responsibilities, requirements came in very late and they were changing right up to release, not enough time was allocated to integration testing, and no one sounded the alarm that this was going to be a disaster.

Now maybe the president knew, maybe he didn't. The responsibility for something like this would've fallen on Kathleen Sebelius. Did she know the project was off the rails? Did she inform the White House? If she didn't know, she didn't do her job, if she did know and didn't sound the alarm, she didn't do her job. The only scenario where she is not to blame is if she sounded the alarm to the president, and the president told her to push ahead. So far there has been no indication that this was the case.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by 6d0debc071 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:32AM (#6646182)
> That's a scary thought because the President is also in charge of another large organization -- the military. So your logic would suggest that the President isn't responsible for the acts of the military, yet in the same breath folks have no problem blaming Bush for Abu Ghraib.

Something being scary doesn't make it untrue. It would not particularly surprise me if the first that Bush heard of Abu Ghraib was when it hit the news.

There are of course relative degrees of responsibility - you are responsible for the people you hire, and if you have few concerns then your responsibility for those concerns individually goes up since you have more time to devote to oversight on them. But do any of us think that a president has few concerns and is directly involved with hiring three or four levels of abstraction beneath them?

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by Aloisius on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:32PM (#6649623)
By the way, Warren Buffet isn't the CEO of GEICO. Tom Nicely is

I picked GEICO because it is a wholly owned subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway. Berkshire Hathaway's CEO is of course, Warren Buffet. Warren Buffet has the power to fire Tim Nicely the same way Barack Obama has the power to fire Kathleen Sebelius. Both of them however have very little daily direct interactions with projects at their subsidiary organizations.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by generj on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @08:19PM (#6644493)
According to the article, Marilyn Tavenner is responsible for authorizing the security checks to be skipped, along with several other administrators at HHS.

Now, I would argue that Sibelius is ultimately responsible for setting unrealistic timelines, and general culture at HHS, but without a smoking gun I'm not going to blame the President. Yet. Although I think he entrusted his only signature act in the hands of a very incompetent woman, and gave her carte blanche for 3 years.

The programmer responsible (and his QA) should still be relegated to typewriters for the rest of their careers.

Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by briandear on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:06AM (#6645704)
The fault lies with Sebelius, however the same logic would absolve Bush of Rumsfeld's errors.
Re:HealthCare.gov deferred final security check, could leak ... by GVIrish on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:50AM (#6646469)
To me the question is, once the president learns of the incompetence of a subordinate, what action does he take? Does the president hold the subordinate accountable, and fire them? Or does the president just let them keep on bungling.

Rumsfeld eventually resigned, but Bush didn't push him out, meaning Bush owns Rumsfeld's failures. In my opinion, if Obama doesn't hold Sebelius and Clapper accountable, he owns their incompetence and misconduct.