News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by MAGZine on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:45PM (#6630053)
You compare the battery life, but not the screen to the macbook air? The screen is higher resolution, has a better coating, and is touch. Other than that, it's smaller and lighter (around 20%, actually), and comparably priced ($1299 for 256GB/8GB surface, $1299 for 256GB/8GB Air). It also has a micro SD card slot, to add further provisions.

This isn't a tablet competitor, it's an ultraportable competitor.

e: made a bit more concrete

Re:Surface Pro 2 by Pxtl on Monday October 28, 2013 @08:15PM (#6630840)
It's an everything competitor. It's the tablet/ultrabook answer to the way smartphones merged PDAs and cellphones.

And like those early smartphones, it's got some growing to do. But the market it's trying to carve out strikes me as a real one with real demand. I'm surprised we're not seeing more doctors and other specialists-on-the-go wielding them.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by _wmd on Monday October 28, 2013 @09:28PM (#6631204)
Kinda tired debating the surface pro on HN, but you hit the nail on the head. This is a desktop computer that sacrifices very little, yet is the size of an iPad with comparable usability. Anyone who voluntarily indoctrinated themselves on the merits of toy mobile operating systems will never understand how awesome the Pro-range surfaces are.

Much like the HTC Dream was basically a first generation joke, I'm hopeful and very much intend to be carrying one of Surface's offspring in my backpack in a few years time.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by tadfisher on Monday October 28, 2013 @10:41PM (#6631572)
Hell, I'm interested in using one with Linux (if they've got the wacom issues sorted out, that is).
Re:Surface Pro 2 by wfraser on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @01:38AM (#6632228)
The only problem with using Linux is that there isn't (as far as I can tell) a good Linux UI that's very touch-friendly. The closest one is Unity, and well, that's all I need to say there. (I realize some people like it, but I'm just not one of them, sorry...)

I'm excited to see what comes of the Ubuntu tablet distro, but at the same time, they were the ones who made Unity, which isn't really good at anything. So I'm not super optimistic either.

Windows's "metro" UI is obviously touch friendly, but even the desktop can be made touch friendly-ish via its DPI scaling, which I think works pretty well. I haven't been able to get that same usability out of any Linux desktop environment yet. (If someone has, I'd love to know about it!)

Re:Surface Pro 2 by vanderZwan on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @05:44AM (#6632884)
> The only problem with using Linux is that there isn't (as far as I can tell) a good Linux UI that's very touch-friendly. The closest one is Unity, and well, that's all I need to say there. (I realize some people like it, but I'm just not one of them, sorry...)

I hope Jolla and Sailfish will help in that department.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by ewzimm on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:28AM (#6634814)
KDE is further along than Unity but still needs a little development to be perfect:

http://plasma-active.org/

Re:Surface Pro 2 by wfraser on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @12:49PM (#6635597)
Wow, thanks! I didn't know about that. I'll try it!
Re:Surface Pro 2 by peatmoss on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @09:30AM (#6633885)
Does this mean that the surface pro 2 is a good choice for those of us who don't mind Unity?
Re:Surface Pro 2 by wfraser on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @12:47PM (#6635581)
Yeah, from a technical standpoint, it runs pretty well. There's still at least one hardware compat issue to be resolved (when I last tried Ubuntu Saucy beta, the wifi didn't work), but it was very performant, and looked nice.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by peatmoss on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @01:46PM (#6636070)
That's good to know. No wifi would be a pretty big buzzkill though. I like the idea of replacing my Mac/iPad combo with a single device. It sounds like the high-DPI screen would be a reasonable replacement for my iPad (a.k.a. PDF journal reader) but I'm far too invested having a competent Unix-like environment on the computer side to live in Windows. Ubuntu's "convergence" tablet vision cannot come quickly enough.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by calciphus on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:18AM (#6632596)
I run my dev servers in VMWare in Ubuntu on my Surface Pro. It's good enough, but more than a little fussy when it comes to touch (or the wacom issues), so I tend to just use it with the keyboard.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by pulmo on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @03:03AM (#6632418)
I don't know why Microsoft is doing this to themselves. Instead if being the best in one market they try to create a new one which competes with the tablet and ultrabook market. But their product can be never as good as a tablet or ultrabook. I just don't think that there are many people who are willing to accept that trade-off.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by stinos on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @03:50AM (#6632527)
Being the best on one market isn't always as beneficial as being good in a couple of markets. Apart from that you're looking at it from a single perspective making you see only certain trade-offs (which are only there for those expecting a tablet or ultrabook anyway) and not the other side of it. Other people might just see a full-blown laptop running a desktop OS with touch and Wacom. And when you get rid of the keyboard you're left with something that's quite usable as a tablet ans still runs a full desktop OS.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by Pxtl on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @10:27AM (#6634315)
There are professionals on the go who want to carry one device, not two, and have both the use-case for a tablet and a notebook. You can't use a notebook standing up, and you can't run real Windows software on a tablet.

