As Harry Truman said, the buck stops here. By the way, Warren Buffet isn't the CEO of GEICO. Tom Nicely is and yes, I would certainly call Mr. Nicely incompetent is a website they had over 2 years of lead time to build faild, especially if it were part of Mr. Nicely's "Signature" achievement and grand promise to revolutionize auto insurance for the company's customers. Should Steve Balmer be blamed for Windows Vista? Balmer had almost 100K employees, so obviously Vista couldn't have been his fault.
Guys, it's a damned website! It's essentially just a guided questionnaire. The "tough" part is that it probably has to talk to insurance company APIs. Other than that, it was purely a greenfield project. I'm sure we could assemble a team of 10 guys (or girls) from right here in Hacker News and could build a better product in 25% of the time at 1/100th of the cost. Actually, I would go so far as to say that the basic functionality could be built with a team of 6 with a budget of $500K. Remember, this site ISN'T administering insurance. It's Kayak for insurance -- that's pretty much it.
There is NO excuse for this level of incompetence. If I built healthcare.gov for a private client I wouldn't have been paid. I probably would have been sued. Yet according to the person to whom I am replying, The White House bears no responsibility because the government is just too damned big for the President to be responsible.
I didn't elect the President to suck, but that's what's happening.
Healthcare.gov is not just a damned website. The backend has to integrate with the IRS, Medicare/Medicaid, Social Security, private insurance companies, and the various state exchanges. No you could not have assembled a team of 10 developers in 25% of the time for 1% of the cost. No offense but you clearly are not familiar with any of the details of why healthcare.gov failed.
Requirements came in so late that development didn't start until March, giving them at the most, 7 months of time to develop this thing. So you're saying that a team of 10 could've gotten this thing built in less than 2 months? And that this fictional team could've gotten away with 1 week of full integration testing? The government integrators (CMS) didn't make that full test happen until 1 week before launch.
I agree that there is no excuse for this level of incompetence, but a lot of that incompetence is on the part of the customer. An ill-prepared group was given systems integration responsibilities, requirements came in very late and they were changing right up to release, not enough time was allocated to integration testing, and no one sounded the alarm that this was going to be a disaster.
Now maybe the president knew, maybe he didn't. The responsibility for something like this would've fallen on Kathleen Sebelius. Did she know the project was off the rails? Did she inform the White House? If she didn't know, she didn't do her job, if she did know and didn't sound the alarm, she didn't do her job. The only scenario where she is not to blame is if she sounded the alarm to the president, and the president told her to push ahead. So far there has been no indication that this was the case.
Something being scary doesn't make it untrue. It would not particularly surprise me if the first that Bush heard of Abu Ghraib was when it hit the news.
There are of course relative degrees of responsibility - you are responsible for the people you hire, and if you have few concerns then your responsibility for those concerns individually goes up since you have more time to devote to oversight on them. But do any of us think that a president has few concerns and is directly involved with hiring three or four levels of abstraction beneath them?
I picked GEICO because it is a wholly owned subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway. Berkshire Hathaway's CEO is of course, Warren Buffet. Warren Buffet has the power to fire Tim Nicely the same way Barack Obama has the power to fire Kathleen Sebelius. Both of them however have very little daily direct interactions with projects at their subsidiary organizations.
The executive branch has 2.1 million employees and is structured as set of a dozen subsidiary companies each with dozens of subsidiary companies. It is impossible for the Whitehouse, any Whitehouse, to manage except in a completely delegatory way. The idea that someone at the Whitehouse is going to be doing checkins with the contractors brought in to build a website is, frankly, laughable considering the number of things competing for attention.
I mean, would you call Warren Buffet incompetent if GEICO rolled out a faulty website because he ultimately controls it?