News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't write code first by ginko on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:17PM (#6628241)
I understand that Hacker News is mostly targeted towards the startup crowd, but asking _hackers_ to have a business model before they write anything is completely backwards to me.

Hackers don't write code because they want to make lots of money. Hackers write code because they are hackers. Building a viable business on top of that code may be a nice side effect of this.

Re:Don't write code first by mildtrepidation on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:36PM (#6628378)
This sentiment is a bit like saying "sailors don't sail because they have somewhere to go. Sailors sail because they want to sail."

It may be true if you're on a lake or in a bay, know the area well, and your intention is to just go and flex your sailing muscles. To practice, enjoy, check out something you're aware of but haven't actually navigated, or something else that's similarly within easy reach.

It loses its applicability when you consider that, no, some sailors actually do have destinations. And some trips are long or difficult enough that they do in fact require planning, specific goals, timelines, and all manner of other preparation.

I'm sure it's not a perfect metaphor, but the point is that the artificial limitation of "hackers hack to hack" is short-sighted and fundamentally flawed. Some do, some don't, and I would say most are somewhere in between. But please don't make the mistake -- on behalf of others -- of defining the entire community in terms of your preconceptions about what hackers do or don't value or attempt in an absolute sense.

Re:Don't write code first by gbog on Monday October 28, 2013 @03:55PM (#6629347)
Yes, comparison is flawed. Imagine Torvalds starting to work on git. Is he sailing to go somewhere? Certainly. Has he a full business plan with all the bs about customers? Certainly not. He sails because he is a sailor, and sailor are explorers too. (Not in real life, but in this comparison)
Re:Don't write code first by pencilcheck on Monday October 28, 2013 @10:05PM (#6631401)
However Linus built git for himself, not for others, therefore he doesn’t need to go through this because he will be the first customer once this product is finished and released.

This article is aiming for entrepreneurs who are building a product for others because no where in the article did he infer any possibility that the product/service is something they want regardless of others.

Re:Don't write code first by greenyoda on Monday October 28, 2013 @11:23PM (#6631786)
"However Linus built git for himself, not for others..."

No, Linus built git to address the needs of a large community of Linux kernel developers:

Git development began after many developers of the Linux kernel chose to give up access to BitKeeper, a proprietary SCM system that had previously been used to maintain the project. The copyright holder of BitKeeper, Larry McVoy, had withdrawn free use of the product after he claimed that Andrew Tridgell had reverse-engineered the BitKeeper protocols.

Torvalds wanted a distributed system that he could use like BitKeeper, but none of the available free systems met his needs, particularly in terms of performance. Torvalds took an example of an SCM system requiring thirty seconds to apply a patch and update all associated metadata, and noted that this would not scale to the needs of Linux kernel development, where syncing with fellow maintainers could require 250 such actions at a time. His goal was for patches to take three seconds.[1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Git_%28software%29#History

Re:Don't write code first by pencilcheck on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:10AM (#6646859)
Still, he is one of the target customers :) And you might noticed in the excerpt you have pasted, it says that

`Torvalds wanted a distributed system that he could use like BitKeeper, but none of the available free systems met his needs`

Re:Don't write code first by adlpz on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:37PM (#6628390)
The word hacker has been twisted into oblivion.

Just assume that any mention to 'hacker' in Hacker News has nothing to do with hacking, but with entrepreneurship.

Re:Don't write code first by sebinsua on Monday October 28, 2013 @04:07PM (#6629425)
It has and it hasn't.

There's always been a yin-yang between hacker and hustler here.

And I am glad this hasn't been destroyed as there is merit in the frame.

We hack and hustle customers and software.

We validate the market on both ends: business and product.

Re:Don't write code first by hermanhermitage on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:53PM (#6628512)
Heh. Or perhaps hacking out some web based product with no meaningful programming involved but exploiting a customer base/segment...
Re:Don't write code first by joshdance on Monday October 28, 2013 @03:41PM (#6629284)
Yes. It seems the term hacker = entrepreneur with some type of technical knowledge. Which is ok.
Re:Don't write code first by AznHisoka on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:40PM (#6628421)
I write code so I can make money... so that in the future, I can write code without worrying about making money. if that makes sense. Because right now, the vast majority of hackers spend 90% of their living hours writing code that doesn't satisfy them intellectually.
Re:Don't write code first by xerophtye on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:15PM (#6628682)
Makes perfect sense to me. Though every once in a while i run into coding job that i actually find satisfying. Like recently made a research project involving a multiple AI agent envoronment
Re:Don't write code first by brownBananas on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:51PM (#6628506)
No, I don't think it's backwards thinking to me, but I do agree with you. People loving hacking because it's a fun thing to do. And most of the times, building a business isn't even the point of it all.

The problem I have with this article and your comment, is the generalization of the term "hackers". Is anyone that codes in their free time, a "hacker"? Is a software engineer that works full time at a company, a "hacker"? What about UI designers that write CSS? What about business guys who throw something together in HTML and jQuery? Are they hackers as well? Different people have different goals for what they are building or hacking on. I really don't understand how we are still throwing such vague terms around like we all fit in this one category of people, and we all want to achieve the same things.

Re:Don't write code first by ovi256 on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:36PM (#6628376)
A "business model" can mean a for-profit enterprise as well as an open source project solving a pain point and showcasing your skills. The questions customer development asks can be used for the open source project too, with great effect.
Re:Don't write code first by xerophtye on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:11PM (#6628652)
yep! that's how good useful open-source code (especially APIs) are built! I mean dont u want people to actually USE what u took time and effort to write? You may not have written it for money, or to make a business, but you would want people using it. So when you code AFTER knowing what people need, the feeling is way more awesome! i mean think about it, u wanna make something really cool that no one uses? or something everyone agrees on is super cool, and would love to actually use?

I actually spent nearly an year writing a rather powerful and challenging mathmatical reasoning engine (heck it can not only solve but LEARN mathematics!) but i had no users in mind. So i could never explain to people why anyone wud want to use it. and that didnt really feel that good

Re:Don't write code first by etler on Monday October 28, 2013 @08:59PM (#6631067)
It depends on your goal. If you're just writing code for yourself, then yes, because you are your own customer at that point. If other people happen to share your sentiment, awesome. If you want to start a startup because you think you have a good idea that other people will want, then do the market research first and make sure people actually want it. If it's something you're doing for yourself, then you probably don't need monetary motivation to do it, even if you're the only one using it.
Re:Don't write code first by al1x on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:35PM (#6628374)
That's kind of the point of this article though. He's pointing out the flaw in the "code first" approach. He started out that way and wound up wasting years of his life. The "hackers" of news.ycombinator.com are (or should be) business-minded hackers (it's kind of the point of ycombinator). This kind of reminder is always helpful.
Re:Don't write code first by jmngomes on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:38PM (#6628408)
Also, writing enough code to build a minimal demo is often necessary to validate technical viability and to ease customer development, as having something to show helps kickstart the conversation and stimulates feedback.
Re:Don't write code first by sukaka on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:48PM (#6628481)
everyone should do what they enjoy, then money will follow. there are niche business areas. i.e. creating apps useful to you, creating an algorithmic trading bot to work the market
Re:Don't write code first by bluedino on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:56PM (#6628536)
Exactly - this is advice for entrepreneurial-focused 'hackers'
Re:Don't write code first by beat on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:00PM (#6628567)
The problem is that they want to hack, rather than doing the scary business stuff. You won't have this problem if you're not a hacker by nature.