I'm surprised every single doctor in a hospital doesn't own one of these yet, for example.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by Elhana on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:27AM (#6634810)
I guess you mean why every doctor doesn't own 2-3 of these, because battery won't last a day...
Re:Surface Pro 2 by mkr-hn on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @01:56PM (#6636144)
That's what the power cover is for.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by Teckla on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @03:19PM (#6636742)
That's what the power cover is for.

And now it's too heavy to carry around all day every day.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by danudey on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:12PM (#6637873)
Part of the reason for this is that a lot of the 'Windows' apps I've seen for healthcare are really, really bad (and have UI much too small/complex to use on a touchscreen), whereas the iOS apps I've seen are much more polished, user-friendly, and accessible because they're designed for touchscreens from the start.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by pulmo on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:57AM (#6639941)
It would be impractical in a hospital. It's relatively heavy and where would you put it when you don't need it without risking theft? And how would you prevent unauthorized access to hospital records when stolen? I think the whole tablet at hospitals thing is a fantasy.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by Pxtl on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:55AM (#6646781)
All of those concerns exist with a clipboard of papers, and you can't encrypt those.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by pulmo on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @02:37PM (#6684924)
Right. But who would want to steal a clipboard?
Re:Surface Pro 2 by arrrg on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:53PM (#6630104)
And has a (certainly decent for a tablet but) awful keyboard and trackpad compared to other ultra-portables. There are clear trade-offs here (there always are and there is nothing wrong with making clear and opinionated trade-offs) and I’m not sure whether the Surface Pro makes the right ones. No doubt Microsoft made all the right trade-offs for some people, the question is only whether those some people are more than a niche.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by MAGZine on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:01PM (#6630144)
Right, at least the bad trackpad is offset by the fact that you can touch. The need for apple-level trackpad is offset by the fact that you can manipulate pages with your fingers, instead.

And from what I've heard and used, both the touch and type cover aren't "awful" or "terrible". They're not 'good' either, but I'd certainly put them in the 'usuable' category. Would I write a book on it? Hell no, but I'd also be tempted to swap my mac's chiclet keyboard for a mechanical keyboard anyhow. There is certainly room for improvement, but people in HN seem to have an particularly high disdain for the surface's covers... they're not the demon they're made out to be.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by arrrg on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:05PM (#6630174)
I think you slightly misunderstood me. I think the cover is pretty awesome. To me it seems like a winning combination with a $500 tablet. But a $1000 tablet/ultra-portable with the keyboard and trackpad? Is that the right trade-off to make?

If the products competing here are $1000 ultra-protables with pretty great keyboards and $1000 tablets with crappy keyboards, which has the bigger audience?

Re:Surface Pro 2 by niels_olson on Monday October 28, 2013 @07:57PM (#6630739)
> which has the bigger audience?

What is the most accessible creative occupation? Writing? STEM fields? Or drawing? We could draw before the written word existed. We could write before we created more abstracted languages like modern symbolic math.

I think the end game is to include high resolution, precise, accurate stylus input, a'la Wacom technology or something like it.

I cry a little every time I see a Microsoft product with Wacom built in and an equivalent Apple product without it. What I'd really like is something like a Surface 2 running Ubuntu or SuSE, but with an Apple-worthy battery life.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by arrrg on Monday October 28, 2013 @08:25PM (#6630885)
Maybe it can be done beyond the niche. My current guess would be no but I’m not super sure about that. Admittedly, do not expect any great insights from me in this regard, all I’m going on is that drawing (with a stylus) has been a (pretty big) niche application in computing for a very long time now and always nothing more. It’s useful for some people, but very far from everyone. Maybe that can change. Actually, I don’t really doubt that (look at all the previously niche-tech that’s in current smartphones because it became cheap enough and that had to find its mass-market applications first, stuff like gyroscopes) but I’m not sure whether it’s the Surface Pro that will do it.

But it has, admittedly, a better shot at doing it than anything else that came before it.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by etler on Monday October 28, 2013 @07:23PM (#6630552)
As it is, I think it's still in niche territory, but I think with some polish it could be a really great product. The big question is whether microsoft can pull off the polish, which historically they haven't been able to (maybe with the new management this will change).

There have definitely been many microsoft products I've seen that were incredibly impressive, but were simply not taken the rest of the way.

Maybe a 3rd party manufacturer can take where the surface is now, and provide that polish, which I think was the goal of the surface anyways. Show what is possible to 3rd parties and let them take the ball the rest of the way. If that can happen, then the surface will have done its job.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by sirkneeland on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:37AM (#6632662)
New management, and don't forget the very talented Nokia engineers that are inbound...
Re:Surface Pro 2 by trailfox on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @07:30AM (#6633261)
Hopefully they fare better then the talented Kin engineers...
Re:Surface Pro 2 by devx on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:07PM (#6630183)
Surface Pro actually has a worse GPU than MBA, too (Intel HD 4600 vs Intel HD 5000), which contributes to that, plus a higher clocked CPU. And we already know that Windows' battery life is terrible [1].

It's all a perfect storm of bad decisions the reason why Surface itself has bad battery life.

[1] - http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2013/10/why-does-windows-ha...

Re:Surface Pro 2 by MAGZine on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:20PM (#6630250)
Windows doesn't have the best power consumption--the facts are irrefutable--it's empirically visible.

In the Surface's defense, it is running a wacom digitizer over a 1080p IPS display. Not only is it pushing 2x the pixels as the 11" MBA, but it's doing it over IPS (up to 15% greater power consumption according to Wiki).

But yes, Windows has much poorer battery life, my speculation is that since Apple targets their hardware to a few small (comparatively) number of hardware permutations, they can take this to their advantage, and power-optimize the shit out of everything.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by etler on Monday October 28, 2013 @07:45PM (#6630665)
The most effective optimizations will probably be on the driver level, which microsoft would have little say over (in terms of the surface, they should but they're weak in the hardware game).

Here's a question complaining about 1/2 battery life for ubuntu, and an answerer said they were able to match the battery life by using proprietary drivers. http://askubuntu.com/questions/158778/why-does-ubuntu-have-a...

Re:Surface Pro 2 by Tloewald on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @09:57AM (#6634063)
Remember how everyone used to give Microsoft a free pass on its awful installation process (driver hell) because it supported so many options, but then Knopper (one guy!) created a Linux distro that auto-installed on almost anything. Microsoft makes tons of money on Windows and has tons of engineers, it could power-optimize for a heck of a lot of configurations. Given that a fairly small number of chipsets account for a huge proportion of PCs, I think it would be easier than we think.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by ibrahima on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @01:05AM (#6632135)
Actually, that's not really true re: the GPUs. They're pretty roughly comparable, and trade off different specs (execution units vs clock speed) with the result that the HD 4600 is actually better in some benchmarks and worse in others.

See http://www.notebookcheck.net/Intel-HD-Graphics-4600.86106.0.... and http://www.notebookcheck.net/Intel-HD-Graphics-5000.91978.0....

Although, that said the Surface Pro 2 actually has an HD 4400 which is definitely inferior to the HD 5000, though the difference is not that really huge (probably roughly 20% overall), which in most cases is not enough to make a difference in playability of games - if you're getting 25fps average on the HD 4400, 30fps on the HD 5000 will be noticeably better but still bad IMO, especially in high load scenarios when the framerate dips. Personally I prefer to play with over a 60fps average so that even in more intense scenes it doesn't drop to below 30fps.

And if you're not playing games, it's really not even relevant.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by wtallis on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:32AM (#6632638)
I've seen it suggested that the higher EU count of the HD 5000 allows it to be clocked lower and thus operated at a lower voltage, adding up to a net power savings for the same level of performance. I imagine this could be particularly significant at moderate GPU loads, rather than fully loading the GPU with a game.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by vondur on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:36PM (#6630330)
I don't think of it as an ultraportable competitor. The Surface pro seems to be running into the same issues with the very first tablet computers that ran Windows, they were/are a niche product. Great if you have a need for a stylus, but simply not worth it compared to a regular laptop. Like others have mentioned, to make it ultrabook capable,(getting a keyboard/storage upgrade) it's far more expensive than nice Windows based ultrabooks.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by oneeyedpigeon on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @05:00AM (#6632738)
This is the point everyone seems to be missing. Microsoft tried releasing tablets with styluses, keyboards, and a desktop OS before - they failed, big time. The market hasn't suddenly changed in the intervening years to one that wants that kind of form-factor. As Apple proved, the market wants a very minimal tablet, with an on-screen keyboard, a great touchscreen, and an OS optimised for those features. For FUN, not for work. A handful of people will use tablets for 'work' and for being creative, a couple of niche industries will find they can integrate tablets into their workflow, but for the average office worker who wants to watch some videos, the iPad is perfect, the surface is 'overkill'.

(edit to correct incorrect autocorrect on ... iPad ;-)

Re:Surface Pro 2 by discreditable on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @07:28AM (#6633251)
> The market hasn't suddenly changed in the intervening years to one that wants that kind of form-factor.

I'll agree that most of the market doesn't want that kind of form factor, but two segments in which the convertable tablet has really taken off are in the education and health care industries. I work with a few schools that manage to hand out tablet + stylus + keyboard laptops to all of their students and do pretty well with it.

My school isn't a fan of the Surface due to serviceability issues (non-replaceable battery being a big one) and that it is a great tablet, but gives up some ground in the general-use laptop area to do that. The other schools in our group share the same sort of sentiments.

Re:Surface Pro 2 by city41 on Monday October 28, 2013 @09:42PM (#6631273)
It really isn't though. I own a Surface Pro 1 and as much as I like it, it's a terrible portable computer. I hook mine up to a monitor, keyboard and mouse 90% of the time.
Re:Surface Pro 2 by iamshs on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @12:03AM (#6631950)
I would respectfully disagree, as i had one too and used it pretty much on the go 30-40% of the time. But then, I do not know your use case.